User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
I absolutly believe that The Warriors of the Big House are headed for GLB glory. Thats not dangerous, but is narrow minded and irrational.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 22:43:07
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
Absolute beliefs can be very narrow minded and dangerous.


there we go. similarly, relativist beliefs can also be very narrow-minded and dangerous.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
I absolutly believe that The Warriors of the Big House are headed for GLB glory. Thats not dangerous, but is narrow minded and irrational.


oh, i'm sure you have your reasons.

and btw... when i said "absolute", i meant it in the logical sense (i.e. logically independent and non-presumptive), not in the sense that indicates strength of belief (the epistemological sense). okay, maybe that just added to the confusion. never mind.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Catullus 16, you bring up a good point. I suppose my primary argument in listing those people would be that they don't fit goseattle's strict interpretation of the requirements for getting into heaven. In his view, anyone who questions the validity of Christianity can't enter heaven. Even if you're correct in saying that some of the people I listed were in sort of a gray area, they still don't fit his requirements.

As for whether or not my views fit that of a "classical deist," who cares? Deism is a philosophy that centers around the belief in God, but the rejection of organized religion. It's quite common to find two deists whose beliefs differ in many aspects of the supernatural, such as the existence of an afterlife.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:03:11
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Legacy
Catullus 16, you bring up a good point. I suppose my primary argument in listing those people would be that they don't fit goseattle's strict interpretation of the requirements for getting into heaven. In his view, anyone who questions the validity of Christianity can't enter heaven. Even if you're correct in saying that some of the people I listed were in sort of a gray area, they still don't fit his requirements.

very true. although i would say "the validity of his version of christianity". for example, john adams was a unitarian and thus a non-trinitarian... which is why he didn't believe in the divinity of jesus. but he certainly believed in the divinity of god and self-identified as a christian. indeed, he even called thomas paine to task for his deist views.

Originally posted by Legacy
As for whether or not my views fit that of a "classical deist," who cares? Deism is a philosophy that centers around the belief in God, but the rejection of organized religion. It's quite common to find two deists who differ many aspects of the supernatural, such as the existence of an afterlife.

deism isn't so much about the rejection of organized religion per se... its merely one of the first iterations of trying to reconcile christianity with the enlightenment. essentially, it starts with the very theistic view that god is perfect and all-rational... and therefore his creation must also be perfect and all-rational and thus not in need of constant tinkering. and yes, deists differed to what degree they saw god as a divine watchmaker, but the core of their belief centered around the rationality of religion, not the rejection of its organization.

but honestly, you can self-identify as whatever you choose. there are many today that call themselves "deists" because they follow the congregationalist/unitarian beliefs of the founding fathers. and while that's more a political statement than a religious one, its always dangerous ground to proscribe against someone's self-identification... which brings us full circle to goseattle and his self-appointment as judge of who is and who isn't christian.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:04:57
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
I know that God created a Universe, not just an Earth. There are trillions of stars and billions of planets out there(rough estimate, not exact #'s). It is naive to think that God is just worried about the"Christians" on this planet. On some other planet(hypotheticaly) they would have a completly different Mesiah and belief system. Does God ignore them? Or again to the Darfur and Buddhist monk analogy, are they ignored by God's love?


By your reasoning, there IS life out there. Have you seen it, heard it, felt it? Is there proof? I think that is more ridiculous to assume than to assume what is right in front of your eyes. Did your god tell you this? How?

Truth is, you have been deceived. Now you are denying the evidence before your very eyes. All the evidence right here and right now. No need to go searching other galaxies. You have been led down the path of darkness by the crooked and depraved world that we live in.

Evidence of God is in the existence of creation and the light of conscience. The fact that we are here on this planet is amazing on its own merits. Our conscience, how it talks to us, woos us, let's us know it's there, that is how God speaks to us. We need to learn how to listen to it, filter out the mad mad world's voice, and understand the Truth.

The process is hard, but so is life. The process of growing in spiritual maturity as Jesus would have us do is bumpy at times, but the difference is that it is worthwhile. Nothing in the world was ever enough, there was always something missing, something more... that i was missing. I found it brother. It is the path to righteousness, love and hope. All other paths eventually will not satisy, there will always be something missing until you take Jesus into your heart. Search your feelings (SW episode IV). You know this to be true. It's in you because God put it there.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:18:30
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
You know this to be true. It's in you because God put it there.


so... someone who already disagreed with you could use the exact same argument to tell you otherwise. this is the problem with all innatist/nativist arguments... even if they are true (most have their doubts), its impossible as humans to parse out what is innate for humans. we're very poor scholars of ourselves because we can't step out of our human frame.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:25:03
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Legacy
Catullus 16, you bring up a good point. I suppose my primary argument in listing those people would be that they don't fit goseattle's strict interpretation of the requirements for getting into heaven. In his view, anyone who questions the validity of Christianity can't enter heaven. Even if you're correct in saying that some of the people I listed were in sort of a gray area, they still don't fit his requirements.

As for whether or not my views fit that of a "classical deist," who cares? Deism is a philosophy that centers around the belief in God, but the rejection of organized religion. It's quite common to find two deists whose beliefs differ in many aspects of the supernatural, such as the existence of an afterlife.


So, what are your requirements for getting into heaven?
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16


so... someone who already disagreed with you could use the exact same argument to tell you otherwise. this is the problem with all innatist arguments... even if it is true (most have their doubts), its impossible as humans to parse out what is innate for humans. we're very poor scholars of ourselves because we can't step out of our human frame.


That is why God gave us the Bible. Because, we cannot, as you say, parse out what is innate. I agree. However, i do believe that the Holy Spirit gives the gift of discernment once you believe on Christ. I used to think like Mark Twain, the Bible was a bunch of fairy tales, fables and lots and lots of gibberish. But you know what, i understand it now. It is amazing. You are so right, we are very poor scholars of ourselves. That is one reason we need God LOL

edit.

That is also the main point of Christ coming to teach us... we are so easily deluded by the world and the spiritual forces against us. Christ came to show us right from wrong and give us hope to persevere over the forces of darkness, who really are going to lose out in the end. They struggle to win our loyaties away from light, truth and goodness. It's real man. You can't put it in your hand, but your heart can see, your spiritual eyes. It takes some practice to get to that point, and daily meditation on the Word and prayer to stay that way and grow. It's real and its wonderful.
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:33:15
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Originally posted by Legacy

Catullus 16, you bring up a good point. I suppose my primary argument in listing those people would be that they don't fit goseattle's strict interpretation of the requirements for getting into heaven. In his view, anyone who questions the validity of Christianity can't enter heaven. Even if you're correct in saying that some of the people I listed were in sort of a gray area, they still don't fit his requirements.

As for whether or not my views fit that of a "classical deist," who cares? Deism is a philosophy that centers around the belief in God, but the rejection of organized religion. It's quite common to find two deists whose beliefs differ in many aspects of the supernatural, such as the existence of an afterlife.


So, what are your requirements for getting into heaven?

I'm not entirely sure I believe in an afterlife. It's one of those things I'm on the fence about. I don't believe in a heaven/hell split, though. It's nothing more than a punishment/reward system used to frighten the populace into conformity.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
That is why God gave us the Bible. Because, we cannot, as you say, parse out what is innate. I agree. However, i do believe that the Holy Spirit gives the gift of discernment once you believe on Christ. I used to think like Mark Twain, the Bible was a bunch of fairy tales, fables and lots and lots of gibberish. But you know what, i understand it now. It is amazing. You are so right, we are very poor scholars of ourselves. That is one reason we need God LOL


all that is fine... and i have no way of proving you wrong (nor do i care to). but note that you have absolutely no way of proving yourself right... which invites the question: why do you believe in what you said above and not something else?

looking at the epistemology behind your beliefs can be a scary thing... but i firmly believe the exercise promotes understanding, especially for those who so strongly identify their beliefs. but then, i'm a moral particularist, so i tend to perceive moral universalists as inherently a little self-righteous (not saying you are).

ETA: (concerning my first sentence) i would, however, debate you on innatism... especially the version(s) posited by this guy:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=453073
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:39:50
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Christ came to show us right from wrong


are you saying humanity didn't know right from wrong prior to 6BCE?
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Legacy

I'm not entirely sure I believe in an afterlife. It's one of those things I'm on the fence about. I don't believe in a heaven/hell split, though. It's nothing more than a punishment/reward system used to frighten the populace into conformity.


So they would have you believe. Another deception that fits right into pride of man and paranoia. Been there, done that too.

Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:46:51
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by atom871

Christ came to show us right from wrong


are you saying humanity didn't know right from wrong prior to 6BCE?


LOL, that could be argued. Let me clarify. He came to show us that it could be done in a righteous holy, God-fearing way. To show us that it could indeed be done, and that it was better. Christ came to die on the cross. That was the sacrifice for our sins, we are cleansed by that shedding of blood. While he was here, he experienced what it was to be human, especially with mind to hardship and temptation. Then, he taught us. He taught us about the Father, heaven, the Holy Spirit and broke it down real simple. It must have been amazing to be with him.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Originally posted by Legacy


I'm not entirely sure I believe in an afterlife. It's one of those things I'm on the fence about. I don't believe in a heaven/hell split, though. It's nothing more than a punishment/reward system used to frighten the populace into conformity.


So they would have you believe. Another deception that fits right into pride of and paranoia. Been there, done that too.

Who are "they?"
Last edited Aug 10, 2008 23:49:26
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.