User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
Page:
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wsdp
Originally posted by Rage Kinard


How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds


no, they would have to actually improve their stadiums rather than throw big money they don't actually have at players.
 
xxedge72x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Groucho
Originally posted by Tito716

http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.


In many cases throwing games to pull a matchup with better stadiums would require a precision that most people in this game are incapable of.

Most people would think they can predict the outcome, throw the game, something happens, and then they get seeded differently... bitch moan whine complain.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by wsdp

Originally posted by Rage Kinard



How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds


no, they would have to actually improve their stadiums rather than throw big money they don't actually have at players.


Or maybe Just Maybe, they could improve their stadium and still have the opportunity to go after FA's in order to be competitive. Sure sounds like that is something you are completely against. So you'd rather keep them down so that they can't afford the FA's so that you have more access to them? Just not sure what you are arguing here and not sure how taxes affect how an owner builds his stadium.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 13:30:27
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by jdros13

Originally posted by wsdp


Originally posted by Rage Kinard




How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds


no, they would have to actually improve their stadiums rather than throw big money they don't actually have at players.


Or maybe Just Maybe, they could improve their stadium and still have the opportunity to go after FA's in order to be competitive. Sure sounds like that is something you are completely against. So you'd rather keep them down so that they can't afford the FA's so that you have more access to them? Just not sure what you are arguing here and not sure how taxes affect how an owner builds his stadium.


money =/= good FAs

Just because you throw money at a problem doesn't solve it.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by jdros13


Originally posted by wsdp



Originally posted by Rage Kinard





How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds


no, they would have to actually improve their stadiums rather than throw big money they don't actually have at players.


Or maybe Just Maybe, they could improve their stadium and still have the opportunity to go after FA's in order to be competitive. Sure sounds like that is something you are completely against. So you'd rather keep them down so that they can't afford the FA's so that you have more access to them? Just not sure what you are arguing here and not sure how taxes affect how an owner builds his stadium.


money =/= good FAs

Just because you throw money at a problem doesn't solve it.



What? So money = good FA's but using money to get good FA's doesn't solve the problem? Sorry but I do not follow your logic there. Weren't you clamoring to force the 5-8's to only be able to spend the rev share $'s on their stadiums so that they couldn't spend them on FA's, leaving more for you?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716

Originally posted by Crushr


Originally posted by jdros13



Originally posted by wsdp




Originally posted by Rage Kinard






How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds


no, they would have to actually improve their stadiums rather than throw big money they don't actually have at players.


Or maybe Just Maybe, they could improve their stadium and still have the opportunity to go after FA's in order to be competitive. Sure sounds like that is something you are completely against. So you'd rather keep them down so that they can't afford the FA's so that you have more access to them? Just not sure what you are arguing here and not sure how taxes affect how an owner builds his stadium.


money =/= good FAs

Just because you throw money at a problem doesn't solve it.



What? So money = good FA's but using money to get good FA's doesn't solve the problem? Sorry but I do not follow your logic there. Weren't you clamoring to force the 5-8's to only be able to spend the rev share $'s on their stadiums so that they couldn't spend them on FA's, leaving more for you?


No. I want them to spend the money on their stadiums so they can generate their OWN revenue. They can spend THEIR revenue on FAs.

Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day.
Teach a man to fish and feed him for a lifetime.



 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxedge72x
Originally posted by Groucho

Originally posted by Tito716


http://goallineblitz.com/game/stadium.pl?team_id=3298

This is the stadium of the #1 team in my league. No we are not an expansion league.

I hope the #8 seed enjoys their 250,000 shared revenue...


This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.


In many cases throwing games to pull a matchup with better stadiums would require a precision that most people in this game are incapable of.

Most people would think they can predict the outcome, throw the game, something happens, and then they get seeded differently... bitch moan whine complain.


There is still financial incentive to win. You act like playoff ticket revenue is the only benefit of getting home playoff games. There is also the money received from extra concession sales. In addition, there is the extra money you get from being able to charge more for tickets and the higher concession sales you get in the regular season because of higher fan support.

Also, that team could still expect at least $1.5 million in ticket sales for each home playoff game then quite a bit more in concessions. Even if they have to give up $500K per home game, they can make quite a bit of cash in a long playoff run.
 
Crushr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Crushr

Originally posted by Tito716


Originally posted by Crushr



Originally posted by jdros13




Originally posted by wsdp





Originally posted by Rage Kinard







How ticked would people be if they had to pay property tax and upkeep on their stadiums and had to purchase the concessions from vendors at wholesale prices in order to have them to sell. Then on top of that you should get taxed on your revenue, the more you make, the higher percentage you have to pay.


non playoff teams and 5-8 seeds would lose their minds


no, they would have to actually improve their stadiums rather than throw big money they don't actually have at players.


Or maybe Just Maybe, they could improve their stadium and still have the opportunity to go after FA's in order to be competitive. Sure sounds like that is something you are completely against. So you'd rather keep them down so that they can't afford the FA's so that you have more access to them? Just not sure what you are arguing here and not sure how taxes affect how an owner builds his stadium.


money =/= good FAs

Just because you throw money at a problem doesn't solve it.



What? So money = good FA's but using money to get good FA's doesn't solve the problem? Sorry but I do not follow your logic there. Weren't you clamoring to force the 5-8's to only be able to spend the rev share $'s on their stadiums so that they couldn't spend them on FA's, leaving more for you?


No. I want them to spend the money on their stadiums so they can generate their OWN revenue. They can spend THEIR revenue on FAs.

Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day.
Teach a man to fish and feed him for a lifetime.





Ok confucius..Please, you still can't grasp the concept that until its in your pocket its not YOUR money.. You will still get the lionshare of the revenue....

 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Crushr
Originally posted by Tito716


No. I want them to spend the money on their stadiums so they can generate their OWN revenue. They can spend THEIR revenue on FAs.

Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day.
Teach a man to fish and feed him for a lifetime.





Ok confucius..Please, you still can't grasp the concept that until its in your pocket its not YOUR money.. You will still get the lionshare of the revenue....



Honestly, I am done with this topic.

I may not like revenue sharing because I think it opens up a slippery slope and I don't trust teams to spend the money wisely.

I really don't mind giving other teams money. Believe me. I just want controls put in place for them to use the money on their stadium so they can generate their own revenue.

Don't come back to me after next season and tell me that "lower seeds still aren't making enough money. We will need to increase the percentage of revenue shared."
 
slakker381
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxedge72x
Originally posted by Groucho

This is exactly why revenue sharing is a bad idea. Under the old system, they had a financial incentive to win. Now their financial incentive is to throw games so that they can be matched up against teams with better stadiums.


In many cases throwing games to pull a matchup with better stadiums would require a precision that most people in this game are incapable of.

Most people would think they can predict the outcome, throw the game, something happens, and then they get seeded differently... bitch moan whine complain.


Not really as hard as you may think...especially towards the end when teams may be fighting for a playoff spot. Not to mention that their are teams that may be on the brink of elimination and a thrown game could determine the teams fate of even making the playoffs.

For example: A team on the bubble needs the #7 seed to win a normally easy game in order to make the playoffs...but the #1 seed has a MUCH bigger stadium than the #2. The #7 may drop to #8 with a loss so they throw the game and put their kicker as the QB, switch the offense and defense..etc, etc..whatever they have to in order to lose. Now the team that probably should have made the playoffs will not all because of revenue sharing!?!

I think that this idea has way too many flaws and the only argument has been coming from teams that are jealous and don't want the better teams to succeed. The "jumbotron" idea brings them more money than revenue sharing and would only provide even more of an incentive to make the playoffs without the risk or lure of a team trying to "throw" a game.

Last edited Oct 2, 2008 15:44:23
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
Crushr's big problem and the reason why he's arguing with everyone: For some reason, he insists on using the term "revenue sharing" when he's talking about what everyone else calls "alternative revenue" or "additional revenue".

Crushr, dude, everyone else defines the "revenue sharing" option as the one where current revenue is split between home team and visiting team where it used to only go to the home team.

I don't remember a single person (and I've read all 28 pages of this thread) who argues that all the revenue from new sources should only go to the home team. No one is arguing that the higher seeds are entitled to THAT revenue. To the contrary, with the Jumbotron proposal the higher seeds are fully agreeable with getting NONE of that new revenue.

Do yourself a favor and save yourself a LOT of frustration and misinterpretation of other people's motives by adopting the same terminology that everyone else is using so we're not talking different languages here.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 19:56:57
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Bort used the term revenue sharing in his announcement (if I am not mistaken). We are honestly getting off track once again from discussing solutions. We know people on one side of the argument want either no change or 'additional revenue sources' or something that will not take from the income they are already making or could make for being a top seed. The other side wants more balance between the top teams, middle teams, and bottom teams. Some revenue system whether 'sharing' or 'additional' IS needed for GLB period! Many owner will just give up on owning teams and say 'screw it' I will never compete with this current system and they will just become players or even worse might just quit GLB all together. It is obvious that the gutted teams are a direct result of poor financial planning on the teams part and/or poor financial structure on the part of this game. One CAN be remedied by Bort and Company and that is why he is planning on implementing something this season.

Now what we REALLY need to discuss if we want to weigh in on that decision process AT ALL is solutions people. If we continue to argue back and forth on pages 26-29 what we argued on pages 1-4 and pages 5-9, etc then we are going nowhere and are like rats in a maze destined to FAIL!

So back to the discussion. If Jumbotron is poor idea and the revenue sharing of a 70/30 split with all concessions going to home team is a bad idea then can someone come up with a alternative suggestion that bridges the gap between those teams making tons of money and those making none (or just 100k of a bonus) because until that issue is resolved GLB will continue to decline slowly and lose more and more players and potential owners, etc and this combined with other non financially related issues and changes will cause many many very supportive (spends lots of money) people like myself to seek an alternative form of entertainment.
 
Knightman
offline
Link
 
I haven't seen a reason why the Jumbotron wouldn't address all concerns. It may be because I got confused by the digressions in some posts, or it may be my early Alzheimer's acting up, but the only argument against it that I thought caused any REAL problem was the one where the poster was worried about the effects of dumping so much extra money into the GLB economy. I addressed that as follows (reposting this in part since this was done late last night so folks reading now probably missed it):


One final attempt to make my point: I wouldn't have a philosophical problem with splitting revenue if, for example, all teams--whether in the playoffs or not--had an alternative way to generate revenue such as merchandising. If we had a merchandising vehicle where more successful teams would generate more money than losing teams in merchandise sales then that would reward good teams and serve as yet another incentive for bad teams to improve. This additional source of funds for the home playoff teams (as well as all the other teams) would offset the loss of ticket revenue from the game itself for the home team, would provide additional revenue from both tickets and merchandising for the lower seeded teams, and would more closely mirror "real life". However, implementing such a system would be VERRRY complicated, so for the sake of practicality, at least for now, I prefer a cleaner system like the Jumbotron. Lots less programming involved in that one and it addresses what is MY major concern of getting some more money into the hands of the lower seeds. Taking money away from the higher seeds on principle is less of a priority for me than it is for you.

Oh, and as an aside, if this idea would be conceptually acceptable to you too, then you have to concede that the argument that the Jumbotron option dumps excessive amounts of money into the GLB Universe (put forth by some proponents of revenue sharing) is not a valid one since merchandising would also be dumping money into the system. Whether the money came from Jumbotron or extra merchandise sales, it's still "new" money that hasn't been there before.


Conflicting viewpoints?
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by valakar
We know people on one side of the argument want either no change or 'additional revenue sources' or something that will not take from the income they are already making or could make for being a top seed. The other side wants more balance between the top teams, middle teams, and bottom teams.


I think this misses the third group, which likes rewarding teams for doing well but wants change to the economic system to also reward teams according to their league level -- which will make it possible for mediocre teams in higher leagues outrecruit winning teams in lower leagues, promoting competition at every league level.

That is where additional income sources become important. I agree that the difference between 4th and 5th place is pretty huge, and wouldn't mind seeing playoff rewards become more graduated. 70/30 split is great for that imo. But the major change needs to be revenue according to league level (also imo).
 
LionsLover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by valakar

We know people on one side of the argument want either no change or 'additional revenue sources' or something that will not take from the income they are already making or could make for being a top seed. The other side wants more balance between the top teams, middle teams, and bottom teams.


I think this misses the third group, which likes rewarding teams for doing well but wants change to the economic system to also reward teams according to their league level -- which will make it possible for mediocre teams in higher leagues outrecruit winning teams in lower leagues, promoting competition at every league level.

That is where additional income sources become important. I agree that the difference between 4th and 5th place is pretty huge, and wouldn't mind seeing playoff rewards become more graduated. 70/30 split is great for that imo. But the major change needs to be revenue according to league level (also imo).


Isn't there already a recruiting advantage being in a higher league? Thought so.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.