User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot
Originally posted by d1sregard

Hi. Football.

QBs pump fake to confuse safeties and spying LBs, not corner backs playing man-to-man. It can also be effective against zone schemes.

Bye. Fail.


Yea, seems thats a point people are sorely overlooking here. CBs in man2man coverage arent looking at the QB enough to be pump-faked...It just doesn't happen...They sometimes sneak a peek, but even then the QBs either not looking, or can't pump-fake him before he stops looking.

CBs in m2m should not be suceptible to pump-fakes, ever. Its called MAN to MAN for a reason, 'not man 2 QB'.

You can tell this Ken dude is lobbying hard for WRs cuz he even thinks the man2man coverage should be nerfed. Geeze you'd make a great politician man! lol


Until, as in real life, zone is as common a coverage as man to man, man to man needs to be weakened and zone improved.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot

Originally posted by d1sregard


Hi. Football.

QBs pump fake to confuse safeties and spying LBs, not corner backs playing man-to-man. It can also be effective against zone schemes.

Bye. Fail.


Yea, seems thats a point people are sorely overlooking here. CBs in man2man coverage arent looking at the QB enough to be pump-faked...It just doesn't happen...They sometimes sneak a peek, but even then the QBs either not looking, or can't pump-fake him before he stops looking.

CBs in m2m should not be suceptible to pump-fakes, ever. Its called MAN to MAN for a reason, 'not man 2 QB'.

You can tell this Ken dude is lobbying hard for WRs cuz he even thinks the man2man coverage should be nerfed. Geeze you'd make a great politician man! lol


Until, as in real life, zone is as common a coverage as man to man, man to man needs to be weakened and zone improved.


Don't weaken man to man. That isn't the problem currently, It's working as intended.

The problem is zone coverage, and the fact it's incredibly flawed, and covering passes at all is a giant farce.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Ken1


Until, as in real life, zone is as common a coverage as man to man, man to man needs to be weakened and zone improved.


Don't weaken man to man. That isn't the problem currently, It's working as intended.

The problem is zone coverage, and the fact it's incredibly flawed, and covering passes at all is a giant farce.


Zones aren't as bad as you make them out to be, although I do support improving them. They don't work as well as they ought to.

We need, as in real life, "We can't shut them down man to man, so we'll have to play zone" to be said more often (even if it's the DC saying it to himself).

We especially need to make it tough to play really tight M2M, as opposed to M2M with a couple of yards of cushion.
 
Link
 
Pump fake works waaaaaaay too often for huge gains. That's not realistic. It should work, but not so regularly. It's even working on a regular basis against CBs with very high vision and super vision SA points. Lame and not like real football at all.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Pump fake works waaaaaaay too often for huge gains. That's not realistic. It should work, but not so regularly. It's even working on a regular basis against CBs with very high vision and super vision SA points. Lame and not like real football at all.


 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Pump fake works waaaaaaay too often for huge gains. That's not realistic. It should work, but not so regularly. It's even working on a regular basis against CBs with very high vision and super vision SA points. Lame and not like real football at all.


You can say that all you want, but passing stats in GLB were still below real life passing stats. If pump fakes were nerfed, we could easily be back to defense dominating.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Our defense has been pretty damn good since our team has been around, and I would guess that at least half the passing yards we've given up have been on Touchdown scoring plays. It seems like we give up a lot more really big plays than we should, and the culprit seems to be the way the CB's react to the various offensive fakes (and the terrible safety AI). I can understand that it's hard to cover man to man, but the way the coverage guys stop on a dime and stand there for 2 seconds when they get faked is what gets me. The fake recovery time needs to be shortened significantly.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Pump fake works waaaaaaay too often for huge gains. That's not realistic. It should work, but not so regularly. It's even working on a regular basis against CBs with very high vision and super vision SA points. Lame and not like real football at all.


Can you provide an example of an 60 vision, 6 Super Vision CB gets faked out badly?
 
spionkopwa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB


Can you provide an example of an 60 vision, 6 Super Vision CB gets faked out badly?


That... must be a lot of money invested just to prevent pumpfake (but wait you may not have enough speed to catch up of the head fake and wait you can totally prevent pumpfake but still you have juke to deal with and wait the power back can run over you and so on)
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by spionkopwa
Originally posted by RAPB



Can you provide an example of an 60 vision, 6 Super Vision CB gets faked out badly?


That... must be a lot of money invested just to prevent pumpfake (but wait you may not have enough speed to catch up of the head fake and wait you can totally prevent pumpfake but still you have juke to deal with and wait the power back can run over you and so on)


Because, of course, your player should be perfect and nothing should be able to beat him.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by spionkopwa

Originally posted by RAPB




Can you provide an example of an 60 vision, 6 Super Vision CB gets faked out badly?


That... must be a lot of money invested just to prevent pumpfake (but wait you may not have enough speed to catch up of the head fake and wait you can totally prevent pumpfake but still you have juke to deal with and wait the power back can run over you and so on)


Because, of course, your player should be perfect and nothing should be able to beat him.


ding ding ding

Even the top CBs get beat in every damn football league across the world. No one is immune to biting on a pump fake or getting beat by a WR.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by spionkopwa

Originally posted by RAPB




Can you provide an example of an 60 vision, 6 Super Vision CB gets faked out badly?


That... must be a lot of money invested just to prevent pumpfake (but wait you may not have enough speed to catch up of the head fake and wait you can totally prevent pumpfake but still you have juke to deal with and wait the power back can run over you and so on)


Because, of course, your player should be perfect and nothing should be able to beat him.


He has a point though.

In real football, players dont miss half as many tackles as they do in this game. A real life Cornerback can be a very good cover guy and a good tackler, there isn't necessarily a big trade off, at least in starting-quality CBs. Maybe Marion Barber will steamroll a CB in the open field once in awhile, but for the most part you dont see Powerbacks just wrecking everyone for entire games.

But in GLB, if you want to be fast enough to cover a speedy WR and have high enough vision to avoid the headfake/pumpfake combo, you might not have enough points to be a good tackler.

Players shouldnt be perfect in this game, but hoping for a higher degree of realism is not asking too much.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by spionkopwa


Originally posted by RAPB





Can you provide an example of an 60 vision, 6 Super Vision CB gets faked out badly?


That... must be a lot of money invested just to prevent pumpfake (but wait you may not have enough speed to catch up of the head fake and wait you can totally prevent pumpfake but still you have juke to deal with and wait the power back can run over you and so on)


Because, of course, your player should be perfect and nothing should be able to beat him.


He has a point though.

In real football, players dont miss half as many tackles as they do in this game. A real life Cornerback can be a very good cover guy and a good tackler, there isn't necessarily a big trade off, at least in starting-quality CBs. Maybe Marion Barber will steamroll a CB in the open field once in awhile, but for the most part you dont see Powerbacks just wrecking everyone for entire games.

But in GLB, if you want to be fast enough to cover a speedy WR and have high enough vision to avoid the headfake/pumpfake combo, you might not have enough points to be a good tackler.

Players shouldnt be perfect in this game, but hoping for a higher degree of realism is not asking too much.


But you really only see that in the lower leagues. Higher leveled players with halfway decent builds don't miss that many tackles. If you go watch a peewee level football game you're going to see a lot of mess.
 
Link
 
Man2Man does not need to be nerfed, I dont knwo what games your watching, but it seems like the perverbial 'playing field' is pretty even to me. WRs succeed against M2M coverage all the time, even against CBs with very good builds, I see it every game. Zone need some work, alot of work, yes, but M2M seems to be working fine.

The problem with fakes is the severity of them, theres no reason why a CB should ever just stop running completely as his assignment streaks down the field, he should be thrown off his path a bit but theres no reason he would just stop running, as soon as a CB gets faked, he knows it. That said, he should never stop moving.

I understand not all fakes are pump fakes Bort but thats not the issue. Maybe it wouldnt seem like such a flaw if the safety AI was a bit more realistic, but as of right now, safeties look lost alot of the time and do not play their assignments correctly. All too often I see a SS blowing his coverage and comming up on a TE running a hitch while WR#2 is streaking down the field. Hardly every do we see the SS play his coverage responsibilities correctly in such a situation.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 21:30:58
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cosmoxl
Originally posted by shield.bearer

Originally posted by datongw


Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.


unless they are playing 'go for picks' or aggressive style...in which case, you take the risk of getting faked out by the QB.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.