Originally posted by Rage Kinard
The problem is you are assuming someone would create a coach when the coach couldn't be associated with the team he was a player for.
I would. I'd probably want to have at least a player or two on the team so I cared about the team, but that's already the way it is in terms of my trying to get my players together on a few teams.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I'm not against coaches. I'm against coaches being added to the game under the conditions that have been laid forth.
I still say no more than 5 per team, and you have to lower the retirement age before becoming a coach. Day 360 (9 full seasons) is probably a good cut off IMO. At the very least you need to reduce the cutoff to 400 so players don't have to worry about what to do when they will start hitting decline mid season.
There's a reasonable case for making it Day 400, or maybe Day 410 so that if a player is going to have significant decline during a season he can coach instead. I wouldn't perpetually limit it to 5 per team; I'd let it grow as the supply grows.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I would also like to see crafting and the negative effects to opponents players abolished.
In one of the threads I suggested that the negative effects to opponents' players not be included, that intimidating coaches get their results by scaring their own players into doing better. I don't see it as important as you apparently do, but it isn't my first choice for an effect.
I understand concerns about crafting, but it seems like so much fun I can't bring myself to oppose it. I understand that it's probably the hardest thing to balance, though, and can understand how people could oppose it.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
One problem that will still remain is the effects haven't and won't be thoroughly tested before it is implemented.
True, but what's the way around that? Is it "no major new features ever to be added" because even with the test server it's not really possible to adequately test them?
The problem is you are assuming someone would create a coach when the coach couldn't be associated with the team he was a player for.
I would. I'd probably want to have at least a player or two on the team so I cared about the team, but that's already the way it is in terms of my trying to get my players together on a few teams.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I'm not against coaches. I'm against coaches being added to the game under the conditions that have been laid forth.
I still say no more than 5 per team, and you have to lower the retirement age before becoming a coach. Day 360 (9 full seasons) is probably a good cut off IMO. At the very least you need to reduce the cutoff to 400 so players don't have to worry about what to do when they will start hitting decline mid season.
There's a reasonable case for making it Day 400, or maybe Day 410 so that if a player is going to have significant decline during a season he can coach instead. I wouldn't perpetually limit it to 5 per team; I'd let it grow as the supply grows.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I would also like to see crafting and the negative effects to opponents players abolished.
In one of the threads I suggested that the negative effects to opponents' players not be included, that intimidating coaches get their results by scaring their own players into doing better. I don't see it as important as you apparently do, but it isn't my first choice for an effect.
I understand concerns about crafting, but it seems like so much fun I can't bring myself to oppose it. I understand that it's probably the hardest thing to balance, though, and can understand how people could oppose it.
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
One problem that will still remain is the effects haven't and won't be thoroughly tested before it is implemented.
True, but what's the way around that? Is it "no major new features ever to be added" because even with the test server it's not really possible to adequately test them?






























