User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LionsLover

Isn't there already a recruiting advantage being in a higher league? Thought so.


Teams that go 14-2 in the regular season and 1-1 in the playoffs in BBB have an easier time recruiting than teams that go 7-9 and miss the playoffs in AAA. Having a significant monetary advantage would help those mediocre AAA teams attract higher-level FAs who might otherwise prefer to win lots of games in BBB (and possibly promotion to A).
 
slakker381
offline
Link
 
The solution is simple...an alternative stream of additional income for the 5-8 seeds. The argument that the rich get richer and the parity between good, mediocre and bad teams is too great is really a moot point to fight considering the previous recommendation of league realignment. The richer teams simply become the lower level teams after their promotion and the league from which they left now becomes more competitive giving everyone an equal opportunity to gain home field playoff advantages. I hate to do this but we can compare this to our own US economy as well...taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy. That is what we are asking to do with revenue sharing...now the difference with GLB and the real world economy is simple...we don't have inflation! Money has no real value and can be added at any time to help progress the world of GLB. Why rob Peter to pay Paul when it's absolutely not necessary?

The "jumbotron" idea brought up initially by Bory might I add, is the obvious choice...it pays only the 5-8 teams, gives a much better incentive to making the playoffs and the disparity between away and home field is lessened while not "taxing" the home team of which may be promoted to a much harder league.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slakker381
The solution is simple...an alternative stream of additional income for the 5-8 seeds. The argument that the rich get richer and the parity between good, mediocre and bad teams is too great is really a moot point to fight considering the previous recommendation of league realignment. The richer teams simply become the lower level teams after their promotion and the league from which they left now becomes more competitive giving everyone an equal opportunity to gain home field playoff advantages. I hate to do this but we can compare this to our own US economy as well...taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy. That is what we are asking to do with revenue sharing...now the difference with GLB and the real world economy is simple...we don't have inflation! Money has no real value and can be added at any time to help progress the world of GLB. Why rob Peter to pay Paul when it's absolutely not necessary?

The "jumbotron" idea brought up initially by Bory might I add, is the obvious choice...it pays only the 5-8 teams, gives a much better incentive to making the playoffs and the disparity between away and home field is lessened while not "taxing" the home team of which may be promoted to a much harder league.


I initially was in favor of the revenue sharing in the form of a gate split (still am). However, I will concede a few points by stating that is not the only way to lessen the financial burdens that have been discussed. I feel the alternative income "jumbotron" is a viable solution to this problem. While I may disagree that it is the "best" solution, I will agree that it is a "viable" solution.

The only problems I see with this that could come up is the following:

1) It will largely increase the gap between teams ranked 9-16 and teams ranked 1-8 (however it will lessen the gap between 1-4 and 5-8). So we will have to understand the issue will still exist but for less teams (that in and of itself is progress while not perfect).

2) It will greatly increase the amount of money in the GLB universe thus basic supply and demand weighs in here and as the player pool further decreases (already has with increase of teams) due to the large gaps mentioned in #1 this will drive the cost of key free agents up to even higher unrealistic (me me me me) status. There is nothing that states this would not be a problem anyways.

Other then these two I am having a hard time finding any other major concerns (or even minor) but I could be overlooking some. Do others have other possible negatives to this idea. It would be a good idea if we listed the positives and negatives of each suggestion so we could weigh in on them and truly have a rational discussion about this that could be referenced by Bort and Company when making any decisions. Thoughts guys?
 
slakker381
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
I initially was in favor of the revenue sharing in the form of a gate split (still am). However, I will concede a few points by stating that is not the only way to lessen the financial burdens that have been discussed. I feel the alternative income "jumbotron" is a viable solution to this problem. While I may disagree that it is the "best" solution, I will agree that it is a "viable" solution.

The only problems I see with this that could come up is the following:

1) It will largely increase the gap between teams ranked 9-16 and teams ranked 1-8 (however it will lessen the gap between 1-4 and 5-8). So we will have to understand the issue will still exist but for less teams (that in and of itself is progress while not perfect).

2) It will greatly increase the amount of money in the GLB universe thus basic supply and demand weighs in here and as the player pool further decreases (already has with increase of teams) due to the large gaps mentioned in #1 this will drive the cost of key free agents up to even higher unrealistic (me me me me) status. There is nothing that states this would not be a problem anyways.

Other then these two I am having a hard time finding any other major concerns (or even minor) but I could be overlooking some. Do others have other possible negatives to this idea. It would be a good idea if we listed the positives and negatives of each suggestion so we could weigh in on them and truly have a rational discussion about this that could be referenced by Bort and Company when making any decisions. Thoughts guys?


To briefly address your 2 issues:

1) I agree that there is still going to be an issue with non-playoff teams...and perhaps there can be other ideas that can still bring in income to teams such as sales of jerseys or gear or anything else that can be brought in to help assist in getting them to be more competitive. Nevertheless, they will still have a better chance at succeeding in the next season after league realignment has been initiated. I've been on a few rebuilding teams, and the problem with a lot of new owners, is that they expect immediate results and success. Experience has told me that it takes time and hard work to create a successful team.

2) Extra money in the GLB universe is not a bad thing! Bort plans on bringing over several other aspects to the game to give the non-owner, player only agents more to do in the GLB community. Money is going to be more of an issue and cutting expected playoff revenue would just complicate the current system. Players know that new things are coming and that has been the primary reason, to several agents that I have personally spoken to and recruited personally, for needing more money for their players. For example, the new advanced equipment, which is above and beyond what owners have originally projected their budgets in seasons past...has been a primary concern among player agents.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 21:47:47
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
Originally posted by slakker381

The solution is simple...an alternative stream of additional income for the 5-8 seeds. The argument that the rich get richer and the parity between good, mediocre and bad teams is too great is really a moot point to fight considering the previous recommendation of league realignment. The richer teams simply become the lower level teams after their promotion and the league from which they left now becomes more competitive giving everyone an equal opportunity to gain home field playoff advantages. I hate to do this but we can compare this to our own US economy as well...taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy. That is what we are asking to do with revenue sharing...now the difference with GLB and the real world economy is simple...we don't have inflation! Money has no real value and can be added at any time to help progress the world of GLB. Why rob Peter to pay Paul when it's absolutely not necessary?

The "jumbotron" idea brought up initially by Bory might I add, is the obvious choice...it pays only the 5-8 teams, gives a much better incentive to making the playoffs and the disparity between away and home field is lessened while not "taxing" the home team of which may be promoted to a much harder league.


I initially was in favor of the revenue sharing in the form of a gate split (still am). However, I will concede a few points by stating that is not the only way to lessen the financial burdens that have been discussed. I feel the alternative income "jumbotron" is a viable solution to this problem. While I may disagree that it is the "best" solution, I will agree that it is a "viable" solution.

The only problems I see with this that could come up is the following:

1) It will largely increase the gap between teams ranked 9-16 and teams ranked 1-8 (however it will lessen the gap between 1-4 and 5-8). So we will have to understand the issue will still exist but for less teams (that in and of itself is progress while not perfect).

2) It will greatly increase the amount of money in the GLB universe thus basic supply and demand weighs in here and as the player pool further decreases (already has with increase of teams) due to the large gaps mentioned in #1 this will drive the cost of key free agents up to even higher unrealistic (me me me me) status. There is nothing that states this would not be a problem anyways.

Other then these two I am having a hard time finding any other major concerns (or even minor) but I could be overlooking some. Do others have other possible negatives to this idea. It would be a good idea if we listed the positives and negatives of each suggestion so we could weigh in on them and truly have a rational discussion about this that could be referenced by Bort and Company when making any decisions. Thoughts guys?


Thanks for moving forward.

1. I think post season scrimmages should have tickets sold to them at 50% expected prices. Same could go for concessions. Maybe you could even do something fun like having the option to donate a portion of proceeds to charities to improve fan support and/or player morale.

2. The economics will work themselves out. As long as there is a limit on max contracts, it should be fine.
 
IamJack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slakker381
taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy.


Couldnt be further from what should happen...

This philosophy basically promotes the wealthy hard working to not function as efficiently and thus affect every "tier" below them...but lets not get into politics here.

I hate the revenue sharing idea that Bort will be implementing!
-There will be zero drive to get a top 4 seed in the playoffs
-This will erase the importance of regular season
-Take from hard working (I put MUCH more hard work into GLB than most) to benefit the not-so-hard working.
Horrible principles.

 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slakker381
...taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy.


Off topic, but I can't let this fallacy stand unchallenged.

"Taxing the wealthy"
(1) we tax INCOME not WEALTH--difference being someone who's already wealthy and doesn't earn income gets taxed nada. This often leads to us aiming for the wrong target.
(2) often attempts to do this result in harm to the very folks we're trying to help. REAL LIFE examples of this abound, but one of the most illustrative is the 1990 Federal Excise Tax on luxury items (cars, planes, yachts etc) which was intended to be a way to tax the rich without increasing the burden on the middle class (who don't have cars over $100k, yachts, or planes). It failed MISERABLY to the point where it had to be repealed in 1993. Why? It changed behavior. The very rich simply bought their yachts overseas. The Joint Committee on Taxation had projected a 1991 windfall of $31 million but instead generated less than $17 million and when the effects of this "tax on the rich" was studied by the Joint Economic Commission, it estimated that this "tax on the rich" cost 330 jobs in jewelery manufacturing, ~1500 jobs in the airplane manufacturing industry, and nearly 8000 jobs in the boating industry. Rich people stopped buying American luxury items and regular American workers who produced those items or worked in those industries got shafted. These were jobs held by regular hard working ordinary people who were the ones hurt the MOST by the "tax on the rich". It also cost the government an estimated ~$8 million in unempoyment benefits. "Taxing the rich" makes for a great sound bite, but following this policy is the road to economic suicide.

Those horrible wealthy people are the ones with money to INVEST and create jobs. No, of course they aren't all wonderful and honest. That's just as overly simplistic as "tax the rich." I'm just saying your statement belies a frightening lack of understanding of economics.

I wish our educational system was able to teach our population the difference between economics and politics.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 22:04:46
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GeauxTigahs
Originally posted by slakker381

taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy.


Couldnt be further from what should happen...

This philosophy basically promotes the wealthy hard working to not function as efficiently and thus affect every "tier" below them...but lets not get into politics here.

I hate the revenue sharing idea that Bort will be implementing!
-There will be zero drive to get a top 4 seed in the playoffs
-This will erase the importance of regular season
-Take from hard working (I put MUCH more hard work into GLB than most) to benefit the not-so-hard working.
Horrible principles.



There are good arguments against revenue sharing. These are not them.

1. Securing twice as much money as seeds 5-8 is not incentive enough? You have to get 30x as much to me motivated?
2. Same argument put a different way. Plus, part of the importance of seeding is getting the easier matchup, thus securing the greater possibility of another game.
3. There are teams at every level of success that work equally hard.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar

The only problems I see with this that could come up is the following:

1) It will largely increase the gap between teams ranked 9-16 and teams ranked 1-8 (however it will lessen the gap between 1-4 and 5-8). So we will have to understand the issue will still exist but for less teams (that in and of itself is progress while not perfect).

2) It will greatly increase the amount of money in the GLB universe thus basic supply and demand weighs in here and as the player pool further decreases (already has with increase of teams) due to the large gaps mentioned in #1 this will drive the cost of key free agents up to even higher unrealistic (me me me me) status. There is nothing that states this would not be a problem anyways.

Other then these two I am having a hard time finding any other major concerns (or even minor) but I could be overlooking some. Do others have other possible negatives to this idea. It would be a good idea if we listed the positives and negatives of each suggestion so we could weigh in on them and truly have a rational discussion about this that could be referenced by Bort and Company when making any decisions. Thoughts guys?


OK, back ON topic:

To me, this is the exact same argument as the original one except it's replaced "high seeds" with "playoff teams" and "low seeds" with "non-playoff teams" and I still don't buy it. If this puts the non-playoff teams at a disadvantage, then they need to get better. I know that sounds simplistic, but asking a team to get to the playoffs is only asking them to be in the top HALF of their league. That's not nearly as large a burden as asking them to go through the season with just 2 losses, as many #4 seeds are required to do. Most #8 seeds are barely 0.500 teams, and with a number of teams in virtually every league that are gutted/rebuilding type, I think 0.500 is not an unreasonable thing to ask of a team for it to get a "reward." I don't think saying "get good enough to be 8-8" is nearly as harsh as saying "go 13-3 in your league to get any decent money".

In addition, a number of the non-playoff will get relegated downward with Bort's new accelerated promotion/demotion schedule. This means that even though they don't share in the playoff windfall, they will still be competitive the following season because they will be playing in a league that is populated by (presumably) weaker teams, thus increasing their chances of making the playoffs and EARNING their reward.

 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by GeauxTigahs

Originally posted by slakker381


taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy.


Couldnt be further from what should happen...

This philosophy basically promotes the wealthy hard working to not function as efficiently and thus affect every "tier" below them...but lets not get into politics here.

I hate the revenue sharing idea that Bort will be implementing!
-There will be zero drive to get a top 4 seed in the playoffs
-This will erase the importance of regular season
-Take from hard working (I put MUCH more hard work into GLB than most) to benefit the not-so-hard working.
Horrible principles.



There are good arguments against revenue sharing. These are not them.

1. Securing twice as much money as seeds 5-8 is not incentive enough? You have to get 30x as much to me motivated?
2. Same argument put a different way. Plus, part of the importance of seeding is getting the easier matchup, thus securing the greater possibility of another game.
3. There are teams at every level of success that work equally hard.


+1....and I don't like the revenue sharing idea. But these are not convincing reasons to reject it. There are plenty of other posts with much better reasons in this thread.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 22:03:01
 
slakker381
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knightman
Originally posted by slakker381

...taxing the wealthy and giving cuts to the middle and lower class is obviously the way to go in restoring the economy.


Off topic, but I can't let this fallacy stand unchallenged.

"Taxing the wealthy"
(1) we tax INCOME not WEALTH--difference being someone who's already wealthy and doesn't earn income gets taxed nada. This often leads to us aiming for the wrong target.
(2) often attempts to do this result in harm to the very folks we're trying to help. REAL LIFE examples of this abound, but one of the most illustrative is the 1990 Federal Excise Tax on luxury items (cars, planes, yachts etc) which was intended to be a way to tax the rich without increasing the burden on the middle class (who don't have cars over $100k, yachts, or planes). It failed MISERABLY to the point where it had to be repealed in 1993. Why? It changed behavior. The very rich simply bought their yachts overseas. The Joint Committee on Taxation had projected a 1991 windfall of $31 million but instead generated less than $17 million and when the effects of this "tax on the rich" was studied by the Joint Economic Commission, it estimated that this "tax on the rich" cost 330 jobs in jewelery manufacturing, ~1500 jobs in the airplane manufacturing industry, and nearly 8000 jobs in the boating industry. Rich people stopped buying American luxury items and regular American workers who produced those items or worked in those industries got shafted. These were jobs held by regular hard working ordinary people who were the ones hurt the MOST by the "tax on the rich". It also cost the government an estimated ~$8 million in unempoyment benefits. "Taxing the rich" makes for a great sound bite, but following this policy is the road to economic suicide.

Those horrible wealthy people are the ones with money to INVEST and create jobs. No, of course they aren't all wonderful and honest. That's just as overly simplistic as "tax the rich." I'm just saying your statement belies a frightening lack of understanding of economics.

I wish our educational system was able to teach our population the difference between economics and politics.



duly noted, "taxing the higher income brackets" (ie - +$250k/yr) is what i meant

Originally posted by Knightman
I don't like the revenue sharing idea. But these are not convincing reasons to reject it. There are plenty of other posts with much better reasons in this thread.


Such as? I understand that there may be other ideas, but the principle is still the same...bring more money into GLB in one way or another. Let the top 4 keep their revenue and give more money to the rest of the league starting with the 5-8's, then the rest of the league. How we get this done is pure schematics...jumbotron, tv revenue, it doesn't really matter.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 23:42:25
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slakker381
Originally posted by Knightman

I don't like the revenue sharing idea. But these are not convincing reasons to reject it. There are plenty of other posts with much better reasons in this thread.


Such as? I understand that there may be other ideas, but the principle is still the same...bring more money into GLB in one way or another. Let the top 4 keep their revenue and give more money to the rest of the league starting with the 5-8's, then the rest of the league. How we get this done is pure schematics...jumbotron, tv revenue, it doesn't really matter.


Well, like I said, I don't like the revenue sharing idea and support the alternative revenue option, so I'm not going to try and make the case for the "other team."

But if you seriously want my answer to this question, you can find it in the posts I've put up over the last few pages. Don't want to rehash it again.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 06:26:31
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Discussion on this has slowed down. Could be the weekend could be an impasse between different arguments or it could be we are getting closer to an understanding. I conceded my original points but when I mentioned the gap between playoff and non-playoff teams I was never implying these non-playoff teams should get rewarded for mediocrity or lack of effort. I was just mentioning that it will further increase the already growing problem of gutting/selling teams.

So as a group (those that have been following this or those that are getting caught up on the discussion) what are the options on the table for discussion. Seems like it is the alternative funding in the form of a "jumbotron" originally brought up by Bort and how exactly that would look. There was other discussion on increased bonuses or other methods. Does anybody know what Bort is planning or wanting to add for this season? I say for this season the alternative income is the only way to go since many people hate midseason changes anyways. It would cause the 'least' complaints and still work towards the problem. However, what should be the long-term solution? I guess we can discuss that more after we see if this is working for people? Thoughts?
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
I guess the discussion died or is in another forum that I have not looked for.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
I guess the discussion died or is in another forum that I have not looked for.


I think we went in circles enough times, heh.

Basically there were a lot of ideas and complaints, but we don't really know how it will work, so at this point it's kind of pointless. Maybe Bort got some ideas from the thread, I don't know.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.