User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
AnTiNiNjA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA

We need SAs higher than OTs do, we need much higher agility, and we need much higher speed. We can't beat even a badly built OT if you take away any of these primary attributes, excluding vision which is really just the icing on the cake.

You see so many OTs bitching about getting beat when they have 1/3rd the agility and 1/4th the speed of the best DEs out there.

I've had players on both sides of the line, simply just retired my O-linemen because they were rather boring and I needed the FP. OTs are not hard to build at all and you can essentially neglect all SAs other than the protect skill.

Of course I remember when you stuck your head in the d-line forum before, there simply is no reasoning with you. Doubt any of this will get through that thick skull of yours.


So I have a thick skull, because I think it's unrealistic (and stupid), that a DE built like a defensive back, is a super-duper pass rusher? We encountered one another in Miked33's thread... his advice was to completely ignore strength and his DE was dominating back in season 3 (and probably still dominating).

Spare me the "we need SAs" BS, OTs need an extra attribute to soft cap (at a minimum, probably 2 is more accurate). A DE needs two maybe three SAs to work on. Do the math and get back to me.

My RT has 56 agility, 35 speed, 48 vision, etc... He wasn't destroyed like some people were, but he got beat a couple times (it was like he was standing still on those plays). Builds aren't the only problem, it's just a piece of the puzzle.

Here's my list of the issues with the game...

#1 Agility > Strength for linemen. It should be Agility = Strength.
#2 How acceleration is figured out, needs to be tweaked. Or pathing needs to be adjusted to help fix all the flying dots. Changing direction should slow a player down, more than it currently does. This in turn would make vision more important, angles would be much more important.
#3 SAs need to become more effective, across the board.
#4 Pathing needs work in many areas (primarily RB pass blocking and OL/DL stunts/pick-ups).
#5 Blitzers need to stop running through other players and/or fitting through small gaps 100% of the time. It should happen, but they should also fall down on occasion or not make it through. Or a novel concept, maybe have to use vision and scheme to actually effectively blitz.


Ok, lets look at it this way from a perspective at lvl 30, a total of 165 SP to add/added without SAs.

LOT
48 speed (About 35 pts)35
48 agility (About 35 pts)70
blocking 60 (About 54 pts)124
48 str (About 30 pts)154
Vision to about 30 with leftover

What a DE without SAs would look like, and still not be able to hold a candle to that OT.
Agility to 68 (About 78 pts)78
Speed to 68 (About 78 pts)156
Vision to about 30 with leftover.

Mind you this is without the skill ups per lvl and training daily, but I think you can see the point. SAs for a DE do NOT become very worth while until you reach te 6+ range, hell I have 11 on mine and still think it doesn't do quite as much as it should.

This is not real life, this is a sim. As the game currently is there is no way to balance things out so that you can build a DE to have decent enough strength without basically handicapping yourself against better OTs.

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AnTiNiNjA
Ok, lets look at it this way from a perspective at lvl 30, a total of 165 SP to add/added without SAs.

LOT
48 speed (About 35 pts)35
48 agility (About 35 pts)70
blocking 60 (About 54 pts)124
48 str (About 30 pts)154
Vision to about 30 with leftover

What a DE without SAs would look like, and still not be able to hold a candle to that OT.
Agility to 68 (About 78 pts)78
Speed to 68 (About 78 pts)156
Vision to about 30 with leftover.

Mind you this is without the skill ups per lvl and training daily, but I think you can see the point. SAs for a DE do NOT become very worth while until you reach te 6+ range, hell I have 11 on mine and still think it doesn't do quite as much as it should.

This is not real life, this is a sim. As the game currently is there is no way to balance things out so that you can build a DE to have decent enough strength without basically handicapping yourself against better OTs.


The point eludes you yet again. If strength was more effective, DEs wouldn't have to spend so many points. They'd do the same thing the OT does, work on two primary stats and then try and work on the other 3-4 secondary stats. I also think that SAs should define your player, not just raw attributes.

OTs and DEs SHOULD engage, whoever has better SAs and rolls better should win the individual battle. The more you win by as a DE, the faster you disengage from the OT. The more you win by as an OT, the longer you keep the DE tied up. It shouldn't be all or nothing, like it is now.
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 14:16:06
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
my DE does just fine as an elusive pass rusher with strength at the 3rd cap. this whole 2 skill DE crap is nonsense. if you play against a pure speed DE, RUN IT DOWN HIS THROAT.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Folks....the OT vs DE battle has far less to do with AGI vs AGI and SPD vs SPD matchups than people seem to assume.

OTs have their own equation, DEs have theirs. They do NOT depend on the same stats.
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
There is an fix to this problem. Get your OT to the soft cap in speed and agility. Then give him the money for 2 sets of EQ. When you play a guy with a lot of sacks (speed rusher) change your EQ so you are all speed and some agility. Then the DE will not be blowing by your OT and even without your EQ you will still be a lot stronger then the DE and you will stop the speed rusher.
 
creeker22
offline
Link
 
Well I haven't really read the thread, but my DE who last season had trouble getting sacks has 7 in his first 2 games and right now my speed is aroun 80(with EQ), agility 61, and strength in the high 50s. Whether it is the bad OTs or what I think agility is what is making the difference for my guy not the speed and that is why I think DEs are still finding themselves successful even though speed has become less important.
 
Kanaan
offline
Link
 
i have 16 sacks in 2 games with my de, and the other de has 18 sacks, the first team was a comp. team, but the second team was rated a 48
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wlarson
my DE does just fine as an elusive pass rusher with strength at the 3rd cap. this whole 2 skill DE crap is nonsense. if you play against a pure speed DE, RUN IT DOWN HIS THROAT.


qft
 
Porch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Madcow8me

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Madcow8me



Originally posted by Madcow8me




Originally posted by sjmay





Originally posted by Madcow8me






Last year we had 5 teams that are could hang with almost anyone. 5 very good teams. it was a very very though conference last year..


Not sure what makes that a very very tough conference, as most conferences have a minimum of 6-8 teams that can hang with almost anyone.

But I am pretty sure those teams you mentioned wouldn't be able to hang with very many AAA or pro teams,



http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=31

So far far all the teams have won their games, all 4 will prob make the playoffs.
team 1,2,5,6

All 4 will do much much more than just hang in SE AAA, I think all 4 teams would hang in any pro league.
Winona, Lostcity, Phucket and Mekong. are all very good team, and we had to compete with them all of last year. Look at all of their RE's, My LT played very well vs all of them, zero sacks between those teams.



im still waiting for someone to tell me that these 4 teams are junk


1 is good, the other 3 are average, satisfied?

Now i know you are full of shit, which one do you think is good. I expect 1 of those 4 teams to win SE AAA and get promoted this year...


Mekong and Phuket should battle it out, they are both strong on some positions and weak on others, it will come down to gameplanning and AI, and like I said, one good team.


LOL.

Mekong never finished higher than 3rd and even that may be high. Phucket never hosted or won a playoff game.

So your good teams were actually not even close to being the best.

Nice call son.
 
creeker22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch

LOL.

Mekong never finished higher than 3rd and even that may be high. Phucket never hosted or won a playoff game.

So your good teams were actually not even close to being the best.

Nice call son.


It doesn't matter how good your team or any SEA AA team that moved up to SEA AAA#2 because Duluth is going to take the league this season and if not us than Laos or Rejang or Okinawa but that is it.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
you know how to stop one of this freak DE's....like this

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223930&pbp_id=2054429

max protection
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223930&pbp_id=2054533


Mo Pressure is a freak DE he only got on sack tonight..because the first quarter we ran at him hard and wore him out..also..keep a TE in to help block
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 20:56:44
 
winchester
offline
Link
 
I do not think they are talking about guys with 15 sacks last year as a problem. They are talking about guys with 90+ sacks. Try to run at this guy and see what happens all game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=123897
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Madcow8me


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by Madcow8me




Originally posted by Madcow8me





Originally posted by sjmay






Originally posted by Madcow8me







Last year we had 5 teams that are could hang with almost anyone. 5 very good teams. it was a very very though conference last year..


Not sure what makes that a very very tough conference, as most conferences have a minimum of 6-8 teams that can hang with almost anyone.

But I am pretty sure those teams you mentioned wouldn't be able to hang with very many AAA or pro teams,



http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=31

So far far all the teams have won their games, all 4 will prob make the playoffs.
team 1,2,5,6

All 4 will do much much more than just hang in SE AAA, I think all 4 teams would hang in any pro league.
Winona, Lostcity, Phucket and Mekong. are all very good team, and we had to compete with them all of last year. Look at all of their RE's, My LT played very well vs all of them, zero sacks between those teams.



im still waiting for someone to tell me that these 4 teams are junk


1 is good, the other 3 are average, satisfied?

Now i know you are full of shit, which one do you think is good. I expect 1 of those 4 teams to win SE AAA and get promoted this year...


Mekong and Phuket should battle it out, they are both strong on some positions and weak on others, it will come down to gameplanning and AI, and like I said, one good team.


LOL.

Mekong never finished higher than 3rd and even that may be high. Phucket never hosted or won a playoff game.

So your good teams were actually not even close to being the best.

Nice call son.


Apparently you haven't seen their upgrades, but let's let that slide. AGAIN, sorry to say it, your team just isn't that good, I am sorry, I know it might hurt your ego, and it might explain why their isn't a bug, but your team is pretty damn average at best.

Too bad my team is a slow build team, otherwise I would show you with Pa Dong, Stockholm, or Tears for Olivia, but alas, they aren't my flex points to waste.
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
I see two discussions going on...

1. About the thread topic (DEs against OTs)
2. SE Asia discussion
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 


Last edited Nov 14, 2008 01:15:52
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.