User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Proposed Energy Changes
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Bort,

Just wanted to say that as a team owner and a player, I am enjoying the complexities of the energy system. It is forcing teams to actually find ways to play their backups a decent number of plays to keep their starters from getting wiped out.

The only thing I might adjust would be the 60 energy minimum at the end of a game. If a starter plays all game, or too long, they should be really hurting. Yes, I know that isn't like real football, but it certainly adds more to the tactics in a game.

For example, we have two runningbacks that are pretty much the same build. The first guy ran against mostly starters, and averaged 3.8 yards a carry. The second guy with pretty much the same numbers ran mostly in the second half, and racked up 6.8 yards a carry.

It is very interesting.

PinTBC
 
Waltang
offline
Link
 
The new energy changes effect EVERY team. Stop your whining, adapt, and win. Every other team your playing is in the same boat. Other teams had more foresight and stocked up on backups before you? Well good for them, this isn't welfare football.

The game is in Beta, and we have to trust Bort to make the proper changes based on the LONGTERM best interest of the game, not based on a couple powergamers who dont like the fact their players cant play 100 snaps a game both ways and be at 100% energy every week.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Waltang
The new energy changes effect EVERY team. Stop your whining, adapt, and win. Every other team your playing is in the same boat. Other teams had more foresight and stocked up on backups before you? Well good for them, this isn't welfare football.

The game is in Beta, and we have to trust Bort to make the proper changes based on the LONGTERM best interest of the game, not based on a couple powergamers who dont like the fact their players cant play 100 snaps a game both ways and be at 100% energy every week.



I AGREE WITH THIS STATEMENT IT IS AFFECTING EVERYONE AND THEY ARE JUST MAKING THE CHANGES TO DEAL WITH IT
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TrevJo

To me, there's one thing that's broken about energy and it's this. As far as I can tell, players regain energy very quickly during the game, but very slowly in between games. That causes the following problem:
-Player A plays 30 starts with 100 energy and plays in the first half, and sits out the entire second half. By halftime he is down to 60 energy or so but by the end of the game he is back up to maybe 90 or even 100. It takes him a couple days of Normal or Intense training to get back to 100 energy.
-Identical player B plays the same 30 plays, but he plays them in the second half. At the end of the game he is down to 60 energy or so. It takes him a couple of days of Relaxed training just to get even close to 100 energy.

So the same two players could have the same workload but it seems to make a great difference as to how close to the end of the game it was.

If I am wrong, I would be happy for the admins to correct me. If I'm right, there should be some adjustment so that this doesn't happen.


Nope, the amount of plays takes a drain on the player's max energy level in the game, no matter when he plays them. That's the number that's used to determine the energy at the end of the game, not whatever his energy was at when the game ended.

The number you see at the end of the game is NOT the energy he had at the end of the game. It's based on the total amount of energy he used during the course of the game.


Great! Thanks.
 
Link
 
We have adjusted out sub settings and made a couple of other changes and all of our d-line guys ended with over 70 energy. And we won the game while holding the other team to 26 yards rushing. Tomorrow we play a really good team so we will see if this is really working for us.
 
Justafan
offline
Link
 
I am not complaining, I love the game and understand the changes completely, but with that said..

As a level 7 SS who played 48 plays I don't understand how I can drop the "max" allowed which I did. I had 27 stamina at the time, I leveled up and now will have abou 33 stamina prior to the next game and will see how it works.

When I was watching the play by play there is no way my guy would be gassed after what he did. We pitched a shut out and the offense on the other team didn't really do much. I understand reasons for losing energy based on plays, but as a saftey there are alot of plays where my player hardly does anything, he's not sheading blockers, he's not even involved in contact (I am a cover guy mostly, in the box/blitz mabey two or three times a game) and I don't see how I am losing the same energy as a DL or OL guy that's going at it every play.

Again, not a complaint and I have no idea how you would fix it, but it's a "game artificiality" that simply might not be able to be fixed. Overall I think this game and the developers are great and 99% of the community that post here at least "gets it" and understand how and why of the game. I am hooked!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Justafan
I am not complaining, I love the game and understand the changes completely, but with that said..

As a level 7 SS who played 48 plays I don't understand how I can drop the "max" allowed which I did. I had 27 stamina at the time, I leveled up and now will have abou 33 stamina prior to the next game and will see how it works.

When I was watching the play by play there is no way my guy would be gassed after what he did. We pitched a shut out and the offense on the other team didn't really do much. I understand reasons for losing energy based on plays, but as a saftey there are alot of plays where my player hardly does anything, he's not sheading blockers, he's not even involved in contact (I am a cover guy mostly, in the box/blitz mabey two or three times a game) and I don't see how I am losing the same energy as a DL or OL guy that's going at it every play.

Again, not a complaint and I have no idea how you would fix it, but it's a "game artificiality" that simply might not be able to be fixed. Overall I think this game and the developers are great and 99% of the community that post here at least "gets it" and understand how and why of the game. I am hooked!


i may be wrong but i have lots of players and the thing i noticed is some of my players that did get low in energy id idnt build evenly and i am thinking thats why they lost moe....maybe im wrong but something i seen and noticed with sme of my players

 
DdgDktaRlz
offline
Link
 
Change your training to Relaxed instead of Intense...... You will get 30 back between games instead of 6.
 
morphy
offline
Link
 
I could see in the future there being a difference between the energy stat (which would fluctuate throughout the game) and a "wear-and-tear" stat. Wear and Tear would affect how intensely you train between games and in the offseason, and its amount after a game would depend on stamina and how much participation is being done.

If you are playing against high level players, you should have more wear and tear from the effort. That way, stamina won't become a useless stat when we are all level 50.
 
Link
 
The issue with the energy isn't that people get tired ... it's that there's no concrete way to manage player's playing time.

For example, in real life football, players recoup energy with "breathers" on the sidelines. If the offensive mounts a long, 10 minute drive, the defense gets a chance to recoup energy and get their second wind.

If a running back breaks a 40 yard run, he takes a couple plays off and then gets back in when he's fresh.

This does not happen in the game. Instead, starters play the whole first half ... get winded, then have no chance to recover in the second half, forcing much of the second half to be determined by backups.

That's a problem.

The solution is to have all your starters actually play "backup" rolls ... then when the game is down to the fourth quarter and OT, you have your play makers in there and not your third string QB.

This is a BAD solution.

The issue is the coaches have no way to control substitution patterns. If we could set the levels position by position, even drive by drive, it would be better. That way we could, for example, yank a RB on a drive who's gassed so he's fresh for the next drive or later in the game.
 
Mike1709
offline
Link
 
or you just have a close sub in/out ratio that means that players rotate quickly in the second half and your starters aren't out of the game for too long at any one time. Lots of short breaks rather than one long one for the whole of the second half without reducing your back-ups playing time to any great degree
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash
The issue with the energy isn't that people get tired ... it's that there's no concrete way to manage player's playing time.

For example, in real life football, players recoup energy with "breathers" on the sidelines. If the offensive mounts a long, 10 minute drive, the defense gets a chance to recoup energy and get their second wind.

If a running back breaks a 40 yard run, he takes a couple plays off and then gets back in when he's fresh.

This does not happen in the game. Instead, starters play the whole first half ... get winded, then have no chance to recover in the second half, forcing much of the second half to be determined by backups.

That's a problem.

The solution is to have all your starters actually play "backup" rolls ... then when the game is down to the fourth quarter and OT, you have your play makers in there and not your third string QB.

This is a BAD solution.

The issue is the coaches have no way to control substitution patterns. If we could set the levels position by position, even drive by drive, it would be better. That way we could, for example, yank a RB on a drive who's gassed so he's fresh for the next drive or later in the game.


i agree we need to be able to control subbing in and out for more players individually not just the team bc some players with low stamina id sub more and so on

Last edited Apr 29, 2008 10:25:58
 
LordMortis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash
The issue with the energy isn't that people get tired ... it's that there's no concrete way to manage player's playing time.

For example, in real life football, players recoup energy with "breathers" on the sidelines. If the offensive mounts a long, 10 minute drive, the defense gets a chance to recoup energy and get their second wind.

If a running back breaks a 40 yard run, he takes a couple plays off and then gets back in when he's fresh.

This does not happen in the game. Instead, starters play the whole first half ... get winded, then have no chance to recover in the second half, forcing much of the second half to be determined by backups.

That's a problem.

The solution is to have all your starters actually play "backup" rolls ... then when the game is down to the fourth quarter and OT, you have your play makers in there and not your third string QB.

This is a BAD solution.

The issue is the coaches have no way to control substitution patterns. If we could set the levels position by position, even drive by drive, it would be better. That way we could, for example, yank a RB on a drive who's gassed so he's fresh for the next drive or later in the game.


While subbing could be better (and I am sure it will be over time), you need to recognize that a stamina of 30 is nothing. A 13th level player is still a rookie and the leagues are young. Coaches/Owners need to come up with more creative ways to sub players until their still rookie starters understand the importance of stamina and they need to work together to solve the problems. In the meantime, I've seen plenty of teams pulling successful 3 man rotations or disguising their starters as 2nd string. There is also the X/0 option that was used in the first season. Let your starters get a little gassed and keep them in. Just don't be surprised with then end the game at 60 energy. Then it's you just tweak the settings at X+10/0 or whatever week to week until you see your players getting to around 70. Options are there. You just have to figure out what you are trying to accomplish and then work toward that end the best way you can.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chuckmoyers
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash

The issue with the energy isn't that people get tired ... it's that there's no concrete way to manage player's playing time.

For example, in real life football, players recoup energy with "breathers" on the sidelines. If the offensive mounts a long, 10 minute drive, the defense gets a chance to recoup energy and get their second wind.

If a running back breaks a 40 yard run, he takes a couple plays off and then gets back in when he's fresh.

This does not happen in the game. Instead, starters play the whole first half ... get winded, then have no chance to recover in the second half, forcing much of the second half to be determined by backups.

That's a problem.

The solution is to have all your starters actually play "backup" rolls ... then when the game is down to the fourth quarter and OT, you have your play makers in there and not your third string QB.

This is a BAD solution.

The issue is the coaches have no way to control substitution patterns. If we could set the levels position by position, even drive by drive, it would be better. That way we could, for example, yank a RB on a drive who's gassed so he's fresh for the next drive or later in the game.


i agree we need to be able to control subbing in and out for more players individually not just the team bc some players with low stamina id sub more and so on



If the player has low stamina, then they will sub more than other players with higher stamina, with the same sub out settings.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Fat Daddy Cash
The issue with the energy isn't that people get tired ... it's that there's no concrete way to manage player's playing time.

This does not happen in the game. Instead, starters play the whole first half ... get winded, then have no chance to recover in the second half, forcing much of the second half to be determined by backups.

The solution is to have all your starters actually play "backup" rolls ... then when the game is down to the fourth quarter and OT, you have your play makers in there and not your third string QB.

This is a BAD solution.

The issue is the coaches have no way to control substitution patterns. If we could set the levels position by position, even drive by drive, it would be better. That way we could, for example, yank a RB on a drive who's gassed so he's fresh for the next drive or later in the game.


That isn't entirely true. I am having very good luck substitutiong and keeping everyone on my team freash, at least after the first couple games. If you don't want your starters exhausted for the second half, there are definate options to take care of this. I need to watch the sim of the second game yet, but everyone on the team came out with more than 70 energy left, and if it played out at all like the first game did, my starters and subs played equal minutes throughout the game.

And for the record, my team purposefully isn't going nuts on stamina.

PinTBC
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.