I apologise beforehand for not reading the entirity of the thread, I got to page 12 and believe I saw enough to get the jist, and to apply my own opinion.
Originally posted by GG
People can disagree with me, that's cool. Dannyg28, the difference between a player with 200 base vs 200 base but him having 0/10 sticky hands vs 10/10 sticky hands would be a LOT less is the point. Look, today you have teams who are all level 25 vs teams who are all level 25. But the games are pretty good, close, still 20 yard runs, pancakes, intercepts, broken coverage etc. Ends up 24-20 score and stats look realistic. That's what '200' would end up creating MORE of.
The solution is to level the playing field. That's what everyone wants! No one wants 100-0 scores, 150 pancakes a game, 1,000 yards rushing by one player in a game etc. Having noobs and vets all on a level playing field is NOT bad for anyone! Vets WILL have more skill that they win but it wont be 100-0 etc.
Also, the new-SAs were maxing out at 100 not 10.
And, about bringing this thread back on topic....yes, that's fine. But my presence in this thread is relevant to the topic because I disagree about creating more disparity and the process of that as discussed in some of the ideas mentioned in this thread. That it would be remiss of GLB to implement these ideas BEFORE addressing (re-doing) the foundation first. But I will tone down my '200' talk in here.
This '200' idea of which you state a staggering amount of times does NOT create individualisation in my eyes, essentially a 300lb 6'2 Center will undoubtedly want to stack strength and blocking. This happens on natural builds. There is a reason why the builds are very similar, because that's what works with this current system. The way in which change would come about, would be the addition combined with choice. You mentioned the SA's being like a vet's learnt experiences from playing in the NFL, but by starting 'rookies' and 'vets' on both 200 is incredibly ignorant of the fact that this game is an MMORPG. I look at the top of my browser to see Goal Line Blitz - Beta- American Football MMORPG.
I'm an agent only person here, my players are all I have but I do help and contribute alot on team forums. I began with just one player, my FS. He was a 2nd string at best, but with leveling and the application of my skill points, I eventually became better, and started above someone 1-2 levels higher until I boosted and passed his level anyway. If I started with the '200', then surely it takes the levelling aspect away,when you consider SA's. Just because Tom Brady is a leader because he's experienced, doesn't mean rookie's cant be. Matt Ryan was selected and is the starter because of this. Your whole '200' and SA tree rejects this theory that rookies can be. The whole '200' thing basically makes every player the same. The longer you've been in the game, the better your Player will be, with the huge significance on SA's?
-- -- --
I'm more of a general forum observer, so I'm not sure how to double quote in one post, so I'll continue with seperations (sorry)
Drifter, you mentioned and supplied a long list of the VP's or Prestige's, and would have to agree on alot of them, I'll mention the ones I don't, I'm not sure of many myself yet though, this isn't a dig at your idea, I think it'd work, but obviously some need tweaking. Some overlapping will essentially take place, but I don't think you had the right attitude towards this. If you think about it though, it occurs a lot. The NFL is essentially the overlapping of skills. You could be immensely strong, yet without the footwork, you're blocking will suffer. You may be a clutch RB, but that may because you're a power back or a superb 3rd down back (ie Turner's chargers days)
A couple I thought of (not sure on the mechanics though) feel free to criticise and give opinions on.
Pass deflecter: Increase jumping and vision so that you're more likely to deflect a pass, needed for weaker pass defenses, could be used by linemen (DE's dropping into coverage) LB's and DB's. Getting this means less points in other abilities though, such as;
'The Motor': Slightly boosts push from the line/snap. D-Linemen could use this, blitz happy LB's
Technical Blocker: Increases the pass or run blocking abilities. (Minor boosts so O-lines don't stack it) but this could be implemented for downfield blocks by WR's
Run stuffer: Reduces the chance that an RB would break for long runs or break your tackle. (If you think about it, pretty much every LB can tackle, but some are just alot better than others, SS tacklers etc. I know this is similar to wrap-up/power, but these would essentially become the new individual tactics I think.
Power pass rush
Evasive pass rush
Man coverage - would mean teams specifically looking for certain players, if a team runs a Cover 1 man scheme, you'd want your CB's to be man-to-man, a shutdown on madden if you like
Zone coverage - similarly, a FS with zone would be more useful.
Then you'd obviously need offensive ones but I didn't give too much thought on these.
Clutch player
Tackle breaker - Rb's or WR/TE's after catch
etc
One I did really like that could possibly end the 'playtime' debate, although i have no idea how it could be/if it could be done
Opportunist: increases the chance you'll perform well on the rare plays you get. could be done on a similar stamina/freshness/breath system.
If a QB takes 30 snaps, but youre a run first team, the 10 times he does pass he has a slight increase to throwing or something.
Anyway, there all my ideas for now, hopefully they help the progression of this idea.