User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
coachtabales
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I pretty much agree with you. I like the idea of coaches, but they should NOT just be giving teams bonuses or equipment or anything like that. Coaches should just be given extra weapons to help them actually coach a team.


Exactly. If you are going to be in a position that has any kind of authority, let that something be a pro and con to the team. If you do your part wrong then it will give the owner grounds to can your arse for being a loser coach. Otherwise, all you're doing is selling bonuses for flex. That is not a coach, that's the equivalent of juicing the team. Retarded.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by coachtabales
Exactly. If you are going to be in a position that has any kind of authority, let that something be a pro and con to the team. If you do your part wrong then it will give the owner grounds to can your arse for being a loser coach. Otherwise, all you're doing is selling bonuses for flex. That is not a coach, that's the equivalent of juicing the team. Retarded.


I would even be fine with it if all they did was give bonuses to the team if those bonuses weren't things like attribute gains and instead were things such as unlocking additional aspects to the playbook.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
You mean pretty much every MMO in existence gives the best stuff to those who

1. spend the most money
2. spend the most time
(or vice versa)

and reach higher levels through that combination.

GLB doesn't allow someone who joined in season 2 to constantly train or find pick up games for their players so they can level up faster and catch older players. Almost every other MMO, if someone plays 3-4 hours a day more than someone created earlier, they will eventually catch them.


That's the first and only reasonable argument I've seen against the implementation of the coach class. You recognize the situation relative to MMO's and explained a difference.

I still hold to my position, despite that you made a truly solid argument, because:

1) The promise of a coach class (or something similarly good for aging players) was what calmed people down about aging, and I don't like to see promises broken.

2) I hate to see Bort pushed against his intentions, because:

a) His intentions have almost always been right.

We wouldn't have had half the problems we had with parity within league levels had he stuck to his guns before I was even here against those who bought low level teams and successfully puished him to make revenue almost the same for BBB as for Pro.

Media revenue is helping with this now, but had he been able to do what he originally wanted, income differences would have kept BBB teams from affording equipment for players and the like if Pro teams were getting triple BBB revenue-- just one way whiners created tons of problems for the game-- and

b) It is his game.

3) I think the coach class is a fun and exciting addition.

4) I fail to see how it affects people who don't own a team and don't have a player old enough to coach in any negative way; it's just jealousy.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


4) I fail to see how it affects people who don't own a team and don't have a player old enough to coach in any negative way; it's just jealousy.


So let's say team A made up of season 3 players all with awesome builds is in USAPL. There are no season 1 players on the team.

Team B has a team of really good season 1 and 2 players and some great season 3 players.

At the end of season 11, team B has 10 players retire and become coaches. They bring in great slow built season 3 players from their farm team to replace all the season 1 players they lost.

Now team A plays team B in weak 12 of the season and once again in the playoffs. Team B has 10 coaches boosting their team or negatively impacting team A. Team A has 0 coaches.

You can't see how not having a player old enough to be a coach hurts a team in any way?

Edit: I wonder how hard Machu Picchu and Doinitin Djibouti are going to get fucked by coaching. It could cost them a WL title.
Edited by Rage Kinard on Sep 8, 2009 12:36:18
Edited by Rage Kinard on Sep 8, 2009 12:35:20
Edited by Rage Kinard on Sep 8, 2009 12:15:31
Edited by Rage Kinard on Sep 8, 2009 12:14:30
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
JCWildcat is adding all coaching threads into the OP of that post. That is not the official price, the official price is "small" and hasn't been set yet.

My understanding is that it's currently planned to cost more than 300 flex points per coach per season. So if there are going to be a maximum of 10 coaches per team, then that's at least 3000 flex per team per season. I wouldn't describe that as "small."


Originally posted by Ken1
=2) I hate to see Bort pushed against his intentions, because:
a) His intentions have almost always been right.

...

...

...

uhm ...

...

...
Edited by jdbolick on Sep 8, 2009 12:20:27
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Actually, it happens all the time...players get career ending injuries or aren't good enough - they disappear from most people's sight and then one day they pop up as a coach someplace - after learning their craft in college or the minors.


Touche for the second example. For the injuries, though, that's just something we can't do. Of course players can get forced out of whatever league their in for one reason or another, but just about any player in this game can find a team to play for. They may not start, nor will they always be a winner, but there is almost certainly a team for them.

I like the idea of making "retired players turned coaches" more sought after. I am in favor of creating coaches along with players, and not restricting it to the 440 day rule. Like I suggested previously, if you simply create a coach from scratch, cool. He'll have the average run of the mill options. However, if you run through the 440 days and then retire and become a coach, I think there should be extras. Unlockables, if you will. Things that regular coaches just don't get. Perhaps higher base skills? Perhaps extra attributes or abilities? More influence or higher effects on games, players, equipment, etc. Whatever the bonus is, it has to be something that makes living out a player's career WORTH IT.

Making the 440 rule the ONLY way to make a coach doesn't seem very interesting to me.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1


4) I fail to see how it affects people who don't own a team and don't have a player old enough to coach in any negative way; it's just jealousy.


Ahh you have it all figured out. Who knew it was only about jealousy?



 
Sweet T
offline
Link
 

Edited by Dynasty Jammers on Sep 8, 2009 12:32:45
Edited by Dynasty Jammers on Sep 8, 2009 12:32:09
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
Another dumb ass idea from the powers that be!

Once again they are creating a new feature to cover up a past dumb ass idea of making our players decline. Now that the population has done the math and it supports retireing our players and collecting the thousands of flex pts and living off those for the next 7+ seasons.

Now borts liight bulb went on and noticed that his cash flow will be declining as his longest and most loyal cash paying customers are loaded with flex pts and wont be buying as much, he has despartly come up with this "coaching" crap and forcing this dumb ass coaching chit on us to drum up another payment stream.

and y should it cost as many flex pts as it does?? to be a coach cost as much as or in some cases more than owning a team or have a player that we can see and enjoy playing the game and having stats. what good is it paying flex pts for something that we wont really be able to tabulate or see stats from. how will we ACTUALLY know that the codes he says will have a real effect on the game??? how can we actually measure it?? if im paying cash i want to actually be able to measure what effect it has.

also...another thoughtless point to all of this is that...how many day 440 players can be a coach after this season?? so their wont be enough coaches avail for each team to even have 1 coach much less all the freakin coaching specialist he is going to make for this game.
What about the new agents and teams comming in...how long will they need to play witout coaches?? just another example of the rich get richer scenario.

also...we(the population) are even more dumb as we are actually helping them by approving this and helping them come up with more ways to take our cash!! not too smart of us IMHO....
Edited by DTRAIN on Sep 8, 2009 13:24:36
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by Robbnva

BORT PLEASE IMPLEMENT A POLL BEFORE DOING ANY MORE WORK ON COACHES

if majority wants it, do it, if majority is against it. SCRAP IT.




 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

Originally posted by Robbnva


BORT PLEASE IMPLEMENT A POLL BEFORE DOING ANY MORE WORK ON COACHES

if majority wants it, do it, if majority is against it. SCRAP IT.






He's heating up!
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
So let's say team A made up of season 3 players all with awesome builds is in USAPL. There are no season 1 players on the team.

Team B has a team of really good season 1 and 2 players and some great season 3 players.

At the end of season 11, team B has 10 players retire and become coaches. They bring in great slow built season 3 players from their farm team to replace all the season 1 players they lost.

Now team A plays team B in weak 12 of the season and once again in the playoffs. Team B has 10 coaches boosting their team or negatively impacting team A. Team A has 0 coaches.

You can't see how not having a player old enough to be a coach hurts a team in any way?

Edit: I wonder how hard Machu Picchu and Doinitin Djibouti are going to get fucked by coaching. It could cost them a WL title.


I did qualify with "who don't own a team," although I was mostly referring to the added complexity of owning a team with added spots to fill.

I've suggested that until there are enough coaches, that coaches be only HC, OC, DC, and ST for each team, with the number of positions increasing as the number of coaches do.

If the number of positions are scaled to the number of coaches, that problem won't exist, as teams will just recruit coaches as with players.

Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Ahh you have it all figured out. Who knew it was only about jealousy?


If you're against it as is but would be fine with it if everyone (you) could make a coach, then it's only about jealousy. That seems to be the case with most of the opponents of the idea.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
If you're against it as is but would be fine with it if everyone (you) could make a coach, then it's only about jealousy. That seems to be the case with most of the opponents of the idea.

Not everyone in this world is so self-absorbed that they only care about what directly affects them. Apparently some people have difficulty realizing that people unlike them may actually be concerned even if an issue doesn't hurt them or may even help them. For instance, some power back owners called for change in S7, and some juke back owners called for change in S9. Meanwhile some certain other posters are nothing more than suckups who mindlessly endorse every idea that Bort comes up with.
 
Sweet T
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
If you're against it as is but would be fine with it if everyone (you) could make a coach, then it's only about jealousy. That seems to be the case with most of the opponents of the idea.


jealousy?...of what?
 
Hugestballs
offline
Link
 
I think this would be a fun idea but I also agree that the coach should in no way be able to affect how an agent is able to build his player. Temporary bonuses, even if they last the entire season, fine. Anything that would change the way a player can be built depending on what team he ends up on would be devestating as an agent that only has a couple of players and not necessarily a whole lot of say on what team/coach I can play for.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.