User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Corners are too fast
Page:
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PaqMarq11
Originally posted by PierreThomas

Originally posted by steellithium


I tried to tell people this a month ago. If you now know this is true, why waste points taking a WR up to such an unbalanced level. The problem is that there isn't enough straight line motion in any play to take advantage of the extra speed. It isn't just corners either. It is any time you watch a player with over a 100 speed. SA's are far more important once you start reaching these levels.


I've been saying this since the start of season 8. I took speed up to the 7th cap on my WRs the beginning of season 8 and they looked slower. But because Bort said there was no diminishing returns and scoffed at the suggestion nobody else would listen.. I feel like such an ass for believing Bort but hell, who are you supposed to listen to?


i do think there is diminishing returns. and yes it should have been announced as such. there should be, i guess. look at the 100meter world record. it is being broken but only by fractions of a second. it has been going down since carl lewis obliterated the record then.


I'm not even saying it should have been announced, Bort shouldn't have been outright denying it for 3 seasons now and telling people that there were no diminishing returns. People pump speed on their WRs to the 7th and 8th cap to find out they completely wasted about 100 skill points and it is bullshit.

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
You have no idea what you're talking about.

Great comeback. Maybe the next time you're left stupified and unable to think up an even remotely coherent rebuttal, you can resort to "your momma" jokes or "I know you are but what am I?"
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bukowski

You have no idea what you're talking about.

Great comeback. Maybe the next time you're left stupified and unable to think up an even remotely coherent rebuttal, you can resort to "your momma" jokes or "I know you are but what am I?"


uh huh
 
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Another thing to consider is play to play energy. Does the receiver's stamina allow them to run streak route after streak route without losing speed?


Even if they run hardly any streak routes, or if it's very early in the game, it looks about the same to me.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PierreThomas
Originally posted by PaqMarq11

Originally posted by PierreThomas


Originally posted by steellithium



I tried to tell people this a month ago. If you now know this is true, why waste points taking a WR up to such an unbalanced level. The problem is that there isn't enough straight line motion in any play to take advantage of the extra speed. It isn't just corners either. It is any time you watch a player with over a 100 speed. SA's are far more important once you start reaching these levels.


I've been saying this since the start of season 8. I took speed up to the 7th cap on my WRs the beginning of season 8 and they looked slower. But because Bort said there was no diminishing returns and scoffed at the suggestion nobody else would listen.. I feel like such an ass for believing Bort but hell, who are you supposed to listen to?


i do think there is diminishing returns. and yes it should have been announced as such. there should be, i guess. look at the 100meter world record. it is being broken but only by fractions of a second. it has been going down since carl lewis obliterated the record then.


I'm not even saying it should have been announced, Bort shouldn't have been outright denying it for 3 seasons now and telling people that there were no diminishing returns. People pump speed on their WRs to the 7th and 8th cap to find out they completely wasted about 100 skill points and it is bullshit.



Wait a second, who told them that was a good idea in the first place? If someone came on here and said my balanced build wasn't performing, everyone would say learn how to build players better. How is this different?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by steellithium
Another thing to consider is play to play energy. Does the receiver's stamina allow them to run streak route after streak route without losing speed?

Good point, and we know that energy burns quickly for both WRs and CBs. With that decreased energy, you get a percentage reduction in attributes, narrowing the gap in speed even further.
 
Link
 
Fuck, this thread is so long. Here comes the CB nerf.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by PierreThomas



WRs speed just shouldn't be limited. It is complete bullshit to have a business owner tell you there aren't diminishing returns on speed, then spend money to boost speed only to find out that was far from the truth. If CBs are worried about getting beat by a WR then they can add speed instead of playing with 90 speed with the expectation they should run step for step with a WR that has 125 speed.


The problem with making real speed equal to your speed attribute is that we'll instantly go back to this game being all about speed. We'll de-evolve back to season 4-5.

Think about it. During a game maybe there's a 95-speed CB matched up against a 110-speed WR. EVERY down the WR simply outruns the CB in a foot race on whatever route is being run, meaning the WR is open close to 100% of the time. That would be absurd.

I'm not sure what the solution is exactly. But it's got something to do with what Deathblade were talking about - that there should not be such a huge variance in how fast dots move. In real life, there are lots of high school players that can run as fast as NFL players. In GLB there are people that can run a 4.0 40-time, and others that run it in 8.0 seconds. That's a bad sim, unbalanced, and extremely problematic for many aspects of the game.


It's simple - let the WR's be as fast as they want to be, but to catch the ball they would also need exponentially greater amounts of Vision, Catching and Confidence. The problem with the Speed WR before is all they needed to do is crank the shit out of Speed/Agility and never put a single hard SP in any other stat.

If they want Willie Gault, fine - but Willie Gault ran so fast he couldn't change directions (route run) worth a shit and couldn't catch a cold buck naked in a Siberian lake in January.

Exponential Speed should need exponential supporting skills to leverage it if you are doing anything else but running to the 100 Meter tape.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by steellithium

Another thing to consider is play to play energy. Does the receiver's stamina allow them to run streak route after streak route without losing speed?


Even if they run hardly any streak routes, or if it's very early in the game, it looks about the same to me.


Bort said on another thread that morale and energy can be low enough to cut attributes in half. So you tell me.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
online
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
Fuck, this thread is so long. Here comes the CB nerf.


bite your tongue! that's the last thing we need. pro basketball type scores.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by Bukowski

You have no idea what you're talking about.

Great comeback. Maybe the next time you're left stupified and unable to think up an even remotely coherent rebuttal, you can resort to "your momma" jokes or "I know you are but what am I?"


no u
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by PierreThomas



WRs speed just shouldn't be limited. It is complete bullshit to have a business owner tell you there aren't diminishing returns on speed, then spend money to boost speed only to find out that was far from the truth. If CBs are worried about getting beat by a WR then they can add speed instead of playing with 90 speed with the expectation they should run step for step with a WR that has 125 speed.


The problem with making real speed equal to your speed attribute is that we'll instantly go back to this game being all about speed. We'll de-evolve back to season 4-5.

Think about it. During a game maybe there's a 95-speed CB matched up against a 110-speed WR. EVERY down the WR simply outruns the CB in a foot race on whatever route is being run, meaning the WR is open close to 100% of the time. That would be absurd.

I'm not sure what the solution is exactly. But it's got something to do with what Deathblade were talking about - that there should not be such a huge variance in how fast dots move. In real life, there are lots of high school players that can run as fast as NFL players. In GLB there are people that can run a 4.0 40-time, and others that run it in 8.0 seconds. That's a bad sim, unbalanced, and extremely problematic for many aspects of the game.


Think about this, CBs used to match WRs speed or at least get close to it. A good CB build had all equipment on speed to hang with WRs. Now people realize they don't need the speed and pump up agility and vision to very high levels to use it as an advantage.

Defenses have safeties and the ability to control exactly who guards what players on every snap. Offenses have limited plays that offer deep routes and no way to specify which WR runs them on different plays. If a WR can outrun a CB and a FS playing up to 20 yards off the ball then more power to them. If a WR is that much faster than a CB then the CB was built wrong. I can push speed up to 110 on a lot of my CBs. A straight up 115 speed WR vs 100 speed CB Would give up about 1 yard for every 10 yards they run. With a CB giving a 5 yard cushion it would take 50 yards for the WR to get past the CB and that isn't even accounting for a safety that can play with zone specialist and ball hawk. I've seen a FS play with over 160 speed.
 
Link
 
Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
online
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by PierreThomas




WRs speed just shouldn't be limited. It is complete bullshit to have a business owner tell you there aren't diminishing returns on speed, then spend money to boost speed only to find out that was far from the truth. If CBs are worried about getting beat by a WR then they can add speed instead of playing with 90 speed with the expectation they should run step for step with a WR that has 125 speed.


The problem with making real speed equal to your speed attribute is that we'll instantly go back to this game being all about speed. We'll de-evolve back to season 4-5.

Think about it. During a game maybe there's a 95-speed CB matched up against a 110-speed WR. EVERY down the WR simply outruns the CB in a foot race on whatever route is being run, meaning the WR is open close to 100% of the time. That would be absurd.

I'm not sure what the solution is exactly. But it's got something to do with what Deathblade were talking about - that there should not be such a huge variance in how fast dots move. In real life, there are lots of high school players that can run as fast as NFL players. In GLB there are people that can run a 4.0 40-time, and others that run it in 8.0 seconds. That's a bad sim, unbalanced, and extremely problematic for many aspects of the game.


It's simple - let the WR's be as fast as they want to be, but to catch the ball they would also need exponentially greater amounts of Vision, Catching and Confidence. The problem with the Speed WR before is all they needed to do is crank the shit out of Speed/Agility and never put a single hard SP in any other stat.

If they want Willie Gault, fine - but Willie Gault ran so fast he couldn't change directions (route run) worth a shit and couldn't catch a cold buck naked in a Siberian lake in January.

Exponential Speed should need exponential supporting skills to leverage it if you are doing anything else but running to the 100 Meter tape.


true.

add to this the strength and accuracy of the qb
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Reminder: A big, fat part of the problem is that the QB just wont throw to WRs much if they're 10+ yards downfield. And hey, nobody is talking about how jacked up TEs are for some reason. TEs are screwed up in the same way as WRs but much worse.

QBs dont throw to WRs because HBs get more separation and are more attractive targets to the QB targeting script. And HBs get that separation because they line up miles away from the guy covering them and because defenses act stupid when the HB runs into the flat.

The game needs some pretty significant repair right now.


Does Jericho Brooks change your mind on hidden attributes yet?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.