User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
lets just agree to disagree and see what Bort does....since he has not posted in this for about 20 pages(i am guessing)


he may leave it and he may change it...but i am sure what ever he does there will be more threads..just like this one complaining about what he does...he is dam if he does and dam if he dont.



 
AD_SoDope
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me

speed is 30ish



LOL, And you are complaining because?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.


Steelers,

Go take a look at the 4 teams that madcow posted, tell me if they are in the top echelon of GLB teams like madcow thinks,

Maybe I am just not seeing it, but I know you have seen a ton more teams.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sois
Originally posted by Warlock


So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.

OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.

This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.

Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.


This is the best explanation of the problem.
OL have to build 4 or 5 skills up.
DE's have to build only three.




Yes, but all things being equal, a 60 agility OT beats a 70 agility DE. DE's have to win by a significant amount (10+) or they don't win any battles.

If you put them on even ground, then DE's would have no way to be ahead by 10 in any category.

If things are even though, OT's win every time.

People are bitching because their 35 speed OT gives up 4-5 sacks to a 60 speed DE. That means that 35 speed is enough on 75% of the passing plays!! Imagine if DE's "won" the battle 75% of the time with 35 speed vs 60 speed for the OT???

It is good the way it is now. As long as OT's stay within 10 of the DE's, they are fine. Plus DE's are hitting a wall at the (3 to 1) or (4 to 1) marks. OT's like the OP can go from 35 to 50 on day 1 of next season when they boost and gain +15. DE's at 4 to 1 can only gain +3 in speed.

Relax - things are fine now.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.


Steelers,

Go take a look at the 4 teams that madcow posted, tell me if they are in the top echelon of GLB teams like madcow thinks,

Maybe I am just not seeing it, but I know you have seen a ton more teams.


For a AA league to have 4 teams that are that good, there was a 5th team that was that good, but the team got sold this year, I would consider a league with 5 teams that good in it to be a good league...
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Yes, but all things being equal, a 60 agility OT beats a 70 agility DE. DE's have to win by a significant amount (10+) or they don't win any battles.

If you put them on even ground, then DE's would have no way to be ahead by 10 in any category.

If things are even though, OT's win every time.

People are bitching because their 35 speed OT gives up 4-5 sacks to a 60 speed DE. That means that 35 speed is enough on 75% of the passing plays!! Imagine if DE's "won" the battle 75% of the time with 35 speed vs 60 speed for the OT???

It is good the way it is now. As long as OT's stay within 10 of the DE's, they are fine. Plus DE's are hitting a wall at the (3 to 1) or (4 to 1) marks. OT's like the OP can go from 35 to 50 on day 1 of next season when they boost and gain +15. DE's at 4 to 1 can only gain +3 in speed.

Relax - things are fine now.


I agree that DEs need a slight edge in builds, due to the fact OTs have the edge in positioning... which is why I also suggested making SAs more effective. This will mean that DEs actually do moves to get past OTs, rather than just running around them.

Things are not fine either. You're jaded if you think otherwise.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.


Steelers,

Go take a look at the 4 teams that madcow posted, tell me if they are in the top echelon of GLB teams like madcow thinks,

Maybe I am just not seeing it, but I know you have seen a ton more teams.


For a AA league to have 4 teams that are that good, there was a 5th team that was that good, but the team got sold this year, I would consider a league with 5 teams that good in it to be a good league...



Honestly, everyone thinks their league is a good league. And good is a very relative word.

For instance, there are no teams in the top 150 GLB teams in your league.


However, may some of the teams be equal in skill level? Of course. Some people think that makes their league good. But you could define a D-league as a "good league" in that way then if the games are close, right?

Regardless of how close the games are, I don't think the OT in the OP is well built FOR PASS PROTECTION. He could be a run blocking god for all I know. I don't care how many similar level players he has faced. That just means your whole league got the same bad info on how to build a good pass protector imo.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.


Steelers,

Go take a look at the 4 teams that madcow posted, tell me if they are in the top echelon of GLB teams like madcow thinks,

Maybe I am just not seeing it, but I know you have seen a ton more teams.


For a AA league to have 4 teams that are that good, there was a 5th team that was that good, but the team got sold this year, I would consider a league with 5 teams that good in it to be a good league...


Like I said, not seeing it.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Madcow8me

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.


Steelers,

Go take a look at the 4 teams that madcow posted, tell me if they are in the top echelon of GLB teams like madcow thinks,

Maybe I am just not seeing it, but I know you have seen a ton more teams.


For a AA league to have 4 teams that are that good, there was a 5th team that was that good, but the team got sold this year, I would consider a league with 5 teams that good in it to be a good league...


Like I said, not seeing it.



You are just some piss ant around here. I dont really care what you see or dont see.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Yes, but all things being equal, a 60 agility OT beats a 70 agility DE. DE's have to win by a significant amount (10+) or they don't win any battles.

If you put them on even ground, then DE's would have no way to be ahead by 10 in any category.

If things are even though, OT's win every time.

People are bitching because their 35 speed OT gives up 4-5 sacks to a 60 speed DE. That means that 35 speed is enough on 75% of the passing plays!! Imagine if DE's "won" the battle 75% of the time with 35 speed vs 60 speed for the OT???

It is good the way it is now. As long as OT's stay within 10 of the DE's, they are fine. Plus DE's are hitting a wall at the (3 to 1) or (4 to 1) marks. OT's like the OP can go from 35 to 50 on day 1 of next season when they boost and gain +15. DE's at 4 to 1 can only gain +3 in speed.

Relax - things are fine now.


I agree that DEs need a slight edge in builds, due to the fact OTs have the edge in positioning... which is why I also suggested making SAs more effective. This will mean that DEs actually do moves to get past OTs, rather than just running around them.

Things are not fine either. You're jaded if you think otherwise.



Why would I be jaded? (I think you mean biased??). Either way, I have OT's and DE's and I think it is fair right now. If I put my DE up against my OT, both would "win" a decent amount of the time. That is the way it should be. If my OT throws a shutout on my DE, it would only be because my DE is a couple levels below.

As an offense, I feel I have to pay attention to the pass rushers and plan for them, but I can also control them enough to be able to do what I want to do on offense. And that's the way I think it should be.

On defense, I don't think my DE's will win every game for me, but I think I can gameplan the rest of my defense to take advantage of that strength. If I can see on film I'm facing a well built OT, then I know I have to blitz more to get the same pressure.

It's a strategy game and right now you need strategy in building your players and strategy in using them properly. I'm happy - especially about the pass rush dynamic. I think the running dynamic needs a little tweak, but I've noticed I've been getting pancaked like crazy. I think some of it may be special teams, but I think Bort turned up the run blocking aspect. And I'm fine with that. I just don't want to see it over-dominant either (one way or the other).

Last edited Nov 13, 2008 12:20:03
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Madcow8me


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




We are facing the best pass rusher in GLB tomorrow (Corn Head from Arctic Bay Yetis). Yes, maybe he'll get 2 or 3, but we'll get 4 or 5 vs them.

If Corn Head isn't the best, he is definitely top 5. It's hard to tell about the guys in USA Pro because so many OT's have shitty builds over there.


Steelers,

Go take a look at the 4 teams that madcow posted, tell me if they are in the top echelon of GLB teams like madcow thinks,

Maybe I am just not seeing it, but I know you have seen a ton more teams.


For a AA league to have 4 teams that are that good, there was a 5th team that was that good, but the team got sold this year, I would consider a league with 5 teams that good in it to be a good league...


Like I said, not seeing it.



You are just some piss ant around here. I dont really care what you see or dont see.


LMAO I am a pissant because your team is average? wow, how about you being a pissant because your OT's build is way way below stellar and you just can't handle it?

Naw, that wouldn't be it, it's gotta be a bug I mean, you would never build a player who can't..oh wait....you did.
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Waaaaaaaaaahhhhhhh
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
speed doesn't mean 40 yard dash time.

You're wrong, as that's exactly what speed means. Look at any other football game on the planet and they all have speed affecting running. Do you see offensive tackles with tons of speed in Madden? No, because no one defines speed that way. Hell, Bort has said that he doesn't either.

If you look at the combine, speed is the 40 yard dash times, while agility is what you measure with the cone drills, etc. Agility is what should determine a back-peddle, side-shifting, and other forms of short-area quickness. Linemen shouldn't have to invest tons of points in speed because real linemen aren't fast. Poor agility, on the other hand, is precisely why some guys like Mike Williams can't pass protect in the NFL and go bust.


Seriously, I know that you do nothing but post in these forums all day every day, but at least try to be more intelligent if you're going to be this much of a spammer.
 
thomasjones7
offline
Link
 
Im not sure if anyone had mentioned it but maybe a solution would be to move the OL into a more realistic starting position. By that I mean, if you watch football you have probably noticed that all of the O lineman, with the exception of the Center, line up about a yard or yard and a half behind the ball. On most of the replays it looks like the OT is being killed off the line and never even has a chance to attempt a block. I'm not sure if Bort has already put this into the sim because the replay arent fully accurate.

Example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mql6BEt6hX0&feature=related The ROT is basically lined up with the QB

http://bztv.typepad.com/newsviews/images/oregon_ducks.jpg
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 12:44:42
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.