User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Proof that Agility, Catching and Vision are overrated. Level 18 WR dominates higher level corners build revealed. (Colon Grifter)
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by Maddoc




It is not, however, because Speed is too good.

It is because secondary skills are not IMPORTANT enough. Same deal with a lot of positions.


Fixed



Same deal, really


Kind of. It is a matter of which end you look at it from though. Saying they are not good enough means that you should get exceptional ability as the attribute gets higher. Saying they are not important enough means that you think a player should suck at something when the attribute is lower.

For instance, catching and vision for WRs. There is no need to have 3rd capped catching because WRs can catch 95+% of passes with 50-55 catching if other skills are high enough. Vision doesn't even need to be capped (well it might now but that is yet to be seen)

 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Either way that's what I meant

The problem is that there's no incentive to spread out stats. We're getting there, but very slowly.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Bort did something to the drops, so builds that had drop problems in previous seasons aren't having the problem anymore. So hopefully nobody put points in sure hands because it isn't needed.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Bort did something to the drops, so builds that had drop problems in previous seasons aren't having the problem anymore. So hopefully nobody put points in sure hands because it isn't needed.


Until the sim changes drastically mid-season and everyone cries because they go all butterfingers all of a sudden.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
Sincerely if the GLB sim is about only 1 attribute is a shame


Currently it is.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Speed isn't "too" good. It's exactly where it ought to be. The problem is that many people took the Speed nerf (especially CB's and Safeties) as a sign that they didn't have to build Speed anymore and that 80 Speed, 80 Agility would help you shut down someone with 110 Speed and 50 Agility. Not the case. First Step counters the low agility, so if you can't keep up with 110 Speed (95+ Speed CB's) you're gonna get burned very consistently vs. an ultra speed player. That is why more often then not, the fastest guys on the field are at WR and CB in the NFL (RB too, but that's irrelevant here).

Still, I do also remember a lot of people saying that Grifter would be terrible in later seasons because of the one-sided build, and it's funny to watch him lead a Pro League, one of the better Pro Leagues, too. I wonder what next season will have for him. USA Pro? Continue in Can Pro? SA Pro?

I want to make my WR in the same template but I know he wouldn't fit into my OC's offense.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by nightmaresabin

Colon Grifter is badass.



He pwns weaker teams. He doesn't do as well against quality opponents. He is still a very good to great WR and most teams would love to have him, but he may not be the best WR on that team.


I'd say this statement is accurate.

Grifter has only played two teams with winning records. The results weren't pretty. 2 catches for 10.5 yds and 0 TD in one and 5 catches for 79.5 and 0 TD in the other. The two 300+ yard games against the worst teams in the league severely skew his stats. He's a 70 yard a game WR at that level. Not bad, but nowhere near dominant.

 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Speed isn't "too" good. It's exactly where it ought to be. The problem is that many people took the Speed nerf (especially CB's and Safeties) as a sign that they didn't have to build Speed anymore and that 80 Speed, 80 Agility would help you shut down someone with 110 Speed and 50 Agility. Not the case. First Step counters the low agility, so if you can't keep up with 110 Speed (95+ Speed CB's) you're gonna get burned very consistently vs. an ultra speed player. That is why more often then not, the fastest guys on the field are at WR and CB in the NFL (RB too, but that's irrelevant here).

Still, I do also remember a lot of people saying that Grifter would be terrible in later seasons because of the one-sided build, and it's funny to watch him lead a Pro League, one of the better Pro Leagues, too. I wonder what next season will have for him. USA Pro? Continue in Can Pro? SA Pro?

I want to make my WR in the same template but I know he wouldn't fit into my OC's offense.


I can make him fit in mine so make him and sign with the Bulldogs.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
sadly, GLB seems to have come full circle on speed, and though this post is old.. it is relevant again.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock


Grifter has only played two teams with winning records. The results weren't pretty. 2 catches for 10.5 yds and 0 TD in one and 5 catches for 79.5 and 0 TD in the other. The two 300+ yard games against the worst teams in the league severely skew his stats. He's a 70 yard a game WR at that level. Not bad, but nowhere near dominant.




Bort did a fantastic job of screwing speed WRs over this season, if you are complaining about speed WRs being to good, it is clear you have no idea what is going on. Look at speed WRs YAC and average. They are down significantly on speed WRs from last season to this season across the board. Grifter lost 5 yards on avg and ~4 on YAC, this isn't the exception, this is the rule. In his ten games so far with 64 catches, he has lost 320 yards due to his average being down, so close to 500 yards if the the pattern holds up for the entire season. It isn't just his speedster it is everyones.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doug_Plank
sadly, GLB seems to have come full circle on speed, and though this post is old.. it is relevant again.


Not true, agility and catching are more important for WRs then they have ever been.
 
Grim Truth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
Originally posted by Doug_Plank

sadly, GLB seems to have come full circle on speed, and though this post is old.. it is relevant again.


Not true, agility and catching are more important for WRs then they have ever been.


True. But well placed SA's take care of both of those.
 
Booboo Laaug
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
Originally posted by BartRock



Grifter has only played two teams with winning records. The results weren't pretty. 2 catches for 10.5 yds and 0 TD in one and 5 catches for 79.5 and 0 TD in the other. The two 300+ yard games against the worst teams in the league severely skew his stats. He's a 70 yard a game WR at that level. Not bad, but nowhere near dominant.




Bort did a fantastic job of screwing speed WRs over this season, if you are complaining about speed WRs being to good, it is clear you have no idea what is going on. Look at speed WRs YAC and average. They are down significantly on speed WRs from last season to this season across the board. Grifter lost 5 yards on avg and ~4 on YAC, this isn't the exception, this is the rule. In his ten games so far with 64 catches, he has lost 320 yards due to his average being down, so close to 500 yards if the the pattern holds up for the entire season. It isn't just his speedster it is everyones.



Either you're quoting the wrong person, or I'm missing something here.
 
carumba10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth


I want to make my WR in the same template but I know he wouldn't fit into my OC's offense.


That is a very important distinction that many players fail to acknowledge. Take the #3 receiver from Texas Tech vs the #1 receiver from Army and compare their stats at the end of the year. The Army guy could actually be a better receiver but will obviously have nowhere near the stats of the Tech guy.

Same thing applies here.

 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booboo Laaug

Either you're quoting the wrong person, or I'm missing something here.


Yes, sorry, grabbed the quote I agreed with and went off on a different tangent. I agree with Bart Rock, what he posted shows that speedsters aren't clearly as dominant as everyone is making them out to be the powerhouse of previous seasons were. The "if you are complaining" part was directed to those who are saying speedsters are overpowered. Mea Culpa.
Last edited Jan 23, 2009 09:22:55
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.