User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DdgDktaRlz
Change your training to Relaxed instead of Intense...... You will get 30 back between games instead of 6.


That doesn't help enough when your losing 40 points a game and only on the field a short time. I don't know if tere is a time of possession (I'll have to look) but in the last game the offense for us was on the field for long sustained drives. In a real game that's huge to keeping a defense fresh. I think that's part of the problem. The game just looks at the plays and doesn't look at what you did or how long you were on the field between them plays.

As I said in my first post, I am not sure this can be fixed and that's fine, but it does cause an issue when a saftey that's honestly expending very little per play is losing as much as a DL or OL guy. Just my thoughts.
 
LordMortis
offline
Link
 
I'm not an owner but I do see one thing that is kicking my starting OLine man's ass. He's on special teams. Once he starts doing kick off returns, he starts getting winded quickly and is liable to only start resting enough to play again at about the time he needs to do another kick off return.

I've suggested pulling me from special teams but the coach considers me too valuable. In the mean time, all I can do is continue to put points in stamina when I can. When you think about it, a stamina of 35 (where I am at) is still very very low. If I want more plays then I have to prioritize stamina even higher than I already have. If the coach wants me to not concentrate on stamina and to remain on special teams then he has to consider that in his depth chart.

There is a lot juggling and a bit of a learning curve that the owners have to go through here. They didn't need to learn so much last season because everyone started every game at 70 energy no matter how hard and no matter how much they played.

I consider this intended element of energy management a good thing.
Last edited Apr 29, 2008 13:48:32
 
NSab
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan
Originally posted by DdgDktaRlz

Change your training to Relaxed instead of Intense...... You will get 30 back between games instead of 6.


That doesn't help enough when your losing 40 points a game and only on the field a short time. I don't know if tere is a time of possession (I'll have to look) but in the last game the offense for us was on the field for long sustained drives. In a real game that's huge to keeping a defense fresh. I think that's part of the problem. The game just looks at the plays and doesn't look at what you did or how long you were on the field between them plays.

As I said in my first post, I am not sure this can be fixed and that's fine, but it does cause an issue when a saftey that's honestly expending very little per play is losing as much as a DL or OL guy. Just my thoughts.


Train nothing on relaxed and you get 36 at least
 
vonbearsalot
offline
Link
 
For the record....

I'm sure there's a lot of complaining about the new energy settings, because people love to complain when hidden behind the anonymity of the internet, but I absolutely love the new settings.

More realism, more need for depth (the challenge of being a GM), it punishes owners who overpay a few studs and have no depth behind them, and rewards smart moves and hard work.

If you don't want a challenge, play Madden on easy. Everyone who complained about not having a team are now complaining that they have one and can't figure it out.

Deal with it, hire a GM, or sell your team.

Good work, Bort.

~Von
 
jrweeks1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vonbearsalot
For the record....

I'm sure there's a lot of complaining about the new energy settings, because people love to complain when hidden behind the anonymity of the internet, but I absolutely love the new settings.

More realism, more need for depth (the challenge of being a GM), it punishes owners who overpay a few studs and have no depth behind them, and rewards smart moves and hard work.

If you don't want a challenge, play Madden on easy. Everyone who complained about not having a team are now complaining that they have one and can't figure it out.

Deal with it, hire a GM, or sell your team.

Good work, Bort.

~Von


I am seeing a lot of good sharing of ideas here. I have no problem with people raising issues as long as we come away with better ideas in approaching specific challenges to the game.

 
Tracker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vonbearsalot
For the record....

I'm sure there's a lot of complaining about the new energy settings, because people love to complain when hidden behind the anonymity of the internet, but I absolutely love the new settings.

More realism, more need for depth (the challenge of being a GM), it punishes owners who overpay a few studs and have no depth behind them, and rewards smart moves and hard work.

If you don't want a challenge, play Madden on easy. Everyone who complained about not having a team are now complaining that they have one and can't figure it out.

Deal with it, hire a GM, or sell your team.

Good work, Bort.

~Von


That is a opinion based on a limited perspective. If like in the case of a new expansion team I play on is very limited in depth. You start out the season with no real documentation of how the energy system works so you go out and play that first game on Hard intensity trying to win. Now you have a bunch of depleted player who can’t really level as quickly to become competitive with more established team who had the benefit of leveling without all of the new restrictions, because they are prema suck on relaxed training and in some cases, still not catching up.

I like the idea of wear and tear as well but I think the implementation of it was a little unfair. Many (despite what some play off on the board) did not and still do not have a real clear understanding of how the energy system or the sub system really works.
That being the case, how can anybody effectively make sound “tactical choices” when most people are completely confused by the ambiguity of the energy system?

Most are not bitching because they want and easy game. They would just like to have all of the information possible in order to play the game the best of their teams ability.

I for one have never played a game in my life from Chutes and Ladders to World of Warcraft and yes, even Madden that at least did not have a instruction manual that explained the nuts and bolts of a game.

THAT is what many are posting about. In case you missed it, beta is a time for feedback from the players to the developers. That means both positive and negative feedback based on all possible gaming situations. Having that info allows the designers to find an equilibrium in the gaming experience for all players. I find it ironic that your brown nosing and bravado laden post draws about the same benefit gained from those… how did you put it? Ahh yes “hidden behind the anonymity of the internet.”

Mr. Pot… I would like to introduce you to Mr. Kettle… oh hey look YOU ARE BOTH BLACK!




 
Hagetaka
offline
Link
 
Not reading 28 pages of this (much of which I imagine is complaining), but let me just say awesome job Bort and DD.

I love that the new stamina settings actually make you make he hard choice on playing hard/normal/relaxed.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vonbearsalot
For the record....

I'm sure there's a lot of complaining about the new energy settings, because people love to complain when hidden behind the anonymity of the internet, but I absolutely love the new settings.

More realism, more need for depth (the challenge of being a GM), it punishes owners who overpay a few studs and have no depth behind them, and rewards smart moves and hard work.

If you don't want a challenge, play Madden on easy. Everyone who complained about not having a team are now complaining that they have one and can't figure it out.

Deal with it, hire a GM, or sell your team.

Good work, Bort.

~Von



As was pointed out above me, people that talk about other people complaining and downing them .. while they are also behind the internet are no better. Sucking up to the teacher and bagging on the "classmates" behind there back doesn't help a thing or make you look any better.

Bottom line is there are issues with the energy system as it currently stands. If you watch the replays of the games and then find out the energy used it doesn't make sence. Is this horrible? No not at all. It's beta and it's a great game. That doesn't make it perfect.

If you look at the forums.. the stickied "guide to creating players" and follow it my level 7 DB shouldn't have 33 stamina, he does and he still loses 40 energy per game.. the max allowed. That tells me, since it's stickied, it's accepted by the mods on here so it must have some truth to it. If you look at the "good SS build" (Which I play) it's a level 16 guy.. his stamina is 36. What is a new guy to think? I shouldn't have to have a 33 at level 7 to play the game as a starter and not lose the max energy I can lose.

Here is the question/problem. If I am going to lose the max energy no matter what, why boost stamina? Why am I wasting my time on it? I trying to make it matter they are almost making it useless. Does more stamina matter on recovering energy? Not to my knowledge. So it's not helping me keep energy, I am losing energy like a DL/OL guy fighting it out every down while I am trotting around on run plays and I am not being helped by it on recovering energy so what good is it?

While your sucking up to the devs and knocking anyone that wants to point out a flaw can you tell me honestly that what I have said isn't true and isn't a issue? For the record I am playing on "normal" intensity and "relaxed" trainning. Also, I am not hidding behind the internet at all it's simply the mode we use (ie the forum) to communicate.

As you said, the developers and mods are doing a great job, and they do listen and better then that they don't seem to react knee jerky which is great also. I don't believe there have been alot of people to give the "I am going to quit this game sux!" posts so it's not simply complaining about things. People want to know how things work and why they work like they do. If the devs posted tonight that the energy thing is a done deal and it's staying the way it is forever I wouldn't say another word. Since it's Beta I will give my input and try to do it in a way that's as positive as negative feedback can be. = )
Last edited Apr 29, 2008 17:47:47
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShevaUKR
its easier to train stamina then speed or some other skill, but for some reason in this game you get same amount XP for every skill. Thats not how it is in RL.


Huh??
 
Link
 
Originally posted by NSab
Originally posted by Justafan

Originally posted by DdgDktaRlz


Change your training to Relaxed instead of Intense...... You will get 30 back between games instead of 6.


That doesn't help enough when your losing 40 points a game and only on the field a short time. I don't know if tere is a time of possession (I'll have to look) but in the last game the offense for us was on the field for long sustained drives. In a real game that's huge to keeping a defense fresh. I think that's part of the problem. The game just looks at the plays and doesn't look at what you did or how long you were on the field between them plays.

As I said in my first post, I am not sure this can be fixed and that's fine, but it does cause an issue when a saftey that's honestly expending very little per play is losing as much as a DL or OL guy. Just my thoughts.


Train nothing on relaxed and you get 36 at least



is this true?
 
NSab
offline
Link
 
Yes it's true.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSab
Yes it's true.


No it's not.

You get 18. Overnight energy regeneration has been a bit buggy and sometimes it goes through twice, which is why you got 36.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tracker
That is a opinion based on a limited perspective. If like in the case of a new expansion team I play on is very limited in depth. You start out the season with no real documentation of how the energy system works so you go out and play that first game on Hard intensity trying to win. Now you have a bunch of depleted player who can’t really level as quickly to become competitive with more established team who had the benefit of leveling without all of the new restrictions, because they are prema suck on relaxed training and in some cases, still not catching up.


Umm, I am the owner of an expansion team with great depth, but even if I were very shallow on depth, I would have made sure to explain that playing on Hard is a terrible thing to do. Look at it this way, with the way the system is now, you can get back to 90 for every game if you simply train on relaxed (all my guys are doing so). It means you won't play as well as you could have in the next game, but you don't lose any exp. I think your team owner needs to seriously look at his substitution rates.


Originally posted by Tracker
I like the idea of wear and tear as well but I think the implementation of it was a little unfair. Many (despite what some play off on the board) did not and still do not have a real clear understanding of how the energy system or the sub system really works. That being the case, how can anybody effectively make sound “tactical choices” when most people are completely confused by the ambiguity of the energy system?


That is the point though, no-one "knows" exactly how the system works, but anyone who took the time to read the announcement should have had a decent idea of what it might affect. I don't expect that I am any smarter than anyone else, and I figured out how to set the slider so my starters and subs would switch fairly evenly.

Originally posted by Tracker
Most are not bitching because they want and easy game. They would just like to have all of the information possible in order to play the game the best of their teams ability.

I for one have never played a game in my life from Chutes and Ladders to World of Warcraft and yes, even Madden that at least did not have a instruction manual that explained the nuts and bolts of a game.


The problem with what you are asking for is that people in general are not stupid. If Bort and DD post the numbers or equations behind the screen, people will VERY quickly have the "optimum builds", and the "optimum settings" and the only difference between teams will be the money spent to gain levels. I like the mystery.

Originally posted by Tracker
THAT is what many are posting about. In case you missed it, beta is a time for feedback from the players to the developers. That means both positive and negative feedback based on all possible gaming situations. Having that info allows the designers to find an equilibrium in the gaming experience for all players. I find it ironic that your brown nosing and bravado laden post draws about the same benefit gained from those… how did you put it? Ahh yes “hidden behind the anonymity of the internet.”


Feel free to include my post with the Brown nosers, or perhaps you would create a category for those of us who don't want it all handed to us, and don't mind figuring things out for ourselves. I know we are a rarity nowadays.

Originally posted by Tracker
Mr. Pot… I would like to introduce you to Mr. Kettle… oh hey look YOU ARE BOTH BLACK!


I would be more shiny silver with a nice copper bottom, but you have a nice day.

PinTBC

 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Umm, I am the owner of an expansion team with great depth, but even if I were very shallow on depth, I would have made sure to explain that playing on Hard is a terrible thing to do. Look at it this way, with the way the system is now, you can get back to 90 for every game if you simply train on relaxed (all my guys are doing so). It means you won't play as well as you could have in the next game, but you don't lose any exp. I think your team owner needs to seriously look at his substitution rates.
[/QUOTE




See this is where I am confused (sorry I am simply and going off what I read on the forums only) how can you "get back to 90 every game" if you can lose 40 energy per game.. and only gain back 30 between games?

As I understand it you can lose 40 energy per game? Is this right?

As I understand it you gain back 15 energy if your "relaxed" trainning"? Is this right?

As I understand it there is two days between games? That's 30 energy gained between games. Is this right?

IF that's all correct, and it might not be, then you will "lose" 10 energy every game. So after the first you would be at 90... second 80.. third 70.. ect ect.

I did play on "normal" intensity and I am on "relaxed" trainning. My guess is I am missunderstanding one of the top issues and how they work because if I am not then your incorrect that you can get back to 90 "every game" as you said. It could be more of me missunderstanding then the way it works, I can be wrong I don't mind I am new. I just want to undersand how it works.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Yes, yes, yes, only if you don't make the change.

If you're an owner or GM, play with the substitution settings. If you're not, play relaxed. That's all you can do.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.