I have a Few DT's, that are a little more balanced. I'd say that the Strong Base SA is helping. But I am not one that believes the Strong Base SA is going to equate to you getting more stats, that SA is there so other players LB's in particular can make plays IMO.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > IS STRONGBASE BROKEN? (by WiSeIVIaN, the guy who posts threads that never really go anywhere)
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
My DT has 11 strong base and 92 strength, yet has done basically nothing rushing the passer (or peroid for that matter) this season.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=273398
I think the issue is you dont have the agility and speed to properly exploit the Strong Base even if the SA activates and gets you past the OL.
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
I'm just saying that he's not getting past OGs peroid with my strength/strong base, aside from a few times vs CPU players. Strong base specifically mentions strength, yet I'm still starvin for defensive pancakes. If I was getting past OG's and just not getting to the QB, I assure you that this thread would not be made...
If you'd like I'll move all 22 pts of equipment to speed/agility, but I donno if thats gonna help my strong base not be worthless...
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
My DT has 11 strong base and 92 strength, yet has done basically nothing rushing the passer (or peroid for that matter) this season.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=273398
I think the issue is you dont have the agility and speed to properly exploit the Strong Base even if the SA activates and gets you past the OL.
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
I'm just saying that he's not getting past OGs peroid with my strength/strong base, aside from a few times vs CPU players. Strong base specifically mentions strength, yet I'm still starvin for defensive pancakes. If I was getting past OG's and just not getting to the QB, I assure you that this thread would not be made...
If you'd like I'll move all 22 pts of equipment to speed/agility, but I donno if thats gonna help my strong base not be worthless...
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by AAflyboys2
I have a Few DT's, that are a little more balanced. I'd say that the Strong Base SA is helping. But I am not one that believes the Strong Base SA is going to equate to you getting more stats, that SA is there so other players LB's in particular can make plays IMO.
In the description it says...
"This player has a powerful lower body and knows how to use it well. The strong base skill gives him a bonus to pushing the blocker out of the way.
This skill works best when used by players with high strength.
Additional levels: Increases the chances of the skill working, and increases the chances of pushing the blocker out of the way"
So I fail to understand how a SA thats designed to get past blockers, is an SA that leads to my teammates making more plays... Even on run plays the description would lead one to beleive it'd result in more DT tackles (currently on a beastly 1.167/game) while allowing the blocker to get to the 2nd level and occupy a LB, resulting in less plays for him?
Makes no mention of helping him occupy blockers or not get pushed back (like the run stuffing SA's)...
I have a Few DT's, that are a little more balanced. I'd say that the Strong Base SA is helping. But I am not one that believes the Strong Base SA is going to equate to you getting more stats, that SA is there so other players LB's in particular can make plays IMO.
In the description it says...
"This player has a powerful lower body and knows how to use it well. The strong base skill gives him a bonus to pushing the blocker out of the way.
This skill works best when used by players with high strength.
Additional levels: Increases the chances of the skill working, and increases the chances of pushing the blocker out of the way"
So I fail to understand how a SA thats designed to get past blockers, is an SA that leads to my teammates making more plays... Even on run plays the description would lead one to beleive it'd result in more DT tackles (currently on a beastly 1.167/game) while allowing the blocker to get to the 2nd level and occupy a LB, resulting in less plays for him?
Makes no mention of helping him occupy blockers or not get pushed back (like the run stuffing SA's)...
gravenimages
offline
offline
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by gravenimages
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...
jrope
offline
offline
Originally posted by MrMoose
I love how, any time someone posts that something may not be working, people always find one low stat and instantly blame said low stat.
It could be possible that strong base actually isn't working. If it was confidence, you'd think that the player would have seen results at some point early in games, even with low vision.
If every stat is so important to softcap at every position, though, players will never touch SAs. I highly doubt you need 50+ in each stat for SAs to fire off or anything.
My DE has 36 vision and 26 confidence. Yet he's playing well this year. His build is working just fine despite 26 confidence:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=184345
Honestly, I think the big issue is simply that O Line loads up on strength, therefore strength based stuff is not nearly as effective. As people focus more and more on non-strength based stuff, it'll become more effective.
this guy's got it exactly right (even tho no one but Bort will ever be truly right). but the points made by mister moose are the most logical. OGs pile up strength like its gold, and it would make it hard. in the case that DT Rhino Clark doesn't do squat against gutted teams, it is most likely that strong base doesn't have the effect that the label makes us dream of.
in regards to vision, it could very well help a player shoot a gap, but i've seen too many DE's get that inside gap-rush lately to believe that everyone has soft capped vision that allows them to fit through a 5 foot gap better than a DE with crappy vision. it's all about the SIM mechanics and the opportunities it offers to players.
Confidence may help you be consistent, along with stamina, but even more of a reason that DT Rhino should excel this year. he comes off the bench with his full stamina and morale, going against O-linemen who have been subjected to energy loss and morale drop because they started the game.
in the end, its most likely that strong base is no 'tunnel vision' in terms of pass rushing ability. or at least how tunnel vision was in the past, when DE's magnetically attached themselves to QB's from 10 feet away. it's obvious that some SA's come more loaded than others. and probably for the better. Wise does a great job building players, but im kind of glad that his 11 strong base didn't break the game and create mass havoc among O-linemen being sent through the stadium walls
I love how, any time someone posts that something may not be working, people always find one low stat and instantly blame said low stat.
It could be possible that strong base actually isn't working. If it was confidence, you'd think that the player would have seen results at some point early in games, even with low vision.
If every stat is so important to softcap at every position, though, players will never touch SAs. I highly doubt you need 50+ in each stat for SAs to fire off or anything.
My DE has 36 vision and 26 confidence. Yet he's playing well this year. His build is working just fine despite 26 confidence:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=184345
Honestly, I think the big issue is simply that O Line loads up on strength, therefore strength based stuff is not nearly as effective. As people focus more and more on non-strength based stuff, it'll become more effective.
this guy's got it exactly right (even tho no one but Bort will ever be truly right). but the points made by mister moose are the most logical. OGs pile up strength like its gold, and it would make it hard. in the case that DT Rhino Clark doesn't do squat against gutted teams, it is most likely that strong base doesn't have the effect that the label makes us dream of.
in regards to vision, it could very well help a player shoot a gap, but i've seen too many DE's get that inside gap-rush lately to believe that everyone has soft capped vision that allows them to fit through a 5 foot gap better than a DE with crappy vision. it's all about the SIM mechanics and the opportunities it offers to players.
Confidence may help you be consistent, along with stamina, but even more of a reason that DT Rhino should excel this year. he comes off the bench with his full stamina and morale, going against O-linemen who have been subjected to energy loss and morale drop because they started the game.
in the end, its most likely that strong base is no 'tunnel vision' in terms of pass rushing ability. or at least how tunnel vision was in the past, when DE's magnetically attached themselves to QB's from 10 feet away. it's obvious that some SA's come more loaded than others. and probably for the better. Wise does a great job building players, but im kind of glad that his 11 strong base didn't break the game and create mass havoc among O-linemen being sent through the stadium walls

pestface
offline
offline
I think Ivan makes a good point. The SA makes every indication of being:
1) Pass-Rush based
2)Effective when used with high strength
3)Helps push blockers
92 strength and 11 in strong base should by all means, occasionally deliver a hurry when 1-on-1 with a similar LG.
Reasons why it probably doesn't work:
-All the newbie guides teach LGs to work on the pass blocking ahead of run blocking
-Many pass blocking SAs for Guards stack up to help stop the strong DTs, even if outmatched
-Offensive Linemen builds are traditionally addicted to strength and blocking over mobility
-Especially at high levels, the passing game goes very fast- a fast QB release will beat everybody but the speed DEs
-A big strong DT pushing the linemen out of the way will take a century to reach an good QB who steps back in the pocket to throw
-Any nerfs to speed DEs are may have the side affect of hurting the pass-rush game.
1) Pass-Rush based
2)Effective when used with high strength
3)Helps push blockers
92 strength and 11 in strong base should by all means, occasionally deliver a hurry when 1-on-1 with a similar LG.
Reasons why it probably doesn't work:
-All the newbie guides teach LGs to work on the pass blocking ahead of run blocking
-Many pass blocking SAs for Guards stack up to help stop the strong DTs, even if outmatched
-Offensive Linemen builds are traditionally addicted to strength and blocking over mobility
-Especially at high levels, the passing game goes very fast- a fast QB release will beat everybody but the speed DEs
-A big strong DT pushing the linemen out of the way will take a century to reach an good QB who steps back in the pocket to throw
-Any nerfs to speed DEs are may have the side affect of hurting the pass-rush game.
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Definitely nice points pestface, though my name is supposed to read wiseman, not wise4ivan. 

justinkicksass
offline
offline
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by gravenimages
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...
Pet peeve of mine. A line by definition is straight. Thus a strait line is redundant redundant.
Originally posted by gravenimages
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...
Pet peeve of mine. A line by definition is straight. Thus a strait line is redundant redundant.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 00:42:52
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by justinkicksass
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by gravenimages
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...
Pet peeve of mine. A line by definition is straight. Thus a strait line is redundant redundant.
An arc is a curved line, no?
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
Originally posted by gravenimages
Something I've not seen asked regards your pass rushing tactic... Set to power I'd imagine?
Yes set to power. Though come to think of it perhaps evasive will lead me to avoiding getting reblocked after I "throw the blocker out of the way". I'll set it to evasive for my next few games, though I have doubts that it'll make a difference. Only so many paths a DT can take to a QB imo, and a straight line is of course the quickest...
Pet peeve of mine. A line by definition is straight. Thus a strait line is redundant redundant.
An arc is a curved line, no?
Havoc
offline
offline
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
60/60 is a bit excessive for purposes of determining whether Strong Base works or not, but at least compare a decent pass rushing DT with Strong Base versus one without that SA, hopefully in the same league to even up the playing field as much as possible.
38 speed DTs against high level competition are simply mediocre-to-bad pass rushers. How should we know if your Strong Base is working if your guy is pretty limited in his pass rushing ability by his low speed/agility.
If your guy had 48 speed and 60 agility at this point he would be getting some sacks, even against good opposition, with or without Strong Base.
The interesting question is would he be getting more sacks/hurries from his nice Strong Base than a similar capable pass rushing build without Strong Base.
I'm not trying to sound cocky or be critical. I just dont think your player is a fair platform on which to evaluate Strong Base.
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
60/60 is a bit excessive for purposes of determining whether Strong Base works or not, but at least compare a decent pass rushing DT with Strong Base versus one without that SA, hopefully in the same league to even up the playing field as much as possible.
38 speed DTs against high level competition are simply mediocre-to-bad pass rushers. How should we know if your Strong Base is working if your guy is pretty limited in his pass rushing ability by his low speed/agility.
If your guy had 48 speed and 60 agility at this point he would be getting some sacks, even against good opposition, with or without Strong Base.
The interesting question is would he be getting more sacks/hurries from his nice Strong Base than a similar capable pass rushing build without Strong Base.
I'm not trying to sound cocky or be critical. I just dont think your player is a fair platform on which to evaluate Strong Base.
pestface
offline
offline
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
60/60 is a bit excessive for purposes of determining whether Strong Base works or not, but at least compare a decent pass rushing DT with Strong Base versus one without that SA, hopefully in the same league to even up the playing field as much as possible.
38 speed DTs against high level competition are simply mediocre-to-bad pass rushers. How should we know if your Strong Base is working if your guy is pretty limited in his pass rushing ability by his low speed/agility.
If your guy had 48 speed and 60 agility at this point he would be getting some sacks, even against good opposition, with or without Strong Base.
The interesting question is would he be getting more sacks/hurries from his nice Strong Base than a similar capable pass rushing build without Strong Base.
I'm not trying to sound cocky or be critical. I just dont think your player is a fair platform on which to evaluate Strong Base.
You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
60/60 is a bit excessive for purposes of determining whether Strong Base works or not, but at least compare a decent pass rushing DT with Strong Base versus one without that SA, hopefully in the same league to even up the playing field as much as possible.
38 speed DTs against high level competition are simply mediocre-to-bad pass rushers. How should we know if your Strong Base is working if your guy is pretty limited in his pass rushing ability by his low speed/agility.
If your guy had 48 speed and 60 agility at this point he would be getting some sacks, even against good opposition, with or without Strong Base.
The interesting question is would he be getting more sacks/hurries from his nice Strong Base than a similar capable pass rushing build without Strong Base.
I'm not trying to sound cocky or be critical. I just dont think your player is a fair platform on which to evaluate Strong Base.
You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by pestface
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
60/60 is a bit excessive for purposes of determining whether Strong Base works or not, but at least compare a decent pass rushing DT with Strong Base versus one without that SA, hopefully in the same league to even up the playing field as much as possible.
38 speed DTs against high level competition are simply mediocre-to-bad pass rushers. How should we know if your Strong Base is working if your guy is pretty limited in his pass rushing ability by his low speed/agility.
If your guy had 48 speed and 60 agility at this point he would be getting some sacks, even against good opposition, with or without Strong Base.
The interesting question is would he be getting more sacks/hurries from his nice Strong Base than a similar capable pass rushing build without Strong Base.
I'm not trying to sound cocky or be critical. I just dont think your player is a fair platform on which to evaluate Strong Base.
You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.
Which would be the point of my thread, that strongbase is useless. The point of my thread isn't "i want my player to get sacks, give me build advice"....
Pestface you seem to know what your talking about. I put you in charge of my thread as I sleep.
Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The speed/agility factor is of course noted. If you'd like I'll come back with this thread again at level 38 and 60 speed/agility, lol.
60/60 is a bit excessive for purposes of determining whether Strong Base works or not, but at least compare a decent pass rushing DT with Strong Base versus one without that SA, hopefully in the same league to even up the playing field as much as possible.
38 speed DTs against high level competition are simply mediocre-to-bad pass rushers. How should we know if your Strong Base is working if your guy is pretty limited in his pass rushing ability by his low speed/agility.
If your guy had 48 speed and 60 agility at this point he would be getting some sacks, even against good opposition, with or without Strong Base.
The interesting question is would he be getting more sacks/hurries from his nice Strong Base than a similar capable pass rushing build without Strong Base.
I'm not trying to sound cocky or be critical. I just dont think your player is a fair platform on which to evaluate Strong Base.
You seem to be arguing that agility/speed are the only way to produce pressure, which would imply strong base is useless.
Which would be the point of my thread, that strongbase is useless. The point of my thread isn't "i want my player to get sacks, give me build advice"....
Pestface you seem to know what your talking about. I put you in charge of my thread as I sleep.

Last edited Oct 1, 2008 02:48:28
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























