User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Also, just to be completely honest...the introduction of this idea would correspond to me and many others leaving this game. It's just that simple.


You would leave the game because something was added? Something that you don't have to participate in if you don't want to, and only marginally affects the game - yet provides hours of fun to those that take part in it?

Low.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by dth42888

Originally posted by Checkmate187


Originally posted by dth42888



I have an IDEA! How about just go make an entire Cheerleader sim game and let Bort worry about more important things i.e. things related to improving the game which happens to be about football.........


Morale isn't important to football? Do you realize it's a part of the in-game performance here?


Theres plenty of other things that contribute to morale already.

BTW Have you ever been to a football game? No one reacts to what the cheerleaders do. They're just nice to look at. Not trying to offend anyone just speaking the facts.


Cheerleaders are merely a mechanism that conveniently fits into the game model. You can think of the effect as 'home field advantage'.


It would be MUCH more acceptable to simply implement a statistical formula which gives the home team a slight edge when simming. Maybe this formula can vary with size of stadium, attendance, and composition of fan base. But cheerleaders = terrible idea.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo

You would leave the game because something was added? Something that you don't have to participate in if you don't want to, and only marginally affects the game - yet provides hours of fun to those that take part in it?

Low.


Word.
 
dth42888
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by dth42888

Originally posted by Checkmate187


Originally posted by dth42888



I have an IDEA! How about just go make an entire Cheerleader sim game and let Bort worry about more important things i.e. things related to improving the game which happens to be about football.........


Morale isn't important to football? Do you realize it's a part of the in-game performance here?


Theres plenty of other things that contribute to morale already.

BTW Have you ever been to a football game? No one reacts to what the cheerleaders do. They're just nice to look at. Not trying to offend anyone just speaking the facts.


Cheerleaders are merely a mechanism that conveniently fits into the game model. You can think of the effect as 'home field advantage'.


So..... why not just have something simple like home field advantage? Does that not fit into the game model?

I don't think you guys realize the time it would take to code everything your wanting to do with this idea. It would be like creating an entirely new game.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by tjking82

Also, just to be completely honest...the introduction of this idea would correspond to me and many others leaving this game. It's just that simple.


Would be sad if it happened, but I don't think it will. If you saw it like I see it....


I see it that my player which I worked hard to build in a football simulation has an outcome being determined by some fools putting together our cheerleading squad. Cheerleaders are essentially a non-factor. If you have them, your fans are a little more excited. Their quality is rarely if ever a factor in home field advantage. Shitty cheerleaders = great cheerleaders. No difference.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82


It would be MUCH more acceptable to simply implement a statistical formula which gives the home team a slight edge when simming. Maybe this formula can vary with size of stadium, attendance, and composition of fan base. But cheerleaders = terrible idea.


Think about it.... you go to your home page to check out what your QB did in his game (or whatever player you have), and check your RB... then you see your cheerleader's team won and she went up a level!

Oh joy!

 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by tjking82



It would be MUCH more acceptable to simply implement a statistical formula which gives the home team a slight edge when simming. Maybe this formula can vary with size of stadium, attendance, and composition of fan base. But cheerleaders = terrible idea.


Think about it.... you go to your home page to check out what your QB did in his game (or whatever player you have), and check your RB... then you see your cheerleader's team won and she went up a level!

Oh joy!



I consider this your coming out party. Congratulations. Maybe we add handbags to the list of items sold at the stadium, just for you.
 
dth42888
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Checkmate187

Originally posted by dth42888


Originally posted by Checkmate187



Originally posted by dth42888




I have an IDEA! How about just go make an entire Cheerleader sim game and let Bort worry about more important things i.e. things related to improving the game which happens to be about football.........


Morale isn't important to football? Do you realize it's a part of the in-game performance here?


Theres plenty of other things that contribute to morale already.

BTW Have you ever been to a football game? No one reacts to what the cheerleaders do. They're just nice to look at. Not trying to offend anyone just speaking the facts.


Cheerleaders are merely a mechanism that conveniently fits into the game model. You can think of the effect as 'home field advantage'.


It would be MUCH more acceptable to simply implement a statistical formula which gives the home team a slight edge when simming. Maybe this formula can vary with size of stadium, attendance, and composition of fan base. But cheerleaders = terrible idea.


Well put.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82


I consider this your coming out party. Congratulations. Maybe we add handbags to the list of items sold at the stadium, just for you.


Groovy input.

 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dth42888

So..... why not just have something simple like home field advantage? Does that not fit into the game model?

I don't think you guys realize the time it would take to code everything your wanting to do with this idea. It would be like creating an entirely new game.


Again, if you read the thread I addressed the coding issue and why it really wouldnt take all that long.

Originally posted by tjking82
I see it that my player which I worked hard to build in a football simulation has an outcome being determined by some fools putting together our cheerleading squad. Cheerleaders are essentially a non-factor. If you have them, your fans are a little more excited. Their quality is rarely if ever a factor in home field advantage. Shitty cheerleaders = great cheerleaders. No difference.


Hate to break it to you but fans affect a players morale both in real life and in this sim. Cheerleaders are just a way of influencing these fans, nothing more. Don't blame the cheerleaders if your play is terrible, blame your player.
 
CONN CHRIS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
mind telling me whats wrong with the suggestion?


You have been given essentially the same answer several hundred times. People came here to play fake football and strategize over fake football games. For most of those people, morale is something to be raised by figuring out how to win fake football games not by buying fake cheerleaders with real money.

Why you keep asking the same question over and over and why you like prepubescent girls so much are things I haven't an answer to.


 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dth42888

Well put.


When cheerleaders are implemented, I am using your avatar as my cheerleaders picture.

Her name will be Honey Bear.

 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by dth42888


So..... why not just have something simple like home field advantage? Does that not fit into the game model?

I don't think you guys realize the time it would take to code everything your wanting to do with this idea. It would be like creating an entirely new game.


Again, if you read the thread I addressed the coding issue and why it really wouldnt take all that long.

Originally posted by tjking82

I see it that my player which I worked hard to build in a football simulation has an outcome being determined by some fools putting together our cheerleading squad. Cheerleaders are essentially a non-factor. If you have them, your fans are a little more excited. Their quality is rarely if ever a factor in home field advantage. Shitty cheerleaders = great cheerleaders. No difference.


Hate to break it to you but fans affect a players morale both in real life and in this sim. Cheerleaders are just a way of influencing these fans, nothing more. Don't blame the cheerleaders if your play is terrible, blame your player.


Cheerleaders affect fans, yes but not in a large way. Fans affect players, yes but not in a large way. Combine these two factors and you find that Cheerleaders affect football players in a negligible, statistically insignificant way. In order to keep it realistic, the cheerleaders would have to have a statistically insignificant effect on the outcome of the game.

If you want a cheerleading game that has no effect on football, why not start up your own GLB-type site just for cheerleader development.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS

You have been given essentially the same answer several hundred times. People came here to play fake football and strategize over fake football games. For most of those people, morale is something to be raised by figuring out how to win fake football games not by buying fake cheerleaders with real money.

Why you keep asking the same question over and over and why you like prepubescent girls so much are things I haven't an answer to.




In real football player morale is influenced by the fans. Why shouldn't this be the same in fake football. However people would complain if fans had an effect on their morale and it was random (something they had no control over). Cheerleaders are a way to influence these fans (something you have control over).

I've addressed

-Why cheerleaders and not something else
-Why it doesn't take as much time as everybody thinks to code
-Why it fits in the game structure
-Why it's good from a business perspective
-Why it's fun

Among other things I'm probably leaving out.

Also like I said tj, they would affect morale but not be an imbalancing factor. They would just add hours of fun to those who decided to make them, a way for owners to influence player morale, and something new to fit into the football world.

Last edited Jun 23, 2008 18:57:59
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
630 posts (between this thread and my original idea thread here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=424530

Not one mod or admin has come in saying 'not a chance'. Haven't locked the thread (first thread was locked after this one was started)

What's that tell ya? Interest... that's what it tells ya.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.