User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wide Open Incompletion Case Study - Intended to answer Borts questions about the frequency of this error
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Ok SCACE... That's cool man.

Sorry for the disagreement earlier, this whole thing has just been really frustrating for me.

Since the beginning of this entire thing, we've been having people telling us that they knew the problem, that they weren't having the problem, but we could still find the problem in their games.

We even went as far to open up TB22's QB build, because people were trying to say that our QB wasn't good enough.

Honestly, we've been dealing with this all year, and its just a bit aggravating, that its still not resolved at this time.
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 10:43:45
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
It doesn't matter what the build is though, again. catchable range is only so far out. If the ball will 'hit the ground' in the same tic it comes into 'catchable range' there is absolutely zero chance of a reception.

Jumping Catch means the ball can be thrown higher/over a defender. But if this were the case on these plays, the ball would also pass the receiver. Jumping catch thus does not increase the catchable range.

Diving Catch does not increase the range that a pass is considered catchable. It instead is providing a bonus to catch balls that are too low. If they are low enough and moving fast enough, the ball will hit the ground in the same tic that the ball is catchable, meaning 100% incompletion. No chance will ever be had to use this ability in this situation. In fact it is USELESS to spend points on Diving Catch because of this. The whole reason to have a diving catch is to catch the ball before it hits the ground within hundreths of a second of one another.

Only 1-Handed Catch increases the range at which you can consider a ball 'catchable' and its at the very end of the SA tree so expensive and per Bort, really wont be useful (like most all SA's) until it is at least seven or higher. And even then, with the speed and angles QB's are throwing the ball, the possible combination of a ball hitting the ground in the same tic it is within catchable range still exists, meaning that the hit the ground first code still makes even this SA, the most powerful receiver SA they can buy, pretty much a waste of points because in those occasions when you actually need it, it will not trigger 100% of the time because ball will be hitting the ground in the same tic.

increasing other attributes etc does not matter because again... no matter what your attributes.. you could have 100's in everything. A catchable ball that will hit the ground in the same tick will 100% never be considered catchable.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.


QFCPL
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 10:50:05
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.


Wow, thanks!
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.



Excellent stuff, good things come to those who wait

 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Bort

Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.



Excellent stuff, good things come to those who wait



like possibly missing WEPL playoffs because one's passing attack was accidentally nerfed all season.

Still, I'm glad that progress is being made.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Good news to me, I get about 4 of these incompletes per game, i'd rather them be drops personally. It just sucks to see the ball end right on top of your dot when you are wide open and get a incomplete.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdupuy3
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by Bort


Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.



Excellent stuff, good things come to those who wait



like possibly missing WEPL playoffs because one's passing attack was accidentally nerfed all season.

Still, I'm glad that progress is being made.


Your ID# is 20 something thousand. You've been around long enough to know Bort is still tinkering with this game.
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Originally posted by jdupuy3

Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Originally posted by Bort



Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.



Excellent stuff, good things come to those who wait



like possibly missing WEPL playoffs because one's passing attack was accidentally nerfed all season.

Still, I'm glad that progress is being made.


Your ID# is 20 something thousand. You've been around long enough to know Bort is still trying to fix a problem that's been a problem since week 1.


fixed
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Sorry folks, I've been in situations the last couple days where I wouldn't have a chance to be around to watch things if stuff went south on me after an update. I don't like to upload something and not have a chance to watch over it while it's running, for obvious reasons.

I'm testing it out on d league teams over the next cpl hours to make sure it doesn't break anything horribly, and then I can get it sent to the rest of the leagues tonight.


Ok, sounds good. Hopefully it'll work and we can go back to being a dominant team.

T
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdupuy3
like possibly missing WEPL playoffs because one's passing attack was accidentally nerfed all season.

Still, I'm glad that progress is being made.


I laughed. Game's been broken for at least 14 weeks and there's no uploading the fix because...it might break something. Guy's got a point.
 
Gladdy11
offline
Link
 
Thanks Bort!

My WR was horrible. I revamped all his equipment, and now i have to do it again!
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by jdupuy3

like possibly missing WEPL playoffs because one's passing attack was accidentally nerfed all season.

Still, I'm glad that progress is being made.


I laughed. Game's been broken for at least 14 weeks and there's no uploading the fix because...it might break something. Guy's got a point.


LOL
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Has the fix been uploaded? My team has been throwing medium depth more than we'd like most of this season due to the odd drops and non-catches when the ball goes right through our WR dot.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.