User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > percentages in training bars should be included in sim calculations
Page:
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
the point of my original post is that the new integer-based system marks a radical departure from how things worked in the past. it really doesn't matter to me if we stay decimal-based or switch to integer-based... i'm just curious why we have a mishmash of both. honestly, it feels like complexity for the sake of complexity... but then, i have the same questions about why we now have four types of currency (FP/TP/ST/BT) when it seems that two (possibly even just one) type would do.


I can totally agree with this. I'm just hoping we are in a transitional phase right now and we will move one way or the other by the end of this season.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
very interesting solution, btw... but until balanced players are rewarded by the sim, targeted builds would remain the best choice.


Oh yeah, that would definitely have to be a part of it too. However, it would be nice in the mean time to have a "stacked" build (i.e. one or two extremely high skills) be less efficient to put together, not more efficient like it currently is.
 
coach
offline
Link
 
I'd like to see some sort of option here. I don't mind the training bar idea, and having decimals doesn't bother me. BUT IMO there is an issue with how this is currently set up.

To see any progress you have to train something over the 100% mark, which is fine. But then once you pass it, you may pass it by quite a bit which makes it difficult to switch training to something else. If I'm at 95%, train to get over 100%, but then see that I'm now at 30%... I'm thinking "crap, I don't want to waste that 30%... might as well stick with it."

This is a potentially endless cycle. It would be nice if we could convert % to decimals, and possibly vice versa (for those wanting to "clean up" the decimals). The suggestion here of using the % as part of the calculation would also do it, though it seems like a conversion would be easier to implement.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
^
heck, i'd be down for any remaining percentage being converted to decimals on the fly (i.e. if you add +20% to 90%, you get 100%+0.1)

i'll support anything that either avoids stray percentages or makes them useful.
 
tsosumi
offline
Link
 
from another post by me regarding this issue:

looking at upgrading my guards equip. strength is at 59.96 and blocking is at 59.01

roughly 12% training increase. One peice of equipment left to upgrade, at 50k per peice. Old system, upgrade blocking train strength for one day. roughly equal.

new system, upgrade one item and train 8 or 9 days worth of tokens to get the same thing. yes, i want to spend 1/4 of this season doing what would have taken me one days worth of training last season to do.

this is just not one player for me. it is several.

qb
60.95 vis
39.91 conf

wr
xx.83 carry

these are issues surrounding build planning, equip upgrades, team money management, player money management, and moving seamlessly from one trianing method to another.

to not roll past training efforts into the new training method is giving the finger to all those who planned their builds including daily training and level stat increases and sp allocations.
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Speaking of fraction, decimal points and percentages.

Is there a script that allows you to see the progress in the training bars similar to the one for the scouting bars?
 
joeflex73
offline
Link
 
I don't see why the bars were added in the first place other than to give an RPG "lvl up" feel. We could've had the new training, used the current % as decimals and had them added immediately to the stats like before.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Speaking of fraction, decimal points and percentages.
Is there a script that allows you to see the progress in the training bars similar to the one for the scouting bars?


not that i know of, but the numbers are right there in the page source so it wouldn't be that hard... i'll go suggest it in the greasemonkey forum.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Speaking of fraction, decimal points and percentages.
Is there a script that allows you to see the progress in the training bars similar to the one for the scouting bars?


not that i know of, but the numbers are right there in the page source so it wouldn't be that hard... i'll go suggest it in the greasemonkey forum.


Mouse over and it tells you exact percent
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Mouse over and it tells you exact percent


true, but it would be nice to have it statically displayed... a la the 'scouting bar numbers' script.

 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Another stimulating thread by Catullus.

The sim does actually support the decimals, and will always support decimal values (Bort said this somewhere, I remember). So there is literally no difference between 10.99 and 11. And in all actuality, there is no difference between 10 and 10.99. I think that if you ran simulations with teams that had the exact same stats, except that one team had +0.99 in every attribute, you probably wouldn't find any conclusive results that 0.99 makes a large scale, or even a small scale difference.

However, I agree with the basic premise of what Catullus is arguing. What is the point in showing a training bar AND having decimals? I mean, these should/could be just combined into one. It really doesn't make sense to have them separate. Just choose one or the other for visual purposes, because neither choice will affect the way the sim runs...
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Another stimulating thread by Catullus.

ha... but didn't i PM you this thread like a half-week ago?

Originally posted by saintedix
The sim does actually support the decimals, and will always support decimal values (Bort said this somewhere, I remember).

indeed... and i can dig up the link, but i don't think too many people are fuzzy on that point. one thing we don't have an explicit confirmation on is whether or not the training percentages are included in sim calculations. we're all dang sure they're not, but technically we're just assuming.

either way, i agree with you agreeing with me. consistency just makes sense... complexity for the sake of complexity = bad.
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16

ha... but didn't i PM you this thread like a half-week ago?


Unread PM's are like wine, better with age

Just kidding, I just was waiting to see what a few people were saying before I jumped in. And yea, I'm pretty sure the training bars aren't included in the sim. It just doesn't make sense to have decimals that count in the sim and bars that don't. Especially when the two are completely unrelated now, and merging them seems like the simplest solution, regardless of whether the new merged/decimal values are used in the sim or not.
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 01:31:10
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
^
i completely agree.
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
It is kind of weird that we can train something and not see any benefit from it until we get to 100% in the progress bar. I wonder if there was some specific reason it was done like that.


I think it's to discourage slow building a bit
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.