User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
Speed should have absolutely nothing to do with the blocking equation.

Successful OT's are described as having great footwork, which should be about agility and nothing at all to do with speed.

Now I have no idea how the sim is coded, but if anything, the OT SHOULD need more agility (yes, more than the soft cap), but speed should bare absolutely no consequence to the sucecss of an OT.


You are right. Guess what, Bort granted your wish. Speed does have nothing to do with the blocking equation. Now, for you to get to the part of GLB where you calculate a block, you need to MOVE INTO POSITION. Moving is speed and agility.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Madcow8me


Last year we had 5 teams that are could hang with almost anyone. 5 very good teams. it was a very very though conference last year..


Not sure what makes that a very very tough conference, as most conferences have a minimum of 6-8 teams that can hang with almost anyone.

But I am pretty sure those teams you mentioned wouldn't be able to hang with very many AAA or pro teams,



http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=31

So far far all the teams have won their games, all 4 will prob make the playoffs.
team 1,2,5,6

All 4 will do much much more than just hang in SE AAA, I think all 4 teams would hang in any pro league.
Winona, Lostcity, Phucket and Mekong. are all very good team, and we had to compete with them all of last year. Look at all of their RE's, My LT played very well vs all of them, zero sacks between those teams.



im still waiting for someone to tell me that these 4 teams are junk
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 11:24:59
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock

So... you're saying that a DE needs 3 attributes and SAs to be successful? Yet, we expect OL to only need 2 attributes and SAs to be successful? Sorry, I'd expect things to be fair, which it isn't atm.

OTs need agility, speed, vision, blocking and SAs... to compare to a DE that only needs agility, speed, vision and SAs. You can argue about speed for an OT, just like I can argue vision for a DE. Either way, DEs need at least one less attribute to work on to be successful.

This is the primary flaw in the "good build, bad build" argument. Make an OT that lacks one of the key attributes and they get demolished by a DE that doesn't... which would be fine if both positions were equal, but they're not atm.

Besides the fact that OL should have the advantage, simply because they know the play and have the "higher ground". Due to pathing issues though, the "higher ground" advantage is worthless for the most part.


This is the best explanation of the problem.
OL have to build 4 or 5 skills up.
DE's have to build only three.

 
Porch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Warlock

Originally posted by sjmay


Geared towards the run, yet you are complaining about pass blocking? Are you sure your OLine is set on pass block and not run block?


It doesn't matter, when you have 7 blockers, they should be able to pick up 4/5 rushers. The interior line was run block focused, the OTs were no focus and as for the backs... one was pass block and one was run block. That should be enough to protect the QB from a 4/5 man rush.

The primary issue is that the back pathing is horrible... the DE builds are merely part of the problem. Especially when this super fast DEs can't be pancaked and demoralized.



I guess you didn't watch the Super Bowl then and watch the Giants and their 4 man line time after time beat the 6 Patriots linemen and RB in pass rushing. And the Patriots were widely believed to have one of the TOP O-line's if not the #1 O-line.

I guess the NFL is unrealistic also.


You mean the one where they had 5 sacks in 53 attempts or one per every 10.5. Now let's compare that to a team raking up 1 per every 4 attempts. Yep they compare.

Hey if they were getting anything that was anywhere near comparable to the NFL I would be fine.

 
Porch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Porch

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Madcow8me



Originally posted by SteelersInsider




Originally posted by Porch





Originally posted by Gyuri1






By the way, I should add that if Bort made changes to the sim during the offseason that makes speed/agility rushers more effective, then disregard everything else I've written above. My argument is against nerfing what has been status quo for a long time (as there were ways to counter the fast speed rushers), but if things have changed making speed/agility DEs more overpowering, then I'm all for toning it back down to what it had been in the past. My OT and two higher-level DEs played against a terrible team today, so it's hard to decipher whether things have changed. The preseason games, however, made it look as if things hadn't changed much.


I think that is part of the problem here. This didn't happen last year at all and we played a lot of teams that had great pass rushers and great D's. We gave up a total of 9 sacks last year in the regular season. We played a lot of really good teams and good DE's while doing that and never got abused like this. It just seems like something changed.

I am stuck by two things in these. One our guy barely moved, ever. I mean it looks like he is on a different snap count. I don't mind getting beat but to get beat like that just looks stupid.




SE Asia Pro AA? Likely you were playing against mostly slow-build teams before. Maybe you are playing against more teams trying to win this year.

Nothing has changed. If anything, it is harder for DE's to get sacks this year.


why dont you put the crack pip down bobby brown.
Last year SE AA4 was prob one of the toughest fucking conferences last year. We had a pretty decent team and we were only an 8 seed in the playoffs. and all of that being said, my player only gave up 1 sack. Now we are one of the top teams in SE AA4, and now all of a sudden my LT wont even put a hand on a DE because he is too busy trying to bite his own ear...



Sorry, but if you are a top team in SE AA4, it was NEVER one of the toughest conferences.


He did say we were the 8 seed so we were not a top team. Nice reading comprehension though.


He said this year his team was a top team, please don't lecture me about reading comprehension when you have none.


1. He said last year our conference was a tough conference.
2. He said last year we were a decent team who won the 8 seed.
3. He said this year we are a top team.

He never said we were a top team in a tough conference. Thanks to the changes our conference got a whole lot easier.

Reading is fundamental.
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
BORT THIS IS SUCH CRAP!!!! JUST BECAUSE MADCOW CAN'T ACCEPT THE FACT THAT HIS BUILD HIS HORRIBLE IS NO REASON TO MAKE HIS GOD-AWFUL POS BUILD ACTUALLY GIVE UP SACKS.

UNACCEPTABLE.
 
Porch
offline
Link
 
By the way that team just collected another 17 sacks in 28 attempts so someone with a top tackle feel free to challenge him. i want to see someone with a good build stop him.
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
BORT THIS IS SUCH CRAP!!!! JUST BECAUSE MADCOW CAN'T ACCEPT THE FACT THAT HIS BUILD HIS HORRIBLE IS NO REASON TO MAKE HIS GOD-AWFUL POS BUILD ACTUALLY GIVE UP SACKS.

UNACCEPTABLE.


Id put my POS build vs your OT build anyday

 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
By the way that team just collected another 17 sacks in 28 attempts so someone with a top tackle feel free to challenge him. i want to see someone with a good build stop him.


It's actually 45 attempts, which is close to the game that my team just had. It's actually worse in the sack per pass play ratio (worse as in more sacks per attempt).
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 11:50:53
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by Madcow8me

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Madcow8me



Last year we had 5 teams that are could hang with almost anyone. 5 very good teams. it was a very very though conference last year..


Not sure what makes that a very very tough conference, as most conferences have a minimum of 6-8 teams that can hang with almost anyone.

But I am pretty sure those teams you mentioned wouldn't be able to hang with very many AAA or pro teams,



http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=31

So far far all the teams have won their games, all 4 will prob make the playoffs.
team 1,2,5,6

All 4 will do much much more than just hang in SE AAA, I think all 4 teams would hang in any pro league.
Winona, Lostcity, Phucket and Mekong. are all very good team, and we had to compete with them all of last year. Look at all of their RE's, My LT played very well vs all of them, zero sacks between those teams.



im still waiting for someone to tell me that these 4 teams are junk


1 is good, the other 3 are average, satisfied?
 
MadCow420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Madcow8me

Originally posted by Madcow8me


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by Madcow8me




Last year we had 5 teams that are could hang with almost anyone. 5 very good teams. it was a very very though conference last year..


Not sure what makes that a very very tough conference, as most conferences have a minimum of 6-8 teams that can hang with almost anyone.

But I am pretty sure those teams you mentioned wouldn't be able to hang with very many AAA or pro teams,



http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=31

So far far all the teams have won their games, all 4 will prob make the playoffs.
team 1,2,5,6

All 4 will do much much more than just hang in SE AAA, I think all 4 teams would hang in any pro league.
Winona, Lostcity, Phucket and Mekong. are all very good team, and we had to compete with them all of last year. Look at all of their RE's, My LT played very well vs all of them, zero sacks between those teams.



im still waiting for someone to tell me that these 4 teams are junk


1 is good, the other 3 are average, satisfied?

Now i know you are full of shit, which one do you think is good. I expect 1 of those 4 teams to win SE AAA and get promoted this year...
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Porch


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by Madcow8me




Originally posted by SteelersInsider





Originally posted by Porch






Originally posted by Gyuri1







By the way, I should add that if Bort made changes to the sim during the offseason that makes speed/agility rushers more effective, then disregard everything else I've written above. My argument is against nerfing what has been status quo for a long time (as there were ways to counter the fast speed rushers), but if things have changed making speed/agility DEs more overpowering, then I'm all for toning it back down to what it had been in the past. My OT and two higher-level DEs played against a terrible team today, so it's hard to decipher whether things have changed. The preseason games, however, made it look as if things hadn't changed much.


I think that is part of the problem here. This didn't happen last year at all and we played a lot of teams that had great pass rushers and great D's. We gave up a total of 9 sacks last year in the regular season. We played a lot of really good teams and good DE's while doing that and never got abused like this. It just seems like something changed.

I am stuck by two things in these. One our guy barely moved, ever. I mean it looks like he is on a different snap count. I don't mind getting beat but to get beat like that just looks stupid.




SE Asia Pro AA? Likely you were playing against mostly slow-build teams before. Maybe you are playing against more teams trying to win this year.

Nothing has changed. If anything, it is harder for DE's to get sacks this year.


why dont you put the crack pip down bobby brown.
Last year SE AA4 was prob one of the toughest fucking conferences last year. We had a pretty decent team and we were only an 8 seed in the playoffs. and all of that being said, my player only gave up 1 sack. Now we are one of the top teams in SE AA4, and now all of a sudden my LT wont even put a hand on a DE because he is too busy trying to bite his own ear...



Sorry, but if you are a top team in SE AA4, it was NEVER one of the toughest conferences.


He did say we were the 8 seed so we were not a top team. Nice reading comprehension though.


He said this year his team was a top team, please don't lecture me about reading comprehension when you have none.


1. He said last year our conference was a tough conference.
2. He said last year we were a decent team who won the 8 seed.
3. He said this year we are a top team.

He never said we were a top team in a tough conference. Thanks to the changes our conference got a whole lot easier.

Reading is fundamental.


And I said, if he is a top team, that conference was NEVER tough, is that really that hard for you to understand? NEVER meaning, well, NEVER, not just last year, not this year, not 3 years from now.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Madcow8me
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Madcow8me


Originally posted by Madcow8me



Originally posted by sjmay




Originally posted by Madcow8me





Last year we had 5 teams that are could hang with almost anyone. 5 very good teams. it was a very very though conference last year..


Not sure what makes that a very very tough conference, as most conferences have a minimum of 6-8 teams that can hang with almost anyone.

But I am pretty sure those teams you mentioned wouldn't be able to hang with very many AAA or pro teams,



http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=31

So far far all the teams have won their games, all 4 will prob make the playoffs.
team 1,2,5,6

All 4 will do much much more than just hang in SE AAA, I think all 4 teams would hang in any pro league.
Winona, Lostcity, Phucket and Mekong. are all very good team, and we had to compete with them all of last year. Look at all of their RE's, My LT played very well vs all of them, zero sacks between those teams.



im still waiting for someone to tell me that these 4 teams are junk


1 is good, the other 3 are average, satisfied?

Now i know you are full of shit, which one do you think is good. I expect 1 of those 4 teams to win SE AAA and get promoted this year...


Mekong and Phuket should battle it out, they are both strong on some positions and weak on others, it will come down to gameplanning and AI, and like I said, one good team.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Originally posted by ron2288

well i really dont know then..did you set the pass distance to short..if you set it to long or medium it tends to not throw short unless it is a check down
I just know we played a team that was equal to us and even had a DE that was higher level then our OT and we used a short passing game.. and again this was the result

use short passing...one of the teams I gm used it we passed for 300 yard and a combined QB completion % of 70%
I can post the link to the game......even last season on my own team and a different one giving up sacks against teams that was our equal was not a big issue.


I am not say there is or is not a bug/or whatever and I am knot saying you have a bad build or anything like that...but if it was a programing bug in the sim...would it not be fair to say that all the teams in GLB would have this problem...since they are using the same programming and sim? It seems like a few teams is having problems and a few or not..(I was not trying to imply my teams are great and powerful..I wish)

But it just seems like there are just a handful complain about this compared to the total number of teams in all GLB...I mean this thread only has 100-220 pot by the same people..if it was a sim bug would not the 1000+ teams all be sharing this and the post count be in the 1000's by now


To be honest, it's not really a bug, it's a problem with design (I'd even consider it an exploit). Anyone can do what these DEs are doing and anyone can build OTs to counter the DEs... we shouldn't have to though, I doubt Bort intended to have DBs going against WRs in the trenches. Which will become the norm, if things aren't adjusted.

That means nerfing agility and buffing strength, so that they're actually balanced. It also means making weak rushers a liability in the running game and slow blockers a liability in the passing game. There has to have balance... right now, DEs have almost no downside, when going all agility/speed. The only downside is if you run the ball directly at the DE (which will net an extra yard or two on the YPC), but every other situation gives the DE the maximum effect of his imbalanced build. There should be a trade-off and there isn't.

So, this might not technically be a bug, it is a major issue that is adversely affecting game play for anyone, who can't see into the future (to effectively counter these exploits). My game, is a perfect example of trying to counter it, with the tools available and the tools being inadequate.

My only solutions are to run 100% of the time (unacceptable), find FAs with the proper build to counter these "freak" builds (improbable), take it with a smile until I can build my own counter-freaks (which will lead to my DB vs WR analogy and is unacceptable IMHO) or bring it to Bort's attention so he can make the proper adjustments (which is what I chose).

Granted this issue won't affect every game this season or even a marginal amount of games, it needs to be addressed before it does.


Can I get an Amen?!?!

AMEN!

Warlock is absolutely right with his assessment.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
By the way that team just collected another 17 sacks in 28 attempts so someone with a top tackle feel free to challenge him. i want to see someone with a good build stop him.



whoever "that team" is..... tell them to challenge my team and I bet they don't get more than 3-5 sacks - that is with no FB or TE help. If I bring those guys to help, then it would be 1 or 0.

Let me know their team name and I'll accept their challenge (I have my 3 out currently so I can't offer).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.