Originally posted by joeyjojok wow pretty anal today... heres another free bump for you...
and your punters arent even that good, you are only 1/3 of what your posible lvl could be by time you retire... do you think your punter should hit coffin corner punts when he isnt even finished growing up yet???
Let's take a different look at this instead of trying to push everyone else out of the way to be the first to flame a thread. If you do that, you're only showing that douchebaggery is your primary skill in life.
I consider "Football" attributes as things that have to do with mechanics, technique, and knowing the nuances of the position/task. For example, a quarterback with 90 in throwing might be able to recognize when a receiver is gaining separation before the corners do, but if he only has 20 vision, he can't see the receiver getting wide open 40 yards downfield, whereas he'd be able to do so 5 yards from the LOS.
Now, let's bring it back to punting. I don't know what every punter's build is, but let's say there are a LOT of points in punting (Over 90, hypothetically). IMO, it is safe to assume that this punter knows what he needs to do in order to pull off a "coffin corner" punt. May not be able to execute it every time due to the odd nature of the ball's movement when bouncing, but he knows how to do it. Now, if he's got a lot of strength and vision, he should be able to get it close to pinned down inside the 10 with regularity.
However, even with attributes, that doesn't seem to be happening. My team's punter has 95+ punting, 50+ strength, 40+ vision, and the only way his punts get downed inside the 5 are if he's able to boom it 60 yards and one of the gunners downs it when it sputters out inside the 5.
Long story longer, the better punters in the league, with their attributes where they are now, should be able to pull off coffin corner punts in my opinion.
When triggering "Coffin Corner" punt: Set a vector target inside the 5 yard line at either sideline. Punter randomly picks which sideline to kick to. Calculate angle between vertical and sideline chosen with punter as angle origin. Utilize whatever accuracy calculations you've got for punters to give +/- on that angle as well as +/- on the power to determine if it makes it out of bounds (and where) or if it bounces first.