User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Nuge20

My compiled suggestion (For Pro Leagues):
MVP Endorsements: Huge endorsements that give +1 to both trees and +15% to something and +10 to attributes (3 MVPs only)
Large Endorsements: Like the current endorsements. Give it to top 2 of each positions MVP (or sim of top 10). +1 to a tree +15% to something and +8 to attributes. (1 per position per Conference)
Medium Endorsements: Give it to a random sim of the top 20 of positional MVPs. +1 to 3 SAs, +10% to something +5 to attributes 2 per position per conference)
Small Endorsements: Random sim of positions in top 50 of positional MVPs +1 to 1 SA, +5% to something, and +3 to attributes (5 per position per conference)
Mini Endorsements: Random sim of all in the league gives +2 to attributes...give to 10% of the league.

Oh and this could use any other factors you want to weight the randomness
For lower leagues just shift down 1...maybe have Pro/AAA start at large, AA and A start at Medium, BBB and casual start at small, and pee wee start at mini...except MVP would be similar for each league but MVPs would have to be within suggested levels.

Limit 4 Large Endorsements per team, 6 medium per team, and 10 small per team...unlimited mini because it is more random


I agree that the boost is way over the top...it creates perpetual MVPs, once you have the shiz-nit, you're locked in.


Yes, that idea of MVP is too big. The current pro items is as big as I would want it to get.
 
zbuckley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
Originally posted by RTJakarta

Originally posted by TxSteve


i think MVP could be based off ONLY games against playoff teams (ie the top 8)

if you're a playoff team - your stats are divided by 7 to get a per game average

if you're not a playoff team - your stats are divided by 8 to get a per game average


stats against the bottom 8 don't count - MVP's are calculated only after game 16 and last for the next season (but only for 1 playoff run)


Nice idea. Dunno about the hypothetical execution, though.



doubt it would be that hard to only include stats against team A, B, C, D, E, F, G (as an example) - but others would know better than me

Nice Idea, this would also probably eliminate teams that go CPU midseason. Not fair if one teams plays a full roster and another gets the same team later in the season after going CPU.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 21:39:35
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by butler312


I didn't read everything, so sorry if this was posted, but is there a way to code it so there is a cap on stats that go towards counting for this MVP formula. This might help with the gutted team problems. For example, maybe you could cap it at 5 rushing TDs and 2 KR TD or something like that. So that if you do play a gutted team and score 20 TDs, it doesn't matter, because only 6 of them will count in the formula. Make the caps equal to about the best day you could have against an equally matched opponent. It will still give a player who plays more gutted teams an advantage, but the difference wouldn't be insane or anything.



That's still a band-aid, not a fix.


Well if you have a proposal that will eliminate gutted and slow build teams in higher leagues then lets here it. No, that won't fix that, but it will help vastly reduce their impact on the endorsements. That has to be done somehow, and regardless of how it is done it will just be a band-aid.



Been hearing them since I've been playing. If you're not familiar, start following this forum more often.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
i think MVP could be based off ONLY games against playoff teams (ie the top 8)

if you're a playoff team - your stats are divided by 7 to get a per game average

if you're not a playoff team - your stats are divided by 8 to get a per game average


stats against the bottom 8 don't count - MVP's are calculated only after game 16 and last for the next season (but only for 1 playoff run)


That removes the whole "MVP race" aspect, though, unless it could be a sort of "fudged" version on the fly, and then a final adjustment after game 16.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
+1 to both trees, +10 to attributes...do we really want to award 15 or more equivalent levels to the "best" player in the league?

That's not a very good idea, imo.


That's why this is problematic.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Obvious problem needing addressed is one or two teams stacking up on the endorsements and them not spreading around.

MVP Endorsements: Take the current endorsements handed out, shrink that number to 2-5 and hand those out based on fame. Each fame is granted a number of 'balls' and they are tossed together, similar to the NBA style where Portland got lucky with Oden. HOWEVER, do not make it such a huge difference like 100 and 75. Make fame have some effect, but not one where a guy is nearly granted the endorsement.

Create 'Significant Endorsements' and replace the current endorsements with these. Give out a handful of these, maybe low 20s. You can use the same formula above, but make fame a little less significant.

Create 'Smaller Endorsements' which would warrant a small cash amount with lesser attribute boosts.

Create 'Mini Endorsements' which would warrant little cash with little attribute boosts.

Both of the Smaller and Mini could be given out in greater number, with no discretion of to who.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
- We remove the current items, let people keep their cash, and maybe give some BT's or something for their trouble.


How about 4 bonus tokens and 1 Va?

1 sp and 1 va isnt the end of the world and 1% of the community wont commit suicide tonight after they find out there lottery ticket was bullshit.

 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TxSteve

i think MVP could be based off ONLY games against playoff teams (ie the top 8)

if you're a playoff team - your stats are divided by 7 to get a per game average

if you're not a playoff team - your stats are divided by 8 to get a per game average


stats against the bottom 8 don't count - MVP's are calculated only after game 16 and last for the next season (but only for 1 playoff run)


That removes the whole "MVP race" aspect, though, unless it could be a sort of "fudged" version on the fly, and then a final adjustment after game 16.


could still have a leader board that shifted as the standings shift...

might actually be interesting - as you'd have guys/teams really rooting for Team X to beat Team Y so that your stats against Team X still stand - (or your stats against team Y - a bad game for you - don't count)

could open a new angle in league dynamic - DAMN - I can't believe team Y got the 8th seed - that screws me over!
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
Bort...

Why not make endorsements something every GLB agent gets. and depending on whatever factors you want ,the guys with higher scores get the top tier of endorsements and all the way down to a 5k bonus for a local car dealership radio ad or something for the bottom tier.

this way everybody feels like the get something. you could get more money each season for the bottom tier depending if you played better than the season before


too much work?
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by butler312

Originally posted by Iceman16


Originally posted by butler312



I didn't read everything, so sorry if this was posted, but is there a way to code it so there is a cap on stats that go towards counting for this MVP formula. This might help with the gutted team problems. For example, maybe you could cap it at 5 rushing TDs and 2 KR TD or something like that. So that if you do play a gutted team and score 20 TDs, it doesn't matter, because only 6 of them will count in the formula. Make the caps equal to about the best day you could have against an equally matched opponent. It will still give a player who plays more gutted teams an advantage, but the difference wouldn't be insane or anything.



That's still a band-aid, not a fix.


Well if you have a proposal that will eliminate gutted and slow build teams in higher leagues then lets here it. No, that won't fix that, but it will help vastly reduce their impact on the endorsements. That has to be done somehow, and regardless of how it is done it will just be a band-aid.



Been hearing them since I've been playing. If you're not familiar, start following this forum more often.


I've read plenty of them too, and I have not thought that any of them would work well enough to be put into place. And apparently Bort agrees with me because none of them have.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TxSteve

i think MVP could be based off ONLY games against playoff teams (ie the top 8)

if you're a playoff team - your stats are divided by 7 to get a per game average

if you're not a playoff team - your stats are divided by 8 to get a per game average


stats against the bottom 8 don't count - MVP's are calculated only after game 16 and last for the next season (but only for 1 playoff run)


That removes the whole "MVP race" aspect, though, unless it could be a sort of "fudged" version on the fly, and then a final adjustment after game 16.


Hop on vent we could finish this in about 20 minutes.

Do you want an MVP stats race?
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TehKyou
What would be the order for determining the endorsements? Does it go from the most valuable to least valuable untill all teams get 3?

Also, when you say "1 'national' endorsement per team" Does that mean there would be 32 national endorsements per league?

So, the order would be like...
1. MVPs get their endorsements first
2. Each team gets their national endorsement
3. Local endorsements fill out untill 3 endorsements per team is reached.


Last question. Are the Local endorsements done by lottery or another "MVP" check thingy?


Were these answered earlier in the thread?
 
bossinthe831
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by Nuge20


My compiled suggestion (For Pro Leagues):
MVP Endorsements: Huge endorsements that give +1 to both trees and +15% to something and +10 to attributes (3 MVPs only)
Large Endorsements: Like the current endorsements. Give it to top 2 of each positions MVP (or sim of top 10). +1 to a tree +15% to something and +8 to attributes. (1 per position per Conference)
Medium Endorsements: Give it to a random sim of the top 20 of positional MVPs. +1 to 3 SAs, +10% to something +5 to attributes 2 per position per conference)
Small Endorsements: Random sim of positions in top 50 of positional MVPs +1 to 1 SA, +5% to something, and +3 to attributes (5 per position per conference)
Mini Endorsements: Random sim of all in the league gives +2 to attributes...give to 10% of the league.

Oh and this could use any other factors you want to weight the randomness
For lower leagues just shift down 1...maybe have Pro/AAA start at large, AA and A start at Medium, BBB and casual start at small, and pee wee start at mini...except MVP would be similar for each league but MVPs would have to be within suggested levels.

Limit 4 Large Endorsements per team, 6 medium per team, and 10 small per team...unlimited mini because it is more random


I agree that the boost is way over the top...it creates perpetual MVPs, once you have the shiz-nit, you're locked in.


Yes, that idea of MVP is too big. The current pro items is as big as I would want it to get.


That's still too big imo... Players get a 5+ level boost? That's far too much
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JugheadASFN
Originally posted by tautology

Posted earlier-

Throw out the results of the best 4 performances for all players. This eliminates gut -games, unless there are more than 4 in your conference (which has become a rarity in leagues above the bottom tiers).

There have been several other suggestions that I thought had merit as well.


tautology -

What do you think of this one below?

Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by JugheadASFN


Bort - I asked this question earlier and it sorta got buried in this thread.

_______________________________________________________________________________________


Is it possible to run the MVP calculations only if the teams have players that average within the "Permitted Player Levels" (exp: Lv 25-100) and if the MVP candidate is within the "Suggested" levels?

This would do two things:

Take out those CPU and gutted/slowbuild teams from skewing stats

and

discourage those ultra higher level players moving down into the "A" and "BBB" leagues to dominate.



Yep






"Suggested levels" is a wide range. You could have level 35 vs level 45...that is a blowout for sure. Helps with the complete gut jobs thought....
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
Originally posted by Bort

- We remove the current items, let people keep their cash, and maybe give some BT's or something for their trouble.


How about 4 bonus tokens and 1 Va?

1 sp and 1 va isnt the end of the world and 1% of the community wont commit suicide tonight after they find out there lottery ticket was bullshit.



Sure, I'm biased, but this seems so minuscule.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.