User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Oh, and babies being sent to hell. No branch of Christianity explicitly states it, but pretty much all of them post "accepting our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ into your heart" as a requirement of going into heaven- babies can't do this, so babies go to hell. Or purgatory, which is like a giant waiting room, and therefore worse than hell

Not even close to all of them, actually. The whole "born again" thing is a very recent movement, and one attributed mostly to Evangelism. Original sin is something of a constant debate, and an idea popularized by Catholicism, but I think you'll find very few theologians who still cling to that idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie

Originally posted by Asheme


It's impossible to have a discussion about religion on the internet (or with normal people in general). Way too much conflation and lack of specificity.

There is no such thing as Christianity, really. It's fragmented into dozens of dominant denominations, and dozens more less prominent ones, each having differing ideas based on church tradition and their "official" interpretation of scripture.


Don't forget the fact that while many people claim to disregard/uphold religion and christianity for intellectual reasons they are clealy emotionally invested on both sides of the coin.


Morals exist without Christianity. Otherwise 66% of the worlds population would be murdering, raping, stealing, child-molesting cannibals.


I agree. Religion has brought very little good to the world that any nonreligious government could bring just as easily. All I'm saying is that arguments about it are futile because there is no concrete, uncontestable proof supporting either side and therefore it boils down to the person's personal and biased opinion

 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Gturtle

Except they are all based upon the same fundamentally flawed book of anecdotes that are "the word of God" despite those very differences of interpretation that has brought us wonderful things like the Spanish Inquisition, and homosexual marriage being made illegal.

Well, yeah, we have antiquated Catholic church tradition and Papal law to blame for a lot of things, but the Catholic church has spent most of its time being a superstructure for nation-states and an instrument of power, and very little time being a bastion of education and enlightenment (except for the Jesuits, of course). Homosexual marriage being illegal has to do with our legacy of Puritanism is this country, not to mention the rapid spread of extreme Evangelism.

Even calling the Bible the "Word of God" is using terminology from specific denominations, and something other factions may or may not agree with.


Revelations is extremely difficult to explain in any way other than "The word of God, as written down by some dude hopped up on hashish." Funny thing is, the only other way to explain it is "some dude smoked some bad hashish; check out this crazy shit he wrote down"
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
I agree. Religion has brought very little good to the world that any nonreligious government could bring just as easily. All I'm saying is that arguments about it are futile because there is no concrete, uncontestable proof supporting either side and therefore it boils down to the person's personal and biased opinion

Mostly it comes down to opinion, yes. Unless I'm talking about these things in an academic setting (lolacademics), I've never been in a discussion about religion that didn't devolve into a shouting match, more or less.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Originally posted by Gturtle

Originally posted by whotookmybowtie


Originally posted by Asheme



It's impossible to have a discussion about religion on the internet (or with normal people in general). Way too much conflation and lack of specificity.

There is no such thing as Christianity, really. It's fragmented into dozens of dominant denominations, and dozens more less prominent ones, each having differing ideas based on church tradition and their "official" interpretation of scripture.


Don't forget the fact that while many people claim to disregard/uphold religion and christianity for intellectual reasons they are clealy emotionally invested on both sides of the coin.


Morals exist without Christianity. Otherwise 66% of the worlds population would be murdering, raping, stealing, child-molesting cannibals.


I agree. Religion has brought very little good to the world that any nonreligious government could bring just as easily. All I'm saying is that arguments about it are futile because there is no concrete, uncontestable proof supporting either side and therefore it boils down to the person's personal and biased opinion



Burden of proof is only placed on one side of the argument. The people who believe in a sky wizard are responsible for proving he exists. It's impossible to prove a negative, and as such, we win by default.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie

I agree. Religion has brought very little good to the world that any nonreligious government could bring just as easily. All I'm saying is that arguments about it are futile because there is no concrete, uncontestable proof supporting either side and therefore it boils down to the person's personal and biased opinion

Mostly it comes down to opinion, yes. Unless I'm talking about these things in an academic setting (lolacademics), I've never been in a discussion about religion that didn't devolve into a shouting match, more or less.


ARE YOU QUESITONING MY INTELLIGENCE ASHMOMO I MADE YOU WHO YOU ARE TODAY [YELLYELLYELLYELLYELLYELLYELLYELLYELLYELL]
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Revelations is extremely difficult to explain in any way other than "The word of God, as written down by some dude hopped up on hashish." Funny thing is, the only other way to explain it is "some dude smoked some bad hashish; check out this crazy shit he wrote down"

I lol'd.

Revelations is indeed an interesting book, but I'd say those who have studied the Bible would apply to it the same qualification they apply to the rest of the books: that it's the testimony of a faithful human (or set of humans, as the case may be), exhibiting both the inherent strength in faith, and the inherent flaws in humanity.
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Burden of proof is only placed on one side of the argument. The people who believe in a sky wizard are responsible for proving he exists. It's impossible to prove a negative, and as such, we win by default.

A knowledge claim is a knowledge claim. If you're claiming something one way or the other, the burden of proof falls on you. If I say that woman has a penis, and you say she doesn't have a penis, the burden lies on both of us to demonstrate whether or not she's packing.

RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Gturtle

Burden of proof is only placed on one side of the argument. The people who believe in a sky wizard are responsible for proving he exists. It's impossible to prove a negative, and as such, we win by default.

A knowledge claim is a knowledge claim. If you're claiming something one way or the other, the burden of proof falls on you. If I say that woman has a penis, and you say she doesn't have a penis, the burden lies on both of us to demonstrate whether or not she's packing.

RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE


Prove you didn't just kill a man, Ashmomo.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Also, this woman you're talking about. Penis, no penis, do you think she likes me?
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gturtle
Also, this woman you're talking about. Penis, no penis, do you think she likes me?

He said, "I love-" as the blood bubbled in his throat.

wat
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by Gturtle

Revelations is extremely difficult to explain in any way other than "The word of God, as written down by some dude hopped up on hashish." Funny thing is, the only other way to explain it is "some dude smoked some bad hashish; check out this crazy shit he wrote down"

I lol'd.

Revelations is indeed an interesting book, but I'd say those who have studied the Bible would apply to it the same qualification they apply to the rest of the books: that it's the testimony of a faithful human (or set of humans, as the case may be), exhibiting both the inherent strength in faith, and the inherent flaws in humanity.


THE BOOK IS REVELATION THERE IS NO S JESUS WINS

 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by Gturtle


Revelations is extremely difficult to explain in any way other than "The word of God, as written down by some dude hopped up on hashish." Funny thing is, the only other way to explain it is "some dude smoked some bad hashish; check out this crazy shit he wrote down"

I lol'd.

Revelations is indeed an interesting book, but I'd say those who have studied the Bible would apply to it the same qualification they apply to the rest of the books: that it's the testimony of a faithful human (or set of humans, as the case may be), exhibiting both the inherent strength in faith, and the inherent flaws in humanity.


THE BOOK IS REVELATION THERE IS NO S JESUS WINS



fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck

He's right, Jesus wins
 
Link
 
Your point that John was probably on the hash whilst writing it is still valid, though.
 
Gturtle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whotookmybowtie
Your point that John was probably on the hash whilst writing it is still valid, though.


Can't really blame John though.

I mean fuck, what else was there to do back then.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.