User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
sjmay - PM me the details - I'd be happy to see what the fuss is about............

BTW - I'm now exploiting the game myself now (as there's no other choice been left by the game designers), as I'm playing my unpowerful KR guys on 'combo' - when, in fact, they have no actual abilities in that department. But, guess what?? They now cut better, make better moves and break tackles that they simply SHOULDN'T be doing if they were 'realistic' - but seeing as how two of my teams have just lost to BS ST plays, it's the old 'If you can't beat them, join them' adage.

Which, incidentally, brings me to Runningmn9's comments about 'testing'

NONE of us are testing, as we generally want to win. Some of us may be doing the odd experiment with players, but if we were really TESTING we'd playing FBs at QB, punters on the O line, etc - and then reporting back whether these hugely unrealistic settings were actually turning out to be better than the intended settings...

THAT would be testing.

As would throwing every point into vision, or jumping or whatever - just to confirm that STUPID builds don't gain an advantage (why did it take three whole seasons for the max speed exploit to come to light?? Why did none of the 'alpha' testers point it out??.

What has happened in 'alpha' is that a load of 'good ole boys' have had a play around and all tried to create an 'uber' team without actually 'testing' anything.

Some of them, if they found an exploit or a 'feature' that didn't work realistically, made sure they abused the crap out of it before it got found out. THAT ISN'T TESTING!! If this wasn't true, then we simply wouldn't have so many of the min/maxxers we did last year, as the exploit would have been fixed almost immediatley.

And now what's happeneing is that lots more people who probably like to brag that they're 'beta testers' THINK they're testing a game, when in fact they're not.

They're PAYING to PLAY a game that doesn't yet work as it should. And constant changes are taking place IN SPITE of them, not BECAUSE of them..........

I've beta tested games in the past - and I can assure you that ISN'T what I'm doing here. If I was, I'd have ALL min/max players with some stupid arsed attribute tables that bore NO resemblence to reality.



Sent,

And I actually agree with you here, I don't think anyone is "testing" the game, we are all playing it, but with that comes the risk that things will/might change if the guy who IS doing the testing, finds something.

The guy who IS doing the testing, is Bort, he has said a number of times, he has a test server that he runs when he makes changes to see how they play out, he runs it until he is happy with it.

Runningman, doesn't agree, which is his right, but then he blasts him about it and then complains about the money he spends,

Anyways, I don't think your power HB will be too succesful on the KR, I could be wrong, but on the ST, you are putting your high tackling guys on it, so good luck with that.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay

In all honesty, has anyone considered that this isn't the case? Granted, he should and probably does make money off of the game, but if this was such the cash cow that you guys are making it out to be, answer me one question.

HOW COME NOT ONE OF THE "BIG GAMING" COMPANIES, have done it? It can't be they don't have the programmers, it can't be they don't have the resources, it can't be they never thought of it, cmon, think realistically here, big game companies, PAY PEOPLE to create games and ideas, you don't think ONE of them out of the thousands, didn't think of this beforehand?


The overhead at a big gaming company would be a lot worse:

- Full QA staff to test before release
- Partial QA staff for ongoing testing after release
- Extra development time to tie in with whatever e-wallet or cross-platform login system someone is trying to push across the company
- Extra development time due to getting QA/QC approval prior to release...can't just say "Looks done" and let people start paying
- Legal/PR/Finance/HR/Facilities/IT overhead

 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Anyways, I don't think your power HB will be too succesful on the KR, I could be wrong, but on the ST, you are putting your high tackling guys on it, so good luck with that.


We just had 3 KR TDs scored against us in one game by a lvl 12 WR from 8 returns, with an average of of over 52 yards per KR and, on another team, a level 20 HB got 1 KR TD out of 5 attempts, with an average of over 38 per return.
On one team, we also had 'odd' KRs - they being a HB and a TE - both of whom managed WAY better averages than my 'specialists'

Anyway - these are the sorts of 'bugs' that WOULD have been obvious from day one had real testing been done, as they're the crazy setups that testers would have tried straight away.

Thing is, we're now on season 4 and these exploits are only just coming to light.

Just like the min/max thing only got addressed a few weeks ago.

I ask again - what was the alpha testing all about, apart from a jolly up by people who just happened to be on Cyberdunk teams together and who obviously liked the idea of being an alpha teter, yet have no clue what it involves.

Like it or not, finding the real 'bugs' in this game and rectifying them IS costing people real money.

And when the game is finally fixed, only 70% of that fee is going to be returned to them.

And what's perhaps more harsh is that ALL of us are paying money to unwittingly find the bugs that SHOULD have been highlighted by the people that are playing this game for free.

One could argue that we're now paying for their lack of testing ability...........in more ways than one.........
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by sjmay

Anyways, I don't think your power HB will be too succesful on the KR, I could be wrong, but on the ST, you are putting your high tackling guys on it, so good luck with that.


We just had 3 KR TDs scored against us in one game by a lvl 12 WR from 8 returns, with an average of of over 52 yards per KR and, on another team, a level 20 HB got 1 KR TD out of 5 attempts, with an average of over 38 per return.
On one team, we also had 'odd' KRs - they being a HB and a TE - both of whom managed WAY better averages than my 'specialists'

Anyway - these are the sorts of 'bugs' that WOULD have been obvious from day one had real testing been done, as they're the crazy setups that testers would have tried straight away.

Thing is, we're now on season 4 and these exploits are only just coming to light.

Just like the min/max thing only got addressed a few weeks ago.

I ask again - what was the alpha testing all about, apart from a jolly up by people who just happened to be on Cyberdunk teams together and who obviously liked the idea of being an alpha teter, yet have no clue what it involves.

Like it or not, finding the real 'bugs' in this game and rectifying them IS costing people real money.

And when the game is finally fixed, only 70% of that fee is going to be returned to them.

And what's perhaps more harsh is that ALL of us are paying money to unwittingly find the bugs that SHOULD have been highlighted by the people that are playing this game for free.

One could argue that we're now paying for their lack of testing ability...........in more ways than one.........


So stop paying money until you feel it's worth it. I agree there are many things that need to be worked on, but Bort is only one man.

I am not trying to jump your case, but you keep bringing up the money issue. Don't spend any more money on the game until you feel it deserves it.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
*disclaimer, didn't read all of this thread, last little bit *

Beta is also a testing phase in game development...and if Bort wants to try and get some money in the process that's fine for him, he's not demanding a fee to play this game, its our own choice. We all know its a work in progress. Keep submitting bugs and they will be looked at, the game has gotten substancially better since season 1 I think we can all agree (obviously) because bugs have been brought to light and have been fixed. Alpha testers were testing the basic elements of the game (as it should be) making sure football logic was observed most of the time. They didn't have access to advanced tactics, level 30 players, etc. Like it or not beta testing is for this type of thing.

Like anything, there's more that factors into a lot of the bugs than just "my CB/KR isn't performing, here's 10 other guys who aren't doing well either. Fix it, must be a problem." the strength of the kick off squad is also a huge issue, one which people neglect by putting CPU/low level players there. Expect them to get run over by a power back they can't tackle. If you have a competent kickoff squad and not CPU spot fillers playing, you're not going to see a lot of 10 missed tackle type plays for a TD. Not saying kickoffs are executed great right now (because they aren't) but just because a power back doesn't have massive agility or vision or 'return spec' doesn't mean they should automatically suck at returning if the defenders can't tackle him often.
 
ilvcountry5
offline
Link
 
The word beta isn't there because it's all a big test still. (Although it is...) Beta is there so people who get POed like in this thread can't claim they paid for a product that didn't deliver what it promised.

And Sigma, as far as I can tell people complaining about CB kick returners sucking are complaining that they spent tons of points in a special ability that seemingly does nothing at all.
 
Savage Smurf
offline
Link
 
Balanced Players FTW!
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ilvcountry5
The word beta isn't there because it's all a big test still. (Although it is...) Beta is there so people who get POed like in this thread can't claim they paid for a product that didn't deliver what it promised.

And Sigma, as far as I can tell people complaining about CB kick returners sucking are complaining that they spent tons of points in a special ability that seemingly does nothing at all.


No, its there because the game is still in beta. Its still a huge test, just that people have gotten attached to the game so much and feel that it should be perfect or they should be compensated for bugs cropping up.

As to KRS: Right, and Bort has addressed this. Its certainly an issue, but one that's more related to running style than anything. Once its fixed so that players will avoid the KOS more realistically (seeing the guys earlier than its too late, etc.) based on running style, it'll be fine.

Its a work in progress guys, help it become better by continuing to post bug reports. Getting angry like this really doesn't help anything, if anything it hurts -- Bort has worked his ass off to try and get everything working correctly, its just such a complicated game -- one tweak sets off a whole other batch of inconsistencies, it takes a lot of work to get the right balance. Patience is a virtue, these things take time.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 11:50:39
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
Originally posted by ilvcountry5

The word beta isn't there because it's all a big test still. (Although it is...) Beta is there so people who get POed like in this thread can't claim they paid for a product that didn't deliver what it promised.

And Sigma, as far as I can tell people complaining about CB kick returners sucking are complaining that they spent tons of points in a special ability that seemingly does nothing at all.


No, its there because the game is still in beta. Its still a huge test, just that people have gotten attached to the game so much and feel that it should be perfect or they should be compensated for bugs cropping up.

As to KRS: Right, and Bort has addressed this. Its certainly an issue, but one that's more related to running style than anything. Once its fixed so that players will avoid the KOS more realistically (seeing the guys earlier than its too late, etc.) based on running style, it'll be fine.

Its a work in progress guys, help it become better by continuing to post bug reports. Getting angry like this really doesn't help anything, if anything it hurts -- Bort has worked his ass off to try and get everything working correctly, its just such a complicated game -- one tweak sets off a whole other batch of inconsistencies, it takes a lot of work to get the right balance. Patience is a virtue, these things take time.


In that case then give a specific respec to KR/PR guys, let us get our points back and make a useful player in the meantime.

The return specialist is an absolute cluster fuck right now and it has nothing to do with building balanced players, I made 20 different sets of equipment, boosted vision, strength, carrying, made agility higher then speed, tried every conceivable combination.

Only to then spend about a week constantly trying to get help in the bugs forum, only to be told it is an elusive running problem. Well, I have not had and of my guys set to elusive for two seasons, because it has been known to be broken since day one.

So come to find out that the solution for the elusive bug on kick returns was to lower vision, yet vision is what everyone was saying you needed to increase to cut better. So now even though I had not been running on elusive that bug STILL effects me.

Meanwhile WRs, RBs, TEs, etc are all more effective return men and can break tackles left and right and seem to cut and make moves without any problems.

Now I have a "CB" who is useless as a returner and because he has so many points tied to that special, is a useless CB.

I have no problem with changes to the game, but as a paying customer I deserve a couple things in exchange:

1. To be informed when these changes are made, specifically, and with at least some general advice on how to adapt to them.

2. If the changes affect something as drastically as the KR/PR problems and render a player completly useless to the degree that these changes have, then I deserve a respec of AT LEAST the 15+ points I have put into the completly broken and useless skill of return specialist.

 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
Originally posted by Sigmaforce

Originally posted by ilvcountry5


The word beta isn't there because it's all a big test still. (Although it is...) Beta is there so people who get POed like in this thread can't claim they paid for a product that didn't deliver what it promised.

And Sigma, as far as I can tell people complaining about CB kick returners sucking are complaining that they spent tons of points in a special ability that seemingly does nothing at all.


No, its there because the game is still in beta. Its still a huge test, just that people have gotten attached to the game so much and feel that it should be perfect or they should be compensated for bugs cropping up.

As to KRS: Right, and Bort has addressed this. Its certainly an issue, but one that's more related to running style than anything. Once its fixed so that players will avoid the KOS more realistically (seeing the guys earlier than its too late, etc.) based on running style, it'll be fine.

Its a work in progress guys, help it become better by continuing to post bug reports. Getting angry like this really doesn't help anything, if anything it hurts -- Bort has worked his ass off to try and get everything working correctly, its just such a complicated game -- one tweak sets off a whole other batch of inconsistencies, it takes a lot of work to get the right balance. Patience is a virtue, these things take time.


In that case then give a specific respec to KR/PR guys, let us get our points back and make a useful player in the meantime.

The return specialist is an absolute cluster fuck right now and it has nothing to do with building balanced players, I made 20 different sets of equipment, boosted vision, strength, carrying, made agility higher then speed, tried every conceivable combination.

Only to then spend about a week constantly trying to get help in the bugs forum, only to be told it is an elusive running problem. Well, I have not had and of my guys set to elusive for two seasons, because it has been known to be broken since day one.

So come to find out that the solution for the elusive bug on kick returns was to lower vision, yet vision is what everyone was saying you needed to increase to cut better. So now even though I had not been running on elusive that bug STILL effects me.

Meanwhile WRs, RBs, TEs, etc are all more effective return men and can break tackles left and right and seem to cut and make moves without any problems.

Now I have a "CB" who is useless as a returner and because he has so many points tied to that special, is a useless CB.

I have no problem with changes to the game, but as a paying customer I deserve a couple things in exchange:

1. To be informed when these changes are made, specifically, and with at least some general advice on how to adapt to them.

2. If the changes affect something as drastically as the KR/PR problems and render a player completly useless to the degree that these changes have, then I deserve a respec of AT LEAST the 15+ points I have put into the completly broken and useless skill of return specialist.



+1
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

Originally posted by sjmay


Anyways, I don't think your power HB will be too succesful on the KR, I could be wrong, but on the ST, you are putting your high tackling guys on it, so good luck with that.


We just had 3 KR TDs scored against us in one game by a lvl 12 WR from 8 returns, with an average of of over 52 yards per KR and, on another team, a level 20 HB got 1 KR TD out of 5 attempts, with an average of over 38 per return.
On one team, we also had 'odd' KRs - they being a HB and a TE - both of whom managed WAY better averages than my 'specialists'

Anyway - these are the sorts of 'bugs' that WOULD have been obvious from day one had real testing been done, as they're the crazy setups that testers would have tried straight away.

Thing is, we're now on season 4 and these exploits are only just coming to light.

Just like the min/max thing only got addressed a few weeks ago.

I ask again - what was the alpha testing all about, apart from a jolly up by people who just happened to be on Cyberdunk teams together and who obviously liked the idea of being an alpha teter, yet have no clue what it involves.

Like it or not, finding the real 'bugs' in this game and rectifying them IS costing people real money.

And when the game is finally fixed, only 70% of that fee is going to be returned to them.

And what's perhaps more harsh is that ALL of us are paying money to unwittingly find the bugs that SHOULD have been highlighted by the people that are playing this game for free.

One could argue that we're now paying for their lack of testing ability...........in more ways than one.........


So stop paying money until you feel it's worth it. I agree there are many things that need to be worked on, but Bort is only one man.

I am not trying to jump your case, but you keep bringing up the money issue. Don't spend any more money on the game until you feel it deserves it.


+100, as in should be required reading.

Anyone who feels the game is not playable as it is now, but feel it might become so in the future, should retire their players asap, keeping their account open so as to keep the FP refunds, and then check back and when you decide it's worth playing use the 70% you got back to make new players and play when you feel it's become worth it.

What minmaxers don't want to admit is that they don't want to do that NOT because of the lost 30% of FP's, but because they know that by playing in Beta they get advantages, such as being as close as they are (depending on their exact start date) to the top of the heap longer.

But if you don't like that tradeoff, then don't make it and wait for the game to be finished. Since you'll have 70% of your FP's still in your account you won't have to pay for a while if you do that.
 
BerkeyTerps
offline
Link
 
GET ME A WHOPPER
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BerkeyTerps
GET ME A WHOPPER


that made me laugh a lot, great line
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
You're never at the top of the heap. Players have artitifically abbreviated careers with an arbitrary 10 season career.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
You're never at the top of the heap. Players have artitifically abbreviated careers with an arbitrary 10 season career.


Right, so that everyone gets a chance at the top of the heap. That's why aging is needed. I sure shouldn't be around the top forever, even as a reward for playing in Beta.

But I joined around the end of Season 1. Most of my players were made in Season 2. That means that until my players, the best of whom started playing in Season 2, start aging in Season 12, there's only one season worth of players better than them.

If I retired them and used the FP's to create players when the game was truly "finished," then my players would eventually be at the top of the heap after 9 seasons, and where mine are relatively speaking after 8.

So I'm getting more seasons just one season behind than I would if I waited for the game to be further done. In return, I'm playing a buggier game (and one that sucked in Season 3 as all-defense and no AI; I find this season far more palatable).

But, those who think the tradeoff isn't worth making have the option to wait. If it were up to me, I'd have something like an 80% FP refund rather than 70% for players retired while still in Beta. But if playing in Beta bothered me more than having only newbie players for quite a while would, I'd do just what I suggested and temporarily retire.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.