User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Recent Upgrades(discussion)
Page:
 
Ivanhoe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Ivanhoe1

Originally posted by Weykool


Originally posted by allstarpdc



From Bort:
Also: We are planning on doing a playoff tickets rev share this year, just to let all those teams who will be making the playoffs know in advance. Haven't decided the exact split at the moment, but thought we should let you know so you can plan for it.

Great, Bort. Thanks for penalizing us teams that are smart & have aggressively built our stadiums...and then rewarding the teams that haven't. Another great move. Well...I guess I can not use that money that I won't be getting to not buy the crappy new EQ that just got nerfed.


Cry me a river.
Revenue sharing has been needed for a long time.
When teams cant compete they get gutted.....and we need to do everything we can to reduce the number of gutted teams.
Giving some teams millions of revenue while giving other teams nothing is is just plain stupid.


I think this is a horrible move. I guess we wait and see how the playoff revenue sharing plan is finally laid out. Wasn’t Bort going to address gutted, financially broken teams in another manner? Prevention is far better than a cure but you can’t prevent human stupidity.

I feel there should be some form of revenue sharing but not at the expense of teams that were managed well financially. Especially teams in their first and second season where they went out and spent all they had to get the best available players, and even throwing money at the not so best available players, without thinking about the future cost, ignoring their stadiums, and totally foregoing setting up a good financial base to grow the team.

This will effect how good owners manage their futures. They will have to plan accordingly knowing that the fruits of their labors will be welfare’d out to others that didn’t want to plan well.

There will be owners out there who know that they don’t have to manage anything. They can ignore the bottom line and gain an upper hand by being aggressive in FA hires/trades because they can count on getting a free handout from other teams in the league that were smart with their money.

This reminds me of another bailout attempt happening in our country right now where people can spend freely and fleece others knowing there wont be any consequences or downside because they will just pass the bill on to others so they can continue the madness.


Melodrama x 100

1. Noone has any idea what playoff revenue sharing will look like. It could be 50/50 (but I don't believe it will be), it could be 1/3 to 2/3, it could be 90/10. It could put all the money from a round into a pool and divvy it up to the playoff teams in the round. Regardless, some form of revenue sharing in the playoffs has been required for a long, long time. As mentioned, the teams (mine included) that have been winners are lucky this wasn't introduced earlier, and this will be for the better of the game going forward.

2. You aren't splitting cash with 15 other teams, this is, as far as I can tell, a playoff revenue sharing model for the 8 playoff teams per conference. So it is better rewarding the teams that are run well and are making the playoffs by spreading the wealth around a bit.

3. If you read the announcement, Bort is dealing with guts through an offseason reorganization or some sort, moving uncompetitive teams down (such as farms, slow builders, guts, or just poorly managed clubs) along with increased promotion to fill those gaps. All teams moved to the bottom get reset with $$$ & base stadium so that everyone getting a new team builds up from the bottom.

I understand that in this greedy and selfish world we live in, noone wants to give anything up, but the fact is, revenue sharing is long overdue.


It was little over the top LoL, but this 700 billion bailout has me riled up, anywho back to GLB .

1. As I mentioned we just have to wait and see how the revenue sharing plan is laid out. Hopefully it is a good, sound plan. I said I was for revenue sharing but not at the expense of other teams.

2. I knew it was a playoff revenue share for half the teams in conference that make the playoffs. I don't understand how it rewards well run teams. The well run teams will be the ones giving up a share of their revenues to the ones that are not well run. If we want to spread the wealth then just let the stadium revenue count toward the regular season, have no stadium revenue during the post-season, and just have one big playoff pot that gets divided evenly among the 8 playoff teams.

3. I read the announcement, I was referring to Weykool's post about gutted teams.

Overall I believe revenue sharing is good for the game in the long run but if teams were managed well in the first place we wouldn't need it.

Edit: I meant Weykool's post, sorry.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 10:54:02
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaveTN
Originally posted by SCACE


So says he who despite having a good team has been arguing in favour of revenue sharing since season 1, smartass.


That might be. You may have always wanted revenue sharing but to support this change as a mid-season change is wrong when you have benefited from 'the system' in place now for so long. I do support the idea but only as a change done during the off-season. I guess I touched a nerve judging by your resorting to name calling, no need. Intelligent debate should involve facts and reasoning not personal flames.



Sorry, I didn't realize you were so sensitive that "smartass" offended you and was me resorting to name calling
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by robelder


Originally posted by SCACE



Hey Rob,

Did you ever stop and think that maybe the world is a fucked up place and it isn't working? The whole "rich get richer" in the real world, while true, isn't exactly working for society as a whole. This is a game where we all come to get away from the BS that life has to offer, and maybe, just maybe, we can have a system on here that doesn't constantly reward the rich just for the sake of being rich.

Think about it.


Yeah, because we tell people who are poor to live off the government (i.e. the rich taxes). These people need to be taught how to manage their finances and learn a good work ethic and they won't be poor anymore. The problem is not in people getting rich it is in other finding ways to get poor. If you give a poor man 100K he'll be poor in a year or two because he doesn't make good decisions. The same will happen in this game. Give breaks to the poor and they'll find a new way to be poor, but tick off people who are good at the game and they're going to quit. I'm much closer than I ever thought. Maybe spending my time somewhere else is the best thing anyway.


man, you have a warped view of reality.


Really? Let me ask you a few questions about why are teams struggling:
Do they have good rosters or bad rosters?
Do they spend their money on stadiums early or players early?
Are they good recruiters?
Do the pay for players in trades to build their team?

These issues will not be changed by taking from the better owners. This is life and it will continue to play out. The same owners will still be good, the only difference is that their reward will be given to the bad teams.



I think you are missing the point. We aren't talking about sharing $$$ with every team in the league (at least not how I understand the announcement). We're talking about the sharing of playoff revenue among playoff teams. Genearlly speaking....

1. Playoff teams have good rosters.
2. Playoff teams, generally at least, have at least a decent idea of how to build a stadium and manage finances while trying to remain competitive year-over-year.
3. Generally, they are good enough at recruiting to make the playoffs.
4. Most teams pay to acquire players at some point or another.

The problem is that the teams at the very top are getting such a disproportionate amount of money for being only 25% of each league. And when you consider that a number one seed can get 4 home games of revenue untouched, that is a mere 3% of the 32 teams in each league getting a massive amount of money.

To write off teams 5-8 as unworthy of more playoff money is absurd and just shows your narrow-minded, and yes, warped point of view.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Ivan - I have to disagree. When the disparity between a 1st place team and a 5th place team can be as much as tens of millions of dollars (assuming the the 1st place team moves on all the way and the 5th place team gets knocked out in the 1st round) and unless the 1st round away teams get very, very lucky, the difference is till in the multi-millions, it doesn't take a genius to see there is a problem.

I'm not saying that every team should get equal amounts of money -- you should earn more being the 1st seed, 2nd seed, and so on. The problem right now, since the start of the game, is the amount of difference between 1st and so-on as you work your way down through the playoff teams.

That doesn't even take into account the non-playoff teams, but as the system stood before today, the top 4 teams earned millions from the playoffs and the bottom 12 (playoff teams included) earned little to no money.
 
DaveTN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE

Sorry, I didn't realize you were so sensitive that "smartass" offended you and was me resorting to name calling


Didn't offend me. I merely pointed out there was no need and to stay within the lines of true debate. You've thus far not given any solid reasoning for a mid-season change to add in revenue sharing in terms of how that is fair to current owners.

 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
I agree with SCACE. This is a sorely needed change and everyone should have known it would be coming at some point.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
The problem is with managing well and that will not change. We just need to learn how to deal with picking up the pieces and getting poorly managed teams into the right leagues, not take away from the well managed teams.

Think about it. Once the better managed teams move up and are playing other well managed teams, is this going to be an issue at the top. And won't the same thing happen at the bottom? And you'll never see a poor managed team make the top anyway, will you? If not won't they drop again?

Just give a bigger bonus. Although the problems can be complex, it is not impossible to come out with a win for everyone instead of a win for some and a penalty for others. That is the way this game is making decisions lately. Bort, you need to look for win, wins, not win, lose scenarios. If you can't find that, then it really shouldn't be done. I do realize that sounds easy in theory and is easier said then done, but maybe you are making too many changes. You don't play the game, we do. If you had to put up with negative changes happening all the time, you'd understand some of us. You can always put together a team of very strategic people to think it through until you can find a win, win.

I want to be open and just talk it through, but this was the most knee jerk reaction I've seen this game make. I saw no discussion or alert that this was coming to debate it in advance from you like you normally do. You just came out and did it. It was also disappointing when trying to work through a bug I was experiencing with my team to get smartalec comments making me look like I was just making stuff up. I had a real issue and was looking to get it resolved. Now in general I'm very unhappy and don't understand why you are treating people this way. I'm more than willing to debate in a nice way. I understand that you are frustrated with people complaining as anyone would, but picking on people who are trying to figure out why the game isn't working and are just talking is poor customer service.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaveTN
Originally posted by SCACE


Sorry, I didn't realize you were so sensitive that "smartass" offended you and was me resorting to name calling


Didn't offend me. I merely pointed out there was no need and to stay within the lines of true debate. You've thus far not given any solid reasoning for a mid-season change to add in revenue sharing in terms of how that is fair to current owners.



How so?

1. It is long overdue, and rather than leave non-homers through yet another season of disparity, it is better to make the change now before the gap increases even further.

2. You can argue that it isn't fair to 4 current owners in each conference but fair to 4 other owners who will benefit from it (the non-homers). I'd argue that homers have been lucky this hasn't been put in earlier, and non-homers have been given the shit end of the stick long enough.

3. Now, the kicker here is that we can argue until we're blue in the face about whether this should or shouldn't happen, but we don't even have the details. If it is a 50/50 share of the gate, I'll be on your side that it is too much. If it is say 10-30% of the gate to the non-homer, I think it will do its job. If it is less than 10%, I'm not really sure it does enough for the non-homers, but at least it is something.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE

I think you are missing the point. We aren't talking about sharing $$$ with every team in the league (at least not how I understand the announcement). We're talking about the sharing of playoff revenue among playoff teams. Genearlly speaking....

1. Playoff teams have good rosters.
2. Playoff teams, generally at least, have at least a decent idea of how to build a stadium and manage finances while trying to remain competitive year-over-year.
3. Generally, they are good enough at recruiting to make the playoffs.
4. Most teams pay to acquire players at some point or another.

The problem is that the teams at the very top are getting such a disproportionate amount of money for being only 25% of each league. And when you consider that a number one seed can get 4 home games of revenue untouched, that is a mere 3% of the 32 teams in each league getting a massive amount of money.

To write off teams 5-8 as unworthy of more playoff money is absurd and just shows your narrow-minded, and yes, warped point of view.


Just give a bigger bonus, changing rules after teams have already spent the offseason planning for this season is not right. I didn't write off the playoff teams, I was upset with taking money from teams 1-4.

What is warped?
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
The problem is with managing well and that will not change. We just need to learn how to deal with picking up the pieces and getting poorly managed teams into the right leagues, not take away from the well managed teams.

Think about it. Once the better managed teams move up and are playing other well managed teams, is this going to be an issue at the top. And won't the same thing happen at the bottom? And you'll never see a poor managed team make the top anyway, will you? If not won't they drop again?

Just give a bigger bonus. Although the problems can be complex, it is not impossible to come out with a win for everyone instead of a win for some and a penalty for others. That is the way this game is making decisions lately. Bort, you need to look for win, wins, not win, lose scenarios. If you can't find that, then it really shouldn't be done. I do realize that sounds easy in theory and is easier said then done, but maybe you are making too many changes. You don't play the game, we do. If you had to put up with negative changes happening all the time, you'd understand some of us. You can always put together a team of very strategic people to think it through until you can find a win, win.

I want to be open and just talk it through, but this was the most knee jerk reaction I've seen this game make. I saw no discussion or alert that this was coming to debate it in advance from you like you normally do. You just came out and did it. It was also disappointing when trying to work through a bug I was experiencing with my team to get smartalec comments making me look like I was just making stuff up. I had a real issue and was looking to get it resolved. Now in general I'm very unhappy and don't understand why you are treating people this way. I'm more than willing to debate in a nice way. I understand that you are frustrated with people complaining as anyone would, but picking on people who are trying to figure out why the game isn't working and are just talking is poor customer service.


You only consider it a penalty because it has always been 100% playoff money to the homers, when it should never have been this way. If the game had started with playoff revenue sharing, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

It is a long overdue change that benefits teams that are well run enough to make the top 8 in their conferences. Your argument about rewarding poor teams is lost on me, as there are very few poorly run teams that make the playoffs, outside of the occasional 7th or 8th seeds in heavily gutted leagues, which is also being fixed based on the announcement.
 
stumanroo
blame stu
offline
Link
 
I don't think it should go over 20%.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
I agree with SCACE. This is a sorely needed change and everyone should have known it would be coming at some point.


The way this change was made is the biggest problem. No discussion from Bort for feedback is like saying I'm the dictator here. Which obviously he is, but if he wants to run it that way, then don't act like we matter and don't be surprised when people get upset. This game is making some very bad PR moves and it is happen more often and closer together.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by SCACE


I think you are missing the point. We aren't talking about sharing $$$ with every team in the league (at least not how I understand the announcement). We're talking about the sharing of playoff revenue among playoff teams. Genearlly speaking....

1. Playoff teams have good rosters.
2. Playoff teams, generally at least, have at least a decent idea of how to build a stadium and manage finances while trying to remain competitive year-over-year.
3. Generally, they are good enough at recruiting to make the playoffs.
4. Most teams pay to acquire players at some point or another.

The problem is that the teams at the very top are getting such a disproportionate amount of money for being only 25% of each league. And when you consider that a number one seed can get 4 home games of revenue untouched, that is a mere 3% of the 32 teams in each league getting a massive amount of money.

To write off teams 5-8 as unworthy of more playoff money is absurd and just shows your narrow-minded, and yes, warped point of view.


Just give a bigger bonus, changing rules after teams have already spent the offseason planning for this season is not right. I didn't write off the playoff teams, I was upset with taking money from teams 1-4.

What is warped?


Again, you only consider it "taking" money because its a change from the way things have been. The money isn't "yours" until the game processes it to your team. All that is changing is the formula that processes the money to your team. You still make a lot more money than you would as a non-homer and much more than a non-playoff team, as you should.

A bigger bonus system only works if it only goes to the non-homers, but then it could, theoretically, penalize the top team if they get knocked out by an 8-seed who saved their boosts but received a bigger bonus while the top seed only got the 1 home game, depending on how big the bonus was.

Sharing the revenue is a logical, and long overdue step.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by Nixx

I agree with SCACE. This is a sorely needed change and everyone should have known it would be coming at some point.


The way this change was made is the biggest problem. No discussion from Bort for feedback is like saying I'm the dictator here. Which obviously he is, but if he wants to run it that way, then don't act like we matter and don't be surprised when people get upset. This game is making some very bad PR moves and it is happen more often and closer together.


Don't play ignorant -- you've been around this game long enough to know that this change has been WIDELY discussed for multiple seasons and honestly, was bound to happen at some point.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by robelder

The problem is with managing well and that will not change. We just need to learn how to deal with picking up the pieces and getting poorly managed teams into the right leagues, not take away from the well managed teams.

Think about it. Once the better managed teams move up and are playing other well managed teams, is this going to be an issue at the top. And won't the same thing happen at the bottom? And you'll never see a poor managed team make the top anyway, will you? If not won't they drop again?

Just give a bigger bonus. Although the problems can be complex, it is not impossible to come out with a win for everyone instead of a win for some and a penalty for others. That is the way this game is making decisions lately. Bort, you need to look for win, wins, not win, lose scenarios. If you can't find that, then it really shouldn't be done. I do realize that sounds easy in theory and is easier said then done, but maybe you are making too many changes. You don't play the game, we do. If you had to put up with negative changes happening all the time, you'd understand some of us. You can always put together a team of very strategic people to think it through until you can find a win, win.

I want to be open and just talk it through, but this was the most knee jerk reaction I've seen this game make. I saw no discussion or alert that this was coming to debate it in advance from you like you normally do. You just came out and did it. It was also disappointing when trying to work through a bug I was experiencing with my team to get smartalec comments making me look like I was just making stuff up. I had a real issue and was looking to get it resolved. Now in general I'm very unhappy and don't understand why you are treating people this way. I'm more than willing to debate in a nice way. I understand that you are frustrated with people complaining as anyone would, but picking on people who are trying to figure out why the game isn't working and are just talking is poor customer service.


You only consider it a penalty because it has always been 100% playoff money to the homers, when it should never have been this way. If the game had started with playoff revenue sharing, we wouldn't be having this discussion.

It is a long overdue change that benefits teams that are well run enough to make the top 8 in their conferences. Your argument about rewarding poor teams is lost on me, as there are very few poorly run teams that make the playoffs, outside of the occasional 7th or 8th seeds in heavily gutted leagues, which is also being fixed based on the announcement.


There are lots of ok, ran teams that make the playoffs and a few well run teams. My problem is changing these rules today, now. If you want to give more money to these teams, fine, but taking it from the ones who already had a plan for this year and recruited for this season based on that plan sucks. I will lose money this season and that is not right. I budget for the whole season and make plans for the next. Now I'm being stolen from.

Should it have been setup differently to begin with. Yes. Does that make it right to change int he middle of the season. No. Whatever the rules are you have to stick with them. There is no problem, we all knew this is the way it worked, so why does anyone have a right to say it should be changed in the middle of the season. The NFL didn't change the rule about the inadvertent whistle on the Broncos/Chargers game. It was a rule and it had to be enforced. Next season they will probably change it. MLB did change a rule with instant replay, but it didn't negatively affect any teams or upcoming games. That is fine. If you want to give a bigger bonus to the other teams, that is fine. But taking from teams who have budgeted is stealing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.