User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Bort comments on the gutting epidemic
Page:
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chrome
Originally posted by Reggie Smash

Exactly. Just sweep starting from the top & moving on down. I don't see what's so difficult about it.

Sure its a nice fix for next season, but you'll just be right back to the same thing within 4 seasons. Its actually funny listening to you guys, in a depressing sort of way. Have any of you even actually had a losing season in GLB? Do you have any idea what it does to a team?

And don't think it won't happen to you, b/c statistically its going to.

When they relegate this off-season, I'll most likely have to ask to get moved down to the next league. I simply won't be able to compete against the winning AA teams who'll be moving up. They've all had 3 seasons of winning to build up their stadiums and talent, while the near .500 teams like my own are slowly bled dry by free agency and the broken economical system.



No, but our old owner ditched with the starting HB, WR, a few of the guards, LB's and Safties. And we came back the next season and went 11-5 after busting our ass for, I would say 10+ collective recruiting hours a day.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chrome
Originally posted by Reggie Smash

Exactly. Just sweep starting from the top & moving on down. I don't see what's so difficult about it.

Sure its a nice fix for next season, but you'll just be right back to the same thing within 4 seasons. Its actually funny listening to you guys, in a depressing sort of way. Have any of you even actually had a losing season in GLB? Do you have any idea what it does to a team?

And don't think it won't happen to you, b/c statistically its going to.

When they relegate this off-season, I'll most likely have to ask to get moved down to the next league. I simply won't be able to compete against the winning AA teams who'll be moving up. They've all had 3 seasons of winning to build up their stadiums and talent, while the near .500 teams like my own are slowly bled dry by free agency and the broken economical system.




That's a big part of the point on why just increasing the promotions and bumps down a lvl isn't enough. By shifting all the teams in your position all the way to the bottom, you will be able to compete on a more lvl playing field. A much higher % (if not all) teams in your conference would also be rebuilding. I'd have to believe that it would be far more enjoyable to play in those games than in game after game that a rebuilding team has no chance of doing anything but getting throttled.

As far as the rest of your post goes, I understand what you're talking about. I GM for a team in Canada. When the teams were released there (little less than 2 seasons ago), I recruited all lvl 1-4 players, while everyone else was going for players in the teens and 20s. We also got hosed by getting 1-2 less home games than most of the teams in our league that season. So, we started off with under lvled players and less $. We've catching up fast now in the lvls (and our builds rock compared to most teams), but are still sucking ass in the $ area.

For what it's worth, if you outline a clear vision of what you are going to accomplish as a team and show the steps you will take to get there, I've found that helps a lot with the players. I do agree though. It is EXTREMELY hard to turn a team around. I think by far the biggest screw job in this game is done to the new guys that buy gutted teams.

 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by palmer_garnett_95
Feel free to just hang out here instead of up there. I agree that would be the best way to do it. I just don't see Bort doing something that simple.


Actually, I probably will, thanks bud.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Oh, and doing this once isn't the solution. In reality, I think you should leave # of teams moved up & down each season the same and then apply what I described at the end of every season. IMO, though there are many reasons owners sell back and it could never be stopped, the biggest one is that their team can't win. By putting them in leagues where they stand a chance, far more owners will keep their teams. I think that makes it important enough to justify applying this every season, myself (while at the same time trying to level the financial playing field a bit also...I think it's crap that you can sell tickets for more the higher you go, but teams in BBB are competing for the same players as teams in the Pros and are supposed to win up to face the teams that have always had an advantage over yours).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PP
Oh, and doing this once isn't the solution. In reality, I think you should leave # of teams moved up & down each season the same and then apply what I described at the end of every season. IMO, though there are many reasons owners sell back and it could never be stopped, the biggest one is that their team can't win. By putting them in leagues where they stand a chance, far more owners will keep their teams. I think that makes it important enough to justify applying this every season, myself (while at the same time trying to level the financial playing field a bit also...I think it's crap that you can sell tickets for more the higher you go, but teams in BBB are competing for the same players as teams in the Pros and are supposed to win up to face the teams that have always had an advantage over yours).


Here's what I have to say about this topic:

Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Here's the fucking deal:

A solution to the problem is necessary, but you must fix the symptoms as well - especially when the symptoms are creating additional problems. You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat? THAT'S NOT HELPING THEIR IMMEDIATE SITUATION.


I don't know why people (as in Bort and his fanbois) want to fuse the symptoms of gutting and the systemic cause of gutting. They are related, but the two issues have different solutions. If Bort fixed the case of gutting, we'd still have Pac 10 Blitz for at least 5 more seasons.


*only posting this here becuase if I find the thread where people are actually talking about it, the fanbois will go bonkers.


 
PP
offline
Link
 
I agree, palmer. I see them as 2 different issues also (though they do feed off one another), and think it's beyond ridiculous to invest everything into stopping it when A) It can never be stopped completely & B) I'd double phthalatemagic's estimate to 10 seasons before it would be shifted out even if it was stopped today.
 
Carnage
offline
Link
 
What I think SHOULD..happen is whenever there is a gutted team they should be moved down to the lowest level league they are in. In case of USA..from Pro down to BBB..and teams should move up accordingly...If there are 2 gutted teams in Pro..then at the end of the season..those teams should be moved down to BBB. When you take into account those who move up because of winning then you go to the next team. Which would of course be the teams the winners faced in the conference finals..

So basically a total of 4 teams would leave pro.. 2 delegated because of losing and 2 because of Gutting..and 4 would come in from AAA..and thus because of 2 going from gutting..on that season 4 would move up from every league into the next highest. of course this would only happen in terms of Gutting..
 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
how about every season have the server do a massive restructure based on lvl. get away from the names USA pro and Europe pro, and just have Eagle league, Bear league, and such. teams of equal lvl will be placed in leagues accordingly. the prize then would be winning your league, and then trying to win in a different league every season.

Just an idea, but i also think lvls should be removed from players. have xp be a factor in gaining sp's, but dont consider players as lvl 1-60 and such, just grab them based off of their abilities.
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
This thread is too long. Someone just make the problems go away.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 01:26:43
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
I wrote up a proposal for a large system of changes to address this problem. It doesn't make it go away completely but I think gets rid of a large portion of the problem while still remaining realistic. You can read about it at http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1106137&page=3 and I will paste the summary below:


Summary
When a team loses it's owner, instead of receiving a random Joe from the queue, their new owner is either appointed by the old owner out of the GMs or voted on by the team. If the owner is appointed by votes, the players vote again at the end of the year to decide if the team is disbanded or continues on. These votes are backed by contracts. If the team chooses to disband, or nobody volunteers to be on the ballot, or if the team is financially insolvent, then the team is erased and all the players are free agents. A new team is created at a bottom tier league and teams are promoted to take the place in each tier at and below the resetting team. The current relegation/promotion system will still be scheduled, but when extra intra-league flow is required from teams resetting, teams will be promoted based on an automatic ranking system. This system will value playoffs and the most recent years the highest.

 
Romeorr
offline
Link
 
the only problem i see with this idea is will the new owner if voted by the team have to pay flex pts. If he does have to pay flex pts, then if the players vote to disband the team will he get his flex pts back? This could also cause some problems if more than one gm wanted to be the owner. Could cause some disgruntled gm to release or trade some players just to get back at the team for not making him the owner.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romeorr
the only problem i see with this idea is will the new owner if voted by the team have to pay flex pts. If he does have to pay flex pts, then if the players vote to disband the team will he get his flex pts back? This could also cause some problems if more than one gm wanted to be the owner. Could cause some disgruntled gm to release or trade some players just to get back at the team for not making him the owner.


To answer your first question, he has to pay flex points only if the team chooses to not disband. I'm not sure this is the best solution, however, and it might best for him to have to make a deposit to get his name on the ballot or maybe after he wins (it's not that many FP after all, and it would get returned if they disband).

As to your second point, it makes sense that some bitter GMs might want to do get back at the team or something a small percent of the time, but if things go to a vote then all ability of the GMs to deal with contracts is suspended till the end of the season (I actually didn't make this clear in my main proposal and need to modify it). And if he is bitter because the owner didn't pick him, then the new owner who did get picked can change permissions if he is worried about this.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 19:14:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.