User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
I guess my viewpoint won't come as any suprise, but IMHO, teams are leaving (or more accurately, team owners and numerous members of various teams) due to the frustration of seeing yet another perfectly decent idea being strangled by 'game players' (AKA cheats).

Just about any and every online multi-player game brings with it the 'players' that simply HAVE to win. Now, that in itself is not a bad thing, but when they HAVE to win at any cost, then it gets very old, very quick.

Take any FPS, and you'll see the emergence of aimbots and 'god mode' codes within no time at all.

Take any online stategy game and you'll see genuine 'strategy' quickly falling foul of the 'do this in the first round and you'll get a win' type of exploit.

There will ALWAYS be exploits in games - the choice you have to make is at what price do you value your winning over anything esle.

Experience quite obviously shows us that, bar a very small minority of hard-core enthusiasts who stick with a chosen game pretty much through anything (yet still don't feel the need to exploit), the VAST majority of honest game players tend to move on when it becomes obvious that the cheats have taken over.

There'll always be people making excuses for this exploiting and saying it's just 'good gaming' (as has been shown on GLB) but if it was 'good gaming' and nothing more, then people wouldn't complain so vocally about it - they'd simply do it themselves.

I could roll out analogies all day, but when you're more concerned with finding angles in the mechanics of the coding than you are about the genuine tactics and strategy of the game that the code is trying to simulate, then you're not just 'game playing' - you're cheating.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
It's still a great game, and I don't see all these players leaving, but part of the problem is immature owners that don't understand the type of commitment it takes to manage a team. If you do get stuck on a team with a kiddie owner you just have to ride it out and that can discourage people. Luckily most of the owners my guys have signed with have been great. Looking out for the team, and not just their players, and trying to work everyone into the mix. Fine line they have to walk, but it's hard to tell from the first couple of pm's if you are dealing with a owner with a head on their shoulders, or a child.
 
Blitz81
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Really? I never used the advanced AI on defense, I use a very simple AI on offense, and my team is doing just fine. You can do just fine with very basic gameplanning AI.

People whine too much. This is an inherent truth.

I agree with increasing the costs of owning a team... to me that would make a HUGE difference. Owning a team should be a huge commitment but at only 1000 flex and 400 per season, it's too easy to do.


I'm not sure that I like this idea, not saying that it won't work I'm just not a fan of it. However if this was to be implemented then one must first fix the FA market. I own a team and plan on staying with it, but I'm not sinking more money than what I do now into a game that I can't enjoy and can't compete. Our team has struggled this season and because of this no one wants to sign, everyone wants to be on a winning team which I can understand. But if I can't sign players then I just can't compete with the winning teams that have no problems signing. The second solution is to keep the players you have well in theory this won't really work either because if they are already lower level than the winning teams then they will always be lower level, unless I can sign higher level players which is hard with a loosing record. THERE MUST be some insintive for players to come and stay with a team that isn't doing so well. I've been fortunate because most of my players have decided to stay with the team and a lot of them are bringing over higher level players that they have to help us rebuild. Had my players not banned together for the good of the team I would have lost half my team then wouldn't been able to sign the higher level players that I needed and would be putting money into a game that I have NO CHANCE of winning at and then yes I would have gotten out of it.

My humble opinion of what's wrong with the game.

1. TOO many teams!
2. Guys spending all this money to build players then have the creators change the way builds work and now we have to adjust our builds to stay competitive. Changes are good, but do them slower.
3. And maybe the biggest problem is guys that simply just don't care! This you can't fix.

Last edited Sep 1, 2008 05:51:46
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Raising the cost for teams is stupid. It punishes the good owners for no reason.

The big problems with GLB are:

1)No real guides on how to build a player (everything out there is guess work.)
2)No real guides on how to do advanced AI.
3)Changes in the offseason with minimal explanation mean that builds that worked last season don't work in the next. (And if you figure out the way the game works, and build a player to suit, that's not an exploit. That's common sense.) Changing the rules the following year so kickers go from getting 65 yard FGs to missing 23 yard FGs means that people spent money for nothing, and the problem (it's possible to build a perfect kicker) which should have been gametested and dealt with during the Alpha period, isn't solved, it's changed to a new problem (it's very hard to build a great kicker) and since there is zero advice about building players - except for unofficial guides that are largely guesses, the game turns into a guessing game, with players hoping that the attributes they pick to improve a)work, and b)don't end up changed next season to be worthless.
4)No search function. Bort (and I really appreciate Bort's work, don't get me wrong) wanders the forums, sprinkling information like fairy dust. With no search function, the game has turned into a game of - hang out in the forums and hope that you find a post by Bort that gives you a piece of critical information and then hope that Bort doesn't change his mind later and reverse (or not implement) the thing he mentioned.
5)Animation is inaccurate. It's almost impossible to figure out what happened in a play (except at a very gross level) from watching the animation. That means it's very hard to improve a player.
6)Slow level ups once you get to level 20+. Let's face it, after level 20, the game gets pretty boring for a player. It ends up working like this. If you are a paying customer, who boosts every season, then you end up in the doldrums of the 20+ levels were you level up three times a season and largely have nothing to do (and no way to fix your player if you built him for last season and there was a change to the best build.) Shouldn't paying customers be rewarded for being paying customers? Why should lower level players ever catch up with high level ones? That doesn't happen in any other game I've heard of, nor does it happen in real life. There are plenty of teams, god knows, so it's not like the level 16s are going to be stuck at backup forever.

I know that some of this will be fixed next season, but at that point, a lot of players will have gone on to find something else to do, which is really too bad. I will be riding this thing out, because I have faith in Bort, and I'm hoping the pain we are going through now will be worth it in the end.

T
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
1)No real guides on how to build a player (everything out there is guess work.)


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=6371

Originally posted by tsherr
2)No real guides on how to do advanced AI.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=775619

I think more of the problem with these two issues is that people don't always know where to look. Bort is handling that with his new player PM that a group of people are working on.

I agree with 3-6 completely though.

 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
I am sure it has been posted. Too many teams who have no chance of competing, but aren't bad enough to move down. The teams coming up next season are better than them, the gutted teams coming down are worse, so in another 40 days all they can expect is a 4th to 8th place finish and another first round exit from the playoffs.

Being a player on that team would sure be fun.

Prime example of this are the US AAA leagues, who have lost at least 30% of their teams already this season and the number will be over 50% before the start of season 5.
 
killertoad
offline
Link
 
Too many teams, impossible to sign free agents.

Too many changes on the fly with no real direction.

The NFL starts this week.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr

4)No search function. Bort (and I really appreciate Bort's work, don't get me wrong) wanders the forums, sprinkling information like fairy dust. With no search function, the game has turned into a game of - hang out in the forums and hope that you find a post by Bort that gives you a piece of critical information and then hope that Bort doesn't change his mind later and reverse (or not implement) the thing he mentioned.


Excellent point. Take this thread for example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=936545

Unless you happened to see that Bort made a comment in some random thread, you would have no idea if this was true or not.
 
Bahnzo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Raising the cost for teams is stupid. It punishes the good owners for no reason.


It's not at all. I just spent $6 to boost ONE guy, for one season. This is his third season, so there's $18 + $9 for custom equipment. An owner doesn't even approach that amount for the cost of owning the team. If I'm going to pay that kind of money for a player, it shows I'm dedicated. An owner needs to show me that same commitment, and $10 for the team and $4 every two seasons doesn't show me anything.

I also like the idea of a seperate no-boosting league(s). Slap them fulla advertising if you need to, but it needs to be done.

 
bladewalker
offline
Link
 
I'm wrapping up my 1st season of ownership, and the primary reason I've seriously considered selling my team is the many dozens of hours I've spent throughout the season on recruiting.

I don't have several hours a day to spend, and most of my time with GLB is spent recruiting. I send multiple offers out almost every single day and only just recently fielded a full team of human starters. I have no time left for scouting and game planning. This isn't what I expected going in.

Having fielded a full team and retained the majority for a second season, I'm going to give it another season and hopefully can spend more time on the gazillion other things an owner should be doing to run a fun team for the players.
 
Link
 
Nobody has picked up on my key theory as of yet with regards to what the biggest factor is, but I don't really want to go into it or explain it as I don't really feel this is the appropriate place to delve into my ideas pertaining to this subject.
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Nobody has picked up on my key theory as of yet with regards to what the biggest factor is, but I don't really want to go into it or explain it as I don't really feel this is the appropriate place to delve into my ideas pertaining to this subject.


Why are you acting like everyone should value your opinion? Arrogance, much?
 
healthguyfsu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Nobody has picked up on my key theory as of yet with regards to what the biggest factor is, but I don't really want to go into it or explain it as I don't really feel this is the appropriate place to delve into my ideas pertaining to this subject.


bwahahaahahaha go back to the star trek convention cave you crawled out of
 
Dvolution
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fuller7586
Originally posted by phthalatemagic

Originally posted by Cedo


increased the prices to be an owner...


Agree with this. Perhaps if it cost more to be an owner not everyone would have signed up, and stayed as just a player. That also has pretty a large effect on the player market, which is allegedly pretty strange right now.


This is the largest problem in the game, and the cause of all problems in my opinion.
I am an owner and I think the price of owning a team should of be about 20 dollars a season, or like 30 dollars for initial purchase, then discounts for the amount of years you add on after purchase. Something like that. There are WAY to many teams in the game and just not enough players to populate these teams.

Right now the players in FA want to go to good teams and play backup. OR they will go to less succesfull teams for a starting spot.

Teams in the middle are stuck signing only a couple players via Fire Sales
Teams at the bottem are screwed cause nobody wants to come to them.
Teams at the top stay weathy because of all the extra money they make in the playoffs and can keep their team going becuase players will go there, and they have the money to pay for it.

The game is broke but it CAN be fixed. Once the game goes live alot of people are going to have FP to play with. As long as Bort increases the price to purchase teams, the game will do very well once live.


I have 4 players, only one is in a team and I had to be reffered to that team. I think most of the team owners/gm are too lazy to scout the D-League as well. I'll admit that my players are only between level 4 and 7, but if a team would prove that htey are willing to invest in one of my player, that said player would certainly have some loyalty feelings. Saying there is a lack of player of population isn't actually accurate. Teams doesn't want to invest in players of too low level. If the player population was really an issue, most of the d-League teams would be populated mostly by cpu players which is not the case at all.
 
Dvolution
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tsherr
Raising the cost for teams is stupid. It punishes the good owners for no reason.

The big problems with GLB are:

1)No real guides on how to build a player (everything out there is guess work.)
2)No real guides on how to do advanced AI.
3)Changes in the offseason with minimal explanation mean that builds that worked last season don't work in the next. (And if you figure out the way the game works, and build a player to suit, that's not an exploit. That's common sense.) Changing the rules the following year so kickers go from getting 65 yard FGs to missing 23 yard FGs means that people spent money for nothing, and the problem (it's possible to build a perfect kicker) which should have been gametested and dealt with during the Alpha period, isn't solved, it's changed to a new problem (it's very hard to build a great kicker) and since there is zero advice about building players - except for unofficial guides that are largely guesses, the game turns into a guessing game, with players hoping that the attributes they pick to improve a)work, and b)don't end up changed next season to be worthless.
4)No search function. Bort (and I really appreciate Bort's work, don't get me wrong) wanders the forums, sprinkling information like fairy dust. With no search function, the game has turned into a game of - hang out in the forums and hope that you find a post by Bort that gives you a piece of critical information and then hope that Bort doesn't change his mind later and reverse (or not implement) the thing he mentioned.
5)Animation is inaccurate. It's almost impossible to figure out what happened in a play (except at a very gross level) from watching the animation. That means it's very hard to improve a player.
6)Slow level ups once you get to level 20+. Let's face it, after level 20, the game gets pretty boring for a player. It ends up working like this. If you are a paying customer, who boosts every season, then you end up in the doldrums of the 20+ levels were you level up three times a season and largely have nothing to do (and no way to fix your player if you built him for last season and there was a change to the best build.) Shouldn't paying customers be rewarded for being paying customers? Why should lower level players ever catch up with high level ones? That doesn't happen in any other game I've heard of, nor does it happen in real life. There are plenty of teams, god knows, so it's not like the level 16s are going to be stuck at backup forever.

I know that some of this will be fixed next season, but at that point, a lot of players will have gone on to find something else to do, which is really too bad. I will be riding this thing out, because I have faith in Bort, and I'm hoping the pain we are going through now will be worth it in the end.

T


Oh and if I start playing WoW now, I bet in 2-3 months max, I've catched up to the level 70... I don't think it's as easy to catch up to older players in this game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.