User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Thoughts on Borts new post about XP changes in the announcements forum.
Page:
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by FairForever


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by thunderdoozer




People WILL be getting refunds for the Flex they bought that they will never use because they will just get punished for it, right?


Because boosting couldn't POSSIBLY be part of the formula I've been talking about (along with contract length, etc)...


Will the formula be released?

As well, thanks for taking the time to clarify it. I do think you're coming off a bit rough though, maybe it's time to take a break for a bit. Some of us are clearly not enthused by the latest development, but we'll all survive.

Thanks for the work you do, right?


No, the formula will not be released. I don't want people finding ways to exploit it.

I agree that I'm probably coming off as gruff...it's 1:30am and I've been dealing with a lot of players doing crappy things lately. I need to go to bed


Fair enough. My team is just wondering how long is long enough to avoid the penalty though. We've stuck together through thick and thin (actually, haven't hit many roadbumps yet). We have a couple of new high-level guys, and hopefully they'll be willing to take the small penalty. But our QB/OT who are high leveled have been with us since the start, I'm just hoping that they won't take a significant hit. I personally don't think they deserve it. But it's your call.

In all honesty, though, I've never seen you so frustrated (except maybe when you're dealing with cheaters ). Get some rest Bort Thanks once again.

I think the late night release wasn't a good idea since we're all tired too


I think we both aren't looking for the full forumula as in exact numbers but exact how each thing would influence such as contract length etc. Everything is still kind of up in the air and once it smooths out I think most of the whiners will stop.
 
CoachZ
offline
Link
 
I applaud this change. We were discussing this very subject in our forums just the other day. There is absolutely NO liquidity in the FA market for the players that SHOULD be available for the team level equivalent of that team.

First season teams who were here from day one, should have a pool of players level 16-24 range, second season teams should have a pool about 8 below that, and the newbie teams should be starting the exact same way the first season teams did...lower level first year players just beginning or coming out of the D leagues.

But that liquidity does not exist. Why? Because ALL teams have the ability to recruit players at any level. Naturally, the more expansion there is in this game, the larger the demand for the highest possible FA is naturally going to occur.

Two things arise out of this. First, teams in the first or second season can't really improve that much, possibly move up from the bottom or middle tier of their league and challenge competitively, because there just aren't enough FA's FOR THEIR LEVEL available...they're spread to thin within ALL the teams . Secondly, newbie and second season teams suffer tremendous ass kickings because one or two teams in their league are loaded with player levels that really have no reason to be competing at such a lower level. for whatever reason...friends, bankrupting payrolls, collusion, etc.

The results of this, is a game that IS NOT FUN for a large majority in here. Now I'm one of the lucky ones. A#1 league is VERY even, very competitive, and so much fun, non of us owners in their can hardly wait for the next game...but this doesn't exist for most.

By penalizing the huge disparity in levels, Bort is trying to make ALL the leagues play like ours. In my book, that's not a good thing...that's a GREAT thing. If a player is penalized for playing in a league below his level, he won't take those nutsy contracts to do so in the future. This will add liquidity back to the FA market, teams will become more balanced, be able to improve within their league...and the game becomes an even better game.

Now, for those that are gonna bitch that this hits them hard...they've been spending hours to recruit their Level 18 guys for the new Africa League, remember this. One of the reasons we play a beta game, is to find out what's WRONG with the game at this stage, and make changes in it's design and rules. Hundreds of first season teams sucking the FA market dry with third season players is wrong. All of us that began with a team the first season didn't have this advantage, and now...neither will the new teams.

The main goal of game testing, for all of you that have never done this before, is to find BALANCE in the game...so it's FUN for everybody. During this testing period, rules and code changes. This is a good rule and code change.

CZ
 
Maksim
offline
Link
 
EXTEND OFF SEASON PLEASE!

So I can at least move my players before it is introduced!
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
I still hope and pray the game is wiped clean once it goes live.....We all need to start from scratch once they get the foundation layed.
You are dreaming! Look at how whipped up the Alpha testers get when they learn they won't gain quite as much XP beating up lower level players! They would go ballistic if they thought the advantage they gained from being first to play the game was going to disappear. LOL.

 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vzone
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by FairForever


I thought about it. Sure.

The main problem is that it was implemented so late in the off-season, teams don't have time to adjust. I just wish it was said earlier in the offseason.


Like most other things I've done that affect performance and whatnot, the plan would be to start off with a really small max modifier and work up to a higher one as needed.


Okay Bort. I'm going to back off and take you at your word that the higher level players that I have spent a lot of time recruiting and my players that I spent a lot of money boosting, are not going to be penalized just because the new team that gave me no choice of level and that was given to me by you happened to be in a lower league.



I think that's where the real problem lies. Allowing 4/8 promotion/relegation would allow teams to move up more quickly, and there wouldn't be as much of a problem, in my opinion.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
Originally posted by MrMoose

Note, I'm just trying to understand a bit of the other side here too, the people upset with this.

RPGs give rewards for defeating more challenging content, I agree. Tom Brady learns more playing against the, say, Giants than he would playing against a college team. I'm sure that NCAA teams learn more playing stronger ones than weaker ones. However, all of these systems have something in common -- the person has the choice as to where they're going to play.

That high level warrior in World of Warcraft can choose to take on monsters 5 levels above him or 10 levels below him. Tom Brady could decide if he really wants to mess around and play a college team. NCAA teams can choose parts of their schedule and decide if they want to learn more against stronger teams or pad their record against weaker ones.

Of course, as I've said before, I do support this to a degree, as I feel Bort is accomplishing just that with the formula. People choosing to go to a weak league and play weak teams as a high level will be penalized. Those that joined a team awhile ago when the league was stronger but saw it get weak won't be penalized for that choice.

I'm sure this has been tested many times and the formula tweaked so that it only hits Joe Chucklefuck that brings level 16 characters from a gutted team into a brand new league.

No. Tom Brady cannot ever again play a college team. His college eligibility is gone. Why? Because the NCAA recognizes what Bort's rule does: that there comes a point (four years in college) when it just isn't right for a man to be playing with boys. So, no, it is not about choice.



Incorrect, view one of my posts about college's actual rules. You are saying that a player who has only played NCAA football for 2 years can go play 10 years in the NFL then go back for his final 2 college years?
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Unconquered
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Bort
No, the formula will not be released. I don't want people finding ways to exploit it.

I agree that I'm probably coming off as gruff...it's 1:30am and I've been dealing with a lot of players doing crappy things lately. I need to go to bed


Fair enough. My team is just wondering how long is long enough to avoid the penalty though. We've stuck together through thick and thin (actually, haven't hit many roadbumps yet). We have a couple of new high-level guys, and hopefully they'll be willing to take the small penalty. But our QB/OT who are high leveled have been with us since the start, I'm just hoping that they won't take a significant hit. I personally don't think they deserve it. But it's your call.

In all honesty, though, I've never seen you so frustrated (except maybe when you're dealing with cheaters ). Get some rest Bort Thanks once again.

I think the late night release wasn't a good idea since we're all tired too


I think we both aren't looking for the full forumula as in exact numbers but exact how each thing would influence such as contract length etc. Everything is still kind of up in the air and once it smooths out I think most of the whiners will stop.


Yeah, an explanation of what factors would affect the formula would be great. I do understand the reluctance to release the full formula.
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Bigmo6967

Originally posted by Dudeamis


Originally posted by Bigmo6967



Originally posted by Dudeamis




Originally posted by seven7





Originally posted by Dudeamis






Originally posted by djfivenine







This is not the right area to target Bort!
I know this game has a big problem with the higher level team always winning. But averaging out the levels of the teams is NOT the answer.
It is the ability to give us more options for TACTICS!
3-4 defense, cover 2 defense, spread offense, power running offense, option offense.
Blitz options, special substitutions, better predictions for the other team's strategy.

If those things are implemented, teams will start winning because their owner and coordinators are smarter and they out witted the other team.

I, for one, will not feel good beating a higher level team if I knew this rule was the reason.


seriously this new rule is a waste of your time. Try making the game better instead of nerfing good recruiters.

so you think a lv 8 going up against a lv 19 is fair? just because you recruited better? i don't own a team yet , all i have is players and i want to see an even playing field for us all , no sense in higher players beating up on the low league guys at all =( lets keep this game balanced and maybe it'll be more fun for us all.


Yes its fair because that lvl 19 could've been recruited just as easly by the other team. Is it fair that the Pats have Randy Moss? Is it fair that the Chargers get LT? This is basically the same as the NFL making the rule that the best players in the league have to sit out of the game more, to make it far to the other teams.


Fake money penalties mean nothing here. Neither does chemistry hits to most players. I would doubt Randy Moss would play on an arena team now would he? Thats kinda the equivalent of some playing there high level guys in low level league intentionally just to stroke their own egos.


Maybe to help a friend out... maybe because he's tired of welfare rules in the NFL. lots of reasons. Maybe he got paid a bunch of money to help turn the arena leagues into a big money marketplace.


Yep where as before there was all pros and no cons to doing just that now there is a negeative. Weigh it out and decide. If playing on the same team as your buddy is all that important then have your GM give him a backup role on the team you should be playing for. If he owns the lower team then fine. Play for him and the longer you stay there the less effect it should have on you. plus you will have your friend there with you offewring his support during your tramatic loss of XP.


With all these "Randy Moss doesn't learn anything against high schooler" arguments, would you also argue that eventually all the high schoolers will get to Randy Moss' level if he continued to play with them? No, you wouldn't.


Of course not. They would grow LIKE HIGH SCHOOLERS. Normally, but probably with a lot less morale from getting trampled on daily.
 
Unconquered
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maksim
Formula wont be released. So when my player is penalised because ive put time and $$$ into it ill have no idea of how to make it better?

This is an awful idea. I have seen more people against it than for it!


Most of the people who are against it don't understand it. I was initially against it until it was clarified. You really have no clue what this is intended for.
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FBGProfessor
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet

I still hope and pray the game is wiped clean once it goes live.....We all need to start from scratch once they get the foundation layed.
You are dreaming! Look at how whipped up the Alpha testers get when they learn they won't gain quite as much XP beating up lower level players! They would go ballistic if they thought the advantage they gained from being first to play the game was going to disappear. LOL.



it makes perfect sense though. i mean to many changes for me to really feel good about what im doing with my players and my team.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 02:37:58
 
Crunk
offline
Link
 
Everyone is just getting out of hand quite frankly. You have no Idea at the moment how this new update in the XP will work and everyone is already throwing a fit about it. I dont think he is trying to..cater to the medium player instead of the hardcore one. But instead catering to fairness. New guy coming in, You have no Idea whether or not he will turn out to be one of those.."Hardcore" players...But at the same time, I for one dont think its very fair if he is coming into a BBB league as a WR or a CB playing at, and this is assuming he boosts right away level 4.. and lined up across from him is a player thats a level 15..I mean..come on.. While I do understand there are some..exemptions to the rule because that 15 may have been there when he was a level 4..I am just saying for your regular run of the mill level 15 and above in a BBB league, they went there to own on lower levels.

Though a part of me also wonders if the majority of those complaining..are doing so because they truly believe this will be bad for GLB? or just simply bad for themselves.. Are the ones complaining the most only doing so because they will be the hardest hit due to the fact they are doing what Bort wants to stop..trying to own on low levels?..Who knows..they will say no..some may even admit it..but your never going to get a straight answer..

This however is good because it does encourage people to put some sort of parity in the leagues where now a days it you see some BBB teams looking as if a Pro Team got lost and fell there as a mistake...only to see them not win it all?..throwing games much?..I think so..

But Parity is needed as I mentioned...Its fun to win dont get me wrong..but its also more fun to know you won against worthy competition.
 
Jericoholic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jvacc26

I'm not sure about that, from the sounds of it some people on here struggle to do basic math, or lack any reading comprehension skills what so ever...


Well, not everybody would be able too, but I know there are plenty of clever people here who could abuse golden info like that.

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
I spend a lot of money on this site and I like the rule. I think many people are overreacting. I don't think Bort is meaning to punish level 18 players in a league where the median is level 14 or 15, he's looking to punish level 18 players in a league where the median is level 10.


Wow, somebody gets it! And perhaps those who recently moved there from a higher median region, with a bunch of their buddies?
 
SAVAGE OPS
offline
Link
 
Maybe some of you boys should have stayed where you were. Maybe the Grass isn't Greener in Africa, lol. I love it!
 
jvacc26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jericoholic
Originally posted by jvacc26


I'm not sure about that, from the sounds of it some people on here struggle to do basic math, or lack any reading comprehension skills what so ever...


Well, not everybody would be able too, but I know there are plenty of clever people here who could abuse golden info like that.



yeah I know, I was just being a dick...it's what I do best...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.