User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > "I love you Grandma." "I love you too. Let's $%!#."
Page:
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

Foo, you are skipping several steps --- jumping to the end --- instead of starting at the beginning. It is very hard to dissect an argument that way.

I will once again suggest that you back up a few steps --- only after you understand his rationale/meaning can you hope to move the discussion ---


I am cutting to the chase. Who is the rapist when two consenting adults have sex and money is exchanged?



If you truly believe that --- and I know full well you do. You are allowing Cat off without a true conversation. Only after you understand his characterization can you move to this point.

When you are attempting to sell a house --- do you immediately jump into the final numbers? No, you work your way there --- it is a step by step process. Certainly, within each sell the steps are different --- just as they are within any debate. You cannot jump to the end --- if you have not gone through the steps. Who knows --- we all may learn something in the process.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
If you truly believe that --- and I know full well you do. You are allowing Cat off without a true conversation. Only after you understand his characterization can you move to this point.

When you are attempting to sell a house --- do you immediately jump into the final numbers? No, you work your way there --- it is a step by step process. Certainly, within each sell the steps are different --- just as they are within any debate. You cannot jump to the end --- if you have not gone through the steps. Who knows --- we all may learn something in the process.


I am not stopping him from sharing his thoughts.

If someone asks what the bottom line is, I tell them the bottom line. I don't jerk people around with semantics. Nor do I make absurd statements that I cannot explain without someone following a script to get me there. What you described is a used car salesman. You ask the price, and he starts talking about the undercoating and low miles. Cat is the used car salesman of P&R.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

If you truly believe that --- and I know full well you do. You are allowing Cat off without a true conversation. Only after you understand his characterization can you move to this point.

When you are attempting to sell a house --- do you immediately jump into the final numbers? No, you work your way there --- it is a step by step process. Certainly, within each sell the steps are different --- just as they are within any debate. You cannot jump to the end --- if you have not gone through the steps. Who knows --- we all may learn something in the process.


I am not stopping him from sharing his thoughts.

If someone asks what the bottom line is, I tell them the bottom line. I don't jerk people around with semantics. Nor do I make absurd statements that I cannot explain without someone following a script to get me there. What you described is a used car salesman. You ask the price, and he starts talking about the undercoating and low miles. Cat is the used car salesman of P&R.


Foo, you are not listening to either me now or Cat earlier.

You are bashing him for not sharing --- yet you refuse to ask?

In this case this is not purely semantics. He is not fooling around with words --- he has told you that he defines it as a 'form.' You have yet to ask why or how --- instead, jumping ahead five steps. Doing so --- rather, bluntly.

Furthermore, script does not equal process (even if it is a step by step one) --- as you will note, I stated that in every instance it is different. In addition --- even though you will give them the base price --- you will state the reasons why the price is what it is. That is the key point you seem to be missing --- in my opinion.

You certainly do not have to take my advice; however, from an outside perspective --- your current path is not going to advance the discussion.
Edited by oppco80 on May 2, 2010 23:32:50
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
I am not interested in hearing his professor's opinion of why he considers it a form of rape. I am interested in who the rapist is. If there is no rapist, there is no rape. Trying to use "Rape" to get an emotional reaction is all he has done, until he specifies who the rapist is.

Why should I go through a pointless exercise to get a simple answer? Do you know who the rapist is?
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
I am not interested in hearing his professor's opinion of why he considers it a form of rape. I am interested in who the rapist is. If there is no rapist, there is no rape. Trying to use "Rape" to get an emotional reaction is all he has done, until he specifies who the rapist is.

Why should I go through a pointless exercise to get a simple answer? Do you know who the rapist is?


I do not know why 'he' characterizes it as such. That is what I am interested to know --- just as I want to know why something is priced as it is --- not simply taking anything at face value.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
I am not interested in hearing his professor's opinion of why he considers it a form of rape. I am interested in who the rapist is. If there is no rapist, there is no rape. Trying to use "Rape" to get an emotional reaction is all he has done, until he specifies who the rapist is.

Why should I go through a pointless exercise to get a simple answer? Do you know who the rapist is?


Do you mind me asking why you included the bolded section.
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Also, it is the job of the person make that idiotic statement to justify their claim. It is not my job to walk him through the process of explaining himself.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Also, it is the job of the person make that idiotic statement to justify their claim. It is not my job to walk him through the process of explaining himself.


Only if they are asked to do so. You asked only about the rapist --- not why the claim was made --- or what it entailed. At least in the dozen or so posts I read.
Edited by oppco80 on May 2, 2010 23:57:45
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
'something' =/= 'form of something'
'rape' =/= 'form of 'rape'
'rape' =/= 'prostitution'

any of that help?


 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Do you mind me asking why you included the bolded section.


Because if it was his opinion, he could easily justify it. Also, the statement was very sociology grad school-ish. Pointless drivel that makes everyone a victim.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Also, it is the job of the person make that idiotic statement to justify their claim. It is not my job to walk him through the process of explaining himself.


why.
 
oppco80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by oppco80

Do you mind me asking why you included the bolded section.


Because if it was his opinion, he could easily justify it. Also, the statement was very sociology grad school-ish. Pointless drivel that makes everyone a victim.


You say this without any interest in asking him why he made the claim? You never asked why he classified it as such ---
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oppco80
Only if they are asked to do so. You asked only about the rapist --- not why the claim was made --- or what it entailed. At least in the dozen or so posts I read.


Because I don't care about the other stuff. Stating there is no rapist would be a perfectly acceptable answer, if that is what he believes, or he could state who the rapist is. Of course, if there is no rapist, there is no rape.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Because if it was his opinion, he could easily justify it.

i have, multiple times. the problem is you're not reading what i wrote. seriously.

Originally posted by foofighter24
Also, the statement was very sociology grad school-ish.

lol, try again.

Originally posted by foofighter24
Pointless drivel that makes everyone a victim.

oh, so that's what this is about? no wonder you're making this so political -- that's what you already think this is. very interesting.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Because I don't care about the other stuff. Stating there is no rapist would be a perfectly acceptable answer, if that is what he believes, or he could state who the rapist is. Of course, if there is no rapist, there is no rape.


Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by Catullus 16

'something' =/= 'form of something'
'rape' =/= 'form of 'rape'
'rape' =/= 'prostitution'

any of that help?




 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.