User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti


 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Gart888

but on the bright side, this will make team mergers viable again

\o/


hell yes it will.


I mentioned that in the other thread and DD said in so many words that it's not a concern.

So, Gart, how many teams will you merge with this offseason???
 
refguru
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
to make it equal going forward you would have to remove some VA points from the dots that are 448 or older. I don't think removing BTs is a viable option and the training gains are small enough that I think it wouldn't wind up being that big of a deal there.

Make those dots revert back to the "new plateau" as much as you realistically can and I think everyone is happy going forward.


Well technically, the 480s+ would sitll have a seasons advantage on the 440s but there are other issues in play:

1. How do you take away BTs and VAs and TPs and SPs, etc from 480s to be equitable? You can't. There is no way to really do this. To simply take away VAs isn't equitable.
2. 439 guys have strategies with some of their AEQ etc. Prob some TPs as well. AEQ was purchased knowing full well they'd have next season to upgrade it to 72.

Originally posted by Ubasstards
instead of removing VAs just let all players accrue to day 480. Same thing really


Right. That's exactly what I'm saying.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jdros13

So players aren't on "equal footing" until day 480, which actually makes it LONGER to wait than under the current system (when you factor in the decline). I'd personally rather it be day 400 that we hit our peak (or earlier) but I definitely don't want to extend the player cycle to over 2 years.


Eh, players starting their 12th season, boosting to 72+, and just accruing VA/training are virtually on the same footing come playoff time as day 480 dots. And there's currently no equivalent for the 2 seasons of solid plateau.


yeah, not sure what jdros is trying to accomplish. Removing VAs doesnt make as much sense as simply letting all dots go to day 480 with VAs and training. I think what he really wants is to just make a player peak at a younger age and need retiring at age 400 days or so
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
I love it, now I get to spend 1/3 less money on this game. Thanks Bort, I'm glad you are willing to make 2/3 less money.
Edited by DONKEIDIC on Jun 24, 2010 13:06:33
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ijg
I mentioned that in the other thread and DD said in so many words that it's not a concern.

So, Gart, how many teams will you merge with this offseason???


More good/high-level players = More good/high-level teams.
Edited by DigitalDaggers on Jun 24, 2010 13:11:44
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
What about non-boosting builds that decide to boost late in their career?

We are going to see so many DIFFERENT decline ages, its a giant "moving" target to predict a declining build imo. Are we going to see 2 different ages, like we see a different color add-on when equip is on?

So much complexity!
 
DigitalDaggers
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
What about non-boosting builds that decide to boost late in their career?

We are going to see so many DIFFERENT decline ages, its a giant "moving" target to predict a declining build imo. Are we going to see 2 different ages, like we see a different color add-on when equip is on?

So much complexity!


4 days of plateau per boost = not a moving target
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Actually just cap vps at 75, and hand out 3tps per day forever, more training = more fun, and capping vas at 75 = balanced dots, you would get vas during plateau until you reach 75... Problem solvedimo


My thoughts exactly. Once Day 480 hits just stop handing out VAs, keep allowing training (people need something to do to keep interest).
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Eh, players starting their 12th season, boosting to 72+, and just accruing VA/training are virtually on the same footing come playoff time as day 480 dots. And there's currently no equivalent for the 2 seasons of solid plateau.


if we allow training/BT's/VA's through 480, sure.

but we are extending the build process to 480 days with this proposal, whereas the initial proposal was to 440 days (and I mis-read it to be 400 days initially apparently).

Look, I have 5 dots that will end this season at 440 days old and selfishly would I like to be able to finish off their AEQ's next season - sure. One of them was going to have their 4th done next season and all of them will have 3 if we could train until then. I thought the point was to make the player pool bigger though (which it is I think) but I have no idea why we would want to make the player lifespan actually longer than it is now.

A 440 day old dot is actually what, like 630 days old in real time when you factor in roughly 16 day offseason/preseasons? And now we are going to have dots that are 560 days old (if I'm reading that right - I'm assuming that the 120 extended plateau starts on day 441). Now we are talking about 800 day old dots (in real time) before they start to decline?

I hope this game is able to stay successful and keep people interested for another 2-3 years, but I would think that we would want to propose shortening the dot's lifespan, not making it even longer. All for an extended plateau for competitive purposes, but to me the eye should be on speeding things up, not dragging them out even further. All that does is keep the current top dots on top for another couple of months and push back those around 300 days old right now and make it a pipe dream for anyone with younger dots than that.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
yeah, not sure what jdros is trying to accomplish. Removing VAs doesnt make as much sense as simply letting all dots go to day 480 with VAs and training. I think what he really wants is to just make a player peak at a younger age and need retiring at age 400 days or so


I'd rather that, but I'm apparently in the minority, which is ok. I really don't want to be committing to 3 years to my next batch of dots though.
 
Craw33
offline
Link
 
Why not just make the cutoff 440?

There would be no need for figuring out VP's TP"s and BT's on the grandfathered players.

 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
4 days of plateau per boost = not a moving target


But currently is was EXACTLY 441 your build is declining, no matter WHAT!

Now a build can boost just 2 seasons and its age can be 465 days old then decline where a life time booster can decline MUCH later in his career ......

This is NOT equal decline aging across the board and more math will be needed to find out who is over the hill or not on every single build!
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
More good/high-level players = More good/high-level teams.


but it doesn't = more good/high quality owners and coordinators.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
But currently is was EXACTLY 441 your build is declining, no matter WHAT!

Now a build can boost just 2 seasons and its age can be 465 days old then decline where a life time booster can decline MUCH later in his career ......

This is NOT equal decline aging across the board and more math will be needed to find out who is over the hill or not on every single build!


at the lower levels, yes, I guess. It's pretty easy to figure out who boosts and who doesn't boost though, so unless you are recruiting a ton of old non-boosters (or infrequent boosters) it won't really be an issue. Any dot getting to L70 in the end game will have a 120 day extension.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.