User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
That's the problem - it's difficult (well, impossible) to prove that it was not a team GM (the actual person, not the account) that edited the tactics.

I guess you have to fall back on what a GM would gain from doing this and lying - since they're asking for a re-sim and from what I've gathered the consensus is that they would probably win, I don't know what the GM or the team would have gained from this whole ordeal. (Other than lulz, which unfortunately is always a factor that has to be considered on the Internet, no matter how rational-seeming the person.)


Exactly, at some point you have to ask what the logic is here. None of us, myself included, knew that Bort didn't have the IP info. Imagine being the "Traitor" on the team knowing that in a few minutes Bort is going to out you? Keeping in mind we all have pre-existing reputations outside of GLB to worry about. Hardly worth the risk.

There was no motive here, and no reason to suspect anyone. Things just went wrong, and there are people will the power to make them right, but that doesn't seem likely.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Amyrlin

That's the problem - it's difficult (well, impossible) to prove that it was not a team GM (the actual person, not the account) that edited the tactics.

I guess you have to fall back on what a GM would gain from doing this and lying - since they're asking for a re-sim and from what I've gathered the consensus is that they would probably win, I don't know what the GM or the team would have gained from this whole ordeal. (Other than lulz, which unfortunately is always a factor that has to be considered on the Internet, no matter how rational-seeming the person.)


One of them's not asking for a re-sim....BJJ, was it?


A bold accusation really, but do you have any reason he'd do this?
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
I didn't intend to accuse him, I was just correcting him on saying "they're" as a cumulative to represent the entirety of the Trout GMs.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I didn't intend to accuse him, I was just correcting him on saying "they're" as a cumulative to represent the entirety of the Trout GMs.


BJJ is the quiet one typically. If I had my guess, I'd say he's steped out so as to not look like an ass (a part, by the way, I'm happy to play when my team gets bent over like this).
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Amyrlin

That's the problem - it's difficult (well, impossible) to prove that it was not a team GM (the actual person, not the account) that edited the tactics.

I guess you have to fall back on what a GM would gain from doing this and lying - since they're asking for a re-sim and from what I've gathered the consensus is that they would probably win, I don't know what the GM or the team would have gained from this whole ordeal. (Other than lulz, which unfortunately is always a factor that has to be considered on the Internet, no matter how rational-seeming the person.)


One of them's not asking for a re-sim....BJJ, was it?


Everyone on our team, myself included, feels screwed by what happened. Of course we'd like a re-sim, and a chance to play this game fairly. My personal viewpoint though is that while that would be nice, it's not in any way mandatory. First and foremost the only way a re-sim should happen is if TBSoDF wants one, and it's clear they don't, so as far as I'm concerned that's that. It's not their fault this happened, and it's not their responsibility to fix it.

If they volunteered to re-sim, I would graciously accept the offer and be the first to credit them as being a remarkably honorable and stand-up team. If they choose not to, though, that does not speak ill of them. The vast majority of teams out there wouldn't. Their refusal of a re-sim does not diminish my opinion of them in any way. And the few posts here that have insinuated that Bort should force them to re-sim against their will are, in my opinion, absurd.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Nope, even though there's a tainted game outcome very obviously hanging in the balance, the right thing to do is to change the game to prevent it, but not acknowledge a team was wronged?


See, I think that is your basic problem. There really is VERY little that Bort could do to stop what appears to have happened here. It appears that someone (a physical someone) logged in and changed your energy settings in an attempt to screw your team.

The ONLY thing Bort could really do would be to add logging so if this happens in the future, you know which account was the culprit. I used to GM an Internet game, and you would be astounded how many "My brother logged in on my account and did this" excuses you get.

Do you agree with the statement "The game can't really stop you from doing something stupid, nor should it"?

If you agree with that statement, then you also have to realize that the game can't stop someone from logging in and putting in some really screwball energy settings.

PinTBC
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by oldskool

I didn't intend to accuse him, I was just correcting him on saying "they're" as a cumulative to represent the entirety of the Trout GMs.


BJJ is the quiet one typically. If I had my guess, I'd say he's steped out so as to not look like an ass (a part, by the way, I'm happy to play when my team gets bent over like this).


Hmm... this post 9 seconds before mine might not have been the most fortuitous timing you've ever had, lol.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by oldskool


I didn't intend to accuse him, I was just correcting him on saying "they're" as a cumulative to represent the entirety of the Trout GMs.


BJJ is the quiet one typically. If I had my guess, I'd say he's steped out so as to not look like an ass (a part, by the way, I'm happy to play when my team gets bent over like this).


Hmm... this post 9 seconds before mine might not have been the most fortuitous timing you've ever had, lol.


And my GM screws me again (KIDDING!).
 
Commander
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Nope, even though there's a tainted game outcome very obviously hanging in the balance, the right thing to do is to change the game to prevent it, but not acknowledge a team was wronged?


See, I think that is your basic problem. There really is VERY little that Bort could do to stop what appears to have happened here. It appears that someone (a physical someone) logged in and changed your energy settings in an attempt to screw your team.

The ONLY thing Bort could really do would be to add logging so if this happens in the future, you know which account was the culprit. I used to GM an Internet game, and you would be astounded how many "My brother logged in on my account and did this" excuses you get.

Do you agree with the statement "The game can't really stop you from doing something stupid, nor should it"?

If you agree with that statement, then you also have to realize that the game can't stop someone from logging in and putting in some really screwball energy settings.

PinTBC


our GMs are grown fucking men who have no reason whatsoever to do this.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Nope, even though there's a tainted game outcome very obviously hanging in the balance, the right thing to do is to change the game to prevent it, but not acknowledge a team was wronged?


See, I think that is your basic problem. There really is VERY little that Bort could do to stop what appears to have happened here. It appears that someone (a physical someone) logged in and changed your energy settings in an attempt to screw your team.

The ONLY thing Bort could really do would be to add logging so if this happens in the future, you know which account was the culprit. I used to GM an Internet game, and you would be astounded how many "My brother logged in on my account and did this" excuses you get.

Do you agree with the statement "The game can't really stop you from doing something stupid, nor should it"?

If you agree with that statement, then you also have to realize that the game can't stop someone from logging in and putting in some really screwball energy settings.

PinTBC


It gets worse, even IPs can be faked and switched, so IP logging really doesn't fix anything. At some point though, you're going to have to trust people, and given all the facts and reasonable assumptions in this situation (things like "I didn't sink my own team" etc) it's not hard to feel compelled to trust here.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
i guess i'll go ahead and waste some space in this thread....

i have no real stake here - though i am on a team in the 'other' conference from these guys...

and - in the AAA championship - the trout beat the crap out of us....

so i suppose my personal - selfish impulse would be "yay the brown trout are out".

in all reality i know nothing about either team.

but (i know this is going to sound stupid)

in life - you are rarely presented with very few opportunities to publicly choose the 'right' path.

i believe those are inflection points for your life - and if you let them pass you by...by making the wrong choice - it will stick with you for awhile...even in an online mmo.

tx - i think you ought to think about that....you can't let the bozo's from the trout - who are currently acting out of emotion instead of logic influence you here.

the evidence seems pretty clear. you've been presented with an opportunity to do the right thing in a very public atmosphere.

and the truth is - the owner of a team who would exhibit such a fair and honest position as to re-do an obviously flawed simulation....is an owner that i would want my players to play for.

 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
It's a Beta game - so I'm opposed to resimming. That being said though - It'd be very nice if:

A) The cause of this problem is learned.

or

B) If the cause cannot be learned, then steps are taken to implement a log which would allow future issues to better be resolved.

I know - nothing new really.. just my input on what is important for the long term health of the game. Resimming isn't in the long term health.. UNLESS, the cause of the problem was illegal or unethical actions on the part of someone who would benefit within the game from the results of a tainted game. (basically, if you opponent hacked the system.. then either resim, or a disqualification for them. If someone outside of their team hacks the system, resim.)
 
pudley4
offline
Link
 
This is dumb. Bort's already said his piece, made some changes that will hopefully help in the future, and offered a resim. BSoDF will take a scrimmage resim only, and they're not budging. Everybody with a brain knows that our settings were screwed with and that this game wasn't a true representation of a "real" sim between our two teams. Let's just take the resim, win by 24, and move on, knowing that we absolutely would do a resim if the roles were reversed. Asheme should probably just lock the thread if he's still around.
 
Xiidaen
offline
Link
 
If the facts are clear the game was flawed, I would suggest re-simming the game. (And the last thing I want to do is face the #$%#$^@ Trout again later)

I agree with TxSteve -- it's rare you get a chance to do the right thing like this. I guess you can't force a team to do it, but I'd like to think I'd accept a rematch in the same situation.



 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
See, I think that is your basic problem. There really is VERY little that Bort could do to stop what appears to have happened here. It appears that someone (a physical someone) logged in and changed your energy settings in an attempt to screw your team.

The ONLY thing Bort could really do would be to add logging so if this happens in the future, you know which account was the culprit. I used to GM an Internet game, and you would be astounded how many "My brother logged in on my account and did this" excuses you get.

Do you agree with the statement "The game can't really stop you from doing something stupid, nor should it"?

If you agree with that statement, then you also have to realize that the game can't stop someone from logging in and putting in some really screwball energy settings.

PinTBC


Indeed. Now that Bort is tracking such things, any malicious tampering with tactics - knock on wood that this is the last one! - will be detected. I'd imagine that if malicious tampering is proven, a recorded re-sim will be automatically granted.

Of course, this comes with the unfortunate negative side effect of at least 5 threads a day to the effect of "we lost this game it must have been a hacker, I DEMAND that Bort IMMEDIATELY stop whatever he's doing and confirm and give us a re-sim!" Which will be bad because a) it's stupid and inane, and b) any hacking - another knock on wood here - is likely to slip by unless the victim had the good fortune to be able to directly observe the effects like Vanilla Thunder and crew have, because the actual victim vs. griefer ratio will be so low as to be virtually zero, so it will become a waste of time to sort through every accusation of hacking.

I also hope that Bort has considered the possibility of a security hole as well and has taken measures to track and prevent such a thing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.