genuine
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Malachorn
offline
offline
I'm just not sure that their world league is going to solve any of the problems for any other league and I'd really like to see that happen, tbh.
Mercaptopropyl
offline
offline
Originally posted by Malachorn
I'm just not sure that their world league is going to solve any of the problems for any other league and I'd really like to see that happen, tbh.
It may not, but don't you think without it (assuming it's set-up well) there's a much smaller chance of seeing that happen?
I'm just not sure that their world league is going to solve any of the problems for any other league and I'd really like to see that happen, tbh.
It may not, but don't you think without it (assuming it's set-up well) there's a much smaller chance of seeing that happen?
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Originally posted by Malachorn
I'm just not sure that their world league is going to solve any of the problems for any other league and I'd really like to see that happen, tbh.
It may not, but don't you think without it (assuming it's set-up well) there's a much smaller chance of seeing that happen?
No, I think your logic is absurd.
I see absolutely no reason to think that the World League helps alleviate any of the problems with the other leagues and only see MANY reasons that the World League could only make those problems worse.
Having said that, I'm actually very much for the idea of a World League... I just don't believe the current system allows for one very well, tbqh.
Originally posted by Malachorn
I'm just not sure that their world league is going to solve any of the problems for any other league and I'd really like to see that happen, tbh.
It may not, but don't you think without it (assuming it's set-up well) there's a much smaller chance of seeing that happen?
No, I think your logic is absurd.
I see absolutely no reason to think that the World League helps alleviate any of the problems with the other leagues and only see MANY reasons that the World League could only make those problems worse.
Having said that, I'm actually very much for the idea of a World League... I just don't believe the current system allows for one very well, tbqh.
Ravenwood
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
It honestly has surprised me (not that it should have) how much of the discussion about something as important as this has been so childish. I am honestly open to listening to any ideas that I think might improve this game, and yet most of the "discussion", regardless of what side people are on has just been a bunch of complaining and whining.
Okay, I was one of the first people to cry 'foul' over the whole I-slam bullshit at the beginning of the Season 8 playoffs, and was told that I was whining. I'm left wondering if your idea of what "whining" is, is the same as mine. I've posted before the 4 main arguments against this idea. Here they are again:
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Recap of the arguments against:
1. A world league erodes the identities and communities of the regions
2. A world league belittles the current pro leagues, which will basically become the equivalent of AAAs
3. A world league takes away the need for a tournament of champions - a tournament which adds a ton of flavour and an element of variety to the game
4. A world league, added at this point, after 10 seasons, gives the impression that GLB is all about keeping a certain few teams, players and agents at the very top of the pyramid, and be damned to everyone else.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2959156&page=4
You're right about one thing though - us debating the matter won't amount to a hill of beans. I think the decision has already been made, and we're going to see a "World League" whether we want one or not.
It honestly has surprised me (not that it should have) how much of the discussion about something as important as this has been so childish. I am honestly open to listening to any ideas that I think might improve this game, and yet most of the "discussion", regardless of what side people are on has just been a bunch of complaining and whining.
Okay, I was one of the first people to cry 'foul' over the whole I-slam bullshit at the beginning of the Season 8 playoffs, and was told that I was whining. I'm left wondering if your idea of what "whining" is, is the same as mine. I've posted before the 4 main arguments against this idea. Here they are again:
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Recap of the arguments against:
1. A world league erodes the identities and communities of the regions
2. A world league belittles the current pro leagues, which will basically become the equivalent of AAAs
3. A world league takes away the need for a tournament of champions - a tournament which adds a ton of flavour and an element of variety to the game
4. A world league, added at this point, after 10 seasons, gives the impression that GLB is all about keeping a certain few teams, players and agents at the very top of the pyramid, and be damned to everyone else.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2959156&page=4
You're right about one thing though - us debating the matter won't amount to a hill of beans. I think the decision has already been made, and we're going to see a "World League" whether we want one or not.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Should be more than 4 USA teams imo.
OPL getting the same number as USA?
I guess it's politically correct though.
my OPL feelings are hurt.
My MEM feelings say it should be 16 teams from USAPL and 16 teams from the other leagues combined.
8 USA Pro
24 from other leagues (3 each)
Top 4 USA Pro from each conference
Conference runner ups in other Pro leagues play a consolation game
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Should be more than 4 USA teams imo.
OPL getting the same number as USA?
I guess it's politically correct though.
my OPL feelings are hurt.
My MEM feelings say it should be 16 teams from USAPL and 16 teams from the other leagues combined.
8 USA Pro
24 from other leagues (3 each)
Top 4 USA Pro from each conference
Conference runner ups in other Pro leagues play a consolation game
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Should be more than 4 USA teams imo.
OPL getting the same number as USA?
I guess it's politically correct though.
my OPL feelings are hurt.
My MEM feelings say it should be 16 teams from USAPL and 16 teams from the other leagues combined.
8 USA Pro
24 from other leagues (3 each)
Top 4 USA Pro from each conference
Conference runner ups in other Pro leagues play a consolation game
Actually, I think that a lot of people think USA Pro should be represented greater in the World League because USA Pro seems to be the premier league right now... well, my feelings is that you don't really want to completely rob USA Pro of all their best teams then. That would only make USA Pro feel even more less special and having USA Pro think it's still the best of the Pro leagues isn't a bad thing.
...besides, I'm not sure it would work very well with how Bort has said before that the promotion/demotion plans for a World League would be.
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Should be more than 4 USA teams imo.
OPL getting the same number as USA?
I guess it's politically correct though.
my OPL feelings are hurt.
My MEM feelings say it should be 16 teams from USAPL and 16 teams from the other leagues combined.
8 USA Pro
24 from other leagues (3 each)
Top 4 USA Pro from each conference
Conference runner ups in other Pro leagues play a consolation game
Actually, I think that a lot of people think USA Pro should be represented greater in the World League because USA Pro seems to be the premier league right now... well, my feelings is that you don't really want to completely rob USA Pro of all their best teams then. That would only make USA Pro feel even more less special and having USA Pro think it's still the best of the Pro leagues isn't a bad thing.
...besides, I'm not sure it would work very well with how Bort has said before that the promotion/demotion plans for a World League would be.
McGrai37
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by McGrai37
Who cares if they're the highest level of competition within their league structures when the league structures are so different?
Sorry, you've lost me. How are the league structures different?
The quality of them.
Originally posted by McGrai37
Who cares if they're the highest level of competition within their league structures when the league structures are so different?
Sorry, you've lost me. How are the league structures different?
The quality of them.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by Malachorn
Actually, I think that a lot of people think USA Pro should be represented greater in the World League because USA Pro seems to be the premier league right now... well, my feelings is that you don't really want to completely rob USA Pro of all their best teams then. That would only make USA Pro feel even more less special and having USA Pro think it's still the best of the Pro leagues isn't a bad thing.
...besides, I'm not sure it would work very well with how Bort has said before that the promotion/demotion plans for a World League would be.
It will definately be 4 from each. I was just trying to show a choice 1/2 between the 2 options presented. Personally, I don't care one way or another.
I'm for the world league though. I like the idea of a league that is designed to show who is best in GLB for the season. Also, I'm tired of all the extra scouting I'm having to do for all these damn tournaments.
Actually, I think that a lot of people think USA Pro should be represented greater in the World League because USA Pro seems to be the premier league right now... well, my feelings is that you don't really want to completely rob USA Pro of all their best teams then. That would only make USA Pro feel even more less special and having USA Pro think it's still the best of the Pro leagues isn't a bad thing.
...besides, I'm not sure it would work very well with how Bort has said before that the promotion/demotion plans for a World League would be.
It will definately be 4 from each. I was just trying to show a choice 1/2 between the 2 options presented. Personally, I don't care one way or another.
I'm for the world league though. I like the idea of a league that is designed to show who is best in GLB for the season. Also, I'm tired of all the extra scouting I'm having to do for all these damn tournaments.
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
It will definately be 4 from each. I was just trying to show a choice 1/2 between the 2 options presented. Personally, I don't care one way or another.
I'm for the world league though. I like the idea of a league that is designed to show who is best in GLB for the season. Also, I'm tired of all the extra scouting I'm having to do for all these damn tournaments.
I'm also for the World league. I've said it before.
Again, I do wish that they'd fix the silliness with the way they've tried to promote/demote teams and whatnot before they go and add a World League to a broken system though, as I believe that a World League being incorporated into their current "system" can only yield even more disastrous results.
It will definately be 4 from each. I was just trying to show a choice 1/2 between the 2 options presented. Personally, I don't care one way or another.
I'm for the world league though. I like the idea of a league that is designed to show who is best in GLB for the season. Also, I'm tired of all the extra scouting I'm having to do for all these damn tournaments.
I'm also for the World league. I've said it before.
Again, I do wish that they'd fix the silliness with the way they've tried to promote/demote teams and whatnot before they go and add a World League to a broken system though, as I believe that a World League being incorporated into their current "system" can only yield even more disastrous results.
McGrai37
offline
offline
Originally posted by hoyaboy1
Something I just realized is that with the World League in place, many of those teams won't bother entering the tourneys, which sucks for the next batch of teams.
I don't think it'll have that big of an effect. Maybe one or two teams will decline but I doubt it'll cripple the tournies.
Something I just realized is that with the World League in place, many of those teams won't bother entering the tourneys, which sucks for the next batch of teams.
I don't think it'll have that big of an effect. Maybe one or two teams will decline but I doubt it'll cripple the tournies.
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
Originally posted by hoyaboy1
Something I just realized is that with the World League in place, many of those teams won't bother entering the tourneys, which sucks for the next batch of teams.
Edit - Bleh, this point is made above, I suck
Have you had to scout and gameplan for these tourneys? I wonder how many of the top teams are going to keep entering into them, because regular season + tourneys just takes too much time.
Something I just realized is that with the World League in place, many of those teams won't bother entering the tourneys, which sucks for the next batch of teams.
Edit - Bleh, this point is made above, I suck
Have you had to scout and gameplan for these tourneys? I wonder how many of the top teams are going to keep entering into them, because regular season + tourneys just takes too much time.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























