User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
Perok
offline
Link
 
and please don't compare this to Cyberdunk.

Cyberdunk is more like World of Warcraft in a basketball arena....
look at my +25 wristbands!!
----------------------------------------------

With the exception of kickoffs the majority of changes are good. The game is getting better. 70+ speed doesn't make a great player in real life, that makes a guy who can run fast- so I'm glad to see that speed is no longer the end all.

We need a little more defined PBP, to "see" the abilities like crushing hits, and jumping catches among the defense.


as for retirement, it has to happen- I would rather just see players peak and decline at arbitrary or random levels... as opposed to taking 10 seasons to hit your peak, then retiring while at your best.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Perok
and please don't compare this to Cyberdunk.

Cyberdunk is more like World of Warcraft in a basketball arena....
look at my +25 wristbands!!
----------------------------------------------

With the exception of kickoffs the majority of changes are good. The game is getting better. 70+ speed doesn't make a great player in real life, that makes a guy who can run fast- so I'm glad to see that speed is no longer the end all.

We need a little more defined PBP, to "see" the abilities like crushing hits, and jumping catches among the defense.


as for retirement, it has to happen- I would rather just see players peak and decline at arbitrary or random levels... as opposed to taking 10 seasons to hit your peak, then retiring while at your best.


Well, you don't have to retire while at your best. I think a lot of people will, but it's meant to be possible to play at least a couple more seasons after that, while in decline-- more than a couple if you're willing to move down leagues, play backup, etc..
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
People are REALLY hung up that it's the min/max builders who are making the most noise.

But it's not just them that are being affected by the constant changes. As I KEEP saying (and I'll open up ANY build if people don't believe me) my players are pretty realistic, yet with the constant changes, all I'm doing is basically putting points into just about EVERY category, as by the time my balanced player starts to perform, something gets tweaked to make him decline, rather than improve.

My 'oldest' player - perhaps my MOST balanced guy - has suddenly started missing tackles, doing weird coverage drops, and generally not being involved in the game at all.

I've tried as many equipment respecs as I could afford, but that's level 16 equipment that I re-bought, so it's not cheap.

So far, I haven't figured out why he's declined in so many areas in such a short space of time and it'll take me a couple of seasons to earn the SPs to make any decent changes.

By the time I've earned enough points to fix his current weaknesses, I'd imagine more changes will have taken place and who knows what skill he'll be lacking in then...

But please drop this 'beta' tester thing, because NONE of us are 'testing' anything. Any bugs we find are just coincidence - not because we've TESTED the game to try to invoke a bug. In fact - the ONLY people that have actually carried out what would be deemed as a proper beta testing scheme ARE the min/max builders.

They built unrealistic players and Bort got to realise that there was a loophole that needed fixing.

In any Beta test, you do completely off the wall things, as that's normally when the game falls over or shows up an error. Just 'playing' it normally does next to nothing and any bugs that do show up take WAY too long to find.

So - if this is a Beta game, then let's be allowed to TEST it properly.

With the users on here, we could probably find ALL the obvious problems within a couple of weeks.

But to do that would mean pulling right back from the competitive leagues and just run game after game after game, respeccing players between each game, building ridiculously unrealistic players and putting them in ridiculously unrealistic situations to see what happens.

But here's the rub - once you've FOUND a loophole, it gets REPORTED so it can be sorted out.

Historically, these loopholes have just been used as a means to win games and only now are they being addressed.

So - what's it to be? Put the leagues on hold and have a season of PROPER testing, or just carry on bouncing from year to year, fix to fix, nerf to nerf, boost to boost??





 
Keiferdog
offline
Link
 
I agree. Sounds like an idea to be greatly addressed.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
People are REALLY hung up that it's the min/max builders who are making the most noise.

But it's not just them that are being affected by the constant changes. As I KEEP saying (and I'll open up ANY build if people don't believe me) my players are pretty realistic, yet with the constant changes, all I'm doing is basically putting points into just about EVERY category, as by the time my balanced player starts to perform, something gets tweaked to make him decline, rather than improve.

My 'oldest' player - perhaps my MOST balanced guy - has suddenly started missing tackles, doing weird coverage drops, and generally not being involved in the game at all.

I've tried as many equipment respecs as I could afford, but that's level 16 equipment that I re-bought, so it's not cheap.

So far, I haven't figured out why he's declined in so many areas in such a short space of time and it'll take me a couple of seasons to earn the SPs to make any decent changes.

By the time I've earned enough points to fix his current weaknesses, I'd imagine more changes will have taken place and who knows what skill he'll be lacking in then...

But please drop this 'beta' tester thing, because NONE of us are 'testing' anything. Any bugs we find are just coincidence - not because we've TESTED the game to try to invoke a bug. In fact - the ONLY people that have actually carried out what would be deemed as a proper beta testing scheme ARE the min/max builders.

They built unrealistic players and Bort got to realise that there was a loophole that needed fixing.

In any Beta test, you do completely off the wall things, as that's normally when the game falls over or shows up an error. Just 'playing' it normally does next to nothing and any bugs that do show up take WAY too long to find.

So - if this is a Beta game, then let's be allowed to TEST it properly.

With the users on here, we could probably find ALL the obvious problems within a couple of weeks.

But to do that would mean pulling right back from the competitive leagues and just run game after game after game, respeccing players between each game, building ridiculously unrealistic players and putting them in ridiculously unrealistic situations to see what happens.

But here's the rub - once you've FOUND a loophole, it gets REPORTED so it can be sorted out.

Historically, these loopholes have just been used as a means to win games and only now are they being addressed.

So - what's it to be? Put the leagues on hold and have a season of PROPER testing, or just carry on bouncing from year to year, fix to fix, nerf to nerf, boost to boost??







Chaos,

I will take you up on that, I will unblock ya, you can PM me your builds if you have questions.


 
druez
offline
Link
 
This thread is dumb, why don't the mods just lock it.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Chaos, funny.

None of my builds have been bothered much by the changes. But then I don't expect my LB's with tackling over 40 to make every tackle, because there's plenty of room above 40, nor my WR that has Catching over 50 and Vision of almost 40 to catch every pass-- because if that happened, there'd be no reason to every raise Catching above 50.

People don't want their players to make mistakes, but balanced, minmax, whatever, they all will and should.

And Druez is right that this thread should be locked. It's not a bug report.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Im going to say this again. This is a beta game, as you fanboys keep saying. That means our players are beta players, correct? If the laws of physics changed because the game is in beta, our attributes should be maliable to a limited degree because we have beta players.

I reject the following:

1. "No one forced you to pay for a player". Well, people did, and have every right to expect to be able to get some use out of the money spent on that player. A one skill point per 2 levels attained one time respec fixes all the problems. Im honestly not sure Id change a thing, but if I had 80 speed 20 agility guys, I certainly would want that right.

2. "Speed was too powerful" I built several speed guys and they didnt work very often. When they did though, everyone noticed. Agility is WAY more powerful now than speed ever was.

3. "Its easy enough to fix your player" This is clearly being said by players who dont have a level 20 or higher guy. it takes a full season to boost some of these guys a level.

The attitude that you are damned if you do and damned if you dont is understandable, but there is always middle ground.

I still like the game, and I honestly enjoy the challenge of a changing landscape, but rignt now you seem to have a random chance going into a game of either missing 0-3 tackles as a team or missing 24-55 tackles as a team. This is the same teams, and the same level comepetion. You have NO ability to get in a WRs face and play tight, and in week 4, blitzes just stopped working. Linemen pass block like gods, and DLs cant win an even matchup. If you truly dont want the game to go forward with a broken sim, keep plugging & make changes to fix these problems and people will adjust. Just give them the ability to.

Lets be honest, though, a lot works better in the game than it did.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 20:17:34
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare

I like the new changes, the game is fixed now, if you don't like it then leave already
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare

I like the new changes, the game is fixed now, if you don't like it then leave already


I reject that too. If the forum search worked, I could show you that it was actually announced at about playoff time, and I was lucky enough to have read it and had time to make adjustments, as you apparently did as well. Dont tell me for a second that you had ANY idea how much stuff was going to change at once midway through last season.

You know I like you man, but you arent THAT smart. Again, I think people should adjust and learn, but the pace of change is so slow at higher levels, I feel it is clear that there should be some allowance for helping with that adjustment.

Hell, if you want to make it for everyone but me and Shaknbake, I have no issue with that, but a limited, one time, minor respec is in order.

I already have one pillar of my team who just stopped boosting because of being painted into a corner. I dont want more.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 21:48:10
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xeef
Originally posted by ShakeNBake

The changes were announced halfway through season 3, would have been smart to prepare

I like the new changes, the game is fixed now, if you don't like it then leave already


I reject that too. If the forum search worked, I could show you that it was actually announced at about playoff time, and I was lucky enough to have read it and had time to make adjustments, as you apparently did as well. Dont tell me for a second that you had ANY idea how much stuff was going to change at once midway through last season.

You know I like you man, but you arent THAT smart. Again, I think people should adjust and learn, but the pace of change is so slow at higher levels, I feel it is clear that there should be some allowance for helping with that adjustment.

Hell, if you want to make it for everyone but me and Shaknbake, I have no issue with that, but a limited, one time, minor respec is in order.

I already have one pillar of my team who just stopped boosting because of being painted into a corner. I dont want more.


Umm,

Except I knew and started making adjustments midway through season 3, not at the playoffs, and yes I knew speed was gonna get adjusted, as well as tackling, the Olinemen change meh, i can see why it was needed, and the biggest change is now they act as a group of linemen instead of individually, but it didn't affect the DE's that were built well.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Chaos, funny.

None of my builds have been bothered much by the changes. But then I don't expect my LB's with tackling over 40 to make every tackle, because there's plenty of room above 40, nor my WR that has Catching over 50 and Vision of almost 40 to catch every pass-- because if that happened, there'd be no reason to every raise Catching above 50.

People don't want their players to make mistakes, but balanced, minmax, whatever, they all will and should.

And Druez is right that this thread should be locked. It's not a bug report.


And I don't expect any of my players to play 100% perfect games either.

But I do expect a guy built as a KR to be a better KR than a slow/strong TE or HB.

And I do expect that my players, built as realistically as I could, to continue progressing year on year as their skills increase. At the moment, any progression or otherwise is too random for MANY positions, with players coming in and out of fashion each season as changes are made.

Fine, we may have been given some info about tackling and speed needing to be changed - but what about the huge stamina hits ST players now get? Or how agility is now the new speed? Or how quite a few other random attributes have an effect on seemingly unrelated skilss (I read somewhere about punters needing jumping???)

With SO many changes and SO many attributes needed addressing, again, the ONLY people that are making huge benefits are the players with uber strong HBs - probably built with all strength, rather than 'realistically', as they smash their way through 10 or more tackles per play on an unrealistically frequent basis.

Or the uber strong freak KRs who do the same............

See - they're as much 'exploits' of a broken sim as the speed freaks were - because what they do is unrealistic given the current state of everyone else's players.....

Anyway - sjmay - PM me with what players you want to look at and I'll open up the build...........

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
PM sent, and sending another.
 
Headbutt
offline
Link
 
I'm curious how many people think they'll be able to keep the 'beta' players they've built when this 'beta' game goes 'live'?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Headbutt
I'm curious how many people think they'll be able to keep the 'beta' players they've built when this 'beta' game goes 'live'?


Everybody, Bort's not wiping the game again.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.