User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
The problem is you are assuming someone would create a coach when the coach couldn't be associated with the team he was a player for.


I would. I'd probably want to have at least a player or two on the team so I cared about the team, but that's already the way it is in terms of my trying to get my players together on a few teams.

Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I'm not against coaches. I'm against coaches being added to the game under the conditions that have been laid forth.

I still say no more than 5 per team, and you have to lower the retirement age before becoming a coach. Day 360 (9 full seasons) is probably a good cut off IMO. At the very least you need to reduce the cutoff to 400 so players don't have to worry about what to do when they will start hitting decline mid season.


There's a reasonable case for making it Day 400, or maybe Day 410 so that if a player is going to have significant decline during a season he can coach instead. I wouldn't perpetually limit it to 5 per team; I'd let it grow as the supply grows.

Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I would also like to see crafting and the negative effects to opponents players abolished.


In one of the threads I suggested that the negative effects to opponents' players not be included, that intimidating coaches get their results by scaring their own players into doing better. I don't see it as important as you apparently do, but it isn't my first choice for an effect.

I understand concerns about crafting, but it seems like so much fun I can't bring myself to oppose it. I understand that it's probably the hardest thing to balance, though, and can understand how people could oppose it.

Originally posted by Rage Kinard
One problem that will still remain is the effects haven't and won't be thoroughly tested before it is implemented.


True, but what's the way around that? Is it "no major new features ever to be added" because even with the test server it's not really possible to adequately test them?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Draxius
Of course you support coaches, you will directly benefit from them before the vast majority of the player base.

Your 'people who oppose coaches are jealous whiners' is nothing more then thinly disguised greed and desire for undeserved advantage.


I also supported-- might never have been as emotional about an argument-- aging in the first place.

I'd have benefited from there not being aging, because I have relatively old players. People were screaming about aging. I said we needed it, that we couldn't have the best players forever. That was where giving a consolation prize such as coaching came from. Newer players should be grateful to what was probably a minority who stuck up for the principle that players had to age so that new generations could reach the top as players.

If it weren't for the less selfish players then, you might be forever looking up at Season 1 and 2 players.
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Draxius

Of course you support coaches, you will directly benefit from them before the vast majority of the player base.

Your 'people who oppose coaches are jealous whiners' is nothing more then thinly disguised greed and desire for undeserved advantage.


I also supported-- might never have been as emotional about an argument-- aging in the first place.

I'd have benefited from there not being aging, because I have relatively old players. People were screaming about aging. I said we needed it, that we couldn't have the best players forever. That was where giving a consolation prize such as coaching came from. Newer players should be grateful to what was probably a minority who stuck up for the principle that players had to age so that new generations could reach the top as players.

If it weren't for the less selfish players then, you might be forever looking up at Season 1 and 2 players.


LOL... How much more pleasant is the air up there? High horse riders make every good thing SUCK at some point in time.

You are the better man for thinking about those that came after you...
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


If it weren't for the less selfish players then, you might be forever looking up at Season 3 players.


fyp

If not for VAs, 99% of season 1/2 players would have been retired 2 seasons ago. As it is 90+% have already retired and won't even be eligible for coaching.

 
Staz
offline
Link
 
On the item crafting - I think that's not a realistic thing, but rather an ability geared specifically to the MMORPG aspect of the game. Not everything is 'real' in this game.
 
gherman
offline
Link
 
bort srs remove this gay shit this makes it so much harded for new players
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
What about time limit on coaches?

I would say 400 days of being a coach.
 
KingCheez
offline
Link
 
So much more shit i'd rather see than this
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Hey bort

Ok...so I've been thinking about coaches.. I'm not in love with the idea..but it's gonna happen, so I can accept that and it is adding some diversity to the game...and I'm all for that. So 10 coaches max per team? That's my problem..that's WAAAY to many.

even if you scale it up...1 peewee, 10 World/PRO..9AAA...8AA..ect..here are the #'s.


World - 32 teams x 10 = 320 Coaches
Pro Leagues - 8 Leagues x 32 teams X 10 = 2560
AAA leagues - 16 leagues x . 32 teams x 9 = 4608.

That's a total of approximately 7500 coaches required for the higher leagues.

Now here is the thing..I did a search on how many lvl 65+ players there are right now..cuz those would be the coaches for next season. THERE ARE ONLY 11,900 OF THEM who are active.

Let's be generous and say that all world/pro/AAA teams don't have the full compliment...let's that that down to 6,000 coaches. NO WAY 50% of season 1 vets are going to be coaches next season. Even if they are, there will be a SERIOUS shortage of coaches everywhere else.

10 is WAAAAAY too many.

Best set up

WL teams get 6
Pro gets 4
AAA gets 3
AA gets 2

That gives you a total of about 4800 max (reality # is around 4K probably). Much more doable then 7500 just in WL/PRO/AAA just by themselves...not to mention the other 1000 teams who will be able to have at least 1.

You gotta figure that at MOST 25% of people who are hitting day 440+ will turn into coaches...it's just not something that the casual person would be interested in..it's totally for the GLB hardcore IMO.

Gameplanning/strategy is so weak everything under AA anyway...that coaches aren't really needed, you just need talent to advance to AA. Then you can get rolling with the coaches.


that's my big idea Bort.

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Hey bort

Ok...so I've been thinking about coaches.. I'm not in love with the idea..but it's gonna happen, so I can accept that and it is adding some diversity to the game...and I'm all for that. So 10 coaches max per team? That's my problem..that's WAAAY to many.

even if you scale it up...1 peewee, 10 World/PRO..9AAA...8AA..ect..here are the #'s.


World - 32 teams x 10 = 320 Coaches
Pro Leagues - 8 Leagues x 32 teams X 10 = 2560
AAA leagues - 16 leagues x . 32 teams x 9 = 4608.

That's a total of approximately 7500 coaches required for the higher leagues.

Now here is the thing..I did a search on how many lvl 65+ players there are right now..cuz those would be the coaches for next season. THERE ARE ONLY 11,900 OF THEM who are active.

Let's be generous and say that all world/pro/AAA teams don't have the full compliment...let's that that down to 6,000 coaches. NO WAY 50% of season 1 vets are going to be coaches next season. Even if they are, there will be a SERIOUS shortage of coaches everywhere else.

10 is WAAAAAY too many.

Best set up

WL teams get 6
Pro gets 4
AAA gets 3
AA gets 2

That gives you a total of about 4800 max (reality # is around 4K probably). Much more doable then 7500 just in WL/PRO/AAA just by themselves...not to mention the other 1000 teams who will be able to have at least 1.

You gotta figure that at MOST 25% of people who are hitting day 440+ will turn into coaches...it's just not something that the casual person would be interested in..it's totally for the GLB hardcore IMO.

Gameplanning/strategy is so weak everything under AA anyway...that coaches aren't really needed, you just need talent to advance to AA. Then you can get rolling with the coaches.


that's my big idea Bort.



I agree with you on that one. We can always scale the number of slots up over time, if needed.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Bort, I've updated the OP as much as I could in an effort for others suggestions not to get lost. No one pmed me anything else, but could be some in these pages as well.
 
Arcadic
offline
Link
 
Suggestion to placate the need for coaches for all teams in S12: (i am unclear as to if coaches have their own levels, but my idea is based on a independent coach level.)

Put Caps on each league for the level of coach they can sign. Cap the AA-Pro leagues, and don't allow coaches to go below the AA tier. Raise the caps similar to the old cap system every season, and add one more tier of the pyramid to be allowed coaches.
The tiers allowed coaches this coming season could be based on who is actually making them, IE, if only enough coaches are made to cover the Pro leagues, then simply only allow the pro leagues to have coaches. My biggest issue with coaches existing, is that teams i compete on do not have access to coaches in the next season or two.

I also support a limit per tier of coaches, as described by others in this thread.

I am totally against the the idea of coaches as a whole, but if they are going to happen, i want it to happen in a fair manner to all who play this game. Letting coaches run wild in their first season is not going to make anyone happy. Capping where the coaches can go for 5-6 seasons will at least make the game playable to those who have no S1-S2 player/connections. I'm quite ticked off about this only being announced as a feature this season, as i had two players who could have become S13 coaches, but instead i retired them this season. Very poor implementation there imo.
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Best keep coaches out of Pee Wee. And if we need one to compete, make it so that we can all create them and not have to get into an off-site bidding war for actual cash to secure one. Make it so that we can all create ONE coach now, and one more for every 300-440+ day player we retire.
 
Arcadic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Best keep coaches out of Pee Wee. And if we need one to compete, make it so that we can all create them and not have to get into an off-site bidding war for actual cash to secure one. Make it so that we can all create ONE coach now, and one more for every 300-440+ day player we retire.


Actually i like the idea that if a player you have retired would be <400 days old, you could be eligable to create a coach.
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Keep them out of pee wee and casual.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.