User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > AI not following Game Plan!!! BUG!!!!
Page:
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larsonite
Again, what I call I Formation Big, was NOT recognized as I Formation but it was recognized as Any I Formation. That would be a BUG!

Thanks for being an IDIOT. Mind joining my division?
-Larsonite


Uh, ignoring most of that..wasn't directed at me anyway.


But, how would the AI recognize anything as "I-Formation" instead of "Any I" since there is no option to choose "I-Formation"?

I guess I don't get what you're saying. There isn't even a choice for "I-Formation". How were you setting up your regular I settings? You had to have already been using "Any I", right? Which would have also triggered on the HB deep formation?
 
Larsonite
offline
Link
 
Weak, Strong, Big, Any I & 2WR Set. These all effected different plays last season. Now Any I & 2WR Set effects the HB deep I as it is not a Weak, Strong or Big.

Also, how does this relate to Single Back Formation not being recognized as in the original post?
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 20:14:05
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larsonite
Weak, Strong, Big, Any I & 2WR Set. These all effected different plays last season. Now Any I & 2WR Set effects the HB deep I as it is not a Weak, Strong or Big.


Nothing has changed there since last season. You had to have the "Any I" input below all of the specific ones last season, and you have to do the same this season. It's no different...At least for me and my AI.
 
Larsonite
offline
Link
 
how does this relate to Single Back Formation not being recognized as in the original post?
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larsonite
Originally posted by tjking82

Originally posted by Larsonite


Originally posted by jeffgarcia



my team played bad it's a bug


Playing bad because of poor builds and/or poor tactics is user error. The AI not following your Tactics because it didn't recognize a Single Back Formation as a Single Back Formation is a BUG!

Last Season, what I call I Formation Big, was NOT recognized as I Formation but it was recognized as Any I Formation. That would be a BUG!

Example of a I Formation: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=164347&pbp_id=2173839

Example of a I Formation Big: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=164347&pbp_id=2174681

so JeffGarcia, are you getting it now! If you team doesn't follow the AI but it is not USER ERROR, it is a BUG!

Thanks for thinking,
-Larsonite


For the record, just because you call something I formation Big does not make it so. If you did a little research (wikipedia anyone?), you would learn that I formation Big is an I formation with 2 TEs. So no, that is not a bug, just a formation you misclassified.


Your not getting what I'm saying. I, me personally, LARSONITE, call that I Formation Play, I Formation Big. Call it what you want. I Formation HB Deep would be far more accurate but since there is NO I Formation Big in this game, I, Me Personally, Larsonite, call it I Formation Big.

I know what the F*CK a I Formation Big is in real life and I don't need a J*CK ASS like you to send be to WIKIPEDIA.

What's really funny, is that you actually made the type you didn't understand Bold. WHAT???? You Dumb Ass!

Again, what I call I Formation Big, was NOT recognized as I Formation but it was recognized as Any I Formation. That would be a BUG!

Thanks for being an IDIOT. Mind joining my division?
-Larsonite


LOL... listen to what you said:

- there's a play that's an I-formation, but the HB is a few yards back compared to the normal I formation
- I CALLED that "I formation big" (for some reason - though I know it's not a big I formation)
- but the SIM didn't recognize it as "Big I", instead as "I (any variation)"

So you basically are saying: the SIM didn't respond to my private idea of calling it "I formation big"!

(That play is an I formation, but no strong I, no weak I, no big I... so just "any I". That is and was the same way since the very start. What you mean by "was NOT recognized as I Formation but it was recognized as Any I Formation" is quite some secret. There's no choice to choose a "I Formation" - just "I (any variation)", "Weak I", "Strong I" and "Big I")
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Stop arguing symantics and try to understand what Larsonite is actually saying in his first post.

He has a legitimate bug, where for some reason, his Singleback defense input is not activating, but his Shotgun 3WR input is.

If this happened on every play it would be simply the order of the inputs or blank fields etc.

But as it happens only sometimes he thinks it is a bug.

The correct input ran in the exact same situation throughout the game, so it wasnt a problem with a Qtr or positional input triggering.

The only thing I could possible think of is...

- Autoadjust is effecting it? (Human Error: Unlikely)
- The OUTPUT has a less than 100% chance of hitting (Human Error : Unlikely if he checked properly)
- That one play it fired on is not 'tagged' the same as the other plays are from that same formation.(Bug)
- The AI was ignored (Bug)

Without knowing exactly the inputs for that game I cant help.

Last edited Sep 30, 2008 05:06:19
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
I took a look at Larsonite's AI when he first posted this, and I couldn't find any human error in his outputs (though I didn't look at his basic tactics to check on auto adjust as we're in the same league and I didn't want to get a wandering eye, but I think human error here is an unlikely cause).
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Looking at the plays the only thing I could think of is if there's a red zone setting somewhere.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
I don't think that's it. The first play he listed in his first post takes place immediately after the last play (the seemingly buggy play) at the exact same part of the field. The only difference is the down (and 3 seconds that ran off the clock), but his input/output don't differentiate by down.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
So did this "bug" show up in the recent 2 games?

Besides that:

- maybe he changed his playbook shortly before gametime? (or even after the data was transferred to the sim)
- maybe he did changes, but forgot to save or hit "UPDATE"?
- maybe some GM accidently screwed something up?

So is this malfunction still happening? Or was it a one-time issue?

It's hard to track something down that only showed up once. And obviously only very few people have issues like that. So what to do? Keep calling Bort for an issue hard to track and already gone?

Could be related to the redzone situation too. I recently bug-reported a cover 1 play in about the same situation and the FS acted like in cover 0 (headed for the HB right from the start). Bort happened to have time to look it up and it actually was the cover 1 play we called - just no explanation for the FS behavior.

We got over it and it didn't show up again so far. I'd suggest to do the same, but watch out if this happens again.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.