User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Fixing a loophole with Bonus Tokens and Advanced Equipment
Page:
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by King Henrik
Originally posted by Bort

Hm, well the only reason we wanted to limit carryover was to encourage people to use them and avoid people saving up 4 seasons worth to do a sudden "before the playoffs megaboost" or something.

I guess we could do a reduced refund on the items, but it would make it really hard to upgrade a new item later if you found something far better. Any suggestions on how to close the loophole without it being too restrictive? Hard eh?


reduced refund would suck. the only people who would exploit this are those that have a lot of cash laying around. is it currently so that you only get half back of the cost of the equip?


Yes, $2k in my example to hoard 32 bonus tokens is wallet busting. But seriously, I think the easy and sensible way to do this is to just make selling Ad. EQ back lose at least some of the bonus tokens. Somewhere between one-quarter and one-half seems fair and reasonable to me. Giving 6 bonus tokens back per level would make hoarding bonus tokens still feasible, but actually have a real cost.

Another possibility would be to return bonus tokens by level. 1/2 spent on level 1 upgrades, 1/4 spent on level 2 upgrades and all on the rest of the upgrades. That would significantly discourage the loophole and would still not be too restrictive on long-term equipment rebuilds. That way, people that built equipment the right way aren't punished much and would only lose about one level of upgrades (6 bonus tokens) no matter how much they had upgraded their Ad. EQ.
 
Saerin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hm, well the only reason we wanted to limit carryover was to encourage people to use them and avoid people saving up 4 seasons worth to do a sudden "before the playoffs megaboost" or something.

I guess we could do a reduced refund on the items, but it would make it really hard to upgrade a new item later if you found something far better. Any suggestions on how to close the loophole without it being too restrictive? Hard eh?


you could alter the system a bit and make it so you can buy equipment tokens((dont really like this as it just adds more tokens) with the bonus tokens.

-or-

make it so that once a bonus token is used on equipment it cant be used for anything else.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by bigpimpin123

We aren't talking about that, we are talking about spending 8 tokens to upgrade advanced equipment. But that would be another problem. Everyone knows they can save up their tokens so this isn't really part of the loophole.


What? Bort asked for way to stop people from hording BT for a "megaboost" I said only allow 2 BT boosts active at once. There would be no real reason to horde them because the "megaboost" would be impossible.


There is already a rule that you can only have 1 'temporary boost' (after using 4 BT) active in a game, so I assume the "megaboost" Bort was talking about would be to equipment.


No, I meant doing a megaboost with a ton of +1 SP's. You can only have on temporary boost active at a time, but you can still turn in more tokens to get more SP's.
 
bachus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Nixx

Originally posted by Knick


Originally posted by bigpimpin123


We aren't talking about that, we are talking about spending 8 tokens to upgrade advanced equipment. But that would be another problem. Everyone knows they can save up their tokens so this isn't really part of the loophole.


What? Bort asked for way to stop people from hording BT for a "megaboost" I said only allow 2 BT boosts active at once. There would be no real reason to horde them because the "megaboost" would be impossible.


There is already a rule that you can only have 1 'temporary boost' (after using 4 BT) active in a game, so I assume the "megaboost" Bort was talking about would be to equipment.


No, I meant doing a megaboost with a ton of +1 SP's. You can only have on temporary boost active at a time, but you can still turn in more tokens to get more SP's.


"megaboost" or slowly getting to the same place by using bonus tokens....why do you care? If someone chooses not to use +1 SPs for a period of time, they in sense are limiting their player for current games, if they save up 3 or 4 SP's to use at one time they are not getting the most out of their player. But that is their stupidity, why do you care about hording SPs? Under the current leveling system it is inherent a player will have to horde SPs to increase player attributes or SAs when at high levels.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bachus
"megaboost" or slowly getting to the same place by using bonus tokens....why do you care?


I agree. I don't see how this is really different than waiting to boost (with flex points), which has been an accepted practice since season 1.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by bachus

"megaboost" or slowly getting to the same place by using bonus tokens....why do you care?


I agree. I don't see how this is really different than waiting to boost (with flex points), which has been an accepted practice since season 1.


It just exacerbates that aspect even more. I've heard complaints about that aspect of the game quite a few times.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Nixx

Originally posted by bachus


"megaboost" or slowly getting to the same place by using bonus tokens....why do you care?


I agree. I don't see how this is really different than waiting to boost (with flex points), which has been an accepted practice since season 1.


It just exacerbates that aspect even more. I've heard complaints about that aspect of the game quite a few times.


It's a part of the game. As much as people complain over it, it's a option players have and some chose to do it that way. You, as an Admin, can't make every group happy.

I won't be happy until you fix EE Pro tbh

 
bachus
offline
Link
 
If the following table is true, high level players have to horde SPs already for attributes to increase at high levels.

Soft cap levels and required skill points to increase attributes:

00.00 <---[ 1:1]---> 48.06
48.07 <---[ 2:1]---> 60.51
60.52 <---[ 3:1]---> 67.97
67.98 <---[ 4:1]---> 73.24
73.25 <---[ 5:1]---> 77.28
77.29 <---[ 6:1]---> 80.53
80.54 <---[ 7:1]---> 83.25
83.26 <---[ 8:1]---> 85.58
85.59 <---[ 9:1]---> 87.60
87.61 <---[10:1]---> 89.40
89.41 <---[11:1]---> 91.01
91.02 <---[12:1]---> 92.46
92.47 <---[13:1]---> 93.79
93.80 <---[14:1]---> 95.00
95.01 <---[15:1]---> 96.13
96.14 <---[16:1]---> 97.18
97.19 <---[17:1]---> 98.15
98.16 <---[18:1]---> 99.06
99.07 <---[19:1]---> 99.99
100.0 <---[20:1]---> etc.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It just exacerbates that aspect even more. I've heard complaints about that aspect of the game quite a few times.


Hmm, OK. To review...

Current bonus token rule: You can stockpile as many as you want, but only 5 can carry over to the next season.

Current advanced equipment sales rule: 100% refund of bonus tokens.

Potential 'exploit': Someone could use 8 (or 16, 24, etc) and upgrade advanced items, then sell them to get all the BT back and use the BT for the +1 skill point right before the playoffs. If someone did a full season of intense training and upgraded items, then next season did another full season of intense, then sold the items, they'd have 32 BT, worth 8 skill points. That's 2 full seasons though, quite a long wait just for 8 skill points. (Actually that math is a bit off, if they planned on using the "megaboost" for the playoffs in the second season.)

I don't think it's such a big issue. Just make it so we can carry over unlimited BT and get 100% refund on advanced equipment sales. If someone wants to be weakened for a few seasons by hording then that would be their choice.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 02:34:07
 
bachus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by Bort

It just exacerbates that aspect even more. I've heard complaints about that aspect of the game quite a few times.


Hmm, OK. To review...

Current bonus token rule: You can stockpile as many as you want, but only 5 can carry over to the next season.

Current advanced equipment sales rule: 100% refund of bonus tokens.

Potential 'exploit': Someone could use 8 (or 16, 24, etc) and upgrade advanced items, then sell them to get all the BT back and use the BT for the +1 skill point right before the playoffs. If someone did a full season of intense training and upgraded items, then next season did another full season of intense, then sold the items, they'd have 32 BT, worth 8 skill points. That's 2 full seasons though, quite a long wait just for 8 skill points. (Actually that math is a bit off, if they planned on using the "megaboost" for the playoffs in the second season.)

I don't think it's such a big issue. Just make it so we can carry over unlimited BT and get 100% refund on advanced equipment sales. If someone wants to be weakened for a few seasons by hording then that would be their choice.


I agree. Not a big deal to retain unlimited bonus tokens from season to season.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
You know - the thing that strikes me most about this thread is the lengths people will go to to find an exploit and work it out to the Nth degree!!

Personally, I think this is another case where keeping it simple would have negated a lot of trouble.

By making the system overly complicated, without really adding any substance to the core enjoyment aspect, you've simply given the maths nerds a chance to run some formulas and work out that by season 6.3, they can save up enough stuff to sell it all and get 18.4 extra skill points....

Or something .........

When people spend more time hypothesising about potential exploits than they do actually just playing, then perhaps going back to the old system is the best course of action........

 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
If you want to prevent the megaboost, why not just limit players to 4 +1SP boosts per season.

Its not possible to get more tokens than that in a season anyway and eliminate the token carryover rule.
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 07:38:55
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
To be honest, I'm not sure that this is a huge issue. I guess if folks want to do it, let them, but they'll be weaker in the long run.

#1 - A +1 STAT (and or +0.5 SA / +1%) from EQ is MUCH better than +2 Skill Points. If someone (for example) wants to take their speed down from 80 to 74 in return for +12 SP, go for it!

#2 - The higher level you are, the high chance that your stats are over the soft caps which makes your use of skill points to raise these skills even more inefficient.

I understand the concern here in that we don't want someone giving a huge SP boost to their guy, but this doesn't tactic comes with a price.

Heck, one of my C's has both STR/BLK at the +5 cap. Why would I take a -2 EQ (10 SP) just to gain +4 SP? Again, I understand the concern, but I don't really know that it's worth worrying about. If someone wants to gimp their guy like this...hey, more power to 'em!

A few workarounds:

1) Create a new currency - Upgrade Tokens (that cost 5 Bonus Tokens). You can either use 5 Bonus Tokens or one Upgrade Token to upgrade an item. When you sell back an item you get upgrade tokens back.

2) Allow direct upgrades of EQ. Let's say you have Superior Yellow Cleats upgrade twice and you just bought a Superior Black Eye. Allow Cleats to directly upgrade the Black Eye, which keeps all the user picked stats, but just changes the underlying bonuses.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
non-issue IMO
 
Waygoban
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
To be honest, I'm not sure that this is a huge issue. I guess if folks want to do it, let them, but they'll be weaker in the long run.

#1 - A +1 STAT (and or +0.5 SA / +1%) from EQ is MUCH better than +2 Skill Points. If someone (for example) wants to take their speed down from 80 to 74 in return for +12 SP, go for it!

#2 - The higher level you are, the high chance that your stats are over the soft caps which makes your use of skill points to raise these skills even more inefficient.

I understand the concern here in that we don't want someone giving a huge SP boost to their guy, but this doesn't tactic comes with a price.

Heck, one of my C's has both STR/BLK at the +5 cap. Why would I take a -2 EQ (10 SP) just to gain +4 SP? Again, I understand the concern, but I don't really know that it's worth worrying about. If someone wants to gimp their guy like this...hey, more power to 'em!

A few workarounds:

1) Create a new currency - Upgrade Tokens (that cost 5 Bonus Tokens). You can either use 5 Bonus Tokens or one Upgrade Token to upgrade an item. When you sell back an item you get upgrade tokens back.

2) Allow direct upgrades of EQ. Let's say you have Superior Yellow Cleats upgrade twice and you just bought a Superior Black Eye. Allow Cleats to directly upgrade the Black Eye, which keeps all the user picked stats, but just changes the underlying bonuses.


Another simple idea is to restrict the refund bonus tokens to be only used to upgrade adv. eq., such as record the amount of the refund bonus tokens of a player when he sells an upgraded adv. eq. and let him boost only if he has bonus tokens more than the amount of refund bonus tokens plus 4. If he use the tokens to upgrade a adv. eq., then subtract the token cost from both current bonus tokens and the recorded amount of refund bonus tokens.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.