User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Discotech
offline
Link
 
WTG on screwing over teams who wish to stick together, they have no control over which league their team is in so why do you have to punish people for wanting to play with their friends or owners who wish to have their own players all on the same team ?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Discotech
WTG on screwing over teams who wish to stick together, they have no control over which league their team is in so why do you have to punish people for wanting to play with their friends or owners who wish to have their own players all on the same team ?


Not true, pleased to be reading AND understanding Bort's OP.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheCondor
The only thing I care about with this change, is whether or not it will affect my level 20 player's when I boost them to level 23 at the start of season 3 for the USA AAA#1 League. If I am not punished for boosting my player's - and the cheaters get theirs, then I'm OK with whatever Bort decides.

EDIT: What I do notice is how there seems to be a lot of ideas of change floating around, I'm not even sure what the main change will be or do, besides put a level cap (or other idea) into defense against high level player's trying to beat up on lower level player's in the lower level leagues.

My suggestion: Don't over-think it, but do take action. So far, Bort, you've done a great job of thwarting cheaters, so I trust you'll do a good job with this part too.


Basically, you won't feel anything from this unless you were well over the recommended level, which won't happen in a USA AAA league with almost any level that currently exists.

And even then, since he will begin everyone with high sportsmanship ratings, the penalty would be very minor.

Now, if next season you decided to take that Level 23 (then level 26 or whatever, 29 with boosts) player to a lower league to dominate it, then you'd feel it-- much more if there were 3 or more other high level players on the team than otherwise.

But as long as you're playing near the highest level (as you are) with your near the highest level player, you'll be fine.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Discotech
WTG on screwing over teams who wish to stick together, they have no control over which league their team is in so why do you have to punish people for wanting to play with their friends or owners who wish to have their own players all on the same team ?



Way to respond without reading the policy...if you're team has stayed together the "Sportsmanship factor" that Bort discussed will keep you from facing a penalty. It is designed to prevent significant numbers of ringers from dropping below a reasonable level.
 
Weykool
offline
Link
 
I dont understand why we need to implement another complicated rule.

What is so hard about Bort swapping the gutted team and the guttee team once they make all the moves?

If a bunch of players from an AAA or AA team all cut and run to a BBB or expansion team just do a manual swap.

The cheaters would end up in the same league with a lower chemistry and the gutted team might stand a chance to recover.
 
HustonJ
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Weykool
What is so hard about Bort swapping the gutted team and the guttee team once they make all the moves?


Would you rather Bort spend time working on Advanced Tactics for the Defense and Offense, or doing the above swaps, including spending the time researching the transaction logs to decide if penalties should be applied or not?

And than applying any and all penalties he thinks are deserved.

The issue is Bort's time.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I'm ok with an idea like this insofar as the implementation of it has a realistic feel. But if it's going to happen I definitely want to know about it before day 1. And yes I realize day 1 is tomorrow. I have some players I am considering boosting early in the season, and I would hate to find out later that I helped out my opponents' XP in doing so.

I also think Bort should get freed up to work on defensive and offensive tactics more.
 
BullDog111
offline
Link
 
I am new to the website and i really like how every thing is going and i like this new XP bonus. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.
 
Weykool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HustonJ
Originally posted by Weykool

What is so hard about Bort swapping the gutted team and the guttee team once they make all the moves?


Would you rather Bort spend time working on Advanced Tactics for the Defense and Offense, or doing the above swaps, including spending the time researching the transaction logs to decide if penalties should be applied or not?

And than applying any and all penalties he thinks are deserved.

The issue is Bort's time.


As opposed to Bort programming all the xp penalties and bonuses and then monitoring how effective it is and then tweaking it after we see the effects and complain about it being to punitive or too much of a bonus?
The chemistry rules were implemented to prevent this kind of thing from happeneing and look at how much time he wasted on that.

Yes....I agree with you. His time is very valuable and shouldnt be wasted on something like this.
My solution only punishes the teams that dont play by the rules and not the rest of us who play fair and seem to get penalized for the actions of a few bad apples.

 
Riggs_Inator
offline
Link
 
Sounds awesome, whens this go active? =P
 
tragicslip
offline
Link
 
(opponents team average / your team average) + (league average/ your team average)
__________________________________________________________________________________

2
= exp modifier.

exp modifier can be no greater than 2 and no less than .5
Last edited Jun 16, 2008 11:44:49
 
adembroski
offline
Link
 
I like the idea on this basis; it justifies teams carrying low level players as backups as "developmental" projects.
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Great idea, Like Adem says it makes sense to have lower level players on the bench to develop.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
One thing - wasn't this what I was advocating in another thread the other day???

Anyway - I notice it's the same turds doing all the moaning about it not being fair.

Call me a cynic, but a far easier bet would be the find all the posters who whine the loudest every time a suggestion is made that would make things more fair for the honest majority - and ban the f**king lot of them!!

The only people that will 'suffer' for a penalty on XPs is the idiots who's ONLY interest is levelling and/or XPs. The sooner we get rid of them, the better for all the rest of us...........

Carry on Bort - be as harsh as you want - because it won't affect the honest players at all...............
 
NiteMaestro
offline
Link
 
I like the idea alot. As for how the 'average' would be determined? I think 'by the team' as in option one, but also taking into account the 'league', 'conference', et.al. averages as well. (The conference first, then league, then other leagues at the same level (i.e., all the AAA leagues in the region as well), then region, then, if you want to go this far, all the regions, then, all active players, and lastly (if you really want to go this far...) all players)
See what I'm getting at??


If the team is a bad team, then the players shouldn't necessarily get 'help' so to speak... However, if the team is just outmatched in it's conference/league, then like in the Pros, they'll step it up quick. (i.e, the AFC South is a perfect example. The Texans have quickly stepped up being competitive within the conference, and are considered to a solid playoff team if they were in a different conference.) I think the system should take these sort of things into account.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.