User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan

As was pointed out above me, people that talk about other people complaining and downing them .. while they are also behind the internet are no better. Sucking up to the teacher and bagging on the "classmates" behind there back doesn't help a thing or make you look any better.


So, if we happen to like the new system we are ass kissers? Cool, I haven't been called that in a ... Hmmm Don't think I've ever been called that.

Originally posted by Justafan
Bottom line is there are issues with the energy system as it currently stands. If you watch the replays of the games and then find out the energy used it doesn't make sence. Is this horrible? No not at all. It's beta and it's a great game. That doesn't make it perfect.

If you look at the forums.. the stickied "guide to creating players" and follow it my level 7 DB shouldn't have 33 stamina, he does and he still loses 40 energy per game.. the max allowed. That tells me, since it's stickied, it's accepted by the mods on here so it must have some truth to it. If you look at the "good SS build" (Which I play) it's a level 16 guy.. his stamina is 36. What is a new guy to think? I shouldn't have to have a 33 at level 7 to play the game as a starter and not lose the max energy I can lose.


Wow, on my team, my four players are the starters. I have a halfback, a DE, a Guard, and a Linebacker, I don't think a single one of them has a stamina over 22, and guess what.. Last game they all ended the game with more than 75 endurance left. We won 38-0, so we aren't slackers. Just for the record, my team is purposefully trying to slowly increase our staminas so I can balance things with the substitution slider, and give everyone good playing time.

Originally posted by Justafan
Here is the question/problem. If I am going to lose the max energy no matter what, why boost stamina? Why am I wasting my time on it? I trying to make it matter they are almost making it useless. Does more stamina matter on recovering energy? Not to my knowledge. So it's not helping me keep energy, I am losing energy like a DL/OL guy fighting it out every down while I am trotting around on run plays and I am not being helped by it on recovering energy so what good is it?


I figured eventually you might arrive at the question. So why did you train stamina so hard? Because someone wrote a guide that says you should? A guide that was out BEFORE the endurance changes? Why didn't you read the post about the energy changes and decide for yourself how it will affect you? At least then if you were wrong, you would actually have someone to blame.

Originally posted by Justafan
While your sucking up to the devs and knocking anyone that wants to point out a flaw can you tell me honestly that what I have said isn't true and isn't a issue? For the record I am playing on "normal" intensity and "relaxed" trainning. Also, I am not hidding behind the internet at all it's simply the mode we use (ie the forum) to communicate.


Yes, I can actually. I like the energy changes. Before this, everyone just humped stamina so they could get the maximum exp a game, now the team owner has to decide how he wants to use the players on his team. The old 60/0 slider doesn't work very well anymore.

Originally posted by Justafan
As you said, the developers and mods are doing a great job, and they do listen and better then that they don't seem to react knee jerky which is great also. I don't believe there have been alot of people to give the "I am going to quit this game sux!" posts so it's not simply complaining about things. People want to know how things work and why they work like they do. If the devs posted tonight that the energy thing is a done deal and it's staying the way it is forever I wouldn't say another word. Since it's Beta I will give my input and try to do it in a way that's as positive as negative feedback can be. = )


Fair enough, as long as us ass kissers can do the same?

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan
Originally posted by PinTBC

See this is where I am confused (sorry I am simply and going off what I read on the forums only) how can you "get back to 90 every game" if you can lose 40 energy per game.. and only gain back 30 between games?

As I understand it you can lose 40 energy per game? Is this right?

As I understand it you gain back 15 energy if your "relaxed" trainning"? Is this right?

As I understand it there is two days between games? That's 30 energy gained between games. Is this right?

IF that's all correct, and it might not be, then you will "lose" 10 energy every game. So after the first you would be at 90... second 80.. third 70.. ect ect.

I did play on "normal" intensity and I am on "relaxed" trainning. My guess is I am missunderstanding one of the top issues and how they work because if I am not then your incorrect that you can get back to 90 "every game" as you said. It could be more of me missunderstanding then the way it works, I can be wrong I don't mind I am new. I just want to undersand how it works.


Cool beans, The lowest your energy should be after a game is 60. It won't currently go lower than that, so if you train on relaxed, you get back to 90 no matter what.

PinTBC

 
porkies
offline
Link
 
We need a manual, as things change - update the manual. I don't want to read 500 posts to figure out simple things that should have been stickied in the manual. I don't want to have to search the forums for things that should be a sticky either. This is a game for me, At least give me a damn manual... I will actually say right now that I won't buy any more flex points until there is one.

I'd be happy enough to know that at least someone is working on one with and ETA.
Last edited Apr 29, 2008 18:56:32
 
presvedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Justafan

Originally posted by PinTBC

See this is where I am confused (sorry I am simply and going off what I read on the forums only) how can you "get back to 90 every game" if you can lose 40 energy per game.. and only gain back 30 between games?

As I understand it you can lose 40 energy per game? Is this right?

As I understand it you gain back 15 energy if your "relaxed" trainning"? Is this right?

As I understand it there is two days between games? That's 30 energy gained between games. Is this right?

IF that's all correct, and it might not be, then you will "lose" 10 energy every game. So after the first you would be at 90... second 80.. third 70.. ect ect.

I did play on "normal" intensity and I am on "relaxed" trainning. My guess is I am missunderstanding one of the top issues and how they work because if I am not then your incorrect that you can get back to 90 "every game" as you said. It could be more of me missunderstanding then the way it works, I can be wrong I don't mind I am new. I just want to undersand how it works.


Cool beans, The lowest your energy should be after a game is 60. It won't currently go lower than that, so if you train on relaxed, you get back to 90 no matter what.

PinTBC



I have guys in the 50's... so you can go lower then 60.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Energy goes lower than 60. Yell at anyone who says otherwise.
 
KTG
offline
Link
 
so i have a question, i havnt read through all this, but the people on this last few pages are saying that stamina doesnt matter, so if im a lvl 2 center, should i bring my stamina up to 20 or just leave it at 16 and work on other stuff?
 
porkies
offline
Link
 
actually, i tested it and I was saying in previous posts that it didn't go below 60. I was wrong. Maybe if it were in a clear definitive manual then I would've known.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Justafan

Originally posted by PinTBC

See this is where I am confused (sorry I am simply and going off what I read on the forums only) how can you "get back to 90 every game" if you can lose 40 energy per game.. and only gain back 30 between games?

As I understand it you can lose 40 energy per game? Is this right?

As I understand it you gain back 15 energy if your "relaxed" trainning"? Is this right?

As I understand it there is two days between games? That's 30 energy gained between games. Is this right?

IF that's all correct, and it might not be, then you will "lose" 10 energy every game. So after the first you would be at 90... second 80.. third 70.. ect ect.

I did play on "normal" intensity and I am on "relaxed" trainning. My guess is I am missunderstanding one of the top issues and how they work because if I am not then your incorrect that you can get back to 90 "every game" as you said. It could be more of me missunderstanding then the way it works, I can be wrong I don't mind I am new. I just want to undersand how it works.


Cool beans, The lowest your energy should be after a game is 60. It won't currently go lower than that, so if you train on relaxed, you get back to 90 no matter what.

PinTBC



So you can't go lower then 60? I dispute this honestly. I don't believe this is correct but I can't "prove" it's wrong. I will bet you a game check your incorrect on this though (what do I have to lose I am on a rookie contract = P )

I still have an issue with a SS playing 48 plays and losing the max energy allowed by the game while playing on "normal" intensity. My first game (74 plays) ok, it makes sence. We can agree to disagree. Your team had a level 6 CB (I believe) that played 40 plays I would like to know what he lost in stamina. My thought is that it's not subtracting energy in a matter that makes sence based on the plays on the field. As I said earlier, it might not be possible for them to do that though. A SS who's not in on alot of the plays (I am coverage, rarely involved in run plays) and following a TE who's running away from the side the ball is thrown to I can't imagine I am using a ton of energy vs a DE who's fighting every play or a TE who's running or blocking every play. That's my only point and as I said it might not be fixable because it would be tough to code how much enenry a specific player used on a specific play. Yes I want it all, sue me. It's Beta so I give my opinions on making it better. As I said, if the Devs say it is what is it is I will give up the fight.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
As I was posting I see many others saying that "energy goes below 60" as I thought. Seems even the techers pet doesn't have it figured out.. but he will sure tell you how it works.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
And just to prove I'm not bluffing:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v334/shigogouhou/below60.jpg
The inactive guy's energy is at 57.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
And just to prove I'm not bluffing:
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v334/shigogouhou/below60.jpg
The inactive guy's energy is at 57.


Ironically he's a SS.. same as my guys position. That's my point on all this, I don't think they have everyone losing energy the same and I don't know if the way they have it currently makes sence. If you watch the games back, at least our teams, my SS isn't flying around the field every play.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan
As I was posting I see many others saying that "energy goes below 60" as I thought. Seems even the techers pet doesn't have it figured out.. but he will sure tell you how it works.


Chuckle, I just reread what Bort posted and he indeed does say that you can lose up to 40 a game, so it apparently can go below 60. My apologies, but it still doesn't change the idea that the system is a good idea. If you don't have depth, then perhaps you need to find some human or CPU backups, and settle your replacement sliders on some numbers that allow your starters to come out of the game with no less than 70 energy left.

PinTBC

 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Justafan

As I was posting I see many others saying that "energy goes below 60" as I thought. Seems even the techers pet doesn't have it figured out.. but he will sure tell you how it works.


Chuckle, I just reread what Bort posted and he indeed does say that you can lose up to 40 a game, so it apparently can go below 60. My apologies, but it still doesn't change the idea that the system is a good idea. If you don't have depth, then perhaps you need to find some human or CPU backups, and settle your replacement sliders on some numbers that allow your starters to come out of the game with no less than 70 energy left.

PinTBC



Look at the picture above. Isn't it odd that the DE's (like you mention) still have high energy.. yet the safties all are hurting? Should you have three SS and three FS? That's crazy. Your missing the point completely. My argument isn't that the energy system isn't good, it's simply that seems to favor some positions more then others and the ones it favors doesn't make sence IMO. I don't care if my SS comes out of each game with his tounge dragging, but a DE that's fighting every down aginst an OL that's fighting back should be the same way. If my stamina is half aginst that DE's and we play similar number of plays he should lose more energy then me. That's just my take on it. The system is a great idea, I am just not positive it can't be tweeked. You can't expect every team to sub three FS and three SS every game and that's simply not realistic either. I understand it's a video game (sim) but it is based on real football to an extent, I can't imagine Bort expects teams to rotate three SS and three FS every game, but if he does so be it that's what the owners and GM's will deal with.

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
To be fair, the last game before that screenshot had 61 pass attempts to 28 rushes, 89 total defensive plays.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=18275
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
To be fair, the last game before that screenshot had 61 pass attempts to 28 rushes, 89 total defensive plays.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=18275


Yea, but none of your players played that many a ton of plays (based on the screen shot you gave above). You have good subs system going obviously. Your safties played 49 and 38 (SS) and 46 and 52 (FS). If your going to split time this close between your starter and back ups and still lose that much energy you would have to rotate between three to keep your energy in good shape.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.