User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Staners


Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.


No, people are being punished for bringing ringers into a low level league to dominate it-- as they should be. My only issue with it at all is that the scrub players, who play very little, shouldn't count toward the medians. Otherwise, I'm thrilled that Bort ignored the power gamers.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
There will still be a problem towards the end of the season, there needs to be a roster lock before the playoffs...that way power gamers who have expiring contracts can't jump down just for the playoffs when they aren't going to get XP anyhow...
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
There will still be a problem towards the end of the season, there needs to be a roster lock before the playoffs...that way power gamers who have expiring contracts can't jump down just for the playoffs when they aren't going to get XP anyhow...


Agreed. I'm not sure how it will have to work, but I agree that this must be addressed,
 
caneswizard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by Staners



Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.


No, people are being punished for bringing ringers into a low level league to dominate it-- as they should be. My only issue with it at all is that the scrub players, who play very little, shouldn't count toward the medians. Otherwise, I'm thrilled that Bort ignored the power gamers.


And how do you not count them, or for that matter, identify them?
 
caneswizard
offline
Link
 
The free agent signings and trade deadlines need to be moved up.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
If it's a 10% hit per game, you're talking about roughly 400-500 xp over the course of the season. That's about a sixth of the xp you get by boosting. Even that assumes boosting at the beginning of the season. It's not enough to deter anyone from boosting.

No, this won't help level 1s catch level 20s, unless the level 20s are playing with the level 1s. And even then, the penalty will decrease as the level 1s get closer.

But the penalties should vary by league. A higher level in an AA league shouldn't be punished as much as a higher level in a BBB league.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caneswizard
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Originally posted by Staners




Surely this is fair. You still have higher level players, just they wont improve as quick as lower level players. Apart from the new WE league, it isnt stopping you or me having these players.


This is ALREADY BEING DONE in the current XP leveling system. Now, people are actually being PUNISHED for boosting their players.

I hope there will be a way to buy back boosts and receive a refund.


No, people are being punished for bringing ringers into a low level league to dominate it-- as they should be. My only issue with it at all is that the scrub players, who play very little, shouldn't count toward the medians. Otherwise, I'm thrilled that Bort ignored the power gamers.


And how do you not count them, or for that matter, identify them?


The way you do it is you only count the highest level player at each position on each team (the highest level depth chart the team could field if it chose to) plus the four highest level players on the team besides those.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
If it's a 10% hit per game, you're talking about roughly 400-500 xp over the course of the season. That's about a sixth of the xp you get by boosting. Even that assumes boosting at the beginning of the season. It's not enough to deter anyone from boosting.


Also, he wisely counts boosting toward a good sportsmanship score.
 
Steelyeye
offline
Link
 
I really do not like this idea.

It forces players to move up if they out level the team they are on, does not matter if you want to play all 10 seasons on your buddy’s team. If that team is not good enough to be promoted you have to leave or get punished.

Now you have to worry if boosting is going to harm you, you don’t want to boost about the team “supposed” level cap. So now you can be punished for helping the team with your boost.

What happens if you are in the AA league and get to the playoffs but can never win it all? Now you whole team is punished because they are above the level of the league, but you are not advancing up.

Forces higher level player to move to the Pro leagues, where there will not be enough starting or back-up spots for them. A starting HB in the AAA leagues might have to choose a third string spot to avoid the penalty, and he is getting less xp’s because he is not playing.

There are not enough spots for every team that is strong enough to move up, some team will lose in the playoffs. Now you are being punished for holding a good team together because they might be one or two levels about the league level.

I am sure I can think of a lot more reasons why this is bad. This is nothing but a forced level cap, which will not be good in the long run.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Steelyeye
I really do not like this idea.

It forces players to move up if they out level the team they are on, does not matter if you want to play all 10 seasons on your buddy’s team. If that team is not good enough to be promoted you have to leave or get punished.

Now you have to worry if boosting is going to harm you, you don’t want to boost about the team “supposed” level cap. So now you can be punished for helping the team with your boost.

What happens if you are in the AA league and get to the playoffs but can never win it all? Now you whole team is punished because they are above the level of the league, but you are not advancing up.

Forces higher level player to move to the Pro leagues, where there will not be enough starting or back-up spots for them. A starting HB in the AAA leagues might have to choose a third string spot to avoid the penalty, and he is getting less xp’s because he is not playing.

There are not enough spots for every team that is strong enough to move up, some team will lose in the playoffs. Now you are being punished for holding a good team together because they might be one or two levels about the league level.

I am sure I can think of a lot more reasons why this is bad. This is nothing but a forced level cap, which will not be good in the long run.



Did you really read the announcement? Boosting helps your score, as does resigning with a team you are on.

The rest of your league is leveling with you. So yes, if you continually make the playoffs and never get promoted, you'll be above the previous year's median. But... the rest of the league will have leveled too, and the median will go up. Bort said the recommended level would be roughly 8 levels above the median. So teams 1-2 levels higher than others will not be affected, or if they do it will be very slight.

A few players can be above the recommended level with no penalty whatsoever. This is only to stop entire teams of high levels moving to the new leagues.

A bit of a heads up would have been better, but this is something that needs to be done.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 06:42:15
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I think that any change like this 9Which I support overall) needs to be sure that Players will never have to leave a team they've signed on .. E.G., add an 'exemption' for players who have been on a team three or more seasons. Players should no be forced to leave their friends.

I think part of this issue though could be resolved by ensuring more teams are promoted and demoted each season. I would say the top 4 from any league should be prmoted and the bottom 8 demoted. This should balance out the leagues fairly quickly.
 
Desaxman
offline
Link
 
The bonus seems like it could be so insignificant as to not matter all that much. If I'm a level 5 playing against a league average of lvl 15, and I get even a 5-10% bonus to my XP, it will let me level up maybe one extra level than I would have playing against a league of level 5s. If I'm a level 15 playing in a league average of level 5, if I lose 5-10%, it probably won't even cost me a full level over the course of a single season. And as the rest of the league gains a little bit more XP, that league median/average should improve as well so eventually I won't have the penalty. And since the lower levels can level faster to begin with, the penalty will go away even faster.

If I choose to stay on a team in a lower level league, then I choose to gain a few less XPs for a while, and as the league "catches up", the penalty goes away and I will still stay slightly ahead of the rest of the league. If I decide I don't want to lose potential game XP, then I don't stay with that team when my contract is up. The team isn't impacted directly, only the players who are exceptionally higher than the league or opponent average, and they aren't hurt that much either. It doesn't affect their skill level, I'm still a level 15 playing against level 5s, and maybe by the end of the season, I'm a level 22 playing against level 16s (and my penalty may be gone and their bonus reduced/gone as well).

I agree that it needs to be looked at more to get specifics as to bonus and/or penalty percentages, but I don't really see how it's that big a deal. Which may be a reason to not implement it in the first place - I'm not convinced it really changes that much. Teams that want to stack themselves against lower level teams still can, and they can still dominate, and it will take more than a season for teams to "catch up" (which they won't because once the average is high enough, the bonus/penalty percentages are gone).

 
Desaxman
offline
Link
 
Oh yeah, the only way I see to try to influence high level players from playing on lower level teams is a soft cap - league X has a level cap at +8 their current average of 7, so anyone higher than a level 15 can still play in that league(soft cap), but their skill points are reduced by the game engine to match the soft cap. So, if I'm level 20, each of my skill points is multiplied by .75 (level 20 x .75 = level 15) and I play like a level 15 player in the game (call it a penalty because it's hard to play at 100% against inferior competition, playing to the level of the opponent, etc.). As the cap moves up, the penalty is less. This does affect the team, so if the goal is to prevent teams from loading up, this may be the disincentive (maybe combined with the player XP bonuses for playing up). Teams that want to stick together can continue to level up their players, play in a lower league, but their play is affected. If/when a player chooses to move on, for example, they haven't lost their leveling up along the way, and if they move to a team in a high enough league, they will be playing at full strength. Level 20 in a level 15 league plays like a level 15. Level 20 in a level 30 league plays like a level 20 (but maybe gets some XP bonuses for "playing up". Players don't develop any more slowly (that normal) for playing down, but their game level is adjusted so the teams aren't blowing everyone out.

Teams and players are somewhat free to choose where they play and if they care if they are penalized. A soft cap combined with small XP bonuses for playing up (and no penalties for playing down) can be used to provide the disincentives for a massive number of players to stack a low level team. Basically, XP bonus for playing up, adjusted game level for playing down.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 08:09:24
 
TrueBlueInMD
offline
Link
 
Bort -- is the league's recommended level ("RL") going to be set at the start of the season and static, or is it going to adjust upward as *all* the players in the league gain XP's/levels (and as various players get traded in or out)? IMHO, it shouldn't be static, because the median player level on which it's based isn't static.

Example: league RL starts the season at 15, median level is 7. Eight weeks later, median level is 11 (some owners of weaker teams have signed a bunch of better players, say, after discovering that having level 4 starters doesn't work all that well), there should be no penalty at all for bringing in a level 18.

***

Everybody: If you read this through and understand it, the impact is only on XP's, not on performance, and on specific players, not whole teams. The intent, and the way it looks like it will work, is to discourage *players* at high levels from being part of stacking schemes. And there is NO bonus for playing "over your head" level-wise.

If you want to build a killer team, this makes it more sensible to sign a dozen guys who are (say) 6-8 levels above the league mean level, than 6 guys who are 10-12 levels higher, both because the players won't lose XP gain and because your signings will actually increase the league median and thus (hopefully, see above) the league RL more that way.

"Unfair to do this on the last day of the offseason." Well, if you put your level 20 guy into a BBB team, tfb. You can avoid the burn by getting him traded to a team where he *isn't* going to be the college kid playing h.s. jv ball.

Most of us are never going to be affected by this at all, and even fewer will see a noticeable effect. And if you do, I don't feel sorry for you.

Bottom line, in simple words: Having a very high level player is an advantage. If you use that advantage to beat up on teams that can't compete at your player's level, you will tend to lose that advantage over time, more quickly than otherwise.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 08:13:57
 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
The only thing I care about with this change, is whether or not it will affect my level 20 player's when I boost them to level 23 at the start of season 3 for the USA AAA#1 League. If I am not punished for boosting my player's - and the cheaters get theirs, then I'm OK with whatever Bort decides.

EDIT: What I do notice is how there seems to be a lot of ideas of change floating around, I'm not even sure what the main change will be or do, besides put a level cap (or other idea) into defense against high level player's trying to beat up on lower level player's in the lower level leagues.

My suggestion: Don't over-think it, but do take action. So far, Bort, you've done a great job of thwarting cheaters, so I trust you'll do a good job with this part too.
Last edited Jun 10, 2008 08:20:08
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.