User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Well Thought-Out Solution to Gutting
Page:
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Orignally this was the first post of the thread. But since length of this post discouraged some people from reading my idea, I switched the first post to a summary and moved this here.

The Problem
When a team is passed on to a random owner, usually some people leave and often the whole team. New owners on teams that are doomed in their current league (that is, doomed without monumental recruiting efforts) often give up. And often time owners of teams that can't make the playoffs in the tough leagues, especially in pro leagues (and USA AAA) where teams can be pretty decent and still not make the playoffs, will grow apathetic over time and won't want the large time commitment any more. The problem is systemic and is not going to go away without a change to how things work. League restructuring is only a stop-gap, not a fix, and gutted teams will get worse over time.

The Solution: Overview
Have there only be three ways for a team to remain intact after an owner leaves:

1) The owner of the team requests a GM take over, and the GM accepts (he doesn't need players on the team, but maybe should have to have been a GM for a certain period of time). I know this happens now, but make it easy and legitimate.
2) If a team isn't passed on to another owner, and the team is not bankrupt, then a voting process is initiated (see below) among the people who own players on the team. An interim owner is then appointed who has restricted powers. He can change game tactics, depth chart, see players' energy, etc., but he can't sign, trade, or release players, or renegotiate contracts. At the end of the season, if 66% of the players (so people who own multiple players have more voting power) on the team vote to keep the team intact, then the interim owner can keep the team for the normal amount of flex points and gain full fledged ownership. If a player's contract is up at the end of the season, and he wants to vote "yes, don't disband the team", he must agree to re-sign a one season extension for his same pay rate (adjusted slightly for increasing levels, and conditional on the team not disbanding). Otherwise, his vote will automatically be no. If less than 66% of the players on the team wish to stay, then everyone is immediately considered a free agent and the team is reset. A new team is promoted to take it's place.
3) Teams in the bottom tier of leagues are immune to resetting. They will go through the same process as other teams once their owner leaves (as described above), and if the team would have reset, instead a new owner is assigned from the waiting list. At this time, all players currently on the team have the option of voiding their contract within one week.

When a new owner takes over, regardless of method, while a player is still under a contract signed by the previous owner, they get to approve all trades they are involved in. Also, if they are still under an old contract after one full season with the new owner, they get the option to terminate their old contract at this time.

The Voting Process
When a team becomes ownerless for any reason (decides to stop paying for team, releases ownership, goes inactive for too long, etc.), all the players on the team will get an alert saying the team is now ownerless and a new voting process will begin in 48hrs. This alert will link to a thread created on the team's forums with further information about the process and a prompt for discussion of the teams future. During this time, anybody who owns a player on the team can submit their name to the ballot (and optionally campaign in the forum thread). After the initial 48 hours, a 48 hour voting period is started and players get a ballot in their inbox (or a link to it) and an alert on their homepage (in the newish "announcement" section). Everyone who submitted their name is voted on, and the owner with the most player votes (not owner votes) is elected interim owner. He is the only person who has a chance of taking over the team at the end of the season. If nobody submits their name, or if the team is unfixably bankrupt (maybe just bankrupt at all to prevent exploitation), the team is still controllable by GMs but is otherwise on cruise control to be reset at the end of the season.

Team Resets and Automatic Promotions
When a team is reset (by not having a new owner or by the team disbanding under the interim owner), the next year they are effectively knocked out of their level in the pyramid and put back at the bottom. You will only be able to buy teams through the normal system in place now on the bottom rung of the league pyramid. A team one league below the level of the resetting team will get promoted automatically at the end of the season to take their place. The resetting teams will come out of the normal two team relegation number but can exceed if needed. So there will be no non-resetting teams relegated if the number of resetters is two or more per conference. If the number exceeds two per conference, then extra teams will get promoted based on a new team ranking system. I am not too particular about the exact ranking system used, but i have come up with a proposal below. A team from two levels below the resetting team (if there are two levels below) will get promoted to take the place of the newly promoted team from a level above it, and so fourth down chain until the lowest level is reached. The resetting team with a new stadium and name and all computer players (to start) will fill the gap at the lowest level.

Ranking System Proposal
Teams will be given points according to past playoff and regular season performances. The latest years and playoffs will be favored heavily. Exact values could be:
Lost in conference finals last season - 25 points
Lost in semis - 15 pts
Lost in quarters - 5 pts
Best record reg season in conference - 12 pts
2nd - 10 pts
3rd- 9 pts
4th- 8 pts
Etc., decreasing one point for each position until 11th gets 1 and 12th gets 0.

All point values for two seasons ago will be exactly one half of season one values. If the team was in a lower league two seasons ago (two lower than the league they are trying to get into) then all these scores are further cut in half again. If the team won the conference finals game two leagues below, count it as 8 (32 but half off for it being 2 seasons ago and half off for it being an extra league down), and count a championship victory as 10 (40*.5*.5). All season values for three seasons ago are worth half of season two's values (so 1/4th last season's). Decimals will be used, and no more than three previous seasons counted. The team with the most points will get promoted. If it's still tied I'll leave that to Bort (scrimmage maybe?). Remember this is only used when there is three or more teams resetting in a higher league. The normal way of the conference champions moving up will still be the main means of promotion.

How Will this Fix Gutting?
The main problem with the current system is of new ownership and owner apathy. Owners who have been with a team a while and take a real interest in that team's success invariably have at least decent teams. This system forces every new owner not affiliated with the team they are taking over to start at the bottom. This clears higher leagues of gutted teams and newbie owners. It also makes riding your team to the upper tier leagues more prestigious as there is now no way to just "queue" your way in. The modifications I am suggesting will work in a newly restructured league system just as well as they will work in the current one. This changed system allows for more promotions and relegations in order to more accurately sort the leagues, without constant restructuring. And this is accomplished in a dynamic and fair way.



Criticisms
Any system that involves some teams moving up through a point ranking system is going to receive complaints, especially from people who were not chosen to move up. This ranking formula is a necessary evil created by the tie situation across same-level leagues, and the fact that sometimes the current number of promoted teams is not enough. I think any system that values the latest years and playoff performance highest will be alright. People will bitch but it is better than any alternative. Currently I think the biggest problem with the ranking system is that it favors teams in week conferences. But the current promotion system does this also, and it is nearly impossible to avoid (see Possible Modifications below for a partial suggestion on this).

Other people might complain that this system breaks up more teams than the old system because of forced team resets. But even if this is true (which it probably won't be because of the new ease of passing a team on) it is irrelevant, since these teams will always be replaced and league competitiveness will not be nearly as affected. This may also help the player market by forcing people off of deadbeat teams.

Bort might take issue with this system making it easier for owners to sell teams for real life cash. I don't think this should be his biggest concern, however, considering the larger things at stake here. And player buying will always be a much bigger issue than team buying and this doesn't change that player buying. Or that fact that motivated people will always find a way to sell teams anyways.

I'm sure people will think of other things and so maybe i will edit this section later. Also, some complaints might be addressed in the section below.

Possible Modifications
*Make interim coaches able to sign players who will be free agents at the end of the season to promise contracts. These special contracts will only take effect if the team is not disbanded at the end of the year. Each signed promise contract with a player of appropriate level erases one "disband" vote from the end of season voting. I think this would probably be best but it comes with some possible problems so I left it out of the main part.
*For teams that don't wish to disband but don't have someone on the team who wishes to take over, make players able to add one other person (unrelated to the team) to the voting on their team's ballot if said player accepts. There could even be a forum where people who wish to take over a team but don't want to go through the normal system could advertise themselves. And the new possible owner would gain access to the forum to tell people why he would be good for the team. Maybe it could take multiple people to add an outsider to the ballot. I also think this would be best but it also comes with some problems.
*The time before the voting or the voting time itself could be modified.
*Special time frames could be adapted if a team becomes ownerless in the period of time more than a few days before the start of the season and less than four days before the end of the season.
*The rules could change to provide for at least one non-resetting team to be relegated each season. So if there are 3 resetting teams in a conference, then those three would drop down plus one more non-resetting team. An extra team would then need to be promoted. This would be a good change if even more mobility between league tiers is desired. Another similar but less harsh suggestion is that if a team doesn't win a game against a team that doesn't end up being reset (so they go 0-X against legit teams), they are automatically demoted.
*If there are non-resetting teams being relegated from a conference in which an extra team is getting promoted, then instead of an extra team being promoted from the league below, the non-resetting team that is getting relegated could just stay in it's current league. This would stop the "cascade of promotion" effect at this league. I don't like this idea but I think some people might.
*Instead of the voting being strictly based on player votes, a system could be implemented where each additional player on a team owned by the same person has marginally less voting power. For example, a good formula for this would be: Voting power gained by each additional Nth player = .9 ^ (N - 1). So the first player someone has on a team would give 1 voting power, the 2nd player .9 more, the 3rd .81, 4th .73, etc. Changing the coefficient to .8 would make a steeper curve and make the first player(s) worth more (1, .64, .51, .41...). I actually like this idea with a coefficient around .9 but I didn't put it in the main part because it's not that important and I thought it would bog down the post and confuse people.
*The ranking points system could take into account strength of conference (or league). I don't think there is currently a good way to do this. Comparing conference levels is a start, but is not enough to get accurate ratings (may be better than nothing as long as it wasn't factored in very hard). I would support this if a way could be figured out to accurately compare the strength of each conference. The only way I can think of now is if there were competitive games with teams on the same tier but different leagues, and a power ranking algorithm could determine the best conferences based on victories and point spreads of like teams. But room would have to be cleared in the schedule for this and I'm not sure it's worth it.
*The percent needed to save a team from resetting at the end of the season could be lowered for lower tier teams.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 06:03:09
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
I've posted 6 times in a row in this thread, why not go for a record breaking 7?
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Good solution. I still think there are steps that can be taken to reduce the number of owners who gut. If you think things are bad now, just wait. The current model for the game requires expansion teams to be created every season (who else would want low level players?). Wait til we don't have 1000 expansion teams every year to give low level players a place to play.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
"1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom."

Theres an easy solution to that. Promote 3 instead of the normal two. Or just only bring one down.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Good solution. I still think there are steps that can be taken to reduce the number of owners who gut. If you think things are bad now, just wait. The current model for the game requires expansion teams to be created every season (who else would want low level players?). Wait til we don't have 1000 expansion teams every year to give low level players a place to play.


Ya, this is a good point. My system will help with this since the bottom tier will contain all the new and gutted teams, and because teams will be promoted out of it more frequently keeping the average level low. But it still will be somewhat of a problem.

I think a good solution to this is to have the bottom tier have the same number of teams as the second to bottom tier, and have teams be double promoted out of the bottom tier. So any team that makes the conference finals at the bottom gets promoted. This will help keep the bottom for only low level players and resetting teams, since the current pyramid model requires half the teams to be at the bottom tier which just won't work long term.

So a league pyramid could look like this (of course the pyramid will be bigger, but just for examples sake)...

Edit: NM, can't draw a pyramid cause multiple spaces are erased.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 16:04:16
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Bump.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
This forum moves too fast.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Greengoose:

This plan will help with slow building teams by moving them all to the lowest division when they are created. No more teams making slow building teams in upper and medium tier leagues which is much more of a problem. People should expect some really bad and weird teams at the lowest level, and bad teams will be moved there more quickly under my system. But it won't change anything besides that regarding slow building and I don't think that's necessarily a negative thing. But this is getting off-topic and a discussion for another thread.

I agree that promotion and relegation can be painful in leagues where there is a high level difference between tiers. Unfortunately this is a result of how Bort created the teams and the order of league creation, and a problem in the current system, not a problem specific to my proposal (not saying how he did it was bad).

Originally posted by greengoose

I think the real problem is there are more teams in GLB than there is capable owners to run them in the first place.


Well no argument there but at least this system does a better job of concentrating all the incapable owners at the bottom. A lot of bad owners are new owners, just because experience is important and bad owners are more likely to quit after a few seasons.


If you are gonna reward every team that slowbuilds - pretty soon EVERYBODY will slowbuild because they know it's the "TICKET" to get down to the lowest leagues.

Slow built teams aren't gutted teams - they aren't sold back. Your proposal only addressed sold back teams unless I misunderstood it.

Personally, I don't think "slow build" teams should be rewarded at all.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 16:33:56
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
Originally posted by seayjoel

well thought out solution to gutting: DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN!!! All trades should have to be approved my a Mod if they see that team A is trading everything for little they can take a look into it and if they feel that they are trying to gut because the owner doesn't want to own a team any more they can reject, and retract all the trades and have the owner sell his team in a responsible manner


This doesn't stop gutting. It just stops the fire sale of players that is a result of gutting. At least when an owner sells all his players, the new owner is left with cash to try and rebuild. If this wasn't allowed, then the owner would sell and all the player contracts would expire (or they would be dropped) at the end of the season and you are now left with a gutted team and no cash in the bank.

Then put up limits to the amount of players that can be cut i don't care how they do it Gutting should just be stopped.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seayjoel
Originally posted by nottom
Originally posted by seayjoel
well thought out solution to gutting: DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN!!! All trades should have to be approved my a Mod if they see that team A is trading everything for little they can take a look into it and if they feel that they are trying to gut because the owner doesn't want to own a team any more they can reject, and retract all the trades and have the owner sell his team in a responsible manner


This doesn't stop gutting. It just stops the fire sale of players that is a result of gutting. At least when an owner sells all his players, the new owner is left with cash to try and rebuild. If this wasn't allowed, then the owner would sell and all the player contracts would expire (or they would be dropped) at the end of the season and you are now left with a gutted team and no cash in the bank.

Then put up limits to the amount of players that can be cut i don't care how they do it Gutting should just be stopped.


So....your solution to "Everybody lets their contract expire" is to limit the number of cuts further than two a day. Brilliant. That fixes absolutely nothing and breaks several other things in the process. It just might get implemented.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seayjoel
Originally posted by nottom

Originally posted by seayjoel


well thought out solution to gutting: DO NOT LET IT HAPPEN!!! All trades should have to be approved my a Mod if they see that team A is trading everything for little they can take a look into it and if they feel that they are trying to gut because the owner doesn't want to own a team any more they can reject, and retract all the trades and have the owner sell his team in a responsible manner


This doesn't stop gutting. It just stops the fire sale of players that is a result of gutting. At least when an owner sells all his players, the new owner is left with cash to try and rebuild. If this wasn't allowed, then the owner would sell and all the player contracts would expire (or they would be dropped) at the end of the season and you are now left with a gutted team and no cash in the bank.

Then put up limits to the amount of players that can be cut i don't care how they do it Gutting should just be stopped.


It can't be stopped - thats the problem.

If I have 10 players on a team and I decide to quit GLB then that owner has to replace 10 players. If he chooses not to do that then the team likely gets sold back and the remaining players are "released" at the end of their contracts (or sooner if the owner can actually release them).

You can't hold players hostage to sold back teams - because thats functionally the same thing as an owner taking a player with a multi-year contract off the depth chart for spite. "You can't leave because I won't let you".

The reality is players sign contract to play for "owners" and to play with other "agents" - not to be the property of a team.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose

If you are gonna reward every team that slowbuilds - pretty soon EVERYBODY will slowbuild because they know it's the "TICKET" to get down to the lowest leagues.

Slow built teams aren't gutted teams - they aren't sold back. Your proposal only addressed sold back teams unless I misunderstood it.

Personally, I don't think "slow build" teams should be rewarded at all.


My system doesn't reward slowbuilding. The "TICKET" to getting to the bottom tier leagues is losing a lot or getting a new team. Most slowbuilt teams are made from new teams. Teams shouldn't want to be at the bottom and so this isn't rewarding them.

Quit trying to hijack my thread, and if you are going to, at least try to make sense.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Slowbuild team gets the benefits of an established team's camaraderie as well as "the best" way to build a team, and they no longer have the detriment of having to spend seasons losing because they're in overmatched leagues as they'd be in the lowest tier against a bunch of teams they'd just waltz over.

I think that's what goose is trying to get at, anyway.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Oldskool summed it up nicely.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Originally posted by greengoose


If you are gonna reward every team that slowbuilds - pretty soon EVERYBODY will slowbuild because they know it's the "TICKET" to get down to the lowest leagues.

Slow built teams aren't gutted teams - they aren't sold back. Your proposal only addressed sold back teams unless I misunderstood it.

Personally, I don't think "slow build" teams should be rewarded at all.


My system doesn't reward slowbuilding. The "TICKET" to getting to the bottom tier leagues is losing a lot or getting a new team. Most slowbuilt teams are made from new teams. Teams shouldn't want to be at the bottom and so this isn't rewarding them.

Quit trying to hijack my thread, and if you are going to, at least try to make sense.



You never addressed what I said before though. I agree gutted teams should be moved down before a new owner takes over. The problem is the landscape of competitive balance won't change much as you still have teams that are just poorly run and also teams that purposely choose to blow their teams up and start from scratch.

Your proposal addresses just one of a multitude of issues that create competitive imbalance and 144-0 games.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 17:27:42
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.