User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Is it really such an awful idea for you to represent CPL, for only a season if you don't make the playoffs.


Well, I'm guessing they wouldn't want to go, since they have perfectly entertaining league forums as opposed to, say, USAPL's shitty league forums.

DUCY?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
This whole idea is whacked. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.


why is this whole idea whacked? And it is broken, or the Pro Leagues would be much more balanced in comparison to each other.

With player decline, etc. starting soon for Season 1-2 players, this is the perfect time to implement something like a World League. The next few seasons are going to be very important in deciding the future direction of GLB.

I think something needs to be done to get rid of the idea that "World League = USAPL" and I think Bort and anyone who cares about the future of this game would have to agree about that. I think that the idea others and I have suggested is really going to help "dethrone" USAPL, and I think that will be a great thing for the game. Once the World League is in place, younger players will have no real reason to prefer the USA region unless they just want to play in a USA league period. But for the players who are more concerned about competition and reaching the top, there won't be any incentive to go to the USA region more than any other region unless they are only looking at the short term that for example, USA AA and AAA leagues are tougher than other region's AA and AAA leagues in comparison. However, with a World League implemented even that should change a lot in the coming seasons until the lower-tier USA leagues will probably only hold a slight advantage.


I am saying this all as an owner of a USAPL team that is very highly unlikely to be a part of the World League with our current generation of players. I am supporting an idea that I feel might favor USAPL right now, but it only does because of the current state of the game, and not because the idea itself favors USAPL.

I would not support an idea that I felt favored USAPL in any way. In fact, a lot of the reason that I am willing to so strongly support this idea is because I feel that it is best for the game, and will ultimately increase the level of competition in the 7 out of 8 regions that aren't USA. I'm not trying to bring USAPL down, but rather raise up the other Pro Leagues.

Of course as a USAPL team owner I would love to see USAPL proving itself in the World League as the best Pro League in the game, but I want our league to truly earn it; I would not enjoy seeing us completely dominate the game however as that's not any fun for anybody.

I am trying my best to get a World League system implemented that I feel is the best for future of the game. It's not about me at all. I already have a team in what's considered the best League in the game right now. If I was following a personal agenda then the best thing for me to do would be to is stop a World League from happening so my team can remain in the current "World League"
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
You need to stop posting 7 paragraph responses that nobody reads, in response to people's 1 sentence posts.
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
You need to stop posting 7 paragraph responses that nobody reads, in response to people's 1 sentence posts.


Seriously, who the fuck is going to read that?
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
why is this whole idea whacked?


Read the other thread for reasons why the idea is whacked, if you want. I'll just say that a "World League" basically makes the current Pro leagues...not quite Pro.

Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
I think something needs to be done to get rid of the idea that "World League = USAPL" and I think Bort and anyone who cares about the future of this game would have to agree about that.


If they go ahead with this dumb idea, at the very least, the various regions should each have equal representation - 4 teams per region. A divisional format would be an interesting twist on the usual league format.

 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skanker irl
Originally posted by Iceman16

You need to stop posting 7 paragraph responses that nobody reads, in response to people's 1 sentence posts.


Seriously, who the fuck is going to read that?


Someone like me, who is more interested in logic than one-liners and soundbites.

I thought it was a great post, and really solid reasoning.

Your post, OTOH, is more like what I expect to hear from a politician - no substance + logical fallacy (appeal to the mob)
Edited by griffin8r on Jul 13, 2009 17:35:11
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
If I was following a personal agenda then the best thing for me to do would be to is stop a World League from happening so my team can remain in the current "World League"


Arrogance, much?

 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
After a few seasons, the majority of players will realize that they're never, ever going to get the chance to compete at the highest level of competition. This is unavoidable - you are shrinking the highest level of competition from 256 teams to 32. Eventually, people will become bored, and begin to tune out. How exactly does this "add" to GLB overall?


You make it sound like all current Pro leagues are considered equal. Playing in, for example, APL is not playing the highest level of competition. With CPL basically two teams now, it's pretty evident that USAPL is the best league in the game. Throw in probably 10 or so teams from the other regions that are up there enough in quality to perform in the tournaments and you have 45ish teams that are playing the "highest level of competition". The World League will allow teams outside the US region to have a chance at the top competition on a regular basis, instead of scrimmages.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGrai37
You make it sound like all current Pro leagues are considered equal.


They may not be equal, but they are at least the highest level of competition within their league structures. Really, it's not complicated - Pro leagues won't be real "pro" leagues if you institute a World League. You may as well rename them AAAA.
 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by McGrai37

You make it sound like all current Pro leagues are considered equal.


They may not be equal, but they are at least the highest level of competition within their league structures. Really, it's not complicated - Pro leagues won't be real "pro" leagues if you institute a World League. You may as well rename them AAAA.


Who cares if they're the highest level of competition within their league structures when the league structures are so different? Assuming regions are awarded equal slots in the World League, this should actually spread out the talent to more of the regions, causing other Pro leagues to live up to the name. Sounds like you're just upset over the semantics of it.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGrai37
Who cares if they're the highest level of competition within their league structures when the league structures are so different?

Sorry, you've lost me. How are the league structures different?
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
Originally posted by McGrai37

You make it sound like all current Pro leagues are considered equal.


They may not be equal, but they are at least the highest level of competition within their league structures. Really, it's not complicated - Pro leagues won't be real "pro" leagues if you institute a World League. You may as well rename them AAAA.


I don't know how much of the 'preserving the value of the Pro leagues' thing really comes into play given the number of Pro teams - some of the best included - that are already folding each season. More and more AAA's are getting the call to the Pro's to fill holes left by guts and re-builds before earning their way up and, in turn, the Pros are already getting a bit watered down. Not the same in every conference obviously, but the gut rate at the top seems to be picking up.

Taking the best from each league and shifting them into the inaugural World League would add to that number of early AAA call-ups and speed that 'renewing of the Pros' process, but it's happening already, and it won't stop, WL or not.

You're right that succeeding in the Pro's would no longer be the ultimate goal - winning in the WL would be. I'm not sure why that's a bad thing. Winning a Pro conference / league with 2-3 dominant teams and a bunch of also-rans and fillers shouldn't be considered the height of GLB success when you could be aiming to beat the best from around the GLB globe by playing them week-in and week-out.
 
Link
 
It honestly has surprised me (not that it should have) how much of the discussion about something as important as this has been so childish. I am honestly open to listening to any ideas that I think might improve this game, and yet most of the "discussion", regardless of what side people are on has just been a bunch of complaining and whining.

If it bothers you enough to complain and whine about something then why don't you do or say something constructive?

Maybe take an example from someone like Rodion a few pages back who took the time to not just say he disagreed with me but voiced his opinions and ideas. I read every word he wrote because this isn't about me and I want what is best for the game. Even though we didn't agree, it was still helpful for me to hear his thoughts, and I'd rather someone help me realize I am wrong about something than I care about being "right" or whatever.


It's also frustrating to me that I feel like I am someone who has experienced many different facets of GLB, and so I feel like I have a lot of knowledge to offer, along with the willingness to help come up with the best possible structure we can for the World League.

I highly doubt any of my posts are even making their way to Bort or anyone who actually has enough influence or power to do something to help improve GLB.

It shouldn't matter what my username is, but the sad truth is that if a great guy like Hulk was making the same exact posts as I have been he would be receiving a much better response. I know I'm not someone whose name carries as much weight as someone like Hulk, but I'm also not some random guy that's never had a player in a league higher than Western Europe AA.


I am pursuing a career in stand-up comedy, and I am somebody who has a hard time even being serious, much less staying serious, so I think it should say a lot that someone like myself has put as much time as I have into this discussion, and cared enough to stay serious about it. I don't jump in on every mega-thread about nerfs and bugs, etc, because I don't have the time to fully contribute to them, and I usually don't feel like it's important for me to do so.

I think this is a very important discussion that is being skimmed over and/or ignored. I'm going out of my way to contribute to this discussion because I feel it is important enough to the future of the game for me to do so, especially if not many others are willing to step up.


You guys may be used to complaining like children and that's as much Bort's fault as anything, because he's allowed it to continue since Season 1. This community has largely forgotten how to be constructive, and many, many people who care about this game and would be constructive if they spoke up instead stay silent because they know that their voice is just going to be drowned out by all the more vocal voices that could care less about trying to actually do something constructive.

This community needs to realize that there is a time to try and be a comedian and a time to be serious. If I was a new player to this game, reading this main forum (and many others) would either drive me away from GLB or if I stayed around, they would cause me to avoid the forums as much as possible because otherwise I'd have a harder time enjoying the game. Come on Bort, you know that it's bad for your business when your forums are most likely to scare off new customers from not only adding to the game but even away from the game itself. You can't honestly tell me you are happy with the current state of the forums.


I know a lot of people are going to hate this post, but I really don't care, because it's something that needs to be said for the sake of the game's future. This is a post that I could have agreed with since I started playing back in Season 1, though things have continued to only get worse for the most part.

I've wanted to make a post like this for several seasons now, but at this point I think it really needs to be made, and I don't want to keep waiting for someone else to say it. I know there are a lot of people who play this game that want to make a post like this as well, but you don't hear from them because they've already lost faith in posting in the forums. Many people, including myself, don't feel like their opinions really matter because they aren't one of the few people who the community actually listens to.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
It honestly has surprised me (not that it should have) how much of the discussion about something as important as this has been so childish. I am honestly open to listening to any ideas that I think might improve this game, and yet most of the "discussion", regardless of what side people are on has just been a bunch of complaining and whining.

If it bothers you enough to complain and whine about something then why don't you do or say something constructive?

Maybe take an example from someone like Rodion a few pages back who took the time to not just say he disagreed with me but voiced his opinions and ideas. I read every word he wrote because this isn't about me and I want what is best for the game. Even though we didn't agree, it was still helpful for me to hear his thoughts, and I'd rather someone help me realize I am wrong about something than I care about being "right" or whatever.


It's also frustrating to me that I feel like I am someone who has experienced many different facets of GLB, and so I feel like I have a lot of knowledge to offer, along with the willingness to help come up with the best possible structure we can for the World League.

I highly doubt any of my posts are even making their way to Bort or anyone who actually has enough influence or power to do something to help improve GLB.

It shouldn't matter what my username is, but the sad truth is that if a great guy like Hulk was making the same exact posts as I have been he would be receiving a much better response. I know I'm not someone whose name carries as much weight as someone like Hulk, but I'm also not some random guy that's never had a player in a league higher than Western Europe AA.


I am pursuing a career in stand-up comedy, and I am somebody who has a hard time even being serious, much less staying serious, so I think it should say a lot that someone like myself has put as much time as I have into this discussion, and cared enough to stay serious about it. I don't jump in on every mega-thread about nerfs and bugs, etc, because I don't have the time to fully contribute to them, and I usually don't feel like it's important for me to do so.

I think this is a very important discussion that is being skimmed over and/or ignored. I'm going out of my way to contribute to this discussion because I feel it is important enough to the future of the game for me to do so, especially if not many others are willing to step up.


You guys may be used to complaining like children and that's as much Bort's fault as anything, because he's allowed it to continue since Season 1. This community has largely forgotten how to be constructive, and many, many people who care about this game and would be constructive if they spoke up instead stay silent because they know that their voice is just going to be drowned out by all the more vocal voices that could care less about trying to actually do something constructive.

This community needs to realize that there is a time to try and be a comedian and a time to be serious. If I was a new player to this game, reading this main forum (and many others) would either drive me away from GLB or if I stayed around, they would cause me to avoid the forums as much as possible because otherwise I'd have a harder time enjoying the game. Come on Bort, you know that it's bad for your business when your forums are most likely to scare off new customers from not only adding to the game but even away from the game itself. You can't honestly tell me you are happy with the current state of the forums.


I know a lot of people are going to hate this post, but I really don't care, because it's something that needs to be said for the sake of the game's future. This is a post that I could have agreed with since I started playing back in Season 1, though things have continued to only get worse for the most part.

I've wanted to make a post like this for several seasons now, but at this point I think it really needs to be made, and I don't want to keep waiting for someone else to say it. I know there are a lot of people who play this game that want to make a post like this as well, but you don't hear from them because they've already lost faith in posting in the forums. Many people, including myself, don't feel like their opinions really matter because they aren't one of the few people who the community actually listens to.


Good post would read again.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Phantom_Opera

Good post would read again.


I can't believe I'm actually asking this, but is that a genuine opinion or sarcasm?

I'm sure you can understand why I might not be sure which.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.