I like the boost to playing against higher level guys, but am a little weary about a penalty for playing lower-level guys.
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
bignath87
offline
offline
How about this for an idea, its gonna be a bit rambly but stick with it.
Each team as a whole gets given XP for playing a game. This XP is then divided among the Offense and Defense. Then it is once again divided among the players on the O and D according to their contribution with a minimum allotment for players who get no playing time (e.g. a 4th string SS or FS)
To tackle the issue that the higher your level the less XP you get there is a smaller factor of XP alloted to the teams higher players. So lets say the whole offense has 1100 split among 11 players, Each player is given 1000 XP but if you are the highest player you loose 11 percent of your XP and it goes to the lowest player, and second highest looses 10 percent to the second lowest players and so forth.
This way the lower levels still level faster then the higher one. On top of this the teams are given XP depending on the average level (e.g. a level 4 average team would get 19000 XP and a level 5 team would get 18000XP)so on and so forth.
An XP boost for certain factors:
Winning
Sacks
Interceptions
Pancakes
More then X amount of P/R yards
Ect
Tell me what you think, and before anyone says it i know i am an idiot ect. But constructive criticism is appreciated.
Each team as a whole gets given XP for playing a game. This XP is then divided among the Offense and Defense. Then it is once again divided among the players on the O and D according to their contribution with a minimum allotment for players who get no playing time (e.g. a 4th string SS or FS)
To tackle the issue that the higher your level the less XP you get there is a smaller factor of XP alloted to the teams higher players. So lets say the whole offense has 1100 split among 11 players, Each player is given 1000 XP but if you are the highest player you loose 11 percent of your XP and it goes to the lowest player, and second highest looses 10 percent to the second lowest players and so forth.
This way the lower levels still level faster then the higher one. On top of this the teams are given XP depending on the average level (e.g. a level 4 average team would get 19000 XP and a level 5 team would get 18000XP)so on and so forth.
An XP boost for certain factors:
Winning
Sacks
Interceptions
Pancakes
More then X amount of P/R yards
Ect
Tell me what you think, and before anyone says it i know i am an idiot ect. But constructive criticism is appreciated.
CanadianQB
offline
offline
Run it very much like a college sked, you are slated to play x# of teams and the nyou are free to sked anyone else during preaseason. League Tournaments (Playoffs) still based on league record, but teams will quickly sort themselves out for xp. Rank all teams before the scheduleling period by average level and put a cap on how hiwhg up/down they can play
kppk11
offline
offline
i dont think we should have the level cap because like everyone in usa a #4 is like over lvl 12which i think is the cap
MidnightJacket
offline
offline
2 words - power leveling. Just let this idea go because it will create more problems than potential good.
I like the idea of an XP bonus, but this isn't the way to do it. I like an XP bonus for units on a team performing well (like a 100 XP bonus to each D-Linemen for all of them playing well), but that's already being discussed on another thread. People could still power level, but it would be MUCH slower and more difficult IMO.
I like the idea of an XP bonus, but this isn't the way to do it. I like an XP bonus for units on a team performing well (like a 100 XP bonus to each D-Linemen for all of them playing well), but that's already being discussed on another thread. People could still power level, but it would be MUCH slower and more difficult IMO.
Last edited Jun 19, 2008 11:04:34
nortyfiner
offline
offline
The idea of getting more XP for playing below level, I know would help a great deal with parity in my league. We have basically the top four or five teams that are truly competitive with each other, and then there's everyone else. We have a really hurting team at the bottom that was gutted and can't even get D-leaguers to sign. More XP for all those middle and bottom teams would really help make things more fun.
Fullback41
offline
offline
what about teams that are rebuilding or have a neglect owner Like Bort's Wrath in SA Pro
ArmchairGM
offline
offline
There's now 29 pages of this thread and I won't check all 29 pages to see if I already posted. I'm opposed to this idea. It handicaps rebuilding teams that are working hard and trying to do it with the players they have signed instead of signing random high lvl players that may not be quality peeps like the lower lvls that the rebuilding teams are trying to develop. In essence it would penalize effort.
HalbIRo
offline
offline
MidnightJacket is right.
result would be 'dead' teams in high leagues that are only used for power-levelling.
If a team could loose a level if they constantly suck (moving up and down like in the european soccer leagues for example) it would make sense because then the teams level would automatically adjust to the players level.
result would be 'dead' teams in high leagues that are only used for power-levelling.
If a team could loose a level if they constantly suck (moving up and down like in the european soccer leagues for example) it would make sense because then the teams level would automatically adjust to the players level.
trazer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Serenity
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise
i agree with this as the realism is that you could "learn by watching" your opponent kick your butt and use those "skills" against others.
I'd almost prefer just a small boost of XP for players playing against players who are higher level and no penalty otherwise
i agree with this as the realism is that you could "learn by watching" your opponent kick your butt and use those "skills" against others.
ryan20662
offline
offline
I have no problem with incentives or the penalties based off of league level or median whichever Bort decides on but the penalty or bonus should be happen as a season ending thing. One it will have no affect on good planning by owners during the season but work toward evening the playing field on subsequent seasons. Two because it could unfairly punish players that choose to boost early. I have a LB in BBB that is probably currently 5 lvls over the league average because I decided to boost early because of problems with his build that I decided to correct early to help the team instead of holding out for greater experience. Conversely I have 3 other players in the same league. One is about league level without boosting, one at league level with boosting and one below. My LB would be unfairly punished all season if the penalty is at every game/daily xp award. At the end of the season he'll most likely be at league level or within the reasonable limit again.
Jonny Patches
offline
offline
What about an XP curve for punters and kickers, since they get far less field time (on average) then your normal player
Rezlov
offline
offline
Why not let stats have to do with XP? You can make it so each tackle is worth 1xp or something like that [probably more] BUT keep a CAP on it so when you have massive blow out games players don't get to much.
Coriantumr
offline
offline
I don't like stat related XP, The stats don't always go to the best players. With stat XP you can favor certain people on offense. The way it is set up even backup players can level up. You pay to play the game if you are any good and stat XP is not any good at all.
As for XP bonus for playing higher levels I think is a great idea because soon, you will become that higher level and not get your bonuses. It will just be a quicker way to even out the teams.
The one thing I don't like is if there is a hole in the league it gets filled with a starter team that is many levels below the average. This is where you get some games that are 200-0. That is ridiculous. These teams should be put into lower level regions but with 1000's of teams out there that is hard to relegate.
As for XP bonus for playing higher levels I think is a great idea because soon, you will become that higher level and not get your bonuses. It will just be a quicker way to even out the teams.
The one thing I don't like is if there is a hole in the league it gets filled with a starter team that is many levels below the average. This is where you get some games that are 200-0. That is ridiculous. These teams should be put into lower level regions but with 1000's of teams out there that is hard to relegate.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























