User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by robelder

Originally posted by Joe_B


If home teams are giving up any revenue then we should get a homefield advantage..maybe +10% accross all attributes or something like that. If your going to take something from home teams in the playoffs then home teams should get some kind of advantage, and it should be a significant advantage.


Agreed and both should be done is season 6.


LOL - I hope this is a joke - the fact that you get the #1 seed and get what should be the easiest road through the playoffs isn't enough of an advantage? Please. Why even have the games -- a 10% advantage across all attributes -- you can't be serious.

And for the record, you aren't giving up revenue -- every team gets 8 home games during the season -- the playoffs are their own animal and noone is guaranteed a spot (as much as some teams like to feel they are, they still have to earn it) -- some amount of revenue sharing with other playoff bound teams is fair and required -- sorry some of you don't get this.

Joe -- I'm sorry, but your suggestion that home teams get that sort of advantage over away teams is absolutely laughable, as is Rob's agreeing its a good idea, but given his life view, I expect nothing less.


You don't answer any of my questions to you SCACE. Thanks for being polite though in disagreeing. I appreciate that and will extend the same to you.

Home games during the season should get an advantage as well, not just playoffs. That is very realistic. If you want our money in the playoffs to make it realistic, then make home field advantage count and give us the fans causing false starts and the other team botching plays under the intense field noise and miscommunication on routes. That is real in all sports. Home teams in general play better in any sport.

I am giving up revenue in the playoffs I would have earned, so yes I am losing playoff revenue.
 
Joe_B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by robelder

Originally posted by Joe_B


If home teams are giving up any revenue then we should get a homefield advantage..maybe +10% accross all attributes or something like that. If your going to take something from home teams in the playoffs then home teams should get some kind of advantage, and it should be a significant advantage.


Agreed and both should be done is season 6.


LOL - I hope this is a joke - the fact that you get the #1 seed and get what should be the easiest road through the playoffs isn't enough of an advantage? Please. Why even have the games -- a 10% advantage across all attributes -- you can't be serious.

And for the record, you aren't giving up revenue -- every team gets 8 home games during the season -- the playoffs are their own animal and noone is guaranteed a spot (as much as some teams like to feel they are, they still have to earn it) -- some amount of revenue sharing with other playoff bound teams is fair and required -- sorry some of you don't get this.

Joe -- I'm sorry, but your suggestion that home teams get that sort of advantage over away teams is absolutely laughable, as is Rob's agreeing its a good idea, but given his life view, I expect nothing less.



You are giving up revenue, allowing other teams a cut of ticket sales from YOUR stadium means that YOU ARE NOT receiving all the revenue from that game played at ,again, YOUR STADIUM. Personaly i don't agree that other teams, my competition, should benefit from my fanacial planning. I've balanced and juggled my money for 5 seasons to max my stadium. It's not fair.

Here is something else that is not fair about it,
I will make more than 5 mil from a playoff home game this season, lets say i'm the #1 seed and that the revenue sharing is 25%, with me being the #1 seed that means the #8 seed would get, at a 25% share of revenue, with my max stadium and ticket pricing the ticket sales would be more than 5 mill and the #8 seed will get more that 1.25 mil.

Now lets assume that the # 2 seed is the warpath from my confrence, http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=390
they don't have a fully upgraded stadium and only do 4mil in ticket sales, that means the #7 seed would get a only 1 mil, again at 25% of home team revenue.

So the lower seed makes more money...what is fair about that.




My +10% was just an extreme example, but a home field advantage has been talked about as long as revenue sharing has been talked about. And if your going to bring in a suggestion to benefit those who don't secure any home playoff games, i think an advantage for home playoff teams need to be brought in.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
/ \ Wow great point. I haven't thought of that yet.
|
 
OUdomination
offline
Link
 
Great point Joe!
 
Weykool
offline
Link
 
What if instead of sharing revenue we just put a cap on what a team can charge for a home playoff game?
Instead of a 70-20-10 split we only allow teams to sell tickets for 2.0 times expected rather than 2.5-3.0 times.
Instead of giving playoff teams a meaningless 100K, 200K, 300K, and 400K we up that amount to 1 mil, 2 mil, 3 mil and 4 mil per round.
We then allow non-playoff teams to sell tickets to home exhibition games at 40%-50% of expected for thier two games with no concessions.
In the end the money would be about the same and there would be no bitching about teams having to share "their money" with other teams.
 
allstarpdc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NTNSTY
allstar, you're assuming that the revenue would be shared with teams that didn't make the playoffs - I don't think that's safe to assume. Even if the Devs decide to share with all teams, the financial consequence doesn't have to be extreme. I think the main problem with the current system is that you can make the playoffs and still not get much money as a reward - it requires home playoff games. If the revenue share is amongst the playoff teams only, I'm sure it'll turn out better than the current system.


But you are still punishing the best teams that worked hard scouting, gameplanning, etc. that got the #1 & #2 seeds A LOT. We already don't have home-field advantage worked into the game & now the biggest advantage to earning a top seed will be gone.
And getting the "easiest road in the playoffs" as an advantage isn't an advantage...TONS of #1 seeds lost to #8 last season. The sim can throw anything at you in the playoffs & any team can win.

Also...teams that never took the initiative to build up their stadiums because they offered stupid-high salaries to get players on their teams now will be rewarded for it.

I just think all that stinks.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Weykool
What if instead of sharing revenue we just put a cap on what a team can charge for a home playoff game?
Instead of a 70-20-10 split we only allow teams to sell tickets for 2.0 times expected rather than 2.5-3.0 times.
Instead of giving playoff teams a meaningless 100K, 200K, 300K, and 400K we up that amount to 1 mil, 2 mil, 3 mil and 4 mil per round.
We then allow non-playoff teams to sell tickets to home exhibition games at 40%-50% of expected for thier two games with no concessions.
In the end the money would be about the same and there would be no bitching about teams having to share "their money" with other teams.


I'm not totally for or against. I like that you're working on ideas to improve it. That is the discussion we need. Your numbers per round are too high. I think 250, 500, 750, & 1 mil would be better. People shouldn't be building stadiums so fast and that is part of the bonus problem, but selling exhibition games does seem fair. I think that teams should be able to sell those tickets at whatever price they choose though. Bort can control what they make through his formulas.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by beachsand


Shouldn't the SA go up on the level 8/24. Equipment starts at level 1 then goes to level 8, then 16, then 24, etc. Every other level means 8, 24, 40.


No, advanced equipment starts as the equivalent of a level 1 item. So level 8 is the first upgrade.


okay I see your point.
 
goblu96
offline
Link
 
Was looking for people thoughts on this section of Bort's last post:

CPU's will be improved a bit to help the team not become a complete steamroll cupcake team. I've been playing with various levels to find one where the CPU's still generally lose, but put up enough of a fight to not lose by 200 points. I've got a script to run that will update current CPUs to be better as well, but this will take a bit to update since there are quite a few of them!



My concern with doing this mid-season is that it will never allow my players from a stats perspective to catch up. In other words giving more of an advantage to those teams and players who have already played the "gutted" teams, making it even harder for my players to get trophies.

Not sure you are planning on implementing this immediately but my recommendation is to wait.... Any other thoughts?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by goblu96
Was looking for people thoughts on this section of Bort's last post:

CPU's will be improved a bit to help the team not become a complete steamroll cupcake team. I've been playing with various levels to find one where the CPU's still generally lose, but put up enough of a fight to not lose by 200 points. I've got a script to run that will update current CPUs to be better as well, but this will take a bit to update since there are quite a few of them!



My concern with doing this mid-season is that it will never allow my players from a stats perspective to catch up. In other words giving more of an advantage to those teams and players who have already played the "gutted" teams, making it even harder for my players to get trophies.

Not sure you are planning on implementing this immediately but my recommendation is to wait.... Any other thoughts?



I would go with no CPU player can get trophies. That is a solution
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
This proves my point. It is not a money issue but a strategy issue. If you give money to the poor they continue to squander it.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1141739&page=15#8894129

Originally posted by xnahog

Originally posted by djfivenine


Discuss....

I always thought it was a decent idea. Not because the 5th-8th seed need some rewards, it's just the 1-4th teams get around $2.5 million for each game, and that is a lot, especially for teams that are just starting out.
That's 5 extra players that they can get from free agency or the cash trade market.


Socialism


That is the problem. Teams that put their money into trades and high dollar FA's and don't spend on there stadium. This is my point. The problem is not money but the strategy of the players and that is why it doesn't matter.

Good owners will spend on their stadium unless it is at max seating and if that is the case you have plenty of money to buy players already.

 
stumanroo
blame stu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beachsand
Originally posted by goblu96

Was looking for people thoughts on this section of Bort's last post:

CPU's will be improved a bit to help the team not become a complete steamroll cupcake team. I've been playing with various levels to find one where the CPU's still generally lose, but put up enough of a fight to not lose by 200 points. I've got a script to run that will update current CPUs to be better as well, but this will take a bit to update since there are quite a few of them!



My concern with doing this mid-season is that it will never allow my players from a stats perspective to catch up. In other words giving more of an advantage to those teams and players who have already played the "gutted" teams, making it even harder for my players to get trophies.

Not sure you are planning on implementing this immediately but my recommendation is to wait.... Any other thoughts?



I would go with no CPU player can get trophies. That is a solution


No what he is saying is half of the teams have already played against this CPU player when they sucked and the human opposition got good stats from it...he will now face that same CPU player that isn't that bad and therefor will get less stats against them...unfair advantage for the early season teams that have played the gutted teams.

Good Point too by the way!
 
stumanroo
blame stu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
This proves my point. It is not a money issue but a strategy issue. If you give money to the poor they continue to squander it.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1141739&page=15#8894129

Originally posted by xnahog


Originally posted by djfivenine



Discuss....

I always thought it was a decent idea. Not because the 5th-8th seed need some rewards, it's just the 1-4th teams get around $2.5 million for each game, and that is a lot, especially for teams that are just starting out.
That's 5 extra players that they can get from free agency or the cash trade market.


Socialism


That is the problem. Teams that put their money into trades and high dollar FA's and don't spend on there stadium. This is my point. The problem is not money but the strategy of the players and that is why it doesn't matter.

Good owners will spend on their stadium unless it is at max seating and if that is the case you have plenty of money to buy players already.



You give a gambling addict $100 dollars because he already lost all of his money...what do you expect them to do with this $100? They will gamble it away and lose it!

Very good point Rob! These teams who are low on money are going to continue to be low on money.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
What questions would you like me to answer for you Rob?
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
What questions would you like me to answer for you Rob?


Show me the money!

Sorry.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.