Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB - aren't you removing the fun out of the game?
Ronnie Brown 23
offline
offline
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
True, but it's nice to have it all summarized in one well-written post that will be noticed. People have talked about a lot of things for a long time without changes being implemented. Hopefully his post will help prevent that.
Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
True, but it's nice to have it all summarized in one well-written post that will be noticed. People have talked about a lot of things for a long time without changes being implemented. Hopefully his post will help prevent that.
jktooley
offline
offline
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
If you compare it to the decisions and plans being currently rolled out, you'd fall under the immediate impression that it was amazing insight...
Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
If you compare it to the decisions and plans being currently rolled out, you'd fall under the immediate impression that it was amazing insight...
odg62
offline
offline
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
Yup, there definitley is a genuine effort.
Its a dam shame that that effort gets second guessed and renigged on and is basically for nothing becuase a small portion of the user base has figured out exactly how to whine in order to get those changes renigged while keeping the game in the exact same sorry state it is in while self serving users continue to be allowed to game the system for their own benefit and only their own benefit.
(if you didnt figure it out, im talking mainly about the roster rules among a few other things)
Great post by Pierre, but it's definitely not new information or insight. This is stuff people have been talking about for months. I dont think there's one inaccuracy in that post. And im a big fan of the game, but these are some pretty big issues for many people. The bright side to all of it is that there seems to be a genuine effort going on to try and fix what's been broken for seasons.
Yup, there definitley is a genuine effort.
Its a dam shame that that effort gets second guessed and renigged on and is basically for nothing becuase a small portion of the user base has figured out exactly how to whine in order to get those changes renigged while keeping the game in the exact same sorry state it is in while self serving users continue to be allowed to game the system for their own benefit and only their own benefit.
(if you didnt figure it out, im talking mainly about the roster rules among a few other things)
Edited by odg62 on Feb 21, 2010 00:46:34
Gustoon
offline
offline
Originally posted by Catch22
First, I think it's a little unfair to blame me for 14 seasons of game issues. I've been on the job for exactly 33 days.
I agree with a lot of what you say PT and I know that fixing a lot of these issues is a priority for me personally. I'm not out to make the GLB experience worse for people, I'm trying to make it better.
I tried to have ALG's removed because I knew that was the cause for cap building/slow building- was shot down so I tried to do the next best thing by helping roll out the archetypes which at least gives players more flexibility and balances disproportionate builds somewhat.
I fully understand why teams merged. I moved about six of my players to Lincoln one season to help them compete at the World League level. I know that owning a team and coordinating is a hell of a lot of work. Been there, done that for 12+ seasons at a very high level for more teams than my own. It's one of the reasons why my next big project will be working on providing a way to where game planning and coordinating doesn't have to turn into a full time job for people.
Does the game's financial system need a lot of work? Absolutely... and it's being worked on. The announcement today was a measure to prevent teams from abusing rules that have been long neglected and never enforced until Bort is able to implement some of the ideas we are discussing and working on in regards to the financial system. Obviously, we (and as I've said previously, I'll take the blame for this) made a poor decision in regards to limiting player movement but we correctly removed that rule when we realized it was going to break up a lot of teams that enjoy playing the game.
The cash farms, however, is a problem and something we don't want to allow. It's not fair to a team that is doing it the right way to see another team use 300 million in funds from three other teams to equip their Pro League team while their team has to struggle to equip their players. It's an unfair advantage and one we're simply not going to allow from here on out. It's fine to equip your players in a normal fashion as they move up from a farm team. It's not fine to sign Player A to Team B, give them 10 million in EQ money, and then immediately trade them to Team A or cut them so they can to go Team A.
I'm doing all I can to try and bring the game forward in a positive manner. I'm probably going to make some mistakes while I learn on the fly. I'll admit to them though and learn from them.
I made a mistake with the announcement today. My intent was good, the message was bad. For that I apologize.
Don't do this myself, but the principle of this is right, just too late.
Alot of agents have gone by the rules and some have exploited, rightly or wrongly, but its there, the game has evolved BY agents and we all deal with it.
With everything thats going on here , personally speaking, its just too much.
It seems that the game is in fact broken in the eyes of some that run this game, when in fact alot of us don't thing so.
A few weeks back we filled in a survey for 30 pieces of silver, all I can say is if this game is being run by that survey, then I don't know zip about GLB.
For quite a few seasons I have had a team thats been promoted by 'default',(Teams above gone CPU etc...) and placed us in leagues that we have had NO CHANCE to win a thing. Despite my protests and requests to stay put, Admin / support (?) have ignored my pleas until either the season has started or its just about to and moving us would be impossible. How convenient.
This has really pissed me off and still does that I (and many like me) have been robbed of many $s and time.
I'd feel a whole lot better if GLB reimbursed me my Flex for these wasted years, but of course that will not happen either.
I'm going to be joining the ranks that are waiting to see how this turns out.
I love GLB, but TBH have just about had enough of the constant tinkering, and now all this just leaves me cold.
First, I think it's a little unfair to blame me for 14 seasons of game issues. I've been on the job for exactly 33 days.
I agree with a lot of what you say PT and I know that fixing a lot of these issues is a priority for me personally. I'm not out to make the GLB experience worse for people, I'm trying to make it better.
I tried to have ALG's removed because I knew that was the cause for cap building/slow building- was shot down so I tried to do the next best thing by helping roll out the archetypes which at least gives players more flexibility and balances disproportionate builds somewhat.
I fully understand why teams merged. I moved about six of my players to Lincoln one season to help them compete at the World League level. I know that owning a team and coordinating is a hell of a lot of work. Been there, done that for 12+ seasons at a very high level for more teams than my own. It's one of the reasons why my next big project will be working on providing a way to where game planning and coordinating doesn't have to turn into a full time job for people.
Does the game's financial system need a lot of work? Absolutely... and it's being worked on. The announcement today was a measure to prevent teams from abusing rules that have been long neglected and never enforced until Bort is able to implement some of the ideas we are discussing and working on in regards to the financial system. Obviously, we (and as I've said previously, I'll take the blame for this) made a poor decision in regards to limiting player movement but we correctly removed that rule when we realized it was going to break up a lot of teams that enjoy playing the game.
The cash farms, however, is a problem and something we don't want to allow. It's not fair to a team that is doing it the right way to see another team use 300 million in funds from three other teams to equip their Pro League team while their team has to struggle to equip their players. It's an unfair advantage and one we're simply not going to allow from here on out. It's fine to equip your players in a normal fashion as they move up from a farm team. It's not fine to sign Player A to Team B, give them 10 million in EQ money, and then immediately trade them to Team A or cut them so they can to go Team A.
I'm doing all I can to try and bring the game forward in a positive manner. I'm probably going to make some mistakes while I learn on the fly. I'll admit to them though and learn from them.
I made a mistake with the announcement today. My intent was good, the message was bad. For that I apologize.
Don't do this myself, but the principle of this is right, just too late.
Alot of agents have gone by the rules and some have exploited, rightly or wrongly, but its there, the game has evolved BY agents and we all deal with it.
With everything thats going on here , personally speaking, its just too much.
It seems that the game is in fact broken in the eyes of some that run this game, when in fact alot of us don't thing so.
A few weeks back we filled in a survey for 30 pieces of silver, all I can say is if this game is being run by that survey, then I don't know zip about GLB.
For quite a few seasons I have had a team thats been promoted by 'default',(Teams above gone CPU etc...) and placed us in leagues that we have had NO CHANCE to win a thing. Despite my protests and requests to stay put, Admin / support (?) have ignored my pleas until either the season has started or its just about to and moving us would be impossible. How convenient.
This has really pissed me off and still does that I (and many like me) have been robbed of many $s and time.
I'd feel a whole lot better if GLB reimbursed me my Flex for these wasted years, but of course that will not happen either.
I'm going to be joining the ranks that are waiting to see how this turns out.
I love GLB, but TBH have just about had enough of the constant tinkering, and now all this just leaves me cold.
odg62
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Do you know why teams merge?
They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging.
And realizing that this type of practice is what is killing parity in GLB should have happened seasons ago but still, stopping the way mergers are carried out in GLB would still be as easy a thing to do now as it would have beforehand, except now there will just be a lot more bitching. oh well, if your serious about fixing the game you do it anyway.
Originally posted by Catch22
Obviously, we (and as I've said previously, I'll take the blame for this) made a poor decision in regards to limiting player movement but we correctly removed that rule when we realized it was going to break up a lot of teams that enjoy playing the game.
No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.
Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.
Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?
The poor decision was reversing the original plan.
Do you know why teams merge?
They merge because the tactics, game management, player management, agent management, financial management and daily stress of owning a team is far too much for 2-3 people at high levels and most importantly because they watched merging teams win multiple championships at high levels and quickly realized unless just a few people own all the players on a team winning it all becomes impossible without merging.
And realizing that this type of practice is what is killing parity in GLB should have happened seasons ago but still, stopping the way mergers are carried out in GLB would still be as easy a thing to do now as it would have beforehand, except now there will just be a lot more bitching. oh well, if your serious about fixing the game you do it anyway.
Originally posted by Catch22
Obviously, we (and as I've said previously, I'll take the blame for this) made a poor decision in regards to limiting player movement but we correctly removed that rule when we realized it was going to break up a lot of teams that enjoy playing the game.
No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.
Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.
Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?
The poor decision was reversing the original plan.
Edited by odg62 on Feb 21, 2010 02:35:09
Edited by odg62 on Feb 21, 2010 02:34:38
Edited by odg62 on Feb 21, 2010 02:34:02
Edited by odg62 on Feb 21, 2010 02:29:55
CinTex
offline
offline
Originally posted by odg62
No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.
Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.
Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?
The poor decision was reversing the original plan.
You can think that all you want however I disagree.... when you build a low level team to move to a Pro team then, that's the plan, its not a merger or collusion or cheating... its pre-recruiting.... there is already a big penalty for it, its called Chemistry....
No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.
Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.
Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?
The poor decision was reversing the original plan.
You can think that all you want however I disagree.... when you build a low level team to move to a Pro team then, that's the plan, its not a merger or collusion or cheating... its pre-recruiting.... there is already a big penalty for it, its called Chemistry....
PierreThomas
offline
offline
Originally posted by odg62
No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.
Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.
Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?
The poor decision was reversing the original plan.
Something tells me you just don't get it. I see you don't own a team, you don't have any players that have reached level 64 and needed equipment, you have one player that has reached level 56, you don't have any players in pro or WL. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being a noob of sorts but you really don't have any experience to speak from when it comes to managing finances at a high level or managing a competitive team.
Mergers are not the problem. The problem is when a majority of the really good teams have left the game from boredom and burnout that there is very few highly competitive teams left and when those good teams go away the players migrate to the handful of great teams that can pay for equipment upgrades and they know they'll win. This is what created the parity void, not mergers.
The rule change wasn't going to hurt the elite teams because they are already set, it was going to hurt the up and coming agents such as yourself because they would never be able to get an equal competitive advantage. Don't believe me? We have several slow build teams about the same level as most of your players, each of the teams have well over a hundred million in the bank and they will all get home field just about every season. Those teams will be able to afford lvl 64 equipment and will be able to rework equipment whenever needed.
These teams didn't cheat or game the system. They simply started over and have a truck load of cash from it. So which team has the advantage, the one scrapping by each season to upgrade about half the team or the one that if fully upgraded and can rework equipment to adapt to an ever changing sim?
I think you completely misinterpreted my post. I'm not for cash farm teams. I've been against them for a long time but I'm also not dumb enough to think they aren't needed to keep up with the Jones'. As far as the thrones go, what better way to take away the hierarchy's advantage than to level the playing field by making equipment equally affordable to all?
If you are simply complaining about teams being able to remain competitive by bringing in new players each season to replace the old then I'm not quite sure hot to comment on that. Would that be kind of like an NFL team having to try and build through the draft and unrestricted free agent rookies every ten seasons instead of using free agency, the draft, trades and practice squads? Yeah, doesn't make much sense now does it?
You may think that the agents with big accounts that have been around forever and are constantly online are trying to whine to game the system but you might be surprised how many people are not. You might be quite surprised to find out just how many of these players are really concerned about the state of the game because they not only have a lot of money, time and energy invested in the game but they also really enjoy playing it and enjoy the friendships that have been made. Most of the long term agents in this game really do want improvement for the game. When we first started in season one and two, it was almost impossible to find level one players willing to sign. I remember the day I got my team I spent 30 consecutive hours recruiting and managed to sign on about ten level one players. I made about fifteen more players and the agents that had already signed created a few more dots and over the next couple weeks managed to get a full team. It probably took 80 hours of recruiting to get it done, now new players have a very difficult time even finding a team. There were 600-750 teams a season being released and the game was doubling in size every few days. By season 7 there were a hundred really good teams and the parity from pro league all the way down to A leagues was pretty damn good. There were some teams in A and BBB leagues that could beat some pro teams. The game was full of excitement, people stayed on the game all day long and the forums had hundreds of threads a day.
Since that time the game has gone down. More people are leaving or losing interest now than are coming in. One of the main reasons is that the game has gotten so damn complicated that a new player can't walk in and possibly fully grasp the game for months. When the game started, a defensive coordinator could set to defend the pass XX%, defend the run XX% and choose how often to defend the inside/outside run or how deep to defend and whether to run zone or man. That is it. A gameplan took ten minutes. Now I'm not saying it should be that simple now but I do think the more we as agents crave the ability to do new stuff like custom depth chart spots, tagging, packages, defensive play creator, route progressions, etc. we are improving the realistic aspect of the game and open endless possibilities. However, at the same time we are making it harder and harder to bring in new players so when the old die out there aren't enough people there to take their place. Not only are there not enough newer players but they can't connect to the game like the early agents could because it was so easy to get involved in the early seasons compared to now where you need to get an online bachelor's degree in AI management just to understand how to play. Before you could worry about stuff like posting in the team forum and shooting the shit with other players, now you have to spend hours on gameplanning. While I would love parity, I'm sure as hell glad that the two main teams I do the most with wont have another competitive game until week thirteen. I used to look forward to the competitive games, now I like looking forward to them way off but as they get close I lose the excitement because I know I'll have to spend hours gameplanning.
This is the best part of the season for me because I can relax. The playoffs are extremely stressful because I have to gameplan for hours for one game for every team I help with and then each of these teams have back to back to back games resulting in a 2-3 games a day @ 2-3 hours a piece for a week straight. If I didn't own my business I would literally have to take a week off work just to get gameplanning done for the playoffs. That is followed by the offseason where we have to manage a handful of rosters, recruit, get players signed, rework VAs and learn a completely new sim each season.
While the realism is great, I don't think working the same hours as an NFL GM was ever really the realism goal. It is no wonder owners can't find coordinators, coordinators get burned out to the point they completely lose interest in the game and suddenly the game starts really declining.
I know Catch is working on putting together another type of league in between casual and the advanced leagues and I even suggested this several seasons back but at this point I think that is a terrible idea as well. Casual leagues had a chance to be an incredible tool for the game but it fell short by not allowing teams to transfer to casual and limiting the casual leagues to lower level players immediately eliminating half the game from being able to participate without starting at level one. Then the casual leagues were too casual. it was like showing up in board shorts and wife beater to a nice steak house that advertises casual dining.
Now a middle league is basically just going to pull some people craving something new from casual and normal leagues giving us three types of leagues with no parity and a huge void in all three leagues.
These are my suggestions to really fix this game quickly or at the very least make it much more stable.
The very first thing that needs to be done is to make equipment very affordable. My suggestion to make things easy to simply make equipment 30% less expensive at each level that way you can keep finances exactly the way they are you don't have to rework the entire finance system. Allow users to get a full flex credit when swapping out custom equipment once each offseason to ajust to the sim. Allow 30 VA point reset each offseason. This will allow teams to adapt to the sim every season. It will allow parity between the rich and the poor. This will eliminate the need to cheat because lets face it, the financial system in this game is not so enjoyable that it makes trying to police the cheating and colluding worth it.
Allow full account mergers for one week again then put the clamps down on multi's because it seems like everyone I talk to has multiple accounts now and it isn't enforced it is something that needs to be done away with. I don't care if you have to charge 500 flex to merge accounts it really needs to get done. The combination of the affordable equipment and the account mergers will instantly eliminate almost all of the useless teams out there making these 255-0 games and free up a lot more players that are sitting on farm teams to collect huge amounts of money so they can sign with the teams that really are trying to compete.
This will also give you a much more realistic idea where the game stands. Now that you have gotten here, condense the leagues instead of filling the holes with computer teams. Computer teams and players should be a last resort of sorts. When reworking the leagues have them set up with appropriate level caps and floors. You can still have some uncapped minor teams but make the owners choose whether they want to play in a competitive league or have their friend with an inappropriately high/low level player on the roster. It they are in uncapped leagues then it is by their own choice and they can't complain about the lack of parity. When setting up the cap leagues find a way to work in creation date to get rid of SSB teams. Make it to where there is a limit on how many SSB and non boosters can play on one team.
Those things will instantly create parity where there is none. Sure, every game wont be a nail-biter but at least people will log on to see if they won, they might even go into the league forums to see rankings and find discussion. This will go such a long way to really help the game as a whole.
The next thing that needs to be done is find a way to greatly reduce the workload on owners and coordinators. Fixing equipment prices will do a lot of that because they wont have to recruit player x to team B, load up the cash in team B for player x, wait 6 days then trade player B from team x to team y just to buy equipment for a player.
I don't know enough about coding to really help much in this area. I know the AI needs to be made much simpler. Maybe have a skeleton AI that has just about every possibility listed and set accordingly already so teams just have to add the plays but can still expand on it. Another thing I know is needed is to have the inputs expanded to where you can set them to fire between certain times. ie: 2nd down 5, strong i, between 200 seconds and 500 seconds run x. Not a lot but something that would help.
One thing I do know that could be a huge time saver is a real comprehensive scouting program. I love the scouting feature that was added but when it comes time to really gameplan it becomes a pretty big waste since it isn't nearly comprehensive enough. Features need to be added but it would help so much. Make dropdown boxes for down and distance so it is much more specific. Right now 3rd and 3-10 just doesn't cut it. Also add another drop down feature to sort plays based on where on the field they take place. Plays inside the 5 are usually very different from plays between the 40s. Then another drop down box with player names that breaks down the play calls based on which players are in, also combinations of players. If you want to keep tagging this is an option that makes tagging much less work. This would save so much time from trying to watch replays, see which formation is being run from which down and distance and figure out which players are on the field then trying to find like situations to see if there is a trend.
The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers.
I know some of this would cost some short term flex monies but I promise it would be returned with plenty to spare.
This turned into a mega post and I can't believe I took the time but it feels like time is running out on keeping GLB around as a great and fun game. I will put myself out there to help out in some areas of the game. I know I've been a very harsh critic for a long time but I really do think Bort is taking steps to try and fix some long term problems. The hiring of Catch was a great step in the right direction and if you guys think I can help then I'd be willing.
No, you did not make a poor decision, you made the right one.
Dont kid yourself. To say the decision which would have bettered the game as a whole for ALL users was "poor", is just a cop out covering up the fact that the decision to reverse it was made based on the resitance by the current heiracrchy dominated by a handful of users who dont want to give up their thrones, regardless of how much it hurts the game.
Those users dont have to be playing together with full farm teams to enjoy the game. 95% of the GLB population enjoys the game without that advantage, why cant they?
The poor decision was reversing the original plan.
Something tells me you just don't get it. I see you don't own a team, you don't have any players that have reached level 64 and needed equipment, you have one player that has reached level 56, you don't have any players in pro or WL. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being a noob of sorts but you really don't have any experience to speak from when it comes to managing finances at a high level or managing a competitive team.
Mergers are not the problem. The problem is when a majority of the really good teams have left the game from boredom and burnout that there is very few highly competitive teams left and when those good teams go away the players migrate to the handful of great teams that can pay for equipment upgrades and they know they'll win. This is what created the parity void, not mergers.
The rule change wasn't going to hurt the elite teams because they are already set, it was going to hurt the up and coming agents such as yourself because they would never be able to get an equal competitive advantage. Don't believe me? We have several slow build teams about the same level as most of your players, each of the teams have well over a hundred million in the bank and they will all get home field just about every season. Those teams will be able to afford lvl 64 equipment and will be able to rework equipment whenever needed.
These teams didn't cheat or game the system. They simply started over and have a truck load of cash from it. So which team has the advantage, the one scrapping by each season to upgrade about half the team or the one that if fully upgraded and can rework equipment to adapt to an ever changing sim?
I think you completely misinterpreted my post. I'm not for cash farm teams. I've been against them for a long time but I'm also not dumb enough to think they aren't needed to keep up with the Jones'. As far as the thrones go, what better way to take away the hierarchy's advantage than to level the playing field by making equipment equally affordable to all?
If you are simply complaining about teams being able to remain competitive by bringing in new players each season to replace the old then I'm not quite sure hot to comment on that. Would that be kind of like an NFL team having to try and build through the draft and unrestricted free agent rookies every ten seasons instead of using free agency, the draft, trades and practice squads? Yeah, doesn't make much sense now does it?
You may think that the agents with big accounts that have been around forever and are constantly online are trying to whine to game the system but you might be surprised how many people are not. You might be quite surprised to find out just how many of these players are really concerned about the state of the game because they not only have a lot of money, time and energy invested in the game but they also really enjoy playing it and enjoy the friendships that have been made. Most of the long term agents in this game really do want improvement for the game. When we first started in season one and two, it was almost impossible to find level one players willing to sign. I remember the day I got my team I spent 30 consecutive hours recruiting and managed to sign on about ten level one players. I made about fifteen more players and the agents that had already signed created a few more dots and over the next couple weeks managed to get a full team. It probably took 80 hours of recruiting to get it done, now new players have a very difficult time even finding a team. There were 600-750 teams a season being released and the game was doubling in size every few days. By season 7 there were a hundred really good teams and the parity from pro league all the way down to A leagues was pretty damn good. There were some teams in A and BBB leagues that could beat some pro teams. The game was full of excitement, people stayed on the game all day long and the forums had hundreds of threads a day.
Since that time the game has gone down. More people are leaving or losing interest now than are coming in. One of the main reasons is that the game has gotten so damn complicated that a new player can't walk in and possibly fully grasp the game for months. When the game started, a defensive coordinator could set to defend the pass XX%, defend the run XX% and choose how often to defend the inside/outside run or how deep to defend and whether to run zone or man. That is it. A gameplan took ten minutes. Now I'm not saying it should be that simple now but I do think the more we as agents crave the ability to do new stuff like custom depth chart spots, tagging, packages, defensive play creator, route progressions, etc. we are improving the realistic aspect of the game and open endless possibilities. However, at the same time we are making it harder and harder to bring in new players so when the old die out there aren't enough people there to take their place. Not only are there not enough newer players but they can't connect to the game like the early agents could because it was so easy to get involved in the early seasons compared to now where you need to get an online bachelor's degree in AI management just to understand how to play. Before you could worry about stuff like posting in the team forum and shooting the shit with other players, now you have to spend hours on gameplanning. While I would love parity, I'm sure as hell glad that the two main teams I do the most with wont have another competitive game until week thirteen. I used to look forward to the competitive games, now I like looking forward to them way off but as they get close I lose the excitement because I know I'll have to spend hours gameplanning.
This is the best part of the season for me because I can relax. The playoffs are extremely stressful because I have to gameplan for hours for one game for every team I help with and then each of these teams have back to back to back games resulting in a 2-3 games a day @ 2-3 hours a piece for a week straight. If I didn't own my business I would literally have to take a week off work just to get gameplanning done for the playoffs. That is followed by the offseason where we have to manage a handful of rosters, recruit, get players signed, rework VAs and learn a completely new sim each season.
While the realism is great, I don't think working the same hours as an NFL GM was ever really the realism goal. It is no wonder owners can't find coordinators, coordinators get burned out to the point they completely lose interest in the game and suddenly the game starts really declining.
I know Catch is working on putting together another type of league in between casual and the advanced leagues and I even suggested this several seasons back but at this point I think that is a terrible idea as well. Casual leagues had a chance to be an incredible tool for the game but it fell short by not allowing teams to transfer to casual and limiting the casual leagues to lower level players immediately eliminating half the game from being able to participate without starting at level one. Then the casual leagues were too casual. it was like showing up in board shorts and wife beater to a nice steak house that advertises casual dining.
Now a middle league is basically just going to pull some people craving something new from casual and normal leagues giving us three types of leagues with no parity and a huge void in all three leagues.
These are my suggestions to really fix this game quickly or at the very least make it much more stable.
The very first thing that needs to be done is to make equipment very affordable. My suggestion to make things easy to simply make equipment 30% less expensive at each level that way you can keep finances exactly the way they are you don't have to rework the entire finance system. Allow users to get a full flex credit when swapping out custom equipment once each offseason to ajust to the sim. Allow 30 VA point reset each offseason. This will allow teams to adapt to the sim every season. It will allow parity between the rich and the poor. This will eliminate the need to cheat because lets face it, the financial system in this game is not so enjoyable that it makes trying to police the cheating and colluding worth it.
Allow full account mergers for one week again then put the clamps down on multi's because it seems like everyone I talk to has multiple accounts now and it isn't enforced it is something that needs to be done away with. I don't care if you have to charge 500 flex to merge accounts it really needs to get done. The combination of the affordable equipment and the account mergers will instantly eliminate almost all of the useless teams out there making these 255-0 games and free up a lot more players that are sitting on farm teams to collect huge amounts of money so they can sign with the teams that really are trying to compete.
This will also give you a much more realistic idea where the game stands. Now that you have gotten here, condense the leagues instead of filling the holes with computer teams. Computer teams and players should be a last resort of sorts. When reworking the leagues have them set up with appropriate level caps and floors. You can still have some uncapped minor teams but make the owners choose whether they want to play in a competitive league or have their friend with an inappropriately high/low level player on the roster. It they are in uncapped leagues then it is by their own choice and they can't complain about the lack of parity. When setting up the cap leagues find a way to work in creation date to get rid of SSB teams. Make it to where there is a limit on how many SSB and non boosters can play on one team.
Those things will instantly create parity where there is none. Sure, every game wont be a nail-biter but at least people will log on to see if they won, they might even go into the league forums to see rankings and find discussion. This will go such a long way to really help the game as a whole.
The next thing that needs to be done is find a way to greatly reduce the workload on owners and coordinators. Fixing equipment prices will do a lot of that because they wont have to recruit player x to team B, load up the cash in team B for player x, wait 6 days then trade player B from team x to team y just to buy equipment for a player.
I don't know enough about coding to really help much in this area. I know the AI needs to be made much simpler. Maybe have a skeleton AI that has just about every possibility listed and set accordingly already so teams just have to add the plays but can still expand on it. Another thing I know is needed is to have the inputs expanded to where you can set them to fire between certain times. ie: 2nd down 5, strong i, between 200 seconds and 500 seconds run x. Not a lot but something that would help.
One thing I do know that could be a huge time saver is a real comprehensive scouting program. I love the scouting feature that was added but when it comes time to really gameplan it becomes a pretty big waste since it isn't nearly comprehensive enough. Features need to be added but it would help so much. Make dropdown boxes for down and distance so it is much more specific. Right now 3rd and 3-10 just doesn't cut it. Also add another drop down feature to sort plays based on where on the field they take place. Plays inside the 5 are usually very different from plays between the 40s. Then another drop down box with player names that breaks down the play calls based on which players are in, also combinations of players. If you want to keep tagging this is an option that makes tagging much less work. This would save so much time from trying to watch replays, see which formation is being run from which down and distance and figure out which players are on the field then trying to find like situations to see if there is a trend.
The next thing that can be done is to offer flex, even a small amount to team owner and coordinators that win a gold or silver trophy in AAA, Pro or WL. This will create a much bigger supply of coordinators that actually care. It will give the non-boosters an incentive to learn how to coordinate and bring more to the game and get them more interested, maybe they will even turn into paying customers.

I know some of this would cost some short term flex monies but I promise it would be returned with plenty to spare.
This turned into a mega post and I can't believe I took the time but it feels like time is running out on keeping GLB around as a great and fun game. I will put myself out there to help out in some areas of the game. I know I've been a very harsh critic for a long time but I really do think Bort is taking steps to try and fix some long term problems. The hiring of Catch was a great step in the right direction and if you guys think I can help then I'd be willing.
CinTex
offline
offline
PT.... 
Incredible insight!..... I know the right people will read that and I hope they take your suggestions to heart...

Incredible insight!..... I know the right people will read that and I hope they take your suggestions to heart...
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by PierreThomas
I don't know enough about coding to really help much in this area. I know the AI needs to be made much simpler. Maybe have a skeleton AI that has just about every possibility listed and set accordingly already so teams just have to add the plays but can still expand on it. Another thing I know is needed is to have the inputs expanded to where you can set them to fire between certain times. ie: 2nd down 5, strong i, between 200 seconds and 500 seconds run x. Not a lot but something that would help.
One thing I do know that could be a huge time saver is a real comprehensive scouting program. I love the scouting feature that was added but when it comes time to really gameplan it becomes a pretty big waste since it isn't nearly comprehensive enough. Features need to be added but it would help so much. Make dropdown boxes for down and distance so it is much more specific. Right now 3rd and 3-10 just doesn't cut it. Also add another drop down feature to sort plays based on where on the field they take place. Plays inside the 5 are usually very different from plays between the 40s. Then another drop down box with player names that breaks down the play calls based on which players are in, also combinations of players. If you want to keep tagging this is an option that makes tagging much less work. This would save so much time from trying to watch replays, see which formation is being run from which down and distance and figure out which players are on the field then trying to find like situations to see if there is a trend.
i cant believe i read all of this...i must be bored...
anyways...a skeleton AI would probably go a long way for any noob OC...I cant even begin to count the number of AI's I have had to transfer to people for a starter.
As far as the scouting program goes...when does it become too much? The scout tool is ok...but I wish Bort would just take Monsterkill and add it to the site with the names of each play added in once it scouts the game. Thats all one needs to plan for a game and it really doesn't even take an intense amount of time if you use it. Can you spend an intense amount of time? Sure...Do you have to in order to be successful? Not at all.
I don't know enough about coding to really help much in this area. I know the AI needs to be made much simpler. Maybe have a skeleton AI that has just about every possibility listed and set accordingly already so teams just have to add the plays but can still expand on it. Another thing I know is needed is to have the inputs expanded to where you can set them to fire between certain times. ie: 2nd down 5, strong i, between 200 seconds and 500 seconds run x. Not a lot but something that would help.
One thing I do know that could be a huge time saver is a real comprehensive scouting program. I love the scouting feature that was added but when it comes time to really gameplan it becomes a pretty big waste since it isn't nearly comprehensive enough. Features need to be added but it would help so much. Make dropdown boxes for down and distance so it is much more specific. Right now 3rd and 3-10 just doesn't cut it. Also add another drop down feature to sort plays based on where on the field they take place. Plays inside the 5 are usually very different from plays between the 40s. Then another drop down box with player names that breaks down the play calls based on which players are in, also combinations of players. If you want to keep tagging this is an option that makes tagging much less work. This would save so much time from trying to watch replays, see which formation is being run from which down and distance and figure out which players are on the field then trying to find like situations to see if there is a trend.
i cant believe i read all of this...i must be bored...

anyways...a skeleton AI would probably go a long way for any noob OC...I cant even begin to count the number of AI's I have had to transfer to people for a starter.
As far as the scouting program goes...when does it become too much? The scout tool is ok...but I wish Bort would just take Monsterkill and add it to the site with the names of each play added in once it scouts the game. Thats all one needs to plan for a game and it really doesn't even take an intense amount of time if you use it. Can you spend an intense amount of time? Sure...Do you have to in order to be successful? Not at all.
I have one question, why has Bort or Catch not asked PT to sit on a board or some type of GLB committee to voice the many opinions/concerns of owners and agents across GLB. You can agree or disagree with PT on many things, but one thing you can not is his genuine concern for the future and betterment of this game! You can't have a bunch of yes men running this game, you need someone that is not afraid to disagree and has valid input to back it up....
BADGERBACKER
offline
offline
Originally posted by CinTex
PT....
Incredible insight!..... I know the right people will read that and I hope they take your suggestions to heart...
Yep, nice read. I hope a few others read it and think about it and consider applying it. Great suggestions.
PT....

Incredible insight!..... I know the right people will read that and I hope they take your suggestions to heart...
Yep, nice read. I hope a few others read it and think about it and consider applying it. Great suggestions.
bhall43
offline
offline
Originally posted by rjssob
I have one question, why has Bort or Catch not asked PT to sit on a board or some type of GLB committee to voice the many opinions/concerns of owners and agents across GLB. You can agree or disagree with PT on many things, but one thing you can not is his genuine concern for the future and betterment of this game! You can't have a bunch of yes men running this game, you need someone that is not afraid to disagree and has valid input to back it up....
much like many of the guys that were hired.
I have one question, why has Bort or Catch not asked PT to sit on a board or some type of GLB committee to voice the many opinions/concerns of owners and agents across GLB. You can agree or disagree with PT on many things, but one thing you can not is his genuine concern for the future and betterment of this game! You can't have a bunch of yes men running this game, you need someone that is not afraid to disagree and has valid input to back it up....
much like many of the guys that were hired.
PT, i don't agree with your comments about the Casual leagues at all.
The rest is near spot on though.
The rest is near spot on though.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.



























