User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World League is coming
Page:
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by jeffgarcia

I don't want to go to the world league. I like CPL. I've been there since season 1. >:O


Should be able to choose if you want to go imo


very true
 
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology


This may have been covered already....

But what are the team incentives to make a run for the WL if you know you are not quite good enough to be a contender there?

WL glory is great...but do you really want to go 4-12 and lose your hard earned fan support?

Fan support should not diminish (or there should be a "hard bottom" at 100-95-90 or so) in the WL.

If this isn't done, there will be massive numbers of thrown games in the playoffs at the Pro level....


I mentioned that as part of my suggestion in the USA Pro forums thread about this and have to agree.

Teams should never be punished imo for making it to the World League, so my suggestion was that either your actual Fan Support is "locked" while you are in the World League and can't go down any lower while you are in the World League, but if you can manage to build up your Fan Support in the World League then I think you do deserve to be able to build it up, because that sounds pretty deserved to me.

However, let's say over the first 6 games of the season you build up your fan support higher, and then you go on a big losing streak and are now lower than when you came into the World League. I don't think your fan support should then be locked at not going below what it was after the first 6 games. So it could still drop from that point to what you came in with, but you aren't "safe" at the Fan Support level you had after 6 games.

How much fan support decreases for a loss in the World League (and probably Pro Leagues at least as well) is something that should be looked at though.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
World League = USAPL
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by tautology


If this isn't done, there will be massive numbers of thrown games in the CPL playoffs


imo....


 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
World League = USAPL


Thanks for the post. I'm glad you'd rather cause problems than try to fix things.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Originally posted by tautology



This may have been covered already....

But what are the team incentives to make a run for the WL if you know you are not quite good enough to be a contender there?

WL glory is great...but do you really want to go 4-12 and lose your hard earned fan support?

Fan support should not diminish (or there should be a "hard bottom" at 100-95-90 or so) in the WL.

If this isn't done, there will be massive numbers of thrown games in the playoffs at the Pro level....


I mentioned that as part of my suggestion in the USA Pro forums thread about this and have to agree.

Teams should never be punished imo for making it to the World League, so my suggestion was that either your actual Fan Support is "locked" while you are in the World League and can't go down any lower while you are in the World League, but if you can manage to build up your Fan Support in the World League then I think you do deserve to be able to build it up, because that sounds pretty deserved to me.

However, let's say over the first 6 games of the season you build up your fan support higher, and then you go on a big losing streak and are now lower than when you came into the World League. I don't think your fan support should then be locked at not going below what it was after the first 6 games. So it could still drop from that point to what you came in with, but you aren't "safe" at the Fan Support level you had after 6 games.

How much fan support decreases for a loss in the World League (and probably Pro Leagues at least as well) is something that should be looked at though.


This is a really great suggestion. I'd love to see fan support limited both at the top and at the bottom by league level.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl

Originally posted by tautology




This may have been covered already....

But what are the team incentives to make a run for the WL if you know you are not quite good enough to be a contender there?

WL glory is great...but do you really want to go 4-12 and lose your hard earned fan support?

Fan support should not diminish (or there should be a "hard bottom" at 100-95-90 or so) in the WL.

If this isn't done, there will be massive numbers of thrown games in the playoffs at the Pro level....


I mentioned that as part of my suggestion in the USA Pro forums thread about this and have to agree.

Teams should never be punished imo for making it to the World League, so my suggestion was that either your actual Fan Support is "locked" while you are in the World League and can't go down any lower while you are in the World League, but if you can manage to build up your Fan Support in the World League then I think you do deserve to be able to build it up, because that sounds pretty deserved to me.

However, let's say over the first 6 games of the season you build up your fan support higher, and then you go on a big losing streak and are now lower than when you came into the World League. I don't think your fan support should then be locked at not going below what it was after the first 6 games. So it could still drop from that point to what you came in with, but you aren't "safe" at the Fan Support level you had after 6 games.

How much fan support decreases for a loss in the World League (and probably Pro Leagues at least as well) is something that should be looked at though.


This is a really great suggestion. I'd love to see fan support limited both at the top and at the bottom by league level.


The games changed, when season 1 players got here they were starting the the pro ranks, if you limit the bottom leagues, it would take 7 seasons to get full support, while those who were here 1st got top support in 2 seasons? That would not work on any level, and would just make people starting the game tomorrow stuck in the bottom leagues forever.
Edited by dpride59 on Jul 13, 2009 16:06:07
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
World League = USAPL


Agree
 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Honestly, if a world league got started I think it could be the start of the end for USAPRO dominance. With a world league in place, USAPRO would no longer be the place for teams to prove themselves since the ultimate goal would now be to play in the world league and why not get there through SEAPRO instead.

With season 1-2 players getting set to retire USAPRO will lose one of its biggest advantages over many other leagues. If you take away their status as the "top league" in GLB then maybe up-and-coming top teams from the cloud will choose to go to one of the "lesser" leagues in order to increase their chance at a world league. Sure USAPRO will likely dominate for a couple seasons but I think by season 14-15 things will be much more balanced with USA only holding a relatively small edge over other leagues.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by jeffgarcia


I don't want to go to the world league. I like CPL. I've been there since season 1. >:O


Should be able to choose if you want to go imo


very true


Is it really such an awful idea for you to represent CPL, for only a season if you don't make the playoffs.

You can schedule scrims, etc. against the few CPL teams or whatever you feel like you're missing out on. It's your choice how seriously your teams want to take those scrims.


I am willing to support an option to let teams decide to stay in their Pro League. However, I think that if for example a CPL teams chooses not to go up, then they shouldn't be replaced by another team from their region, and instead are forfeiting a spot in the World League for their region.

It will probably cause some problems with deciding which team gets to replace them, but I think we can come up with a solid system/plan to deal with it.

Just off the top of my head the best two options I could come up with for now would be...

1) Let teams who finished one game short of making it to the World League (would be the Conference Finals losers in every season after this one) that would like a shot at the World League to request to move up. Have some sort of committee that decides which of the teams who submitted a request is the most deserving of moving up.

2) Have a system in place rather than letting opinion decide.

I'd suggest dealing with the extra spot like this. Put the regions in an order based on how many World League teams they have representing them. The region with the most teams gets the first opportunity to fill the spot. However, if the team (or should it be 2 teams?) next in line declines to be moved up to the World League we'd move on to the next region on the list until we find a team to move up.

If two or more regions have the same number of teams in the World League then their should be ordered either randomly or by their overall performance in the World League that season.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
This whole idea is whacked. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
Honestly, if a world league got started I think it could be the start of the end for USAPRO dominance. With a world league in place, USAPRO would no longer be the place for teams to prove themselves since the ultimate goal would now be to play in the world league and why not get there through SEAPRO instead.

With season 1-2 players getting set to retire USAPRO will lose one of its biggest advantages over many other leagues. If you take away their status as the "top league" in GLB then maybe up-and-coming top teams from the cloud will choose to go to one of the "lesser" leagues in order to increase their chance at a world league. Sure USAPRO will likely dominate for a couple seasons but I think by season 14-15 things will be much more balanced with USA only holding a relatively small edge over other leagues.


Thank you. Great post.


I own a team in USA Pro and I know right now if we could magically the take the perfect top 32 teams and put them in the World League right now that USAPL would end up with the most teams.

However, I have been posting so much in this thread because I love the competition in USAPL and I don't think it has to stay restricted to there, especially with Season 1-2 players getting close to their decline. I would love to see the other regions have just as much depth in their Pro Leagues.


The World League structure I have already lined out only favors USAPL because of the current state of the game. However, it leaves it wide open for any region to either become the next USAPL, or hopefully after several seasons we'll end up with a better balance of teams from each region in the World League.

I really do believe that implementing this World League structure will not only add to GLB overall, but I think it will help bring the regions closer together in competition than is possible without a World League.

I think a lot of people saying "World League = USAPL" are missing the point that if it's as true as they believe then without an actual World League things are very likely to stay this way.

Look at West Scranton for example. They moved from OPL because they wanted more competition and had no other way of getting it. OPL can build itself up, but WSI can't build the OPL up.


Also the easiest road to the World League is probably not going to be through USAPL. That is a really good thing though, because it means that teams in EEPL and other "weaker" regions will have a much easier time reaching the World League, but if they want to compete there they will have to improve in relation to the top teams in GLB now, rather than just based on EEPL. That means the teams that are gearing up to be future World League or Pro League will have to work towards a higher standard/goal of being able to compete in the World League.

The end result of this will probably cause some above average but lesser Pro League teams to face the fact that they have to improve to hold on to the same success that they've had. Some teams may end up folding from the pressure, but the end result of either should be a stronger Pro League.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
The games changed, when season 1 players got here they were starting the the pro ranks, if you limit the bottom leagues, it would take 7 seasons to get full support, while those who were here 1st got top support in 2 seasons? That would not work on any level, and would just make people starting the game tomorrow stuck in the bottom leagues forever.


Most teams I notice in the Pros today have only recently risen to that point. Things change, folks get bored, people move on. Fixing the economy today would be a good thing for the game in the long run.

 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
I really do believe that implementing this World League structure will not only add to GLB overall.


Well, you're wrong.

After a few seasons, the majority of players will realize that they're never, ever going to get the chance to compete at the highest level of competition. This is unavoidable - you are shrinking the highest level of competition from 256 teams to 32. Eventually, people will become bored, and begin to tune out. How exactly does this "add" to GLB overall?

There have been plenty of good arguments made against this idea, and only 1 good argument in favor of it: "The best should play against the best."

Here's the thing - you can have the best play against the best in the format of a tournament. It doesn't need to be the standard, run-of-the-mill 32-team league.

"Oh, but I can't be bothered game planning an extra few games that a tournament would involve. Boo!"

Really? Well then I guess you're not that excited about playing against the best, are you?
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mercaptopropyl
Originally posted by Iceman16

World League = USAPL


Thanks for the post. I'm glad you'd rather cause problems than try to fix things.


uh wat
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.