User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
And there is the whole problem. You will be deciding on whether yourselves violated the rule that yourselves drafted. I think it is a foregone conclusion as to the outcome of this inquiry.


Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Sorry - but you'll have to forgive me this one comment....

Does your actual 'honesty' depend on who you know??


Little problem with this: If you guys already think that every Mod is out to cheat and keep every other player down, there's nothing I can actually say to prove otherwise. So you either have to trust that Bort picked good Mods and tries to keep everyone honest or you're just not going to trust any of us. There's not much which can be done beyond that.

Originally posted by oldskool
OK, we'll roleplay.
Given my example PM:

Originally posted by lame excuse that apparently is acceptable and will not result in punishment

I'm going to paypal everyone on my GMed team $10. Because they're all my friends! That's why they always re-sign with me year after year, we're buddies like that. I love my friends.

Oh uh, that new guy we just signed? Also my friend. That's why he got $10. Because I love my friends. Remember?

...is this person suspended? Banned? Reprimanded?


Well, if I saw it posted publicly, then I would assume the only reason for that to happen is so others find out that this owner is paying out FP and it's a thinly-veiled attempt to use that as a recruiting tool.

If that was posted privately, then someone would have to PM it to me for me to see it, in which case, the person PM'ing me would most likely have some sort of other evidence that these people were/n't all friends. If not, I'd ask the admins to look into certain factors to determine it.
 
Enders
offline
Link
 
I think this is an extremely good (and needed) rule. Flex Points being part of trades would just mean that the teams that had the richest owners would be the best teams in the game. Whats the fun in that?

If you have a problem with this, stop sucking at recruiting imo. Go out and start putting time and effort into recruiting Free Agents instead of just saying "I'll give you XXXX amount of Flex Points if you join me!"
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
You do realize that this entire conundrum can be avoided by simply banning all fp transactions.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
You do realize that this entire conundrum can be avoided by simply banning all fp transactions.


Yes, and I've said 3 times now that banning them all is a possibility that is being discussed, but has not been decided upon yet. Until there are any rule changes, we will go with and enforce the current rules.
 
po
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enders
I think this is an extremely good (and needed) rule. Flex Points being part of trades would just mean that the teams that had the richest owners would be the best teams in the game. Whats the fun in that?

If you have a problem with this, stop sucking at recruiting imo. Go out and start putting time and effort into recruiting Free Agents instead of just saying "I'll give you XXXX amount of Flex Points if you join me!"


Why some people dont have the time to put 20 hours a day into recruiting. Just like other sports money talks.

I dont see though how this is any different though than 4 friends or even 1 person owning an entire team and just destroying the competition, like a team in my conference did this season.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Jed - I believe you are a GOOD mod - and seem to be an honest one too.

Shame that you are having to take the flak for the dishonest and/or juvenile ones, but there's a simple answer to that......

Question is, how important is it to Bort that this game is seen to be one built on integrity compared to not wanting to upset a couple of people??

It's not your call to make, but it's a call that needs to be made by someone.

Either way, it won't be ME that's losing any money because of the actions of a couple of selfish people, so all I'm trying to do is highlight the situation as I see it.............

 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Thanks, I'm really trying here

There's a fine line to dance on any rules, especially ones as controversial as this one. You want to make the penalties harsh enough to deter people from breaking the rules, but at the same time, it's a much more friendly place if every rule doesn't end with "and if you break this, YOU'RE BANNED FOREVER!!!!!"

This rule may be one of them which requires that, but one step at a time. We wanted to get some reaction to this rule first and see what enforcing it was going to be like.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
We wanted to get some reaction to this rule first and see what enforcing it was going to be like.


Then why did you all sign off on it if you weren't sure it was ready >_<

We've been had!
 
po
offline
Link
 
I just dont really get why I guess.

To me its no different than a guy owning his entire team or two or 3 guys owning the entire team. I would love to see a rule where a player can only own 3 guys on any given team. Thats a rule I would love to see. Not a sportsmanship penalty a rule disallowing one owner to have 3 players on one team.

If winning means that much to them let them spend the money.

I am not going to spend that money, but some people arent that good at recruiting. I know I am not.

I just would think GLB would be for it. Gifting FP would help generate more money for GLB. I would just make it so you cant gift the original 400 FP or any FP that are given away as a gift (i.e. holiday, EOS)

Thats just my two cents. I certainly have no intention of giving people money to play a fake game on my team. I ll build my own players before I do that. Cuz then when they leave in a season it was 10 bucks that you might as well have just lit on fire.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 15:53:52
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Then why did you all sign off on it if you weren't sure it was ready >_<

We've been had!


We were all sure that, anyone who would be caught in the net of this rule would definitely deserve a suspension like discussed. It's easier to have a looser net like this and, if we need, tighten it (have I mentioned yet that there's some discussion of that yet? ) if needed. So if there are loopholes left open which are needed to be addressed or if the penalty is not severe enough, it can always be changed later to be more strict.


And to Po: I guess it's just 2 different views, but that's not the same in our eyes. In one case, it can give one team a gigantic advantage and the integrity of the whole game can be put into jeopardy. In the other, unless the owner of all those players knows more than every single person on the other teams he's facing knows about their players put together, there's not as significant of an advantage. But it is still against the spirit of the game, so something is being put in place to discourage it. If, even with the new rules, it turns into a larger issue, the rules can always be revisited to look at a harsher penalty.
 
Enders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by po
Originally posted by Enders

I think this is an extremely good (and needed) rule. Flex Points being part of trades would just mean that the teams that had the richest owners would be the best teams in the game. Whats the fun in that?

If you have a problem with this, stop sucking at recruiting imo. Go out and start putting time and effort into recruiting Free Agents instead of just saying "I'll give you XXXX amount of Flex Points if you join me!"


Why some people dont have the time to put 20 hours a day into recruiting. Just like other sports money talks.

I dont see though how this is any different though than 4 friends or even 1 person owning an entire team and just destroying the competition, like a team in my conference did this season.


I don't spend 20 hours recruiting and I do just fine. Just figure out how to present your team in the way the player wants. Its not hard.

Why should owners be forced to spend money on other players?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Side note: I also support a complete reset.



I don't think a complete reset has to be done.

All that has to be done.

1. Strip all players off all rosters.
2. Take away all stadium upgrades.
3. Remove all equipment and cash from every player and start them out with $2500 regardless of level.
4. Give every team $3 million at start the offseason before ticket sales.
5. Open the doors for stadium building and recruiting for everyone at the same time.

Players don't all have to be reset to 0. Just make it very hard for a handful of teams to horde all the top level players and remain financially successful.

 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed


We were all sure that, anyone who would be caught in the net of this rule would definitely deserve a suspension like discussed. It's easier to have a looser net like this and, if we need, tighten it (have I mentioned yet that there's some discussion of that yet? ) if needed. So if there are loopholes left open which are needed to be addressed or if the penalty is not severe enough, it can always be changed later to be more strict.



So, essentially, the current rule will remain in place long enough for those who it was designed to benefit to have squeezed everything they can from it until the public outrage reaches a level when finally all FP transactions will be banned giving those who took advantage of the rule the ability to say "it wasn't against the rules then."

"Well, we know this rule isn't strict enough, but we still want to be able to dominate for at least a few more seasons, so we won't make it apply to us yet."

"stop trying to find loopholes. - this is a rule. not a negotiation."
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 19:41:48
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Jed



We were all sure that, anyone who would be caught in the net of this rule would definitely deserve a suspension like discussed. It's easier to have a looser net like this and, if we need, tighten it (have I mentioned yet that there's some discussion of that yet? ) if needed. So if there are loopholes left open which are needed to be addressed or if the penalty is not severe enough, it can always be changed later to be more strict.



So, essentially, the current rule will remain in place long enough for those who it was designed to benefit to have squeezed everything they can from it until the public outrage reaches a level when finally all FP transactions will be banned giving those who took advantage of the rule the ability to say "it wasn't against the rules then."

"Well, we know this rule isn't strict enough, but we still want to be able to dominate for at least a few more seasons, so we won't make it apply to us yet."

"stop trying to find loopholes. - this is a rule. not a negotiation."


The only thing that is gonna make you happy is A. get your one player into the USA PRO league, or B. remove all the mods,

Seriously, let the mods talk without putting words into their mouth or trying to twist their words, and you wonder why you come off like an asshole sometimes.
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
All I know is Jed is all for the communitys best interest. When I brought this topic up at first, he was the one who I think brought it to the other mods and admins attention. Also, if you look he is the one here telling us they are currently discussing a harsher penalty. Once that is in place theres only one more thing left and this rule will be fine, and that is banning all "gift" FP transactions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.