User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Kblitz
is bort really a fat man?



I have the feeling he is overweight.
 
slntkilla
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ultrajer
+1


 
Momara94
offline
Link
 
Its a good idea
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by quzur
Originally posted by Kblitz

is bort really a fat man?



I have the feeling he is overweight.


LOL...avatars can be deceiving. Hell I'm an old guy...who'd guess that from my avatar.
 
CurtKingston
offline
Link
 
Skills should determine the weight for a position. A HB could drop weight if he has nothing but speed and not really any strength to give him weight. Olinemen should be big because of their strength levels but agility/speed keeps them down to a minimum for their positions which can be set by the GLB God.
 
Stephen A
offline
Link
 
Like the idea... but don't think the "fastest" players should be those players under 160lbs... maybe just under 200lbs.

I don't think there is an NFL player (other than maybe a kicker) that is under 160lbs. Just remove the 2 lightest weight classes and this is a much better idea.

Example: Justin Gatlin (olympic sprinter) weighs 183 pounds and deangelo hall (one of the fastest men in the NFL) weighs 197 pounds (and he's only 5'11").
 
Dubs48
offline
Link
 
thats awsome +100
 
DDJSoDope :3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just thought up this random idea while driving in the car, so I thought I'd post it here so as not to forget and see what people thought:

Currently, everybody basically has the same base speed value for what 100 speed will get you. It's modified by height/weight a little, along with acceleration, but not a huge amount.

So here's the idea for a new attribute:

Each player has a "weight class," or whatever we want to call it, defined by how heavy they are and what position they are.

Each "weight class" would have a base max speed and acceleration value that having 100 speed gets you. We could convert this into 40 times or something to make it easy to understand, and base it on top NFL combine scores for various positions.

Each "weight class" would also factor into blocking, breaking blocks, and tackling, as bonuses.

We figure out the base weight classes for each player currently in the game, and put it on their profile page for reference.

For instance, you could have something like:

Class lightweight < 160 lbs : base 3.75s 40, -20% block/break block penalty
Class middleweight 161-190 lbs : base 4.0s 40, -10% block/break block penalty
Class light heavyweight 191-225 lbs : base 4.25s 40, +0% block bonus
Class heavyweight 225-260 lbs : base 4.5s 40, +10% block bonus
Class super heavyweight 261 - 300lbs : base 4.75s 40, +20% block bonus
Class OMGweight 301+lbs : base 5s 40, +30% block bonus

etc. etc.

Here's the part that I think could be kinda interesting: You could adjust your weight class through training or special skills (perhaps veteran abilities?). Maybe you're in the middleweight class but you want to move down to lightweight to be faster, so you choose a skill to do so, etc.

Something like this could make it so we could show calculated 40 times for different players, etc. on their profile. It'd let you know what you're getting for your weight or lack of it, too.


never going to happen / 0 replies / nb4l
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I prefer adjusting soft caps based on side using normal distribution of all player weights. I personally think 90 speed should equal 90 speed any way you look at it, but it should take more SP to get there for a larger player.


it already DOES take more Skill points to get there. Just like it would take a lot more skill points for a WR to become a 100 blocker than a big guy. a C does not get speed added automatically at each level, a WR does. so for my Cs that have 100 speed, it took MUCH more of a sacrifice in other areas to get them to that level.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=502492

Check him out, sure hes got unrealistic speed for his size, but hes also sub par in strength blocking and all SAs. Hes sacrificed a TON to get there. It already is punative to make your big guy fast.
Last edited Apr 14, 2009 12:56:21
 
Battleking69
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DDJesus
never going to happen / 0 replies / nb4l


what an idiot...

 
xeef
offline
Link
 
http://walterfootball.com/draft2009CB.php

Check this out. I just pulled a few examples. These arent even pros. 300 lb guys DO run sub 5 second 40s. Honestly look this site over and see how many corners dont have the eye popping speed youd think they should. I think its more realistic to just let the natural progression in this game decide which positions get speed advantages.

Lawrence Marsh*, Florida
Height: 6-5. Weight: 305.
Projected 40 Time: 4.87.
Projected Round (2010): Top 25 Pick.
2/14/09: As a mere sophomore, the ultra-athletic Lawrence Marsh compiled 28 tackles, 5.5 TFL and three sacks for college football runner-up Florida.

Carlos Dunlap*, Florida
Height: 6-6. Weight: 290.
Projected 40 Time: 4.70.
Projected Round (2010): Top 5 Pick.
2/12/09: Owning Mario Williams' measurables, Carlos Dunlap dominated the SEC as a sophomore, registering 13.5 TFL and 9.5 sacks.

7/30/08: A 290-pound defensive end who runs a 4.7... why does that sound familiar? Hint - the Texans chose that guy over Reggie Bush. Carlos Dunlap didn't produce much as a true freshman, but he racked up four sacks in the spring game, creating some cause for excitement among Gator fans.

Tyson Jackson, LSU
Height: 6-4. Weight: 295.
Projected 40 Time: 4.85.
Combine 40 Time: 4.91.
Pro Day 40 Time: DNP.
Benchx225: 20. Vertical: 28.5.
Projected Round (2009): 1.
11/16/08: Tyson Jackson has 4.5 sacks this year, but he won't provide much of a pass rush in the NFL. He'll be great against the run.


Marvin Austin*, North Carolina
Height: 6-3. Weight: 305.
Projected 40 Time: 4.88.
Projected Round (2009): Top 25 Pick.
2/14/09: Didn't exactly set the world on fire as a sophomore, registering 38 tackles, 1.5 TFL, one sack and a pick-six. Next season will be huge for hi
 
DDJSoDope :3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Battleking69
Originally posted by DDJesus

never going to happen / 0 replies / nb4l


what an idiot...



NO U
 
WestVirginia
offline
Link
 
will this ever be put in and if yes

When?
 
frondz
offline
Link
 
+1 Awesome Idea
 
HeadlesssKES
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xeef
Originally posted by dmfa41

I prefer adjusting soft caps based on side using normal distribution of all player weights. I personally think 90 speed should equal 90 speed any way you look at it, but it should take more SP to get there for a larger player.


it already DOES take more Skill points to get there. Just like it would take a lot more skill points for a WR to become a 100 blocker than a big guy. a C does not get speed added automatically at each level, a WR does. so for my Cs that have 100 speed, it took MUCH more of a sacrifice in other areas to get them to that level.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=502492

Check him out, sure hes got unrealistic speed for his size, but hes also sub par in strength blocking and all SAs. Hes sacrificed a TON to get there. It already is punative to make your big guy fast.


On one hand I love the idea..

but on the other hand.. THIS ^^^^

I mean... If you want a fast C, you can roll a max of TEN (10!!!).. then you don't get a single per-level bonus (and if you do, it's the minor one, and IMO needs to be changed so that you don't), etc..

The position determines so much about a starting value, a per-level value, etc, that another restriction doesn't need to be in. I like how the system currently is, and it fosters different builds.

I also play Court Rivals, and my main complaint with the game is that it is near IMPOSSIBLE to build a dual-threat player. I am trying to create a Boris Diaw style player - can pass and rebound, with little offensive game - and I am in the 3rd or 4th season and going nowhere.

In this game, you can experiment.. and those experiments can actually lead somewhere worthwhile. I love that. Don't change that. On the surface, weight classes are a great idea, but... there are enough natural restrictions. just let the natural ebb and flow of player creation, the counter balancing of OL vs DL, etc, determine where builds go, and let those that want to be different... be different.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.