8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
lowrye
offline
offline
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
Barnsie
offline
offline
Originally posted by lowrye
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
My HBs haven't neglected Str/Carry, and they are fumbling like crazy...
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
My HBs haven't neglected Str/Carry, and they are fumbling like crazy...
Joseph Trabell
offline
offline
Originally posted by lowrye
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
I agree with this. My team lost 2 big games because of fumbling problems. I think it had to do with the defense having strong players and able to run their guys on power tackling. Our HBs are only really lacking in confidence. Once we get that up on them I believe the HBs may still fumble here and there against those same teams, but not enough to cost us the game.
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
I agree with this. My team lost 2 big games because of fumbling problems. I think it had to do with the defense having strong players and able to run their guys on power tackling. Our HBs are only really lacking in confidence. Once we get that up on them I believe the HBs may still fumble here and there against those same teams, but not enough to cost us the game.
lowrye
offline
offline
Obviously no HB/WR/QB/FB is completely neglecting Strength/Carry/Confidence. Everyone puts some points in there. But It is also pretty much guranteed that Wr/HB all have more agilty & speed then they do str/carry/confidence. (I'm sure there some out there where there is an exception but for the most part..)
Lets look at 2 players from their creation.. A LB & a HB.
HB - From the beginning he is putting the majority of his points into Speed & Agilty, with some into carrying, catching, & strenght.
LB- From the beginning he is putting the majority of his points into speed & agility (to keep up with the HB), with some going into strength & tackling.
The two players are probably trying to soft cap speed & agility as fast as possible.
After speed & agilty is soft capped:
HB - Starts focusing on carrying, strength, catching, & lets not forget confidence.
LB - Starts focusing on Strength & Tackling. Mix in a point or two towards confidence, catching maybe for some INTs.
The fact of the matter is Defensive players get 'stronger' faster than offensive ball handlers. There is no denying that if you look at the overall 'strength' of Linebackers, CB's, & safties compared to overall 'strength' of HB's, TE's, WR's.. The defense has more points!
Lets also not forget that defensive players have SA's specially designed to improve the chances to cause fumbles. WR's have no SA for protection of fumbles.
We could argue back and forth about who is right and get off on 80 different tangents. The fact of the matter is that when my defensive player is tackling your offensive player. I believe the defense has more strength & more tackling (with SA's to cause fumbles) than you have in Strength & carrying.
Lets look at 2 players from their creation.. A LB & a HB.
HB - From the beginning he is putting the majority of his points into Speed & Agilty, with some into carrying, catching, & strenght.
LB- From the beginning he is putting the majority of his points into speed & agility (to keep up with the HB), with some going into strength & tackling.
The two players are probably trying to soft cap speed & agility as fast as possible.
After speed & agilty is soft capped:
HB - Starts focusing on carrying, strength, catching, & lets not forget confidence.
LB - Starts focusing on Strength & Tackling. Mix in a point or two towards confidence, catching maybe for some INTs.
The fact of the matter is Defensive players get 'stronger' faster than offensive ball handlers. There is no denying that if you look at the overall 'strength' of Linebackers, CB's, & safties compared to overall 'strength' of HB's, TE's, WR's.. The defense has more points!
Lets also not forget that defensive players have SA's specially designed to improve the chances to cause fumbles. WR's have no SA for protection of fumbles.
We could argue back and forth about who is right and get off on 80 different tangents. The fact of the matter is that when my defensive player is tackling your offensive player. I believe the defense has more strength & more tackling (with SA's to cause fumbles) than you have in Strength & carrying.
Vando
offline
offline
I'm noticing it happening all through the divisions, not just the top end. It can't be a particular area 'coming into it's own' or it would have been spotted already by now.
GwennA
offline
offline
We're seeing it too. And so far, its been mainly on players with plenty of strength and carry. Or, in the case of our power backs, str+carry+cover up.
Its been especially bad on special teams where our 40+ str, 30+ carry returner has fumbled at least once in every competitive game this season.
We run pure power backs, so strength, carry and cover up are focuses. We had almost no fumbles at all last season. Last game we had 6. 3 of them came from a back with:
Strength 60.82, Agility 49.13, Carry 35.39, Confidence 32.49, 2 Ranks of Cover Up.
There's no way that that should be fumbling 3 times in a game against fairly equal competition, and 6 times this season already compared to 5 fumbles all of last season combined.
Its been especially bad on special teams where our 40+ str, 30+ carry returner has fumbled at least once in every competitive game this season.
We run pure power backs, so strength, carry and cover up are focuses. We had almost no fumbles at all last season. Last game we had 6. 3 of them came from a back with:
Strength 60.82, Agility 49.13, Carry 35.39, Confidence 32.49, 2 Ranks of Cover Up.
There's no way that that should be fumbling 3 times in a game against fairly equal competition, and 6 times this season already compared to 5 fumbles all of last season combined.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 10:34:18
Bevo53
offline
offline
This has been a major problem on my team as well. We have a power back with 80+ str 40+ carrying and 5 in cover up, but he already has 7 fumbles this season on only 133 carries. Last season he only had 9 fumbles and he had 10 the year before that.
The other back on my team already has 4 fumbles on only 93 carries. He only had 5 fumbles all of last year. This HB has str and carrying at the soft cap and a couple of points in cover up.
It seems we have at least 3-4 fumbles every game now and we just hope to recover them.
The other back on my team already has 4 fumbles on only 93 carries. He only had 5 fumbles all of last year. This HB has str and carrying at the soft cap and a couple of points in cover up.
It seems we have at least 3-4 fumbles every game now and we just hope to recover them.
Barnsie
offline
offline
Originally posted by lowrye
We could argue back and forth about who is right and get off on 80 different tangents. The fact of the matter is that when my defensive player is tackling your offensive player. I believe the defense has more strength & more tackling (with SA's to cause fumbles) than you have in Strength & carrying.
I doubt it. I'm sure my HB has more str + carry than your LBs, or else your LB wouldnt even be able to chase him down. I'm talking about a serious power HB here.
And when I say "not neglecting", I mean 40+ carrying in the case of my elusive HB. Let me mention that I'm in a level 21 capped league, so consider than when I say 40 carrying. Are we supposed to get carrying to 60 for this to stop?
I'm fine w/ defenders forcing some more fumbles. But we're seeing almost 2 fumbles a game. And as I mentioned, I can assure that they teams we're playing against don't have good defenders - they are gutted.
Once we get to the real part of our schedule, I'll be curious to see if we can't average about 3-4 fumbles/game
.
We could argue back and forth about who is right and get off on 80 different tangents. The fact of the matter is that when my defensive player is tackling your offensive player. I believe the defense has more strength & more tackling (with SA's to cause fumbles) than you have in Strength & carrying.
I doubt it. I'm sure my HB has more str + carry than your LBs, or else your LB wouldnt even be able to chase him down. I'm talking about a serious power HB here.
And when I say "not neglecting", I mean 40+ carrying in the case of my elusive HB. Let me mention that I'm in a level 21 capped league, so consider than when I say 40 carrying. Are we supposed to get carrying to 60 for this to stop?
I'm fine w/ defenders forcing some more fumbles. But we're seeing almost 2 fumbles a game. And as I mentioned, I can assure that they teams we're playing against don't have good defenders - they are gutted.
Once we get to the real part of our schedule, I'll be curious to see if we can't average about 3-4 fumbles/game
.Last edited Oct 2, 2008 10:45:05
hntrr31
offline
offline
My "elusive" HB fumbled again today.
he's at least soft capped in Strength and Carrying, and at least 3 in cover up. We played gutted teams the last two games, and he's fumbled 3 times. Two more fumbles and he will have more than all of last season, with 380 carries and 3000 yards.
If it's a change in the game, cool. Just let me know what's changed so I can adapt.
Otherwise, something happened as a result of another action and this is a consequence that isn't good for the game.
he's at least soft capped in Strength and Carrying, and at least 3 in cover up. We played gutted teams the last two games, and he's fumbled 3 times. Two more fumbles and he will have more than all of last season, with 380 carries and 3000 yards.
If it's a change in the game, cool. Just let me know what's changed so I can adapt.
Otherwise, something happened as a result of another action and this is a consequence that isn't good for the game.
sunder B
offline
offline
Originally posted by caponesgun
The league leaders in USA Pro have 13 forced fumbles in five games having played no real "cupcakes". 2-3 a game seems a bit high to me against equal leveled competition but I could be wrong.
You're not wrong, QFT.
The league leaders in USA Pro have 13 forced fumbles in five games having played no real "cupcakes". 2-3 a game seems a bit high to me against equal leveled competition but I could be wrong.
You're not wrong, QFT.
Kirk Gibson
offline
offline
Originally posted by lowrye
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
I can fully appreciate trying to make logic of all of this but the effect has been too extreme. Its happening at high levels and low levels. Its happening against gutted teams and great teams. We can all speculate but at the end of the day even IF everything is working as intended the amount of fumbles occurring is hurting the quality of the game.
Originally posted by Kirk Gibson
8 fumbles in last nights game, 4 for them 4 for us. Ridiculous....
Maybe it was raining??
On a serious note.. Maybe Defensive SA's are finally starting to kick in with higher level players.. Snarl, Growl, Big Hit.. All designed to Demoralize offensive players & make them FUMBLE more.
At the beginning of GLB speed was the best. Then came agilty freaks. Now the defense is getting stronger. Maybe instead of offensive playmakers focusing mainly on Speed & agilty.. More attention needs to be on confidence - carrying - strength.
For a while the Offensive builds were designed & Defensive players had to create builds to combat those. Now maybe the ball is in the defensive players court a little more and you need to counter us! (As you can tell, I am a defesive minded player.)
I can fully appreciate trying to make logic of all of this but the effect has been too extreme. Its happening at high levels and low levels. Its happening against gutted teams and great teams. We can all speculate but at the end of the day even IF everything is working as intended the amount of fumbles occurring is hurting the quality of the game.
Sahoj
offline
offline
Seems like a normal progression. We all knew last season defensive builds
were not yet at a point where they could catch up to pure power backs.
We knew it would take at least a full season.
Ding.
My back is up in fumbles too despite a significant Cover Up SA
and mediocre carrying. Got him doing Tiki Barber drills now.
Hah. My defense is forcing more fumbles as well, so I'm happy.
Cheers,
Sahoj
were not yet at a point where they could catch up to pure power backs.
We knew it would take at least a full season.
Ding.
My back is up in fumbles too despite a significant Cover Up SA
and mediocre carrying. Got him doing Tiki Barber drills now.
Hah. My defense is forcing more fumbles as well, so I'm happy.
Cheers,
Sahoj
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 11:37:56
islander1
offline
offline
we're seeing an increase in fumbles in our games so far as well...not sure if I'm ready to call foul on it yet though. Fumbles happen. I guess if an unusually high trend continues for 10-12 games then maybe Bort should scale it back slightly?
MD
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
we're seeing an increase in fumbles in our games so far as well...not sure if I'm ready to call foul on it yet though. Fumbles happen. I guess if an unusually high trend continues for 10-12 games then maybe Bort should scale it back slightly?
I agree fumbles happen but when alot of HBs are seeing themselves on pace to double or triple there past seasons total, somethings up. I cant speak for everyone but i know my HB gets a good dose of points spent in Carry, Strength, Cover Up and Confidence. I even added more to them this season. Yet his totals are already far surpassing last season and every other season.
All were asking is for Bort or whoever, to look into this because it seems fairly unbalanced right now.
we're seeing an increase in fumbles in our games so far as well...not sure if I'm ready to call foul on it yet though. Fumbles happen. I guess if an unusually high trend continues for 10-12 games then maybe Bort should scale it back slightly?
I agree fumbles happen but when alot of HBs are seeing themselves on pace to double or triple there past seasons total, somethings up. I cant speak for everyone but i know my HB gets a good dose of points spent in Carry, Strength, Cover Up and Confidence. I even added more to them this season. Yet his totals are already far surpassing last season and every other season.
All were asking is for Bort or whoever, to look into this because it seems fairly unbalanced right now.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























