User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
War_Shock
offline
Link
 
season 4's not that bad...
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
My stance is that if you sell someone SPEED and the obvious effectiveness that it had (at the time) and don't bother telling me that you are going to change it, then do it with no remorse...

It is the same as the gas staion letting my fill my tank, pay, then coming out and removing half of the gas that I just paid you for, and telling me that you will be offering no refund of any kind.

Some people are going to be looking around for a cop, because they just got robbed.

Say what you want about it being a Beta game, but these people paid good money for the full product that was in front of them, and then had it taken away from them.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
I may have to go on strike, and remove my avatar (I know, nobody wants that). I would like to know how a level 4 OT can hold a lvl 30 DE from getting a sack, and keeping him to only 1 hurry.
 
megaman1337
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


In all honesty, has anyone considered that this isn't the case? Granted, he should and probably does make money off of the game, but if this was such the cash cow that you guys are making it out to be, answer me one question.

HOW COME NOT ONE OF THE "BIG GAMING" COMPANIES, have done it? It can't be they don't have the programmers, it can't be they don't have the resources, it can't be they never thought of it, cmon, think realistically here, big game companies, PAY PEOPLE to create games and ideas, you don't think ONE of them out of the thousands, didn't think of this beforehand?



That's the same type of mindset that stops inventions before they start. It's entirely possible for a regular joe to find untapped markets with their inventions before large companies do. It happens all the time with what one would think could be the most obvious invention in the world, yet average joe creates it first and makes millions. Bort found a niche that was largely, if not completely untapped, and because of that can charge whatever he wants. That is until competent competition emerges...
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Could I get a link for the post on jumping being a needed attribute for punters? Bort has always said that if it makes sense, then it's probably accurate, and jumping for punters makes zero sense.

T
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Back to the topic of KRs - and using oldskool's TOS thing about exploiting being classed as cheating - well, what do you call the number of people using HBs and other associated big, slow, strong guys as KRs?

Surely that's exploiting the fact that the power running game rules all and 'real' KRs can't do shit??

And finally, because it's just turning into another pissing contest.

Sjmay - READ my post about my REALISTIC players that I am now finding are next to useless - that ISN'T me exploiting things. I have NO min/max players - and for the most part my players are fine - but whilst the exploiters are STILL prospering as they bounce from loophole to loophole, my guys are suffering in the backlash....

And on that topic, seeing as you now have 'the answer' about how to make the KR game work thanks to the PM off GoVikings - are you going to make a PUBLIC thread about it so that we ALL can benefit (you know, like you're telling me to do) or are you going to keep it to yourself??

I mean, there's obviously SOME bit of info that makes the difference between shit KRs and 50+ yarders, so surely it should be info that ALL can use??
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foshizzel17
I dont analyze every play tho, i look at the overall effect and make a conclusion on my next course of action from there.


Well overall our team doesn't get pressure - though we got pressure the first 3 games in the season. I was trying to figure out why, because I didn't really change anything and couldn't figure out why our players are rushing like retards and bunching up instead of spreading out.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by somecut8

Well, see your LE goes to the outside of the OT - which is what I want. Ours go to the inside. It shouldn't have to do with the build because even if he has a bad build, he can still go to the outside - he'll just be blocked by the OT instead of beating the OT.

See, no DE rushes up the field and outside of the OT, they rush to the inside: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=96093&pbp_id=3678805


It does have to do with how their pass rush is set up, elusive will go around, bullrush will, well does what it sounds like lol.

And yes, builds have a lot to do with it.


Ok, I've told all my DEs to use elusive. I better see their first step be up the field instead of going towards the guard. This should have nothing to do with build - you can have 1 speed and 1 agility and your first step can still be up the field instead of going inside.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Respecs aren't going to happen.

If they cost money, people will bitch that it's not fair you have to pay for "reaiming at a moving target", so they need to be free.

If they happen during the season, people bitch that it makes scouting impossible due to "reaiming at a moving target" (sound familiar?), so you have to limit them to the offseason.


I'll say it again, because you appear to not have a clue about game development. Or running a successful software development company. Or building a successful software product.

The current strategy that Bort is using isn't really testing his game (according to any known software testing methodology that has ever been deemed successful). If Bort wants his game tested, he needs people to TEST it, not PLAY it. Maybe you are too ignorant to know why those aren't the same things. I don't know. I've been developing and testing software for 15 years, and I've beta tested a dozen or so games. I understand that playing a game and testing a game aren't the same thing.

I also understand that because of the cost of this game, I'm not going to spend my time testing. I'm going to spend my time playing. Which again, is not the same thing. To test the game, you need respecs. Lots of them. If someone was beta testing a FPS game, and was testing the final level - would they be forced to play through the other 25 levels in the game EVERY TIME? Or would the developers give them a cheat code to jump to the level - because they are more concerned about the tester testing the level, rather than playing the other 25 levels?

How are the testers supposed to test all the various permutations of Lvl 40 player builds in this game for high-level balancing? Make a Lvl 1 player and play him for a year and a half? That's fucking stupid if your goal is getting your game tested.

A tester needs cheat codes (in this case, respecs, the ability to change levels, etc.) to get this game tested. This game needs to be tested, and the current methodology isn't going to cut it. So something has to change. All Bort has to do is to set this kind of testing environment up OUTSIDE the environment that the paying customers are playing in and everyone can be happy. You don't have to cry like a little bitch about respecs, and we don't have to cry like little bitches about sim instability.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Back to the topic of KRs - and using oldskool's TOS thing about exploiting being classed as cheating - well, what do you call the number of people using HBs and other associated big, slow, strong guys as KRs?

Surely that's exploiting the fact that the power running game rules all and 'real' KRs can't do shit??

And finally, because it's just turning into another pissing contest.

Sjmay - READ my post about my REALISTIC players that I am now finding are next to useless - that ISN'T me exploiting things. I have NO min/max players - and for the most part my players are fine - but whilst the exploiters are STILL prospering as they bounce from loophole to loophole, my guys are suffering in the backlash....

And on that topic, seeing as you now have 'the answer' about how to make the KR game work thanks to the PM off GoVikings - are you going to make a PUBLIC thread about it so that we ALL can benefit (you know, like you're telling me to do) or are you going to keep it to yourself??

I mean, there's obviously SOME bit of info that makes the difference between shit KRs and 50+ yarders, so surely it should be info that ALL can use??


Chaos,

Never thought about using either of our power backs, on Stockholm or Shanghai as a returner, til now lol.

As far as KR being effective, GoViking made an interesting revelation, I will PM it to ya. Not my formula, not mine to make public, if he wants to, I'm all for it.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by superpunk

My team went from absolutely sucking, to being a playoff team, straight back to sucking again.

What's great is there's almost no way to know why. We are the same team we were last season, just added a few good players who are playing well.

It's all a big mystery - like the female orgasm. I thought we were in like flint with the importance of balanced builds, we stomped our competition in the preseason, regular season hits - we suck ass.

Bummer.


We are in the same boat, expansion team 5-11, playoff team 12-4, we are now 3-3-1, it sucks lol, but that has more to do with the AI and certain builds than the game just randomly being changed.


I thought more of a focus on balanced builds would really help us. Looked that way after the preseason and our first three games.

Not so.

Backfired.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by oldskool

Respecs aren't going to happen.

If they cost money, people will bitch that it's not fair you have to pay for "reaiming at a moving target", so they need to be free.

If they happen during the season, people bitch that it makes scouting impossible due to "reaiming at a moving target" (sound familiar?), so you have to limit them to the offseason.


I'll say it again, because you appear to not have a clue about game development. Or running a successful software development company. Or building a successful software product.

The current strategy that Bort is using isn't really testing his game (according to any known software testing methodology that has ever been deemed successful). If Bort wants his game tested, he needs people to TEST it, not PLAY it. Maybe you are too ignorant to know why those aren't the same things. I don't know. I've been developing and testing software for 15 years, and I've beta tested a dozen or so games. I understand that playing a game and testing a game aren't the same thing.

I also understand that because of the cost of this game, I'm not going to spend my time testing. I'm going to spend my time playing. Which again, is not the same thing. To test the game, you need respecs. Lots of them. If someone was beta testing a FPS game, and was testing the final level - would they be forced to play through the other 25 levels in the game EVERY TIME? Or would the developers give them a cheat code to jump to the level - because they are more concerned about the tester testing the level, rather than playing the other 25 levels?

How are the testers supposed to test all the various permutations of Lvl 40 player builds in this game for high-level balancing? Make a Lvl 1 player and play him for a year and a half? That's fucking stupid if your goal is getting your game tested.

A tester needs cheat codes (in this case, respecs, the ability to change levels, etc.) to get this game tested. This game needs to be tested, and the current methodology isn't going to cut it. So something has to change. All Bort has to do is to set this kind of testing environment up OUTSIDE the environment that the paying customers are playing in and everyone can be happy. You don't have to cry like a little bitch about respecs, and we don't have to cry like little bitches about sim instability.




Well said...I sure hope Bort reads that post!

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Chaos,

PM sent, I don't know how effective is yet, haven't had a game run yet with it.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
sjmay - PM me the details - I'd be happy to see what the fuss is about............

BTW - I'm now exploiting the game myself now (as there's no other choice been left by the game designers), as I'm playing my unpowerful KR guys on 'combo' - when, in fact, they have no actual abilities in that department. But, guess what?? They now cut better, make better moves and break tackles that they simply SHOULDN'T be doing if they were 'realistic' - but seeing as how two of my teams have just lost to BS ST plays, it's the old 'If you can't beat them, join them' adage.

Which, incidentally, brings me to Runningmn9's comments about 'testing'

NONE of us are testing, as we generally want to win. Some of us may be doing the odd experiment with players, but if we were really TESTING we'd playing FBs at QB, punters on the O line, etc - and then reporting back whether these hugely unrealistic settings were actually turning out to be better than the intended settings...

THAT would be testing.

As would throwing every point into vision, or jumping or whatever - just to confirm that STUPID builds don't gain an advantage (why did it take three whole seasons for the max speed exploit to come to light?? Why did none of the 'alpha' testers point it out??.

What has happened in 'alpha' is that a load of 'good ole boys' have had a play around and all tried to create an 'uber' team without actually 'testing' anything.

Some of them, if they found an exploit or a 'feature' that didn't work realistically, made sure they abused the crap out of it before it got found out. THAT ISN'T TESTING!! If this wasn't true, then we simply wouldn't have so many of the min/maxxers we did last year, as the exploit would have been fixed almost immediatley.

And now what's happeneing is that lots more people who probably like to brag that they're 'beta testers' THINK they're testing a game, when in fact they're not.

They're PAYING to PLAY a game that doesn't yet work as it should. And constant changes are taking place IN SPITE of them, not BECAUSE of them..........

I've beta tested games in the past - and I can assure you that ISN'T what I'm doing here. If I was, I'd have ALL min/max players with some stupid arsed attribute tables that bore NO resemblence to reality.

 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Got the PM - thanks for that....
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.