User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > The Best Damn Mafia Forum > Past Games > The Quick and The Dead Mafia
Page:
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Here's another thing about this whole "questioning" process that I don't understand.

Sugar beat TheS in the dual, and according to Sugar he won the RPS battle pretty easily. Now, since we are not supposed to take the plot of the movie and directly apply it to the game, I am discounting TheS's quip about not being able to shoot someone.

He didn't raise his gun because he was dominated in the RPS battle. This has nothing to do with him being a good guy or a bad guy.

 
benmint0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zook28
What reason did I have TO unvote? It's D1 and we have no information to work off of, how am I supposed to believe a claim on D1? Hell, it was my FIRST POST OF THE GAME, a fact that is conveniently forgotten about anytime this is brought up.

I can't think of another game where someone's first post/vote on D1 has garnered this much attention.



Your explanation is what's getting all the attention. Because it doesn't add up. Like I've said before, you were caught in a lie and I'm keeping my vote on you because you seem like the scumiest of them all
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by schrauben
Not having a reason to unvote is completely different that you didn't have time too. Think about what you're saying. I would have understood that more than not doing it because you're not online much at that time. It's a stretch.


Go ahead and show me a thread where someone has a clear cut reason for a D1 joke vote.
 
schrauben
offline
Link
 
As I was reading through catching up that day, I was ready to unvote TheS, but never had a chance, by the time I was caught up he was nominated. That's the feeling I was getting from you in defense of not unvoting when you had the chance that you say you didn't have.
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by benmint0n
Your explanation is what's getting all the attention. Because it doesn't add up. Like I've said before, you were caught in a lie and I'm keeping my vote on you because you seem like the scumiest of them all


I suppose standard protocol would be that I could use this post to spin and deflect to you; something I don't feel the need to do as I know that I've done nothing wrong. The only reason you're not being questioned is the fact that I went out of my way to answer questions and participate while you ride along.
 
benmint0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zook28
I suppose standard protocol would be that I could use this post to spin and deflect to you; something I don't feel the need to do as I know that I've done nothing wrong. The only reason you're not being questioned is the fact that I went out of my way to answer questions and participate while you ride along.


So it's not the fact that your answer doesn't match up with how things actually happened on Day1? Haha okay zook, nice try.
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by schrauben
As I was reading through catching up that day, I was ready to unvote TheS, but never had a chance, by the time I was caught up he was nominated. That's the feeling I was getting from you in defense of not unvoting when you had the chance that you say you didn't have.


Schraub, you know I love semantics but I really don't see a difference in what you're saying and to what I said. The thing that is being argued is that I had a vote on a person who was lynched and that I did not pull it off in time.

Mind you we have no idea that TheS is a good or a bad guy, the only thing we DO know is that he never got a shot off. Sugar mentioned that was due to the fact he lost the RPS battle so poorly.
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by benmint0n
So it's not the fact that your answer doesn't match up with how things actually happened on Day1? Haha okay zook, nice try.




Yes Detective Ben, you're sooooo good at this game.
 
schrauben
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zook28
I suppose standard protocol would be that I could use this post to spin and deflect to you; something I don't feel the need to do as I know that I've done nothing wrong. The only reason you're not being questioned is the fact that I went out of my way to answer questions and participate while you ride along.


This I disagree with, here's my take, whether you are good, bad or otherwise. You didn't unvote TheS cause it wasn't you being nominated and you really didn't care who it was, but that sounds bad to say, so when I posted my reason for not unvoiting, you +1'd it. Then when you get asked the question and Ben suggests that was your reason you didn't want him speaking for you and you restated poorly that you weren't on line when in fact you were. I've seen enough for my vote. Sorry Zook, not buying it.

Vote Zook
 
schrauben
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zook28
Schraub, you know I love semantics but I really don't see a difference in what you're saying and to what I said. The thing that is being argued is that I had a vote on a person who was lynched and that I did not pull it off in time.

Mind you we have no idea that TheS is a good or a bad guy, the only thing we DO know is that he never got a shot off. Sugar mentioned that was due to the fact he lost the RPS battle so poorly.


I know you love semantics, but the story doesn't add up. You specifically stated that you weren't online and couldn't unvote, that was incorrect. You were online and could have unvoted whether you did or didn't isn't the point. It's your explanation for why you didn't that is damming.
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Here schraub, you'll love this then.

I'm doing this for two reasons. One, to prove my innocence and for two, to use my night time investigation on Ben and reveal who he is during the day phase.

vote Zook
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Oh, and FYI Schraub, you're my vote for tomorrow as you just pushed an officer of the law a little too far.
 
benmint0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by schrauben
I know you love semantics, but the story doesn't add up. You specifically stated that you weren't online and couldn't unvote, that was incorrect. You were online and could have unvoted whether you did or didn't isn't the point. It's your explanation for why you didn't that is damming.


This has been my point since page 16


Originally posted by benmint0n
Also, Zook, your explanation that you didn't have a chance to unvote TheS before the hammer is a blatant lie because you posted after he was put to L-1 but before the hammer.

You are scum.

 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by benmint0n
Originally posted by schrauben

I know you love semantics, but the story doesn't add up. You specifically stated that you weren't online and couldn't unvote, that was incorrect. You were online and could have unvoted whether you did or didn't isn't the point. It's your explanation for why you didn't that is damming.


This has been my point since page 16


Originally posted by benmint0n

Also, Zook, your explanation that you didn't have a chance to unvote TheS before the hammer is a blatant lie because you posted after he was put to L-1 but before the hammer.

You are scum.



I'll say the thing that neither of you will say, then. Two people had to go up...and in the grand scheme of things, other players are more active than TheS so I didn't mind it.
 
Sugar Kapaa
\m/
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by zook28
Oh, and FYI Schraub, you're my vote for tomorrow as you just pushed an officer of the law a little too far.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.