User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


I fail to see how it affects people who don't own a team and don't have a player old enough to coach in any negative way; it's just jealousy.



That's beneath you, Ken. You usually have the ability to think about the larger game.
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Not everyone in this world is so self-absorbed that they only care about what directly affects them. Apparently some people have difficulty realizing that people unlike them may actually be concerned even if an issue doesn't hurt them or may even help them. For instance, some power back owners called for change in S7, and some juke back owners called for change in S9. Meanwhile some certain other posters are nothing more than suckups who mindlessly endorse every idea that Bort comes up with.


TBH, coaches would probably help MY TEAM moreso than all my competitors.

Thats the reason I'm against it. I don't want an unfair advantage. It's NO different than playing a game like Call of Duty with a wall hack.

Its an unfair advantage that is way too open to exploitation. Additionally, it adds a really deep and complex strain to a ownership and management team.

From researching what is what (VERY hard to do) to recruiting (Demand will be off the charts, supply astronomically low) to general fun (how fun could a coach be?), this whole idea is lame.

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

That's beneath you, Ken. You usually have the ability to think about the larger game.

He does?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by = Ken1

I've suggested that until there are enough coaches, that coaches be only HC, OC, DC, and ST for each team, with the number of positions increasing as the number of coaches do.

If the number of positions are scaled to the number of coaches, that problem won't exist, as teams will just recruit coaches as with players.


Let's say MEM has 10 players that can become coaches now. They can have 3 go to MEM and the rest go to WL competitors, or the other 7 can go to other lower leveled teams in their network until there are enough coaches to fill more teams and then bring in the others to MEM so they have 10 3rd season coaches where other teams have 10 1st season coaches. Which do you think they will choose?

Have you done the math on how many coaches will be needed? There are 1,824 teams at AA and higher level.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
I'm really hoping that the whole coaching idea is scraped. There are so many other critical issues in this game that need to be fixed that spending time on this is just a waste of resources.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Not everyone in this world is so self-absorbed that they only care about what directly affects them. Apparently some people have difficulty realizing that people unlike them may actually be concerned even if an issue doesn't hurt them or may even help them. For instance, some power back owners called for change in S7, and some juke back owners called for change in S9. Meanwhile some certain other posters are nothing more than suckups who mindlessly endorse every idea that Bort comes up with.


This isn't going to help me. I don't have anyone who can become a coach until near the end of Season 12. The vast majority of my first wave of players were created at the very end of Season 1 or around the beginning of Season 2.

I'm one of those who care about things that don't affect me or I wouldn't be in this argument.

I also argued vociferously for aging before there were ideas floated such as the coach idea, rather than just opposing aging because in a no-aging game I'd always have Pro-caliber players.

People who care about others and the game can be against the entire idea, but I'm calling selfishness where it's "Coaches are fine, if I get to make one, but otherwise they suck."
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Let's say MEM has 10 players that can become coaches now. They can have 3 go to MEM and the rest go to WL competitors, or the other 7 can go to other lower leveled teams in their network until there are enough coaches to fill more teams and then bring in the others to MEM so they have 10 3rd season coaches where other teams have 10 1st season coaches. Which do you think they will choose?

Have you done the math on how many coaches will be needed? There are 1,824 teams at AA and higher level.


The number can be set as limited as is needed by the number available. I don't know this, but it's possible that the number of coaches would only support, say, a staff of 4 for each WL team (128 total coaches). If so, then in the first season they might only exist in WL.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

That's beneath you, Ken. You usually have the ability to think about the larger game.


I will say this: I know your opposition is principled and not selfish. I'm pretty sure you want to throw out the whole idea rather than just open it to everyone, and really those who hold that position I may disagree with, but they aren't just whining jealously.

I had no players playing until Season 2 (although a few made before Season 1 was over; I found the site late in Season 1) and expect to have no coaches coaching until Season 13. I think I'll have fun running coaches in Season 13 if the idea isn't killed, though, and I expect others will have the same, even if some get to have it earlier than I do.
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader


That's beneath you, Ken. You usually have the ability to think about the larger game.


I will say this: I know your opposition is principled and not selfish. I'm pretty sure you want to throw out the whole idea rather than just open it to everyone, and really those who hold that position I may disagree with, but they aren't just whining jealously.

I had no players playing until Season 2 (although a few made before Season 1 was over; I found the site late in Season 1) and expect to have no coaches coaching until Season 13. I think I'll have fun running coaches in Season 13 if the idea isn't killed, though, and I expect others will have the same, even if some get to have it earlier than I do.


Some got to experience the game before you, but you still probably spent money on the game just like they did. This does not mean they should get to buy GLB 2010 while you are stuck playing GLB 2009 for another 4 months.

Coaching Motto : "Ready! Fire!!!! Aim?"
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
The number can be set as limited as is needed by the number available. I don't know this, but it's possible that the number of coaches would only support, say, a staff of 4 for each WL team (128 total coaches). If so, then in the first season they might only exist in WL.


The problem is you are assuming someone would create a coach when the coach couldn't be associated with the team he was a player for.

Also, what about all the players that have to wait until mid season to become a coach? How do you know how many coaches there will be room for if 1/2 the coaches that will be created next season have to wait until day 12, 18, 24, etc. before they can become a coach.

I'm not against coaches. I'm against coaches being added to the game under the conditions that have been laid forth.

I still say no more than 5 per team, and you have to lower the retirement age before becoming a coach. Day 360 (9 full seasons) is probably a good cut off IMO. At the very least you need to reduce the cutoff to 400 so players don't have to worry about what to do when they will start hitting decline mid season.

I would also like to see crafting and the negative effects to opponents players abolished.

One problem that will still remain is the effects haven't and won't be thoroughly tested before it is implemented. The VAs have been around for multiple seasons and are still having a negative effect on the SIMs and this is just another round of VAs in a different format that will probably stack with the current VAs that are already pulling the game out of balance.
 
Draxius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
This isn't going to help me. I don't have anyone who can become a coach until near the end of Season 12. The vast majority of my first wave of players were created at the very end of Season 1 or around the beginning of Season 2.

I'm one of those who care about things that don't affect me or I wouldn't be in this argument.



If this is true then pledge not to use any of your Season 2 players to become coaches. In fact, if opposition to coaches is only whining and crying by jealous players, then you should pledge to not use any you have right now to make a coach.

Create a new player today, and have him be your first coach in season 22 or 23.

If you don't agree to do that, then it proves your support of coaches is selfish and unprincipled (just like you claim people who oppose coaches are).
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
ready fire aim!
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dawgs1235
ready fire aim!


this^
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Draxius
If this is true then pledge not to use any of your Season 2 players to become coaches. In fact, if opposition to coaches is only whining and crying by jealous players, then you should pledge to not use any you have right now to make a coach.

Create a new player today, and have him be your first coach in season 22 or 23.

If you don't agree to do that, then it proves your support of coaches is selfish and unprincipled (just like you claim people who oppose coaches are).


I was going to say that it was like saying if you oppose universal health care, pledge never to use any the government enacts, or if you oppose a tax loophole, never to use it.

But then, that isn't even a fair analogy because I support coaches. Your post is fail.
 
Draxius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I was going to say that it was like saying if you oppose universal health care, pledge never to use any the government enacts, or if you oppose a tax loophole, never to use it.

But then, that isn't even a fair analogy because I support coaches. Your post is fail.


Of course you support coaches, you will directly benefit from them before the vast majority of the player base.

Your 'people who oppose coaches are jealous whiners' is nothing more then thinly disguised greed and desire for undeserved advantage.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.