User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Test Server Discussion > Potential Changes (things we're testing)
Page:
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
And another few:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981721&pbp_id=57385
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981721&pbp_id=57641
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981721&pbp_id=57833

I don't know how I can make it any clearer. I posted exactly what you asked for and you just don't want to see it.

That build (a non-STOP archetype btw) is built pretty damn well to block on special teams. If 90+ blocking and 22.5% Hold Block isn't enough hold a block for more than a second than something is way off. By all means please continue with your tirade though. It is most amusing.


Don't waste your time mere. He's just trolling. I've already proven by the numbers that returns were fine. If anything a slight nerf to KR TDs (with a corresponding boost to average) and a huge buff to PR TDs was in order.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Is this supposed to be a haiku?


its an emphatic statement of fact.
imagine prez Obama saying it, a good 3 or 4 second pause between every other word,
long enough so even the slow ppl can catch on...
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by merenoise

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2093278

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981553&pbp_id=40654

Now please quietly exit this thread with your tail between your legs and stop pretending that you know what you are talking about.


He didnt whiff the block. He connected. Strength isnt really that high to continue to hold the block much longer than he did. Been watching a ton of ST's replays over the last hour and STOP's are generally too average at everything so they are more good for wedge guys than first wavers. Most of them are getting caked or arent able to hold the block very long. But its because of your blocking being that high and your % AEQ that you at the very least are connecting and impeding a gunner for a moment.


Not my dot, it is Time Trial's, was just pointing out that dots built specifically to block on special teams with over 90 blocking and hold block AEQ aren't really impeding the progress of dots much more effectively than dots without it.

I don't think they should automatically be able to hold the block indefinitely, or that they should always be able to impede the coverage team but if dots which are pretty specialized can't get it done what chance do dots that aren't optimized have to ever make any kind of difference in the blocking on KRs?
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Don't waste your time mere. He's just trolling. I've already proven by the numbers that returns were fine. If anything a slight nerf to KR TDs (with a corresponding boost to average) and a huge buff to PR TDs was in order.


this is what they are trying to do

KRs wont be effected as much, except you have unspecialized guys vs specialized guys out there,
you need to adjust
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
its an emphatic statement of fact.
imagine prez Obama saying it, a good 3 or 4 second pause between every other word,
long enough so even the slow ppl can catch on...


You aren't Obama and this is the internet. You'll get a better response if you don't type like a retard.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
this is what they are trying to do

KRs wont be effected as much, except you have unspecialized guys vs specialized guys out there,
you need to adjust


Actually they aren't trying to do this. They are completely nerfing KR returns to a point where both the average yards per return and TDs per attempt will be less than realistic which goes along with the fact that the average yards per punt return and average TD per punt return are well below realistic levels. Prior to the change there was at least the trade off where more KR TDs made up for the terrible PR sim, but now they have completely destroyed STs.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Not my dot, it is Time Trial's, was just pointing out that dots built specifically to block on special teams with over 90 blocking and hold block AEQ aren't really impeding the progress of dots much more effectively than dots without it.

I don't think they should automatically be able to hold the block indefinitely, or that they should always be able to impede the coverage team but if dots which are pretty specialized can't get it done what chance do dots that aren't optimized have to ever make any kind of difference in the blocking on KRs?


i get that that is what USED TO WORK.
but it shouldn't work if the player yr trying to block is gonna break free on a regular play,
just becuz its ST... 100 strength and 90 block is not really enough to get it done for long periods,
against top players... thats just how it is. sux we all have to adjust now,
but we all do, so thats that
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
And another few:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981721&pbp_id=57385
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981721&pbp_id=57641
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981721&pbp_id=57833

I don't know how I can make it any clearer. I posted exactly what you asked for and you just don't want to see it.

That build (a non-STOP archetype btw) is built pretty damn well to block on special teams. If 90+ blocking and 22.5% Hold Block isn't enough hold a block for more than a second than something is way off. By all means please continue with your tirade though. It is most amusing.


He holds the block for 7 ticks in replay 1.
12 ticks in replay 2.
Only 3 ticks in replay 3. So pretty much a whiff there.

He only has 109 strength and his connection has happened in every replay you have shown. He just isn't going to hold guys forever. Thats realistic ST's man.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981484&pbp_id=44759

The difference between our full blown STOP's and guys that are built to actually block is night and day here.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
Actually they aren't trying to do this. They are completely nerfing KR returns to a point where both the average yards per return and TDs per attempt will be less than realistic which goes along with the fact that the average yards per punt return and average TD per punt return are well below realistic levels. Prior to the change there was at least the trade off where more KR TDs made up for the terrible PR sim, but now they have completely destroyed STs.


no they haven't.
now you need some guys who are ST blocking specialists,
AND ST tackling specialists. thats MORE ST

why don't you dummies wait to see how this plays out before you fly off the handle?
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Not my dot, it is Time Trial's, was just pointing out that dots built specifically to block on special teams with over 90 blocking and hold block AEQ aren't really impeding the progress of dots much more effectively than dots without it.

I don't think they should automatically be able to hold the block indefinitely, or that they should always be able to impede the coverage team but if dots which are pretty specialized can't get it done what chance do dots that aren't optimized have to ever make any kind of difference in the blocking on KRs?


Except they are. As I just showed.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
He holds the block for 7 ticks in replay 1.
12 ticks in replay 2.
Only 3 ticks in replay 3. So pretty much a whiff there.

He only has 109 strength and his connection has happened in every replay you have shown. He just isn't going to hold guys forever. Thats realistic ST's man.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1981484&pbp_id=44759

The difference between our full blown STOP's and guys that are built to actually block is night and day here.


bleeding head idiot and texas hothead,
you trolls are wrong.
this guy is right.
listen to him
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by darncat
no, they are not.
they are mostly blitz DEs, with one balanced in there
not a single STOPs amongst all those DEs who are blocking,
and they are under-leveled to boot...
are u even paying attention to what yr posting?!?


uhhhh....most defensive "STOPs" use more advantageous archetypes. STOP archetype is for the clueless and o-linemen STOPs.

So they are under leveled...a nice thing about STOPs is the 15% bonus from the special teamer VA...add 15% to all of their attributes and see if they are still under-leveled. Under-leveled STOPS are definitely viable in higher level leagues...it is one of the few positions where I will take an under plateau player on a WL/Pro team.

Really we can ignore those replays...they do not matter. I am not raging about this because I want some sort of unfair advantage on either side of STs. I know GLB STs...I have focused on STs for the teams I coordinate since S3. My interest is in seeing a balanced STs, I want to see STs where there is at least some strategy and some reward for having better STOPs/returner/depth chart setup.

STs balance was pretty close last season...few too many kickoff TDs, not enough punt return TDs, FF STOPs were suitably nerfed from previous seasons only forcing a few fumbles each in a season. The kickoff TDs could have been fixed with one minor change (no sideline kickoffs, no very short kickoffs...probably would have knocked ~30-40% off the totals). PRs could have been improved by giving the SE1/2 a little better chance to hold blocks on the gunners. Special teams fixed...small changes...still strategy...painless...everyone happy.

Do not understand the reason or advantage to nuking STs when it was so close to good? I watched one replay this morning and I was like WTF is going on here...who broke kickoff coverage??? So now blocking/hold block% are all-important for the return game. Most teams already had their kickoff returns full of o-linemen except for the BW which requires players nearly as fast as the returner or the returner runs past them into the coverage. Problem is now linemen are not holding blocks nearly as effectively and low blocking fast players seem basically invisible in the BW.

If you think about real football, both sides of STs are generally populated by low blocking defensive players like LBs and secondary players...speed has always been the number one attribute on STs. Players do not need to really hold blocks...they just need to get in the way and provide screens/lanes. Most NFL coverage teams do hold lanes because returners are more apt to east/west movement.

With these changes the coverage is dominant/unbalanced on kickoffs. Need a lot of fast blockers w/hb% to have any chance...generally the only fast blockers on a GLB roster are a blocking FB and sometimes a combo TE...and the rare blocking focused STOP. Usually not more than 2 or 3 on a roster. So basically STs kickoff return game is dead...return TDs will come on the rare case where the returner cuts on a group of defenders and gets an outside lane. It looks like it will be normal for 5-10 defenders to crush the BW. Coverage is so easy that I really do not think STOPs are going to be necessary...minimally can pull back from 3 to 2 on most teams.

An unnecessary bad change imo...thought Catch was hired because he understood the actual play dynamics of the game??? not seeing it...
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
uhhhh....most defensive "STOPs" use more advantageous archetypes. STOP archetype is for the clueless and o-linemen STOPs.

So they are under leveled...a nice thing about STOPs is the 15% bonus from the special teamer VA...add 15% to all of their attributes and see if they are still under-leveled. Under-leveled STOPS are definitely viable in higher level leagues...it is one of the few positions where I will take an under plateau player on a WL/Pro team.

Really we can ignore those replays...they do not matter. I am not raging about this because I want some sort of unfair advantage on either side of STs. I know GLB STs...I have focused on STs for the teams I coordinate since S3. My interest is in seeing a balanced STs, I want to see STs where there is at least some strategy and some reward for having better STOPs/returner/depth chart setup.

STs balance was pretty close last season...few too many kickoff TDs, not enough punt return TDs, FF STOPs were suitably nerfed from previous seasons only forcing a few fumbles each in a season. The kickoff TDs could have been fixed with one minor change (no sideline kickoffs, no very short kickoffs...probably would have knocked ~30-40% off the totals). PRs could have been improved by giving the SE1/2 a little better chance to hold blocks on the gunners. Special teams fixed...small changes...still strategy...painless...everyone happy.

Do not understand the reason or advantage to nuking STs when it was so close to good? I watched one replay this morning and I was like WTF is going on here...who broke kickoff coverage??? So now blocking/hold block% are all-important for the return game. Most teams already had their kickoff returns full of o-linemen except for the BW which requires players nearly as fast as the returner or the returner runs past them into the coverage. Problem is now linemen are not holding blocks nearly as effectively and low blocking fast players seem basically invisible in the BW.

If you think about real football, both sides of STs are generally populated by low blocking defensive players like LBs and secondary players...speed has always been the number one attribute on STs. Players do not need to really hold blocks...they just need to get in the way and provide screens/lanes. Most NFL coverage teams do hold lanes because returners are more apt to east/west movement.

With these changes the coverage is dominant/unbalanced on kickoffs. Need a lot of fast blockers w/hb% to have any chance...generally the only fast blockers on a GLB roster are a blocking FB and sometimes a combo TE...and the rare blocking focused STOP. Usually not more than 2 or 3 on a roster. So basically STs kickoff return game is dead...return TDs will come on the rare case where the returner cuts on a group of defenders and gets an outside lane. It looks like it will be normal for 5-10 defenders to crush the BW. Coverage is so easy that I really do not think STOPs are going to be necessary...minimally can pull back from 3 to 2 on most teams.

An unnecessary bad change imo...thought Catch was hired because he understood the actual play dynamics of the game??? not seeing it...


Don't bother. He's about as sharp as a jelly donut.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
the reason is, what doesnt work on the field of play shouldnt on ST
90 and 100 wont get it done vs an elite player built for a specialized purpose.
it just wont. you know this...
so why should it be different on ST? it shouldn't and WON'T anymore. thats good.
ST stats will be the same if you can put in some guys who can really block.
some 2 way STOPers will be useful but most probably wont anymore.
thats too bad but its real. find me a real NFL team that uses FS for their wedge blocks
and i will show you a big pile of suck. no, you guys need to quit complaining,
and realize that their is offensive ST and defensive ST, and few can do both at the highest level.
 
darncat
offline
Link
 
90 and 100 wont get it done.
crybabies go cry a river
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.