User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
BRG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


He's a high tackling dude, correct? That's the general idea - get high tackling and you will barely ever miss tackles. I guess the question is what should be considered high tackling?

Perhaps I should just do like people always end up suggestions - do what I think is right and people will figure it out and adjust, etc.

I do like the idea of gang tackles though.


While being able to tackle is one thing - a defender needs to get around blocks so there must be a split between agility / speed / strength / tackle to be able to get into position to get past the blocker, push through if need and have high enough tackle to bring the guy down.

With all that being said based on the breathe freshness, a defender also has to have "enough in his tank" to have adequate in game attributes to accomplish this throughout the game.

That would lead me to think that you need an MLB or DT with at least +10 Field General to keep the unit going
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by britdevine316

If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


The problem with speed is...against "balanced" builds...they get destroyed. You can't stop 100 speed with 70 speed. You CAN stop 100 strength with 70 strength.

Personally, I think balanced builds should have an OK chance against everything...but speed FORCES people to unbalanced their build or get dominated.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by britdevine316

If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


I agree, but when 90% of your D players are all Speed +agil, they went that way because the sim allows them to perform better with high speed and agility, not high STR and tackle.

Players with High STr and Tackle, just don't make it to enough plays on D to justify the High STR+Tackle
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:35:10
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
I have to commend you Bort. I have made many comments about the lack of communication between GLB and its customer base. You getting ideas from the players of the game on this issue instead of just making a change is a big positive.

Thanks
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by britdevine316

If a player pushes tackling to anything above 60 in this game, they are going to get burnt so bad by everyone with 100+ speed it's not even funny.



Why shouldn't there be a way to get burnt by 100 STR as opposed to speed, then? Or 100 AGI or 100 Jumping, etc. Metagame, right?


How does the D "burn" the O then?
 
jsully75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
This reminds me a lot of high agility DEs vs high strength/blocking OTs...


most of the good OT's have adjusted, but there will always be the stubborn ones...
 
Rutang
offline
Link
 
Realistically, the angle at which the defender is to the ball carrier would have an impact on whether the tackle is made. If a LB is squared up on an RB, and is coming up to make a hit, then the chance he makes the tackle without getting dragged for yardage would be much better than if he wasn't squared up and only got a glancing blow on the RB. Also, if the LB is more agile than the RB, the LB would be able to stay squared up on the RB, even if the RB tried to juke.

Right now, HBs are stronger than DT, and LB are faster than some CB. so the attribute system is a little unrealistic. But, you have to reward the RBs who have dedicated all of their SPs to strength, even if its unrealistic.

In football, all players get tackled. LaRon McClain is one of the strongest backs in the league. He doesn't dominate the entire league. He drags guys for additional yardage, but his lack of agility/speed means he gets hit closer to the LOS, and gets tackled before he gets a head of steam. When he does get going, he does truck some LBs and DBs, but he doesn't just truck them and keep going on every play. The probability that the RB would run over the defender should be low, but falling forward or dragging guys for additional yardage should be more common.

If a 240 defender has 60 strength and 60 tackling, I wouldn't think that guy would get run over oftern, and wouldn't get dragged for 3 yards on every tackle.


 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by THE PWNER
Originally posted by Iceman16

Originally posted by THE PWNER


Read the first few pages, seems like all the suggestions would take us back to the pre-nerf of the power back builds in season 3 or 4. The requirements people are stating are not going to happen at all. TBH, I think the current formula is probably about right because it is what we are used to. To continually change this type of formula is what throws people off of this game.


inb4gameisbetaargument

The sim is not perfect. That's why adjustments are made.


i agree this is beta, adjustments are made. But not redoing what it takes to make a tackle 7 seasons and almost a full year into the game. Adjustment by definition is "a small change; a minor correction; a modification" not a redoing of half the game (tackling is half the game right? The part that stops the play!)


It's still in beta though. Doesn't matter how long it's for.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Robbnva



Originally posted by Bort




Originally posted by britdevine316





Tackling should be more important than Str in the tackling equation for sure.


It already is. Quite a bit more. STR mostly helps you hold them back when you make the tackle.


I have already given you my answer and my results for LBs. 5 of my 10 tackles were against an HB who had almost 100 broken tackles last season, you want answers yet you ignore posts by people trying to provide advice.
my LB had NO missed tackles and 3 TFL


He's a high tackling dude, correct? That's the general idea - get high tackling and you will barely ever miss tackles. I guess the question is what should be considered high tackling?

Perhaps I should just do like people always end up suggestions - do what I think is right and people will figure it out and adjust, etc.

I do like the idea of gang tackles though.


I posted a few pages back, 60 strength and tackling, my guy is just a hair under those numbers but I am lower level, level 40s should be closer to the 4:1 cap perhaps


I wonder how he would do against some of the guys who had 3-400 brtk last year?


pluck him and give him a shot in your test sims, PM the results
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Well it's very hard to come up with formulas since there are all sorts of variables such as tackling style, running style, and SAs.

Here's my best shot without specific formulas:
tacklng should be split into two steps.

1) "Starting" the tackle = grabbing on and trying to bring him down
2) Stopping the carrier completely / to the ground

"Starting" the tackle should be easier against power backs than faster elusive backs. Make it compare the current speed of the ball carrier to the tackling and agility? of the defender in some fashion.

Stopping the carrier is a strength contest. Defender has more strength means they're likely stopped immediately. Runner has more strength and they continue on slightly but slow down proportionate to the strength of the defender.

More than one defender should be able to tackle at once, also. They have to pass part 1 ( which should be easier since the runner is slower) then their strength gets added to the defending side. Basically if one defender has the tackle started and another defender gets there, it should be basically a sure tackle right there. But a 100 strength back against two 25 strength corners may still be pushing on... etc.

Hope that made sense, took a while to get my thoughts out.

Also, tackling style would affect chances to do part 1 and part 2.... wrap up is a bonus to starting, while power is a bonus to the strength during the stopping part.

Summary....
-Tackling in two parts, grabbing on and stopping
-Part 1 should be relative to speed of runner... easier on power backs than elusive but still a decent success rate for even 30 tackling corners on wrap up
-Part 2 is a strength contest, with the runner slowing down. Maybe have their speed reduced by the differential in strength, plus a decent (50%?) chance of falling down every tick? (60 speed/100 str vs 60 str defender is now only 20 speed but keeps going until they fall down or someone else helps)

-High tackling skill is still useful as it allows you to use power tackling instead of wrap up and make the stop faster. Maybe if you have 70 tackling you can do "part 1" from above just as successful as someone with 35 tackling on "wrap up", but now you have a big boost to strength for the stop.
-High strength is very useful as it stops the runner once the tackle has started (plus still would effect the fumble chance)

Well that's all I have for now, it sounds very eloquent in my mind so I hope I've conveyed this well. Some numbers may not be perfect (doubt they are) but as I don't have access to formulas and everyone's builds I made up halfway reasonable numbers as examples.

If Bort or someone else would like to discuss ideas with me, I'd be happy to do them via PM or whatever
Last edited Dec 29, 2008 20:36:10
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bberyquiet
When's the last time you saw a successful RB based on power only in NFL. They have a low ypc avg., and have a hard time getting past the line of scrimmage. Should they break tackles, yeah. But there should be a lot more agile and faster players there to make the play (or bigger/stronger d-lineman).
They are usually goal line backs only!


+1
 
McGrai37
offline
Link
 
If you make Tackling more important, I think you'd need to make Carrying more important in breaking tackles. Otherwise it's giving players on offense one less thing to worry about getting high then the defenders trying to tackle them.
 
Stray Doug
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Boozer
I agree with some earlier posts that corners probobly couldnt bring down a 100 strength Power Back very often.


Not single-handedly, but they could grab hold and significantly hinder the RBs speed/agility until other help arrives or he manages to break free of them... if we're going to increase str/tack skill requirements to make tackles against these guys, then we need a "non-binary" tackle system... it's not just make or miss... it's make tackle (bring to ground), miss completely (negligible effect on RB), partial miss (you don't latch on, but significantly slow down, maybe even knock back a step, or cause to lose balance for several ticks, etc.), and gang tackle (you don't bring to ground, but you don't fall down either, you're holding onto the RB and making him carry you with him, significantly hampering his speed and agility).
 
Link
 
i think something that's funny about this thread is two somewhat conflicting points have been made:

-powerbacks who are slow (50 speed) should be easier to take down, because 50 is slooooooow.
-tackling shouldnt have to go over 50, because that's totally enough tackling.

 
Squicken
offline
Link
 
First off I don't think carrying should really have much if anything to do with breaking tackles. It seems more like the ability to do things without losing the ball, such as stiff arms, juke/spin, and plowing through the line.

The RB build that you posted is pretty much the best you could possibly expect somebody to have to be a tackle breaking machine, so I think you should have pretty much the best tackling machine to take him down consistently. somebody with 70str/70 tackling should still be able to get him maybe 60-80% of the time. A guy with 25 str / 25 tackling would be lucky to get him 25% of the time.

I think a problem with this though is that there are a whole lot more things that it seems a defensive player needs to focus on, and can't realistically get his stats that high while still maintaining speed, agility, vision, stamina, confidence, on top of those makes it too unbalanced.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.